Guess The Plus + Grade--CAC or no CAC "Revealed"
HighRelief
Posts: 3,675 ✭✭✭✭✭
I would give this one at least a 65 although the hairlines could be limiting the grade to the 64+. JA liked it enough to knight it with his green bean and I agree with him 100%. We have some very good graders in this forum and I appreciate your feedback on the coin.
0
Comments
I like it, 65+ or higher.
JA his own mind, are those hairlines?
MS64+ CAC
+1
Those are die polish lines so I guess they would be hairlines.
I would love that coin in a 64+ PL holder and a CAC sticker
65pl
rainbowroosie April 1, 2003
66+ PL and CAC green
65+ CAC.... Cheers, RickO
64+ and not CAC, imho.
I love that look !!! 65+ , CAC yes. If it didn’t get JAs approval and you know why please let us know
Very nice MS65/6+PL
Hoard the keys.
64+ CAC
65+PL
JA does not consider plus status in whether to bean. I guess no bean.
"Got a flaming heart, can't get my fill"
65+ PL no CAC
I wonder. Let's say a coin is graded a 65+ by PCGS. Does he grade it as just a 65 and maybe give it a gold bean (high end 65), if he agrees, or does he grade it as a 65+ and just give it a green bean as a 65+, if he agrees.
65.+. No
65
MS65+ DMPL; no CAC, possibly the mirrors aren’t deep enough, but looks like it could deserve a bean.
Darn... off by one increment....
Oh well... back to the books... 
Cheers, RickO
Bingo
I'm better than 90% on Morgan dollars. No comment (bragging) about my accuracy on other coins.
Several posters thought the coin was a plus, but not CAC. What do you think would prevent a sticker if you acknowledge it is premium for the grade? Clearly, if PCGS and CAC had the exact same standards, all plus coins would also sticker.
Dang, even I nail one every now and then. My grade minus 1 works sometimes.