Options
Hi friends. I need expert opinions and thoughts about which coins to send for grading to PCGS.?
collectors
Posts: 44 ✭
Choices are 1909 VDB matte proof? 1909 VDB double die. 1922 d. 1924 s. If I post pics can everyone give honest opinions about which ones to send?? Thx friends...
Tagged:
0
Best Answers
-
Options
PTVETTER
Posts: 5,882 ✭✭✭✭✭
the VDB look odd even for a Philly mint
The period after the D is misplaced??Pat Vetter,Mercury Dime registry set,1938 Proof set registry,Pat & BJ Coins:724-325-72111
Answers
Nothing that you picture is worth sending in.
Waiting for the negative Nancys.
GREAT.. sending it
Make sure to update us on how they graded!
🥇🥇🥇🥇🥇
💰💰💰💰💰
📫📫📫📫📫
Do you know what the markers for a 1909 VDB "double die" are?
You can see them here:
http://doubleddie.com/287322.html
I would say the chances of your well circulated (but still fairly nice) 1909 VDB being certified as a matte proof are very low.
Usually the decision to have a coin slabbed depends on the cost of slabbing, the price with or without slabbing (at the given grade level), and the likelihood of the coin being classified in the variety category and grade you expect.
For example, say cost of slabbing is $30, grade looks like F-12, but 50% chance that it will return as "no grade due to cleaning". And sale price in an F-12 slab is $15, vs. $5 raw.
Expected profit of slabbing = .5*15 + .5*5 - 30 = -$20 . So you lose $20 on average by slabbing. At best you lose $15.
send them all, God will sort them out.
Give Me Liberty or Give Me Debt
Good luck.
bob
Are you serious?
Good luck!
Best of luck with your submission... Please let us know the results....It can be helpful to others considering submissions. Cheers, RickO
Probably want to clarify on your submission as you have a spelling errror.
It is not a MATTE PROOF
It is a MAT PROOF
For myself, having coins graded, has the same 2 basic criteria as buying coins:
1 Does it make numismatic sense?
2 Does it make financial sense?
and there is perhaps a 3rd criteria.....does it make common sense?
of course, if you have "endless deep" pockets and simply want to see your coins locked in to plastic, it does not matter.