What is this? Found in attic of my parents new house in upstate NY?

ambro51

I replied to the first email “keep looking”, his reply:
So we shall see. I hate to see an interesting mystery such as this to disappear.

Onastone

@ambro51 said:

I just bought the example on eBay. Quite interesting, in that there are “two” of them. Can I get a weight and diameter of the OPs piece, for comparison. There are some similarities to the 1811 Vexator Canadiensis token, in general terms only. Let’s see what it looks like when it arrives, if it’s an electro. Both pieces have what looks like normal circulation type wear. Interesting.

It'll be interesting to compare the other side too!

mothra454

@coinJP said:
Oh man...hate when sellers do that

Did he recently visit your father by any chance??