A fine compromise. We meet at 30%. You can divide by half if you feel he has no value to the defense. I do agree that just being the QB of the Champs does not in itself make one great. Greatness stands out when it is obvious that in all probability that team would not have won the Super Bowl without that QB.
@Brick said:
A fine compromise. We meet at 30%. You can divide by half if you feel he has no value to the defense. I do agree that just being the QB of the Champs does not in itself make one great. Greatness stands out when it is obvious that in all probability that team would not have won the Super Bowl without that QB.
That’s how I feel as well. I pretty much think it’s pretty clear that the Pats would not have won 6 Super Bowls, forget about sniffing 9 appearances without Brady.
@Brick said:
Alex Smith is more than a pretty good journeyman QB. Under appreciated. Underrated. He was quite valuable to the Chiefs. Just not as valuable as Mahomes.
And he almost had his leg amputated last year and is back this year playing at a high level
as demonstrated in the win over the Steelers.
Comments
Dilfer won a Super Bowl!!!!!!
Don't forget Brad Johnson.
He may be the ultimate example!
A fine compromise. We meet at 30%. You can divide by half if you feel he has no value to the defense. I do agree that just being the QB of the Champs does not in itself make one great. Greatness stands out when it is obvious that in all probability that team would not have won the Super Bowl without that QB.
http://www.unisquare.com/store/brick/
Ralph
That’s how I feel as well. I pretty much think it’s pretty clear that the Pats would not have won 6 Super Bowls, forget about sniffing 9 appearances without Brady.
And he almost had his leg amputated last year and is back this year playing at a high level
as demonstrated in the win over the Steelers.