How to price extreme NT (toning) coins. lets discuss..
Silvermahomes here, I am a avid collector of Morgan Silver Dollars, as well as other USA coins, I particularly enjoy collection naturally toned coins or known sometimes at NTs Toners, Etc. HOWEVER it can be very hard to do because of the wide range of toning. I know things are "only worth what people will pay for it" but what I mean is for example I enclosed 2 pictures, each are the same coin, grade everything besides 2 things the coin grading company which both PCGS and NGC are compatible with pricing. The big difference is the toning HOWEVER if you look them up in the priceguide, they both are going to say the same price (around $80-$100 tops) again, HOWEVER the second picture with the toning with is what the star means on the slab. The NGC coin could bring double,triple or even more compared to its counterpart. I know each toner is unique and the "sub" population much smaller then a regular MS coin. I find myself going nuts for an extreme toned coins like in pic # 3.
sooo please tell me what you guys and gals say about toning, are there any standards for pricing them? i know the more balanced and seminary of the toning makes if more valuable
I am new to this site but not to collecting
I have a Youtube channel all about coins etc: