Morgan NEWP - 1904-P

asheland

This is slightly tougher and I like the date…
What do you guys think?
There were a few sent in, all looked similar toning wise, a few made 63, there was a single 62 and one 64. This coin looked the best to me, better than the 64 honestly. The toning to me is decent, not gorgeous, but not ugly either. The originality is pretty obvious.

coinbuf

That looks very nice congrats on the addition.

Type2

Nice, I like it.

golden

Looks nice.

mannie gray

Looks solid for a 63.

markelman1125

Sweet Morgan 👍👍

ricko

Looks like a solid 63 in the picture - that being said, not a great picture to grade from. Based on your post, I think it was one of a few you sent in.... so did you believe it merited a higher grade? In hand, it may, of course... Cheers, RickO

asheland

@ricko they were sent in from the shop I work at, I only briefly saw them when they came in raw and forgot all about them.

When I heard they were 1904-P, I was intrigued.

I didn’t have any expectations for grades. When they came back yesterday and I viewed them, I liked this 63 better than the 64 that came back. Obviously I was interested in the 64 primarily, but it did nothing for me, and I’ll admit, it was the toning on it. It was very meh looking. I found this 63 to be the pick of the litter. I recall they were in a paper roll when they came in, hence the toning.

asheland

Thanks everybody for the compliments. 👍

johnny9434

Nice, I like the color of it