Options
Two ebay listings, same Buffalo?
TriPodBuffalo
Posts: 106 ✭✭✭
I was checking out ebay listings and stumbled on to this Buffalo
Current listing
https://ebay.com/itm/154442953668?hash=item23f58473c4:g:o5kAAOSwezBglHMr
To me, it looks similar to this Buffalo from a prior sale.
Previous listing
Could this be the same coin?
0
Comments
Why would they have cracked it out?
Might be from the same roll, hence the similar (but not identical) appearance.
Sure looks the same, I am not sure why it would be though. The original sale of the coin for 17 hundred is from a buffalo specialist who found it in an old PCI 45 Holder and asked me to submit it for him. I did and it came back 62. Late die erosion or whatever, I dont know why anybody would crack that and try and sell raw.
That's a very unattractive coin IMO. I'd rather have a nice AU58 than that coin.
Not the same coin.
interesting the slab buyer has the same number of feedback as th raw seller
Those are two different Buffalo nickels.... check the rims and other points. Cheers, RickO
@ricko That was my feeling. But I also agree with koynekwest in that I would not want either one. They are both very ugly coins.
Prior seller's feedback (Left for others - page 1) from prior sale:
Current seller's feedback (Received as buyer from seller - page 11) from prior sale:
Yep. Some of them really were minted that badly in 1918.
Pete
sure look like same coin to me - I wonder if it sold and if that is what buyer gets
If it is the same coin the $300 loss serves them right for such BS about "from original roll" on almost every listing they make.
Collector, occasional seller
I have a feeling this Buffalo will show up in another listing soon.
To me it looks like a dead ringer to the slabbed coin.
I vote the same.