Options
1928 P Quarter, FH or not
Here is another Standing Liberty Quarter straight graded by PCGS as an AU 55. 
0
Here is another Standing Liberty Quarter straight graded by PCGS as an AU 55. 
Comments
Can't tell from that photo but here's how our hosts call it:
https://www.pcgs.com/grades/#gradeFH
I think thats another pic of the 18-D you posted yesterday.
Need a better picture.
clarkbar04 you are right. This id dirty but the toning is olive and about as dark as the 1918D. Here is the 1928P. Yeah or Nay?
Thats no brainer FH.
That coin is more like a 58FH with 3 points of dirt impeding luster.
Another nice original coin that is correctly graded.
My post was not intended as a GTG type of post. The issue was FH or not. According to Pop Reports at PCGS, they have graded five 1928 P as AU55 FH. I think the coin is accurately graded by PCGS standards but they missed the boat on the FH. Details are 58 but the dirt or originality lowers it. PCGS has a preference for blast white AU type SLQ. I have looked at lots of them. When I see a blast white PCGS AU58 SLQ, I usually pass. It is not what I am looking for. My Registry Set is based on what I like and not numbers. just sayin...mh
@mightyhunter .... So perhaps you should send it in for reconsideration. And request information on the decision if still not FH. Cheers, RickO
ricko, I purchased this coin raw and submitted it myself a few years back. The COST for reconsideration just isn't worth it. It will stay in my Registry Sets until they are disposed off. The number or FH designation is not all that important to me. I posed the initial question about the FH to the forums to see if they were seeing what I did. just sayin..mh