<< <i>Ok then , lets get it straight , you are saying a seller can list an item and send a different item and the buyer should leave a positive because after all it was a mistake on the sellers part. >>
No, you don't have it straight. That's not what I'm saying.
One more time- sometimes, sellers make mistakes in their listings. The fact you happen to bid on one is no reason to expect to get something the seller doesn't have. Example- seller intends to sell a 1977 proof set and mistypes the description as "1987". You win the auction, but you're not going to get a 1987 set because the seller doesn't have one. This would seem to be self-evident. The adult response to a seller making such a mistake is to treat him the same way you'd like to be treated when (not if) you make a mistake yourself. Feedback is optional. >>
Two key words there buddy , Seller & Mistake. Why should a buyer accept a sellers mistake ? You know that won't fly.
<< <i>Two key words there buddy , Seller & Mistake. Why should a buyer accept a sellers mistake ? You know that won't fly. >>
So all sellers should be infallible? You never make mistakes? If I was the seller on this deal I would have offered a partial refund based on the difference in bullion value and ended it there. The buyer was, IMO, a giant PITA and wouldn't have been satisfied under any circumstances.
<< <i>Two key words there buddy , Seller & Mistake. Why should a buyer accept a sellers mistake ? You know that won't fly. >>
So all sellers should be infallible? You never make mistakes? If I was the seller on this deal I would have offered a partial refund based on the difference in bullion value and ended it there. The buyer was, IMO, a giant PITA and wouldn't have been satisfied under any circumstances. >>
When i make a mistake i face up to it and rectify it , i don't defend it with ideas the buyer should empathise with me , they rarely do.Mr P's conversation with me hasn't originated with this particular transaction,i commented as it shows what will usually happen in these scenarios. If it's too much trouble for a seller to get it right i am not going to be a happy camper either.What would you do if you order a pepperoni pizza and a ham and pineapple pizza gets delivered ? Chow down thinking the pizza place will get it right next time ?
I respect everyone's right to have an opinion, even if it's different than mine. I appreciate MrPotatohead's input, and he made this a much more interesting discussion than if everyone agreed with me. It's always fun to have someone to stir the pot a bit and come up with different points of view.
Again, I did what I thought was right for not only me, but the eBay community as a whole. This guy doesn't deserve to be a seller on eBay. Under no circumstance should profanity EVER be used in a business transaction.
<< <i>I respect everyone's right to have an opinion, even if it's different than mine. I appreciate MrPotatohead's input, and he made this a much more interesting discussion than if everyone agreed with me. It's always fun to have someone to stir the pot a bit and come up with different points of view.
Again, I did what I thought was right for not only me, but the eBay community as a whole. This guy doesn't deserve to be a seller on eBay. Under no circumstance should profanity EVER be used in a business transaction.
-Paul >>
Paul,
Thanks for the post, I am a noob when it comes to selling on ebay and these threads always help me avoid potential conflicts.
Successful coin BST transactions with Gerard and segoja.
Successful card BST transactions with cbcnow, brogurt, gstarling, Bravesfan 007, and rajah 424.
<< <i>So, let me get this straight. You asked for a partial refund without returning the coin while hinting at bad feedback? Are you reallu surprised at the seller's reaction?
Russ, NCNE >>
This guy wanted me to waste a few dollars to send a 1967 Kennedy back, and then he SAID he was going to send a 64 Kennedy back. I simply didn't trust him to keep his word, do you blame me? I would have just been out my shipping fees PLUS the 40%er, and I really don't think I would have gotten the 64.
-Paul >>
There are dirtbags crawling all over eBay contacting sellers after receipt of an item claiming some sort of problem, and demanding partial refunds while threatening or hinting at bad feedback. This seller has no way of knowing that you aren't one of those dirtbags.
Russ, NCNE >>
I don't disagree. But I think my 400+ positive feedbacks should have said something.
-Paul >>
Should, but doesn't. Buyer feedback is meaningless now.
Who should pay for the shipping when a mistake like this is made? The buyer because he is returning a coin or the seller because it was his mistake? I know what I think, but want to hear others....
2nd question: Should the seller, particularly on a low value issue like this, cross-ship or wait until they got the item back in order to send the correct one? >>
Non-issue if I were the seller. I'd have just refunded the difference and let the buyer keep the coin since it was my mistake.
However, I can still see this seller's point of view. Feedback extortion happens all the time on eBay, and the OP's approach to this could certainly be interpreted that way.
<< <i>When i make a mistake i face up to it and rectify it , i don't defend it with ideas the buyer should empathise with me , they rarely do.Mr P's conversation with me hasn't originated with this particular transaction,i commented as it shows what will usually happen in these scenarios. If it's too much trouble for a seller to get it right i am not going to be a happy camper either.What would you do if you order a pepperoni pizza and a ham and pineapple pizza gets delivered ? Chow down thinking the pizza place will get it right next time ? >>
If I'm reading this thread correctly, the seller offered a refund but the buyer wanted to keep the coin AND get a refund which, IMO, is hardly equitable. Buyer could have returned the Kennedy for the price of a 1st Class stamp and ended it there but instead chose to make a Federal case out of what amounts to about $8. Absolutely, the seller made a mistake and should correct it but some buyers are just impossible to please.
<< <i>When i make a mistake i face up to it and rectify it , i don't defend it with ideas the buyer should empathise with me , they rarely do.Mr P's conversation with me hasn't originated with this particular transaction,i commented as it shows what will usually happen in these scenarios. If it's too much trouble for a seller to get it right i am not going to be a happy camper either.What would you do if you order a pepperoni pizza and a ham and pineapple pizza gets delivered ? Chow down thinking the pizza place will get it right next time ? >>
If I'm reading this thread correctly, the seller offered a refund but the buyer wanted to keep the coin AND get a refund which, IMO, is hardly equitable. Buyer could have returned the Kennedy for the price of a 1st Class stamp and ended it there but instead chose to make a Federal case out of what amounts to about $8. Absolutely, the seller made a mistake and should correct it but some buyers are just impossible to please. >>
The OP wanted the difference between the value of a 90% Half (what was listed on eBay) and a 40% Half (what he received in lieu of the 90% Half).
<< <i> If I'm reading this thread correctly, the seller offered a refund but the buyer wanted to keep the coin AND get a refund which, IMO, is hardly equitable. Buyer could have returned the Kennedy for the price of a 1st Class stamp and ended it there but instead chose to make a Federal case out of what amounts to about $8. Absolutely, the seller made a mistake and should correct it but some buyers are just impossible to please. >>
No wonder you think I'm crazy. I don't know what thread you're reading but it's certainly not this one.
1- Any mention of feedback is likely to piss off a seller. Meant as a threat or not, it's often taken that way. 2- The seller's language is unacceptable in any case, and it's for that above all else that I wouldn't want to do business with him. Tempers are never good.
Now, if it were me, I'd have done whatever made sense that the buyer wanted, whether it was replace the coin or refund the difference in value. My mistake, my problem. That said, I believe eBay/PayPal policy is that the item must be returned at the buyer's expense. This may be poor policy--if the seller screws up, the seller should pay for it--but it is what it is. Apart from the language, the seller was within his rights to request the return at your expense. Again, bad business practice, but within the letter of the law.
As far as language and feedback threats go, let's face it. Most people who sell a lot have dealt with plenty of buyers they'd love to send a nasty message to, and most have had a feedback threat of some kind. The importance that eBay places on feedback causes sellers to be on their guard, and while most buyers are fine, the occasional bad apple can be horrible to deal with.
I recently sold a set that I thought was original (though missing a coin), and didn't realize a different piece had been swapped out. The buyer got it and filed a claim with PayPal immediately. No courtesy to even email me, but rather just have the accusations fly immediately. It took a while to finally get the buyer to agree to return the set AT MY COST. Yes, the buyer was mad that it had to go back. This was an international package, and when I was sent the tracking number, I told the buyer I'd let him know when it arrived. Fast forward two weeks, I get an email with a feedback threat if I don't send a refund within 24 hours, and the PayPal dispute goes to a claim because I'm not communicating. I go to track the package, and it's still stuck in customs. Took another few days to convince the buyer that it hasn't arrived. Again, nothing polite, just anger.
I'm not saying what you did was that out of line (the feedback comment subject to my previously stated thoughts), but sometimes, the seller can do everything right (after the initial mistake) and the buyer still comes out throwing punches. I think the #1 thing I've learned being a seller is how to be a buyer. I give the benefit of the doubt, and I give sellers a chance to make things right. No need to ever say something inflammatory.
If you don't receive what you purchased on ebay, you file a "not as described" claim, return to sender with sig or del. confirmation as applicable and wait for your refund. An effort to work it out with the seller is commendable but should be aborted at the first sign of trouble. And yes, the return is at the buyer's expense - that comes with the territory.
Governments can print currency. Only the people can print faith in it — and they’re running low on ink.
<< <i> If I'm reading this thread correctly, the seller offered a refund but the buyer wanted to keep the coin AND get a refund which, IMO, is hardly equitable. Buyer could have returned the Kennedy for the price of a 1st Class stamp and ended it there but instead chose to make a Federal case out of what amounts to about $8. Absolutely, the seller made a mistake and should correct it but some buyers are just impossible to please. >>
No wonder you think I'm crazy. I don't know what thread you're reading but it's certainly not this one.
-Paul >>
Well I don't know if you are crazy or not but you said earlier that: "This guy wanted me to waste a few dollars to send a 1967 Kennedy back, and then he SAID he was going to send a 64 Kennedy back. I simply didn't trust him to keep his word, do you blame me? I would have just been out my shipping fees PLUS the 40%er, and I really don't think I would have gotten the 64. " So you clearly did NOT want to send the coin back (which could have been done for the price of a #10 envelope, a sheet of paper and a 1st Class stamp - certainly not a "few dollars". You wanted to have your cake and eat it, apparently.
<< <i> If I'm reading this thread correctly, the seller offered a refund but the buyer wanted to keep the coin AND get a refund which, IMO, is hardly equitable. Buyer could have returned the Kennedy for the price of a 1st Class stamp and ended it there but instead chose to make a Federal case out of what amounts to about $8. Absolutely, the seller made a mistake and should correct it but some buyers are just impossible to please. >>
No wonder you think I'm crazy. I don't know what thread you're reading but it's certainly not this one.
-Paul >>
Well I don't know if you are crazy or not but you said earlier that: "This guy wanted me to waste a few dollars to send a 1967 Kennedy back, and then he SAID he was going to send a 64 Kennedy back. I simply didn't trust him to keep his word, do you blame me? I would have just been out my shipping fees PLUS the 40%er, and I really don't think I would have gotten the 64. " So you clearly did NOT want to send the coin back (which could have been done for the price of a #10 envelope, a sheet of paper and a 1st Class stamp - certainly not a "few dollars". You wanted to have your cake and eat it, apparently. >>
That's not exactly what I call having your cake and eating it too. If I sent that coin back, I honestly feel like he would say he never got it and I'd be out $6+. Therefore I would have to put Delivery Confirmation on it, which means using a bubble mailer, which means a couple bucks to send it.
<< <i>When i make a mistake i face up to it and rectify it , >>
According to the OP, that's what the seller wanted to do- get the item he shipped in error returned and replace it with the proper item. For some reason, this was not acceptable to the buyer.
<< <i>If it's too much trouble for a seller to get it right i am not going to be a happy camper either. >>
Seller wanted to get it right- buyer didn't want to return the item that was sent by mistake.
<< <i>When i make a mistake i face up to it and rectify it , i don't defend it with ideas the buyer should empathise with me , they rarely do.Mr P's conversation with me hasn't originated with this particular transaction,i commented as it shows what will usually happen in these scenarios. If it's too much trouble for a seller to get it right i am not going to be a happy camper either.What would you do if you order a pepperoni pizza and a ham and pineapple pizza gets delivered ? Chow down thinking the pizza place will get it right next time ? >>
If I'm reading this thread correctly, the seller offered a refund but the buyer wanted to keep the coin AND get a refund which, IMO, is hardly equitable. Buyer could have returned the Kennedy for the price of a 1st Class stamp and ended it there but instead chose to make a Federal case out of what amounts to about $8. Absolutely, the seller made a mistake and should correct it but some buyers are just impossible to please. >>
Are you sure about the first class stamp thing? That is definitely not allowed by USPS regulations - it would have to go back with an additional charge for having a rigid object (coins can't "usually" pass through the automated machines) OR, it would have to be sent as a large envelope/package, making the minimum return postage $1.71 or $1.75, or so (with delivery confirmation).
Not a big bone of contention, but I sure the heck wouldn't be sending a coin as large (and rigid) as a half dollar back in a first class envelope...
John
John C. Knudsen, LM ANA 2342, LM CSNS 337 SFC, US Army (Ret.) 1974-1994
<< <i>When i make a mistake i face up to it and rectify it , >>
According to the OP, that's what the seller wanted to do- get the item he shipped in error returned and replace it with the proper item. For some reason, this was not acceptable to the buyer.
<< <i>If it's too much trouble for a seller to get it right i am not going to be a happy camper either. >>
Seller wanted to get it right- buyer didn't want to return the item that was sent by mistake.
edited- spelling >>
We both know and i posted early in the thread my point was not with this seller/buyer , our conversation began and revolved around a different thread in which you felt a seller is justified in sending what he has rather than what he listed.I only pointed out in this thread that the outcome has been pretty much as i had suspected in scenarios such as this.Ive no opinion on whos right or wrong in this thread , only interested that the outcome was just as i had thought.
<< <i>Are you sure about the first class stamp thing? That is definitely not allowed by USPS regulations - it would have to go back with an additional charge for having a rigid object (coins can't "usually" pass through the automated machines) OR, it would have to be sent as a large envelope/package, making the minimum return postage $1.71 or $1.75, or so (with delivery confirmation).
Not a big bone of contention, but I sure the heck wouldn't be sending a coin as large (and rigid) as a half dollar back in a first class envelope...
John >>
A half dollar coin isn't all that thick or heavy. Folded inside a couple of sheets of letter sized paper, it can easily be sent for the price of a 1st Class stamp in a #10 envelope. I've both sent and rec'd coins that way many times and have never had a problem.
<< <i>...our conversation began and revolved around a different thread in which you felt a seller is justified in sending what he has rather than what he listed. >>
Why are you continuing to insist that I have said things I have not?
In the thread in question, the situation was that the seller listed one thing in the title and a different one in the description. Clearly, one of those (title/description) is in error. My claim is, and has always been, that in the situation described, the seller is justified in sending the item he intended (and has on hand) to sell, and is not obligated to send the item he didn't intend (and does not have on hand) to sell.
It's a pretty simple concept- you can't send somebody something you don't have.
<< <i>...our conversation began and revolved around a different thread in which you felt a seller is justified in sending what he has rather than what he listed. >>
Why are you continuing to insist that I have said things I have not?
In the thread in question, the situation was that the seller listed one thing in the title and a different one in the description. Clearly, one of those (title/description) is in error. My claim is, and has always been, that in the situation described, the seller is justified in sending the item he intended (and has on hand) to sell, and is not obligated to send the item he didn't intend (and does not have on hand) to sell.
It's a pretty simple concept- you can't send somebody something you don't have. >>
..groan..here we go again..you have said the seller was justified in sending whatever he had regardless of what the buyer expects and theres the end to it.I said in the scenario as that the seller will be negged up one wall and down the other.What part don't you understand ?
1- Any mention of feedback is likely to piss off a seller. Meant as a threat or not, it's often taken that way. 2- The seller's language is unacceptable in any case, and it's for that above all else that I wouldn't want to do business with him. Tempers are never good.
Now, if it were me, I'd have done whatever made sense that the buyer wanted, whether it was replace the coin or refund the difference in value. My mistake, my problem. That said, I believe eBay/PayPal policy is that the item must be returned at the buyer's expense. This may be poor policy--if the seller screws up, the seller should pay for it--but it is what it is. Apart from the language, the seller was within his rights to request the return at your expense. Again, bad business practice, but within the letter of the law.
As far as language and feedback threats go, let's face it. Most people who sell a lot have dealt with plenty of buyers they'd love to send a nasty message to, and most have had a feedback threat of some kind. The importance that eBay places on feedback causes sellers to be on their guard, and while most buyers are fine, the occasional bad apple can be horrible to deal with.
I recently sold a set that I thought was original (though missing a coin), and didn't realize a different piece had been swapped out. The buyer got it and filed a claim with PayPal immediately. No courtesy to even email me, but rather just have the accusations fly immediately. It took a while to finally get the buyer to agree to return the set AT MY COST. Yes, the buyer was mad that it had to go back. This was an international package, and when I was sent the tracking number, I told the buyer I'd let him know when it arrived. Fast forward two weeks, I get an email with a feedback threat if I don't send a refund within 24 hours, and the PayPal dispute goes to a claim because I'm not communicating. I go to track the package, and it's still stuck in customs. Took another few days to convince the buyer that it hasn't arrived. Again, nothing polite, just anger.
I'm not saying what you did was that out of line (the feedback comment subject to my previously stated thoughts), but sometimes, the seller can do everything right (after the initial mistake) and the buyer still comes out throwing punches. I think the #1 thing I've learned being a seller is how to be a buyer. I give the benefit of the doubt, and I give sellers a chance to make things right. No need to ever say something inflammatory. >>
Jeremy could not have said it better. This is truly how a gentleman should handle these situations whether they are the seller or the purchaser! Kudos Jeremy!
Charter member of CA, Coinaholics Anonymous-6/7/2003 Kewpie Doll award-10/29/2007 Successful BST transactions with Coinboy and Wondercoin.
In this particular scenario I'd just ship the guy a '64, let him keep the 40% coin and be done with it. It's not worth getting all bent out of shape over. I would however add this person to my BBL for any implied negative FB threat and also report same to ebay as FB extortion.
Seller messed up. Simple. He should have rectified it, meaning he should have sent the buyer a prepaid envelope are resend the coin that was stated in the description. That is the right thing to do, that course of action I take with my customers.
<< <i>Seller messed up. Simple. He should have rectified it, meaning he should have sent the buyer a prepaid envelope are resend the coin that was stated in the description. That is the right thing to do, that course of action I take with my customers. >>
Yup, the proper way to do it. The seller has to make it all right.
And for all we know the seller was a dirt bag and substituted the 1967 on purpose. And if the OP sent back the coin, I would certainly consider the fact that the seller would claim they received an empty package, etc. The dirtbag game can go back and forth until postage and handling bleeds both parties into the red. I would have done exactly as the OP did. Once I've been shorted in a transaction where the potential to be further shortchanged occurs, I'm not about to take that path. I learned that lesson years ago in a Coin World mail bid sale that included about $900 in overgraded better date seated coins. Rather than eat the $400 loss, I returned all the coins for a "full refund" as guaranteed by the seller. Unfortunately they changed their minds once the coins were in hand and kept my $1,000 and the coins worth $500. All of a sudden only losing $400 wasn't such a bad outcome. And the real irony of that was that in that group was a perfect original and problem free 1855-s 50c in VF25 that was advertised as an XF (worth $275 then). Even today that VF coin would be worth thousands.
Comments
Seems like lots of people have problems with Mr.P......
He seems to always take a contrarian position. Must be a lawyer!!!
Successful BST xactions w/PCcoins, Drunner, Manofcoins, Rampage, docg, Poppee, RobKool, and MichealDixon.
<< <i>
<< <i>Ok then , lets get it straight , you are saying a seller can list an item and send a different item and the buyer should leave a positive because after all it was a mistake on the sellers part. >>
No, you don't have it straight. That's not what I'm saying.
One more time- sometimes, sellers make mistakes in their listings. The fact you happen to bid on one is no reason to expect to get something the seller doesn't have. Example- seller intends to sell a 1977 proof set and mistypes the description as "1987". You win the auction, but you're not going to get a 1987 set because the seller doesn't have one. This would seem to be self-evident. The adult response to a seller making such a mistake is to treat him the same way you'd like to be treated when (not if) you make a mistake yourself. Feedback is optional. >>
Two key words there buddy , Seller & Mistake. Why should a buyer accept a sellers mistake ? You know that won't fly.
<< <i>Two key words there buddy , Seller & Mistake. Why should a buyer accept a sellers mistake ? You know that won't fly. >>
So all sellers should be infallible?
You never make mistakes?
If I was the seller on this deal I would have offered a partial refund based on the difference in bullion value and ended it there.
The buyer was, IMO, a giant PITA and wouldn't have been satisfied under any circumstances.
<< <i>
<< <i>Two key words there buddy , Seller & Mistake. Why should a buyer accept a sellers mistake ? You know that won't fly. >>
So all sellers should be infallible?
You never make mistakes?
If I was the seller on this deal I would have offered a partial refund based on the difference in bullion value and ended it there.
The buyer was, IMO, a giant PITA and wouldn't have been satisfied under any circumstances. >>
When i make a mistake i face up to it and rectify it , i don't defend it with ideas the buyer should empathise with me , they rarely do.Mr P's conversation with me hasn't originated with this particular transaction,i commented as it shows what will usually happen in these scenarios.
If it's too much trouble for a seller to get it right i am not going to be a happy camper either.What would you do if you order a pepperoni pizza and a ham and pineapple pizza gets delivered ? Chow down thinking the pizza place will get it right next time ?
Again, I did what I thought was right for not only me, but the eBay community as a whole. This guy doesn't deserve to be a seller on eBay. Under no circumstance should profanity EVER be used in a business transaction.
-Paul
<< <i>I respect everyone's right to have an opinion, even if it's different than mine. I appreciate MrPotatohead's input, and he made this a much more interesting discussion than if everyone agreed with me. It's always fun to have someone to stir the pot a bit and come up with different points of view.
Again, I did what I thought was right for not only me, but the eBay community as a whole. This guy doesn't deserve to be a seller on eBay. Under no circumstance should profanity EVER be used in a business transaction.
-Paul >>
Paul,
Thanks for the post, I am a noob when it comes to selling on ebay and these threads always help me avoid potential conflicts.
Successful card BST transactions with cbcnow, brogurt, gstarling, Bravesfan 007, and rajah 424.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>So, let me get this straight. You asked for a partial refund without returning the coin while hinting at bad feedback? Are you reallu surprised at the seller's reaction?
Russ, NCNE >>
This guy wanted me to waste a few dollars to send a 1967 Kennedy back, and then he SAID he was going to send a 64 Kennedy back. I simply didn't trust him to keep his word, do you blame me? I would have just been out my shipping fees PLUS the 40%er, and I really don't think I would have gotten the 64.
-Paul >>
There are dirtbags crawling all over eBay contacting sellers after receipt of an item claiming some sort of problem, and demanding partial refunds while threatening or hinting at bad feedback. This seller has no way of knowing that you aren't one of those dirtbags.
Russ, NCNE >>
I don't disagree. But I think my 400+ positive feedbacks should have said something.
-Paul >>
Should, but doesn't. Buyer feedback is meaningless now.
<< <i>I'm not taking sides but let me ask this:
Who should pay for the shipping when a mistake like this is made? The buyer because he is returning a coin or the seller because it was his mistake?
I know what I think, but want to hear others....
2nd question:
Should the seller, particularly on a low value issue like this, cross-ship or wait until they got the item back in order to send the correct one? >>
Non-issue if I were the seller. I'd have just refunded the difference and let the buyer keep the coin since it was my mistake.
However, I can still see this seller's point of view. Feedback extortion happens all the time on eBay, and the OP's approach to this could certainly be interpreted that way.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>When i make a mistake i face up to it and rectify it , i don't defend it with ideas the buyer should empathise with me , they rarely do.Mr P's conversation with me hasn't originated with this particular transaction,i commented as it shows what will usually happen in these scenarios.
If it's too much trouble for a seller to get it right i am not going to be a happy camper either.What would you do if you order a pepperoni pizza and a ham and pineapple pizza gets delivered ? Chow down thinking the pizza place will get it right next time ? >>
If I'm reading this thread correctly, the seller offered a refund but the buyer wanted to keep the coin AND get a refund which, IMO, is hardly equitable.
Buyer could have returned the Kennedy for the price of a 1st Class stamp and ended it there but instead chose to make a Federal case out of what amounts to about $8.
Absolutely, the seller made a mistake and should correct it but some buyers are just impossible to please.
<< <i>
<< <i>When i make a mistake i face up to it and rectify it , i don't defend it with ideas the buyer should empathise with me , they rarely do.Mr P's conversation with me hasn't originated with this particular transaction,i commented as it shows what will usually happen in these scenarios.
If it's too much trouble for a seller to get it right i am not going to be a happy camper either.What would you do if you order a pepperoni pizza and a ham and pineapple pizza gets delivered ? Chow down thinking the pizza place will get it right next time ? >>
If I'm reading this thread correctly, the seller offered a refund but the buyer wanted to keep the coin AND get a refund which, IMO, is hardly equitable.
Buyer could have returned the Kennedy for the price of a 1st Class stamp and ended it there but instead chose to make a Federal case out of what amounts to about $8.
Absolutely, the seller made a mistake and should correct it but some buyers are just impossible to please. >>
The OP wanted the difference between the value of a 90% Half (what was listed on eBay) and a 40% Half (what he received in lieu of the 90% Half).
<< <i>
If I'm reading this thread correctly, the seller offered a refund but the buyer wanted to keep the coin AND get a refund which, IMO, is hardly equitable.
Buyer could have returned the Kennedy for the price of a 1st Class stamp and ended it there but instead chose to make a Federal case out of what amounts to about $8.
Absolutely, the seller made a mistake and should correct it but some buyers are just impossible to please. >>
No wonder you think I'm crazy. I don't know what thread you're reading but it's certainly not this one.
-Paul
1- Any mention of feedback is likely to piss off a seller. Meant as a threat or not, it's often taken that way.
2- The seller's language is unacceptable in any case, and it's for that above all else that I wouldn't want to do business with him. Tempers are never good.
Now, if it were me, I'd have done whatever made sense that the buyer wanted, whether it was replace the coin or refund the difference in value. My mistake, my problem. That said, I believe eBay/PayPal policy is that the item must be returned at the buyer's expense. This may be poor policy--if the seller screws up, the seller should pay for it--but it is what it is. Apart from the language, the seller was within his rights to request the return at your expense. Again, bad business practice, but within the letter of the law.
As far as language and feedback threats go, let's face it. Most people who sell a lot have dealt with plenty of buyers they'd love to send a nasty message to, and most have had a feedback threat of some kind. The importance that eBay places on feedback causes sellers to be on their guard, and while most buyers are fine, the occasional bad apple can be horrible to deal with.
I recently sold a set that I thought was original (though missing a coin), and didn't realize a different piece had been swapped out. The buyer got it and filed a claim with PayPal immediately. No courtesy to even email me, but rather just have the accusations fly immediately. It took a while to finally get the buyer to agree to return the set AT MY COST. Yes, the buyer was mad that it had to go back. This was an international package, and when I was sent the tracking number, I told the buyer I'd let him know when it arrived. Fast forward two weeks, I get an email with a feedback threat if I don't send a refund within 24 hours, and the PayPal dispute goes to a claim because I'm not communicating. I go to track the package, and it's still stuck in customs. Took another few days to convince the buyer that it hasn't arrived. Again, nothing polite, just anger.
I'm not saying what you did was that out of line (the feedback comment subject to my previously stated thoughts), but sometimes, the seller can do everything right (after the initial mistake) and the buyer still comes out throwing punches. I think the #1 thing I've learned being a seller is how to be a buyer. I give the benefit of the doubt, and I give sellers a chance to make things right. No need to ever say something inflammatory.
Governments can print currency. Only the people can print faith in it — and they’re running low on ink.
-Paul
<< <i>
<< <i>
If I'm reading this thread correctly, the seller offered a refund but the buyer wanted to keep the coin AND get a refund which, IMO, is hardly equitable.
Buyer could have returned the Kennedy for the price of a 1st Class stamp and ended it there but instead chose to make a Federal case out of what amounts to about $8.
Absolutely, the seller made a mistake and should correct it but some buyers are just impossible to please. >>
No wonder you think I'm crazy. I don't know what thread you're reading but it's certainly not this one.
-Paul >>
Well I don't know if you are crazy or not but you said earlier that:
"This guy wanted me to waste a few dollars to send a 1967 Kennedy back, and then he SAID he was going to send a 64 Kennedy back. I simply didn't trust him to keep his word, do you blame me? I would have just been out my shipping fees PLUS the 40%er, and I really don't think I would have gotten the 64. "
So you clearly did NOT want to send the coin back (which could have been done for the price of a #10 envelope, a sheet of paper and a 1st Class stamp - certainly not a "few dollars".
You wanted to have your cake and eat it, apparently.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
If I'm reading this thread correctly, the seller offered a refund but the buyer wanted to keep the coin AND get a refund which, IMO, is hardly equitable.
Buyer could have returned the Kennedy for the price of a 1st Class stamp and ended it there but instead chose to make a Federal case out of what amounts to about $8.
Absolutely, the seller made a mistake and should correct it but some buyers are just impossible to please. >>
No wonder you think I'm crazy. I don't know what thread you're reading but it's certainly not this one.
-Paul >>
Well I don't know if you are crazy or not but you said earlier that:
"This guy wanted me to waste a few dollars to send a 1967 Kennedy back, and then he SAID he was going to send a 64 Kennedy back. I simply didn't trust him to keep his word, do you blame me? I would have just been out my shipping fees PLUS the 40%er, and I really don't think I would have gotten the 64. "
So you clearly did NOT want to send the coin back (which could have been done for the price of a #10 envelope, a sheet of paper and a 1st Class stamp - certainly not a "few dollars".
You wanted to have your cake and eat it, apparently. >>
That's not exactly what I call having your cake and eating it too. If I sent that coin back, I honestly feel like he would say he never got it and I'd be out $6+. Therefore I would have to put Delivery Confirmation on it, which means using a bubble mailer, which means a couple bucks to send it.
-Paul
<< <i>Two key words there buddy , Seller & Mistake. Why should a buyer accept a sellers mistake ? >>
I don't know- because you understand everybody makes them sometimes?
<< <i>You know that won't fly. >>
Not on eBay, anyway. Not that anybody disputes this, of course.
<< <i>When i make a mistake i face up to it and rectify it , >>
According to the OP, that's what the seller wanted to do- get the item he shipped in error returned and replace it with the proper item. For some reason, this was not acceptable to the buyer.
<< <i>If it's too much trouble for a seller to get it right i am not going to be a happy camper either. >>
Seller wanted to get it right- buyer didn't want to return the item that was sent by mistake.
edited- spelling
<< <i>
<< <i>When i make a mistake i face up to it and rectify it , i don't defend it with ideas the buyer should empathise with me , they rarely do.Mr P's conversation with me hasn't originated with this particular transaction,i commented as it shows what will usually happen in these scenarios.
If it's too much trouble for a seller to get it right i am not going to be a happy camper either.What would you do if you order a pepperoni pizza and a ham and pineapple pizza gets delivered ? Chow down thinking the pizza place will get it right next time ? >>
If I'm reading this thread correctly, the seller offered a refund but the buyer wanted to keep the coin AND get a refund which, IMO, is hardly equitable.
Buyer could have returned the Kennedy for the price of a 1st Class stamp and ended it there but instead chose to make a Federal case out of what amounts to about $8.
Absolutely, the seller made a mistake and should correct it but some buyers are just impossible to please. >>
Are you sure about the first class stamp thing? That is definitely not allowed by USPS regulations - it would have to go back with an additional charge for having a rigid object
(coins can't "usually" pass through the automated machines) OR, it would have to be sent as a large envelope/package, making the minimum return postage $1.71 or $1.75, or
so (with delivery confirmation).
Not a big bone of contention, but I sure the heck wouldn't be sending a coin as large (and rigid) as a half dollar back in a first class envelope...
John
SFC, US Army (Ret.) 1974-1994
<< <i>
<< <i>When i make a mistake i face up to it and rectify it , >>
According to the OP, that's what the seller wanted to do- get the item he shipped in error returned and replace it with the proper item. For some reason, this was not acceptable to the buyer.
<< <i>If it's too much trouble for a seller to get it right i am not going to be a happy camper either. >>
Seller wanted to get it right- buyer didn't want to return the item that was sent by mistake.
edited- spelling >>
We both know and i posted early in the thread my point was not with this seller/buyer , our conversation began and revolved around a different thread in which you felt a seller is justified in sending what he has rather than what he listed.I only pointed out in this thread that the outcome has been pretty much as i had suspected in scenarios such as this.Ive no opinion on whos right or wrong in this thread , only interested that the outcome was just as i had thought.
<< <i>Are you sure about the first class stamp thing? That is definitely not allowed by USPS regulations - it would have to go back with an additional charge for having a rigid object
(coins can't "usually" pass through the automated machines) OR, it would have to be sent as a large envelope/package, making the minimum return postage $1.71 or $1.75, or
so (with delivery confirmation).
Not a big bone of contention, but I sure the heck wouldn't be sending a coin as large (and rigid) as a half dollar back in a first class envelope...
John >>
A half dollar coin isn't all that thick or heavy. Folded inside a couple of sheets of letter sized paper, it can easily be sent for the price of a 1st Class stamp in a #10 envelope. I've both sent and rec'd coins that way many times and have never had a problem.
<< <i>...our conversation began and revolved around a different thread in which you felt a seller is justified in sending what he has rather than what he listed. >>
Why are you continuing to insist that I have said things I have not?
In the thread in question, the situation was that the seller listed one thing in the title and a different one in the description. Clearly, one of those (title/description) is in error. My claim is, and has always been, that in the situation described, the seller is justified in sending the item he intended (and has on hand) to sell, and is not obligated to send the item he didn't intend (and does not have on hand) to sell.
It's a pretty simple concept- you can't send somebody something you don't have.
<< <i>
<< <i>...our conversation began and revolved around a different thread in which you felt a seller is justified in sending what he has rather than what he listed. >>
Why are you continuing to insist that I have said things I have not?
In the thread in question, the situation was that the seller listed one thing in the title and a different one in the description. Clearly, one of those (title/description) is in error. My claim is, and has always been, that in the situation described, the seller is justified in sending the item he intended (and has on hand) to sell, and is not obligated to send the item he didn't intend (and does not have on hand) to sell.
It's a pretty simple concept- you can't send somebody something you don't have. >>
..groan..here we go again..you have said the seller was justified in sending whatever he had regardless of what the buyer expects and theres the end to it.I said in the scenario as that the seller will be negged up one wall and down the other.What part don't you understand ?
<< <i>Here's my take...
1- Any mention of feedback is likely to piss off a seller. Meant as a threat or not, it's often taken that way.
2- The seller's language is unacceptable in any case, and it's for that above all else that I wouldn't want to do business with him. Tempers are never good.
Now, if it were me, I'd have done whatever made sense that the buyer wanted, whether it was replace the coin or refund the difference in value. My mistake, my problem. That said, I believe eBay/PayPal policy is that the item must be returned at the buyer's expense. This may be poor policy--if the seller screws up, the seller should pay for it--but it is what it is. Apart from the language, the seller was within his rights to request the return at your expense. Again, bad business practice, but within the letter of the law.
As far as language and feedback threats go, let's face it. Most people who sell a lot have dealt with plenty of buyers they'd love to send a nasty message to, and most have had a feedback threat of some kind. The importance that eBay places on feedback causes sellers to be on their guard, and while most buyers are fine, the occasional bad apple can be horrible to deal with.
I recently sold a set that I thought was original (though missing a coin), and didn't realize a different piece had been swapped out. The buyer got it and filed a claim with PayPal immediately. No courtesy to even email me, but rather just have the accusations fly immediately. It took a while to finally get the buyer to agree to return the set AT MY COST. Yes, the buyer was mad that it had to go back. This was an international package, and when I was sent the tracking number, I told the buyer I'd let him know when it arrived. Fast forward two weeks, I get an email with a feedback threat if I don't send a refund within 24 hours, and the PayPal dispute goes to a claim because I'm not communicating. I go to track the package, and it's still stuck in customs. Took another few days to convince the buyer that it hasn't arrived. Again, nothing polite, just anger.
I'm not saying what you did was that out of line (the feedback comment subject to my previously stated thoughts), but sometimes, the seller can do everything right (after the initial mistake) and the buyer still comes out throwing punches. I think the #1 thing I've learned being a seller is how to be a buyer. I give the benefit of the doubt, and I give sellers a chance to make things right. No need to ever say something inflammatory. >>
Jeremy could not have said it better. This is truly how a gentleman should handle these situations whether they are the seller or the purchaser! Kudos Jeremy!
Kewpie Doll award-10/29/2007
Successful BST transactions with Coinboy and Wondercoin.
I would however add this person to my BBL for any implied negative FB threat and also report same to ebay as FB extortion.
RIP Mom- 1932-2012
"wanted refund and keep the coin total rip off avoid"
Just got off the phone with eBay though, and they're removing it, as they should.
-Paul
This comment has been removed by eBay.
Seller: joeyshay69 ( 44)
No longer a registered user
Glad that's over with!
-Paul
<< <i>Seller messed up. Simple. He should have rectified it, meaning he should have sent the buyer a prepaid envelope are resend the coin that was stated in the description. That is the right thing to do, that course of action I take with my customers. >>
Yup, the proper way to do it. The seller has to make it all right.
And for all we know the seller was a dirt bag and substituted the 1967 on purpose. And if the OP sent back the coin, I would certainly consider the fact that the seller would claim
they received an empty package, etc. The dirtbag game can go back and forth until postage and handling bleeds both parties into the red. I would have done exactly as the OP
did. Once I've been shorted in a transaction where the potential to be further shortchanged occurs, I'm not about to take that path. I learned that lesson years ago in a Coin World
mail bid sale that included about $900 in overgraded better date seated coins. Rather than eat the $400 loss, I returned all the coins for a "full refund" as guaranteed by the seller.
Unfortunately they changed their minds once the coins were in hand and kept my $1,000 and the coins worth $500. All of a sudden only losing $400 wasn't such a bad outcome. And the
real irony of that was that in that group was a perfect original and problem free 1855-s 50c in VF25 that was advertised as an XF (worth $275 then). Even today that VF coin would
be worth thousands.
roadrunner