Which one would you rather have?

ScarsdaleCoin

Would you rather have the AU. Straight grade... but it has a spot on Obverse or the UNC which is net grade as a details cleaned?

Which one is more valuable?

Walkerfan

That's a legitimate question.

I almost never choose a problem coin but that one doesn't look too bad.

It is a higher grade with no distractions, as well, so I would take it over the AU token.

thebeav

I think the spot would bother me. Cleaning won't.
I have 6 volumes of the 'Tarbell System' magic books. They're quite good.

drei3ree

I hate spots, so cleaned for me!

ChangeInHistory

Unc details

Unknown

This content has been removed.

ricko

The pictures could be better, but the 'cleaned' coin does appear to have more detail. Cheers, RickO

divecchia

"UNC Details" for me. I really hate spots.

Donato

BuffaloIronTail

@drei3ree said:
I hate spots, so cleaned for me!

I'm seeing spots...............and I have a headache from trying to decide.

Pete

airplanenut

Can I pass? Unless those are the only two I'll ever have access to, I don't think I'd like either enough to want one of them.

Cameonut

I don't like spots and I don't like cleaning. So I will pass on both unless these are the only two extant.

santinidollar

I don’t know how difficult those are to obtain, so I don’t know if my advice to hold out for better is applicable.