Options
Gold Shield?
I'm looking at a PCGS coin on eBay. I did a certification check and it matches coin and grade, but indicates it is in a Gold Shield holder. The eBay photos show it clearly not in a Gold Shield holder. Possible explanations?
0
Comments
Ask seller.
Check the cert number on the Cert page. It will tell you if it is a Standard holder or Gold Shield.
https://www.pcgs.com/cert/
- Bob -

MPL's - Lincolns of Color
Central Valley Roosevelts
I have asked, but no response yet. Auction finishes in 3hours.
I did this it says Gold Shield. Auction photos are not gold shield.
He could be using an old photo of the coin before it received a Gold Shield holder.
- Bob -

MPL's - Lincolns of Color
Central Valley Roosevelts
It could be an older photo (before a reholder) or it could just be an error on the cert lookup page (they could have accidentally entered gold shield even if it wasn’t).
OK. So the seller says coin photos are current and it must be a PCGS issue. Coin is also CAC.
A lister on eBay does not have to link a gold shield image he can use his own.
I usually try to list both but it can be done with either or both or just his.
Check seller feedback. Be careful. Sometimes on eBay if everything doesn’t add up it may be best to pass. No disrespect to the seller as I don’t know who it is or what coin you are referring to.
Good chance it is something with reholdering but issues similar to this have come up where it is a counterfeit holder & coin. Not saying that is the case here but look close.
As long as the holder and coin looks real (which it probably does), the odds are that the cert lookup page has an error. I’ve had something similar happen before (cert page had wrong TruView image). After contacting PCGS, it was resolved very quickly.
Use caution.
The choice it yours, but for me, any red flag and I just move on....If you get it, let us know what you find out. Cheers, RickO
Auction ended and I was not a bidder. Here is the coin that the cert said was gold shield.
Cert is standard not Gold Shield.
SNAD
I can't find auction or cert
That's my point it is clearly not Gold Shield, but when you do a verification on 24704698, PCGS says it is.

The coin and the slab looks real. It appears to just be a typo.
This is nowhere near SNAD level as the seller doesn’t mention gold shield anywhere in their listing and they don’t control what is on the Cert page. Again this is likely easily resolved by contacting PCGS (if the future buyer wants).
Here is a link...sold for $345.10 plus shipping
https://www.ebay.com/itm/1938-walking-liberty-half-dollar-Cac-MS-66/264548567568?hash=item3d9852ca10:g:yykAAOSwGshd3tpV#vi__app-cvip-panel
I think there’s an infinitely greater chance that there’s a snafu with the verification page than that there’s shenanigans with the coin, holder and sticker. I wouldn’t have let the “Gold Shield” issue deter me.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
Mis-read the OP, thought it was mentioned.
As usual buyer beware... and not just coins.
No worries.
Buyers should always be careful, but we should also be hesitant to instantly blame the seller. I've seen minor things like this get blown out of proportion when there wasn't much need. This is a case where a quick call/email to PCGS should take care of any error on the cert page.