HockeyAutoCollector's signed rookies (Updated: Many new additions)

HockeyAutoCollector · November 21, 2010 11:21AM

Hey all,

I decided to start on a new endeavor in my autograph collecting. Most of you know that I usually deal with autographs of deceased hockey hall of famers and have them made into custom cards for my collection. Lately I have gotten to the point where it is difficult to pick up autographs for my collection, so I have decided to start collecting signed rookies of HOF players and a few future HOFers. I am starting by wanting to obtain the autographs of the 50 greatest living players, but I am sure I will stray from that somewhat. I was also inspired by Mike Navarro's thread, but knew I would only want to focus on hockey.

I will try to update this as I get some in. Here are the first batch of 4 that I have received back and scanned. These were all PSA crack outs and then either signed at a signing or TTM.

And two of the greatest players to ever play

MULLINS5 · November 21, 2010 11:33AM

woah! I heard Orr doesn't sign his rookie!

Great project, I look forward to seeing more great signatures!

HockeyAutoCollector · November 21, 2010 1:04PM

<< woah! I heard Orr doesn't sign his rookie!

Great project, I look forward to seeing more great signatures! >>

Orr will sign them, for the right price.

thenavarro · November 21, 2010 1:11PM

Outstanding!

Mike

jswieton · November 21, 2010 2:58PM

The Orr and Howe are mindblowing!!! WTG

HockeyAutoCollector · November 23, 2010 2:50AM

Just got these two back in the mail

Stan Mikita is known to be hit or miss signing TTM, so I was very happy to see this one come back.

Dickie Moore broke Gordie Howe's single season point record in the 58-59 season and ended up having the second highest point total in the pre-expansion era. He wrote a nice note and mentioned that the name and date of birth on the back of the cards were wrong and actually the information for his brother. He corrected it on the back of the card and initialed, which I thought was pretty cool.

georgebailey2 · November 23, 2010 3:04AM

<< 
Orr will sign them, for the right price. >>

Which is....?
Does he do it through his web-site?
While I don't have the rookie card (anymore), I would like to get the HHOF Legends postcard signed.

Regards, Paul

3SportHOFCOLLECTOR · November 23, 2010 4:54AM

Great Bobby Orr Rookie that has been worth some serious dough. The Gordie is pretty nice as well. That Bobby Orr is definitely something you don't see every day. That is perhaps the crown jewel to any hockey hall of fame autograph collection.The card has be a $1,500 the minimum, most likely well over $2,000 slabbed. Heck the card alone is $800 to $1000. Plus you got Stan Mikita TTM was he free? Mikita is one of the most unreliable signers TTM.

HockeyAutoCollector · November 23, 2010 5:11AM

<< 

<< 
Orr will sign them, for the right price. >>

Which is....?
Does he do it through his web-site?
While I don't have the rookie card (anymore), I would like to get the HHOF Legends postcard signed.

Regards, Paul >>

He will sign most cards through his website for $125/card. His rookie card he charges 4x that. Pretty ridiculous, but it was definitely an essential one for my collection.

HockeyAutoCollector · November 23, 2010 5:15AM

<< Great Bobby Orr Rookie that has been worth some serious dough. The Gordie is pretty nice as well. That Bobby Orr is definitely something you don't see every day. That is perhaps the crown jewel to any hockey hall of fame autograph collection.The card has be a $1,500 the minimum, most likely well over $2,000 slabbed. Heck the card alone is $800 to $1000. Plus you got Stan Mikita TTM was he free? Mikita is one of the most unreliable signers TTM. >>

Mikita does not sign for free, or at least that is what I hear. I heard he charges anywhere from $25-40 for his signature through the mail. I sent $40 and was happy to get the card back.

Orr's card is definitely the highlight of my signed rookie card collection. Overall, I would say my Hobey Baker or Georges Vezina autographs are the highlights of my autograph collection.

lanemyer85 · November 23, 2010 5:45AM

nice Stosh.

artistlost · November 23, 2010 6:05AM

MORE!!!!!

please.

nice stuff.

georgebailey2 · November 23, 2010 7:03AM

Thanks for the info. Nice collection, too!

3SportHOFCOLLECTOR · November 23, 2010 10:54AM

Hobey Baker and Veznia, wow. Hobey Baker is super rare and certainly the rarest Big Name Hockey Hall of Famer. Do you have Dryden on his rookie, he is the toughest living Player and the next toughest is probably George Armstrong for some reason. I don't know why George Armstrong is so tough?

jswieton · November 23, 2010 12:35PM

Dryden will sign TTM but he will personalize your card.

HockeyAutoCollector · November 23, 2010 11:00PM

<< Hobey Baker and Veznia, wow. Hobey Baker is super rare and certainly the rarest Big Name Hockey Hall of Famer. Do you have Dryden on his rookie, he is the toughest living Player and the next toughest is probably George Armstrong for some reason. I don't know why George Armstrong is so tough? >>

Armstrong supposedly will not sign for anyone now. Not TTM or in person, don't know what led him to that.

Here is my Dryden. I picked it up about a month ago on eBay.

Also, if anyone wants to check out the Baker, Vezina, or any other of autographs in my custom card collection just use the link in my signature line.

HockeyAutoCollector · November 23, 2010 11:08PM

Here are my two new additions TTM:

Marcel charges $10/autograph, but was also nice enough to include a signed postcard when he returned my card. I met Marcel when I was about 12 at a local rink and was definitely glad to add this one to my collection.

And the "Broad Street Bullies" captain, Bobby Clarke.

3SportHOFCOLLECTOR · November 24, 2010 1:34AM

That is a great Dryden! The Hobey Baker is also amazing. The whole collection is really something. I bet you can count on one hand the people that have all those autographs.

HockeyAutoCollector · December 1, 2010 1:46AM

After a slow week, here is my latest TTM success:

11-time Stanley Cup winner, Henri Richard. He also included a nice signed Molson Export card. A great TTM signer!

ssdawg77 · December 1, 2010 8:59AM

Very nice collection.

HockeyAutoCollector · December 3, 2010 7:31AM

Another TTM success today.

HOF Guy Lafleur, one of the few guys in my search that I actually got to see play.

MULLINS5 · December 3, 2010 8:36AM

LaFleur, Richard, and Clark have always been great TTM signers.

Dionne just recently (within the past three years) charges for his TTMs -- I think the money goes to charity?

I missed out on a Bossy signing in October, so if you hear of one please let me know. There is a PSA/DNA one on eBay at the moment (I don't know the seller).

I got a two Billy Smith TTMs back in the mail Monday after a 12 month wait

Very cool so far!

MULLINS5 · December 3, 2010 2:26PM

Not that you need any help, but here is a nice place with a lot of HOFers on a regular basis.

They will spam the heck out of your email though.

Toronto Card Show - Frank Mahovlich

HockeyAutoCollector · December 3, 2010 11:09PM

<< LaFleur, Richard, and Clark have always been great TTM signers.

Dionne just recently (within the past three years) charges for his TTMs -- I think the money goes to charity?

I missed out on a Bossy signing in October, so if you hear of one please let me know. There is a PSA/DNA one on eBay at the moment (I don't know the seller).

I got a two Billy Smith TTMs back in the mail Monday after a 12 month wait

Very cool so far! >>

I am not sure if Dionne's fee goes toward any charity. I know for guys like Flaman and Schmidt the money goes toward cancer research.

I missed the Bossy signing too. I picked up a signed one on eBay about a month ago. The auto is sort of small, so I may look for another one. The seller who currently has one up I have bought from before, Billy Smith and Denis Potvin signed rookies if I remember correctly. I will let you know if I see another Bossy signing come up.

Did you get Smith's rookie card signed TTM? The reason I bought one already signed is that someone told me he doesn't sign them anymore.

HockeyAutoCollector · December 3, 2010 11:11PM

<< Not that you need any help, but here is a nice place with a lot of HOFers on a regular basis.

They will spam the heck out of your email though.

Toronto Card Show - Frank Mahovlich >>

They have my Mahovlich rookie up there right now waiting to get signed.

MULLINS5 · December 4, 2010 6:52PM

<< 

<< Not that you need any help, but here is a nice place with a lot of HOFers on a regular basis.

They will spam the heck out of your email though.

Toronto Card Show - Frank Mahovlich >>

They have my Mahovlich rookie up there right now waiting to get signed. >>

very cool.

Yes, the Billy Smith was a TTM - Here it is (I covered my address with a lighter version of the foil above because it didn't scan well).

I sent this out December 2009...didn't expect to see it come back to be honest.

MULLINS5 · December 4, 2010 7:41PM

Will you be looking to get Tretiak?

If so, do you know what is considered his rookie?

HockeyAutoCollector · December 5, 2010 5:06AM

<< Will you be looking to get Tretiak?

If so, do you know what is considered his rookie? >>

I would like to get Tretiak, but I am not 100% sure what I would consider his rookie. I believe there is a 1979 Panini sticker, but I don't know what else there is besides that. I was thinking about trying to pick up the sticker to send to him but haven't found one yet.

HockeyAutoCollector · December 6, 2010 6:40AM

Good Monday for autograph returns. I got back my Glenn Hall and Marcel Pronovost rookies from AJ Sportsworld. They were signed at the Toronto Expo last month. I also received John Bucyk and Edgar Laprade back TTM.

HockeyAutoCollector · December 7, 2010 6:07AM

1951 Parkhurst Red Kelly RC - TTM

HockeyAutoCollector · December 10, 2010 6:56AM

Here is today's haul:

1951 Bill Gadsby - TTM
1952 Leo Boivin - TTM
1974 Bob Gainey - eBay
1981 Jari Kurri - eBay

HockeyAutoCollector · December 11, 2010 3:30AM

1973 Larry Robinson - TTM.

Hopefully he can help my team turn it around this year, but it doesn't look good so far.

HockeyAutoCollector · December 13, 2010 8:28AM

Two more successes today.

Bobby Hull - signed TTM
Tony Esposito - signed at show last weekend

thenavarro · December 13, 2010 9:15AM

Awesome Hull, I've been wanting one of those for awhile now, but I'm too cheap to shell out the funds for the raw card.

Mike

MULLINS5 · December 13, 2010 9:39AM

Very nice Hull indeed, I wouldn't send that one TTM, you have guts

I sent T. Esposito a sticker for my '81 set and he sent it back unsigned. I tried once more, this time with a check for $20 -- he cashed it and sent the sticker back signed.

eyebone · December 13, 2010 10:21AM

great stuff sean. keep it going and thanks for posting.

eyebone

HockeyAutoCollector · December 14, 2010 12:54AM

Thanks, guys. I was a bit worried about getting this one back, but Hull has been signing a decent amount TTM since the Hawks won the Cup. He has also been doing a ton a shows lately, though I found that out after I sent the card out. I thought it was nice that he added the #16, which is the number he wore his first 4 seasons in the league.

artistlost · December 14, 2010 1:06AM

This is my favourite thread!

Love the autos...keep them coming.

mathew

HockeyAutoCollector · December 14, 2010 8:31AM

<< This is my favourite thread!

Love the autos...keep them coming.

mathew >>

Thanks Mathew, I appreciate it!

Here is the latest addition. This was signed at a private signing put on through his company last month and I got it back in the mail today.

Wayne Gretzky

HockeyAutoCollector · December 16, 2010 6:31AM

Two in the mail today.

Phil Esposito - signed at a show this past weekend put on by Sportsworld in MA
Dave Keon - TTM

HockeyAutoCollector · December 18, 2010 6:43AM

Saturday brought another good day and an end to a good week of getting autographs back in the mail. Here was today's take, all TTM:

Eddie Giacomin - Mr. Giacomin and Rod Gilbert coached a clinic that I took part in about 20 years ago (when I was 12). Definitely one of the more memorable childhood experiences and I was happy to get this one back. Sent $10, but he added an additional HOF card that he personalized.

Ted Lindsay - signed my rookie card and sent additional postcard.

Dick Duff - signed my rookie card and added an additional signed photo. Also wrote a note that I shared the same name as his good friend.

Alex Devecchio - signed my card and replied to my questions in the letter I sent. Sent $10.

Gilbert Perreault- sent $10

thenavarro · December 18, 2010 7:08AM

Sean,

You are blowing through these quickly!! How many more do you have that are still on your wantllist?

Mike

HockeyAutoCollector · December 18, 2010 7:46AM

<< Sean,

You are blowing through these quickly!! How many more do you have that are still on your wantllist?

Mike >>

Mike,

My initial goal, once I started to actually do this, was to collect the top 50 living players from the 100 greatest players list that the Hockey News put out in 1998, minus Eric Lindros. Since then I have decided to collect every living player off that list, plus about another 40 or so names, including all of the living HOFers from the 1951 Parkhurst list. So I am definitely on my way, but still have some to go. As of right now, I believe I have another 14 out for TTM, another 10 or so for signings, and the only a couple I need to figure out how to track down.

thenavarro · December 18, 2010 8:04AM

<< 
My initial goal, once I started to actually do this, was to collect the top 50 living players from the 100 greatest players list that the Hockey News put out in 1998, minus Eric Lindros. Since then I have decided to collect every living player off that list, plus about another 40 or so names, including all of the living HOFers from the 1951 Parkhurst list. So I am definitely on my way, but still have some to go. As of right now, I believe I have another 14 out for TTM, another 10 or so for signings, and the only a couple I need to figure out how to track down. >>

Sean,

Since we didn't have NHL teams in Dallas when I was young, or much tv coverage either, I didn't follow the game that closely and typically my exposure was limited to watching the US in Olympic hockey. That being said, I might be asking a question that has an obvious answer, but why were you excluding Eric Lindros??

Take care,

Mike

HockeyAutoCollector · December 18, 2010 8:19AM

<< 
Sean,

Since we didn't have NHL teams in Dallas when I was young, or much tv coverage either, I didn't follow the game that closely and typically my exposure was limited to watching the US in Olympic hockey. That being said, I might be asking a question that has an obvious answer, but why were you excluding Eric Lindros??

Take care,

Mike >>

Personally, I didn't think Lindros deserved to be on the list of the top 100 players ever. In 1998, his career was going pretty well, but after that he went downhill with his concussions and such. So, at least in my opinion, he was a good player, could have been great without injuries, but because of the concussions, he didn't live up to expectations.

MULLINS5 · December 18, 2010 8:33AM

If he stayed with Quebec instead of crying his way to Philadelphia maybe he could have been a part of one of the cup teams.

HockeyAutoCollector · December 20, 2010 7:16AM

One more today.

Fern Flaman - TTM

HockeyAutoCollector · December 28, 2010 7:36AM

Three new ones today:

Frank Mahovlich - signed at Toronto Card Show 12/12
Yvan Cournoyer - TTM. Definitely excited to get this one back. Cournoyer has not been signing much through the mail lately, either sending back the cards or adding one of his own Molson Export cards. I was lucky enough to get my rookie card signed!
Dino Ciccarelli - signed at Max Sports show in MN 12/19

HockeyAutoCollector · December 30, 2010 6:45AM

Today's mail brought:

Bill Barber - TTM. Quite possibly one of the ugliest cards, but I am glad to cross another one off my list.

HockeyAutoCollector · January 3, 2011 6:31AM

I hope everyone had a great New Years!

My first TTM of the year is from Michel Goulet.

artistlost · January 3, 2011 6:45AM

Wow...just went through this thread again. Amazing collection.

Thanks a bunch for sharing!

mathew

HockeyAutoCollector's signed rookies (Updated: Many new additions)

Comments