1884-CC Morgan GTG - *GRADE REVEALED*

mothra454

Cougar1978

Borderline MS64 / 65

I say MS64 overall appears to be a pleasing coin. This issue one of my favs.

mothra454

Reverse is prooflike in hand, if that helps

jesbroken

Photo grading allows scuffs and face chatter to overrun the obverse causing an MS63 estimated grade.
Jim

Oney

MS64....obverse chatter holds back from a MS65. Nice coin with what appears to be decent eye appeal.

ELVIS1

Seen worse in a 65

Kliao

MS-64

Meltdown

Looks 65 to me. That's a clean cheek.

Smudge

64

asheland

MS64 shot 65

mothra454

@Oney said:
MS64....obverse chatter holds back from a MS65. Nice coin with what appears to be decent eye appeal.

Thanks! I think it has pretty good eye appeal and nice luster (which is hard to capture). Here's a pic with better lighting:

clarkbar04

I could see that in a 65 holder.

GoldenEgg

@asheland said:
MS64 shot 65

Agree!

DelawareDoons

65.

privatecoin

64

WDH

65

jughead1893

65

pointfivezero

Splitting the difference and taking the bait...

64+ PL

mothra454

Keep 'em coming guys! For reference, what would you GTG on this other one? (different coin)

asheland

@mothra454 said:
Keep 'em coming guys! For reference, what would you GTG on this other one? (different coin)

That looks 66

asheland

@mothra454 said:

@Oney said:
MS64....obverse chatter holds back from a MS65. Nice coin with what appears to be decent eye appeal.

Thanks! I think it has pretty good eye appeal and nice luster (which is hard to capture). Here's a pic with better lighting:

New picture, I'm leaning 65 now...

DollarAfterDollar

MS 66. Common date CC's get a bump because, CC. The chatter is very superficial.

Jmis

64 good day 63 bad day

Collect4fun

63

Mgarmy

64

cheezhed

Give me a 65

Walkerfan

63

mannie gray

First coin 65-
Second one 66

Jimnight

64

mothra454

@cheezhed said:
Give me a 65

Given! Thanks for the input guys. I guess the big bag mark high on the cheek seals its fate? The "reference" coin was from an auction site and is MS65 CAC green

ricko

Late to the game, but would have said 64....Probably what it would get if submitted here....IMO... Cheers, RickO

DoubleEagle59

I see the grade now but would have guessed 'a solid ms64'.

mothra454

@ricko said:
Late to the game, but would have said 64....Probably what it would get if submitted here....IMO... Cheers, RickO

Don't worry, it's staying in the older holder. And not likely to tone any more so you can rest easy there too

ricko

@mothra454.... I am SO relieved.... Cheers, RickO

mothra454

btw does anyone else think the "4" in the date and the mm look kind of unique? This "4" has a pointy top when all the others I've seen have a flat top (like the reference coin). Also the "CC" looks a little different than most. Just a unusual die pair maybe?

Collect4fun

I couldn’t tell how deep the cut was in the cheek. > @ricko said:

Late to the game, but would have said 64....Probably what it would get if submitted here....IMO... Cheers, RickO

logger7

Ve4y high end look, without the defect probably a two point bump. Lock cac.