Well struck 1924 Peace

Peace1

Input welcome...considering sending for grading

ricko

Nice looking Peace dollar... Not super high grade...Cheers, RickO

anablep

Looks to have really nice luster!

jedm

I like Peace dollars, and I like that one! It looks like a 63 or 4, but they aren't really high dollar even at that grade. I'd enjoy it as is. Looks like you're kinda new here, so WELCOME!

ricko

@Peace1 .... Oh yeah... Welcome aboard... Cheers, RickO

JJM

welcome.........looks like a 64

BryceM

Maybe it's just the photo, but it looks like a slider to me. I don't see a compelling reason to pay to have it graded.

Peace1

BryceM

The additional photos help. I see it as an MS coin now, probably not AU.

That said, I don't think it's particularly well struck, maybe slightly above average. There is lack of high-point definition on in the central hair and along the eagle's shoulder and front of the eagle's leg.

That aside, the coin has some extensive water marks, which I find distracting. They don't bother some people, but I've never seen coins with this graded above MS64 or so. The worst water spot is on the cheek, which is the #1 focal spot on a Peace dollar. There are abrasions on the fields, cheek, and neck that keeps this out of gem territory.

So, lets say it's MS63 with an outside shot at MS64. That makes it a $60-70 coin, tops. It's easy to find coins of this quality in large quantities. They made 12 million of this date. It's still a nice, attractive coin, but I don't think there's any reason to submit it for grading. With shipping, you're looking at least a $40 investment, if you can combine it with other orders. Without grading maybe it sells for $40-50. After grading maybe it sells for $50-60. That doesn't seem like a good return on investment.

Peace1

@BryceM said:
The additional photos help. I see it as an MS coin now, probably not AU.

That said, I don't think it's particularly well struck, maybe slightly above average. There is lack of high-point definition on in the central hair and along the eagle's shoulder and front of the eagle's leg.

That aside, the coin has some extensive water marks, which I find distracting. They don't bother some people, but I've never seen coins with this graded above MS64 or so. The worst water spot is on the cheek, which is the #1 focal spot on a Peace dollar. There are abrasions on the fields, cheek, and neck that keeps this out of gem territory.

So, lets say it's MS63 with an outside shot at MS64. That makes it a $60-70 coin, tops. It's easy to find coins of this quality in large quantities. They made 12 million of this date. It's still a nice, attractive coin, but I don't think there's any reason to submit it for grading. With shipping, you're looking at least a $40 investment, if you can combine it with other orders. Without grading maybe it sells for $40-50. After grading maybe it sells for $50-60. That doesn't seem like a good return on investment.

I bought two like this for $30 shipped so I still will make money if I decide to sell...thank you for your input

Jimnight

Looks 63.

mannie gray

64 would likely be the max on this coin.

lkeigwin

No thank you.
Lance.

oreville

Carefully place some mineral oil on the coin and hopefully the watermark will come off. Otherwise a pleasant looking silver dollar but do not spend more $ on having the coin graded unless you get a PCGS quarterly special deal.

anablep

I still like its luster potential but that white substance on the obverse detracts from the coin's overall look.

ChrisH821

It's a nice coin but not worth the expense to grade. IMO a coin like that will generally sell for the same amount in or out of a holder.
Even if it comes back 64 it's a $60 coin that you will have paid $40 to grade. You are better off selling it raw for $30 or so, this is assuming your goal is to sell one or both of them.
Priority #1 should be attempting to get that water spot off the coin(without ruining it). With that it doesn't matter if it comes back 65, no one is going to pay 65 money for a coin with a big water spot right on the cheek.

jerseycat101

64 Max, i agree with the masses here. Put it in an album

Cougar1978

Nice CH BU - I would put in flip or 2x2 price at CW Trends 63 money. Open to negotiation if room. Would not spend money slab it.

Certainly a shot at 64 if u decide send it in to our hosts.

nwcoast

Nice album coin.
Spend the money that might have gone to grading and have some fun. Maybe buy another coin.