Are PSA/DNA graded cards allowed in set registries?

abcoltsfan

I have an Andre Dawson PSA 9 that is also DNA certified. Would this be allowed in the registry? I just tried to add it to the basic registry set and it would not go through. Any help would be appreciated. Thanks.

DBesse27

Signed cards, as long as the card itself is graded, can be added to player sets. You need to “report a Cert that matches this composite” and they should add it for you. If it still gets rejected, email the set registry folks directly about the issue and they should allow it. I have signed cards in my Hannah and Yaz registry sets.

1951WheatiesPremium

@abcoltsfan said:
I have an Andre Dawson PSA 9 that is also DNA certified. Would this be allowed in the registry? I just tried to add it to the basic registry set and it would not go through. Any help would be appreciated. Thanks.

If it is for the Topps set, I believe the answer is no.

If it is for a player or master set, I believe the answer is yes.

You may need to ‘Request a Cert that should match a checklist’ and that will probably do it.

DBesse27

@1951WheatiesPremium said:

@abcoltsfan said:
I have an Andre Dawson PSA 9 that is also DNA certified. Would this be allowed in the registry? I just tried to add it to the basic registry set and it would not go through. Any help would be appreciated. Thanks.

If it is for the Topps set, I believe the answer is no.

If it is for a player or master set, I believe the answer is yes.

You may need to ‘Request a Cert that should match a checklist’ and that will probably do it.

Correct, only allowed in player sets.

abcoltsfan

@DBesse27 said:

@1951WheatiesPremium said:

@abcoltsfan said:
I have an Andre Dawson PSA 9 that is also DNA certified. Would this be allowed in the registry? I just tried to add it to the basic registry set and it would not go through. Any help would be appreciated. Thanks.

If it is for the Topps set, I believe the answer is no.

If it is for a player or master set, I believe the answer is yes.

You may need to ‘Request a Cert that should match a checklist’ and that will probably do it.

Correct, only allowed in player sets.

Thanks for the clarification. What is the reasoning behind this do you know? My card is his RC. I was trying to add to the Topps registry. It makes no sense needing a 2nd PSA 9. Thanks.

1951WheatiesPremium

I think the idea is that for actual company sets, you can compete either in the PSA OR PSA/DNA registry. That’s why they have the two distinct and separate registries.

For player sets, it’s pretty much anything goes and whatever you have to do to get to complete...

JoeBanzai

@abcoltsfan said:

@DBesse27 said:

@1951WheatiesPremium said:

@abcoltsfan said:
I have an Andre Dawson PSA 9 that is also DNA certified. Would this be allowed in the registry? I just tried to add it to the basic registry set and it would not go through. Any help would be appreciated. Thanks.

If it is for the Topps set, I believe the answer is no.

If it is for a player or master set, I believe the answer is yes.

You may need to ‘Request a Cert that should match a checklist’ and that will probably do it.

Correct, only allowed in player sets.

Thanks for the clarification. What is the reasoning behind this do you know? My card is his RC. I was trying to add to the Topps registry. It makes no sense needing a 2nd PSA 9. Thanks.

BASIC Set.

What is the card? Signed after the fact or pulled from a pack already signed? If you want a good answer, you need to give good information.

A basic set (generally speaking) is just that, the basic card of the player, no league leader, team or multi player cards allowed. I am assuming that would exclude anything signed unless that was the basic card in the year issued.