Options
An ebayer to block.....joeyshay69 - Final update!!
coinkid855
Posts: 5,012 ✭✭✭
joeyshay69. I bought a lot from him that consisted of a 1oz silver round and what was in the description as a "64 kennedy." He ended up sending a 67. After a few relatively polite emails, I told him I didn't want to neg him and would rather work it out. He didn't like my idea and here's his (edited) mail response to my neg:
"told u id refund **** u . ebay ***** if u arent rippeing off seller u feel ripped off **** off and die loser"
Save yourself the trouble.
-Paul
Edited to fix username.
"told u id refund **** u . ebay ***** if u arent rippeing off seller u feel ripped off **** off and die loser"
Save yourself the trouble.
-Paul
Edited to fix username.
0
Comments
Very unprofessional.
Never do business with someone like him/her.
Thanks for the heads-up.
Governments can print currency. Only the people can print faith in it — and they’re running low on ink.
<< <i>I would defintely report him to ebay.
Very unprofessional.
Never do business with someone like him/her.
Thanks for the heads-up. >>
Oh I did, don't worry. He already has another negative from a recent sale too. He'll be NARU'd soon enough.
-Paul
<< <i>Never mention neg feedback in an ebay message when trying to resolve a conflict with a seller. He could easily report feedback extortion and ebay would agree with him. >>
I actually didn't, even though I sort of alluded to it in my OP. I mentioned that if we could resolve the issue I would still leave a positive. I wouldn't exactly call that a threat.
-Paul
Buyers:
The buyer isn't allowed to threaten to use Feedback or detailed seller ratings in an attempt to force a seller into providing:
- Goods or services that weren't included in the original item's description or purchase price
- A refund
- A return
Russ, NCNE
Drunner
(English teacher and Doily Slut)
<< <i>So, let me get this straight. You asked for a partial refund without returning the coin while hinting at bad feedback? Are you reallu surprised at the seller's reaction?
Russ, NCNE >>
This guy wanted me to waste a few dollars to send a 1967 Kennedy back, and then he SAID he was going to send a 64 Kennedy back. I simply didn't trust him to keep his word, do you blame me? I would have just been out my shipping fees PLUS the 40%er, and I really don't think I would have gotten the 64.
-Paul
<< <i>Never deal with anyone who can't use proper grammar and syntax on eBay. I've found that 99% + of our problems here are from people who do not have a command of the English language.
Drunner
(English teacher and Doily Slut) >>
I agree 100%!
-Paul
<< <i>
<< <i>So, let me get this straight. You asked for a partial refund without returning the coin while hinting at bad feedback? Are you reallu surprised at the seller's reaction?
Russ, NCNE >>
This guy wanted me to waste a few dollars to send a 1967 Kennedy back, and then he SAID he was going to send a 64 Kennedy back. I simply didn't trust him to keep his word, do you blame me? I would have just been out my shipping fees PLUS the 40%er, and I really don't think I would have gotten the 64.
-Paul >>
There are dirtbags crawling all over eBay contacting sellers after receipt of an item claiming some sort of problem, and demanding partial refunds while threatening or hinting at bad feedback. This seller has no way of knowing that you aren't one of those dirtbags.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>This guy wanted me to waste a few dollars to send a 1967 Kennedy back, and then he SAID he was going to send a 64 Kennedy back. I simply didn't trust him to keep his word, do you blame me? >>
You trusted him enough to make the purchase in the first place. And from your first post, had a polite email exchange until you brought up the issue of feedback. I know you said it wasn't a threat, but do you suppose it's possible he saw things differently?
<< <i>
<< <i>This guy wanted me to waste a few dollars to send a 1967 Kennedy back, and then he SAID he was going to send a 64 Kennedy back. I simply didn't trust him to keep his word, do you blame me? >>
You trusted him enough to make the purchase in the first place. And from your first post, had a polite email exchange until you brought up the issue of feedback. I know you said it wasn't a threat, but do you suppose it's possible he saw things differently? >>
Yes, apparently he did. But he clearly should not be selling on eBay if he's going to lash out the way he did over one unhappy buyer, especially when it's justified.
-Paul
<< <i>Never deal with anyone who can't use proper grammar and syntax on eBay. I've found that 99% + of our problems here are from people who do not have a command of the English language. >>
Yes! That's red flag #1 in my book... and all I need is one. Minor typos are one thing; not even trying (and probably thinking it's cool) is quite another.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>So, let me get this straight. You asked for a partial refund without returning the coin while hinting at bad feedback? Are you reallu surprised at the seller's reaction?
Russ, NCNE >>
This guy wanted me to waste a few dollars to send a 1967 Kennedy back, and then he SAID he was going to send a 64 Kennedy back. I simply didn't trust him to keep his word, do you blame me? I would have just been out my shipping fees PLUS the 40%er, and I really don't think I would have gotten the 64.
-Paul >>
There are dirtbags crawling all over eBay contacting sellers after receipt of an item claiming some sort of problem, and demanding partial refunds while threatening or hinting at bad feedback. This seller has no way of knowing that you aren't one of those dirtbags.
Russ, NCNE >>
I don't disagree. But I think my 400+ positive feedbacks should have said something.
-Paul
<< <i>Yes, apparently he did. But he clearly should not be selling on eBay if he's going to lash out the way he did over one unhappy buyer, especially when it's justified. >>
Just a wild guess, but I'll bet he feels his actions are justified, too. Sorry, but IMO- when you bring feedback into a discussion over a problem transaction, you're just asking for trouble.
<< <i>
<< <i>Yes, apparently he did. But he clearly should not be selling on eBay if he's going to lash out the way he did over one unhappy buyer, especially when it's justified. >>
Just a wild guess, but I'll bet he feels his actions are justified, too. Sorry, but IMO- when you bring feedback into a discussion over a problem transaction, you're just asking for trouble. >>
Fair enough. I really did try not to sound like I was threatening him though. Oh well.
-Paul
<< <i>Auction ended on 9/13, negative feedback was left on 9/20. Allowing a minimum of two days for delivery, that's just five days to work out any issues before dropping the bomb. Pretty quick on the trigger, I'd say. But then, that's just me... >>
I sent him an email yesterday, and he responded tonight. At first he told me the auction stated I would receive a 67 Kennedy Half, which it clearly doesn't. I already sent my first message when he admitted I was right. But after that it quickly went south, obviously, resulting in the Neg.
-Paul
<< <i>But after that it quickly went south... >>
Without the return of the coin that was shipped to you in error, I'm not surprised. Try looking at it from his point of view- he's got the coin you shipped by mistake, won't return it, and is hinting at leaving you negative feedback. How happy are you going to be with the situation?
<< <i>
<< <i>But after that it quickly went south... >>
Without the return of the coin that was shipped to you in error, I'm not surprised. Try looking at it from his point of view- he's got the coin you shipped by mistake, won't return it, and is hinting at leaving you negative feedback. How happy are you going to be with the situation? >>
Let's get this straight. This isn't a coin, really. It's bullion. He sent me 0.15oz instead of the 0.37oz I was supposed to get. So now because of HIS mistake, I have to send him the 0.15 oz back on MY dime and then HOPE he sends me the rest? If I were him, I would send me the difference in value via Paypal without hesitation and would apologize for MY mistake.
He stated in one of his emails that he was no longer going to sell on eBay anyways because of the poor prices he got (undoubtedly because of his spelling), so why would I send a coin back to someone who has no fear of getting a neg? He probably already closed out his Paypal, so I'd be stuck. Again, he blew this way out of proportions. It's $8. I cared more on principle than anything. He wanted it his way, I wanted it mine, and he didn't want to negotiate. Neg, move on, end of story.
-Paul
<< <i>So now because of HIS mistake, I have to send him the 0.15 oz back on MY dime and then HOPE he sends me the rest? If I were him, I would send me the difference in value via Paypal without hesitation and would apologize for MY mistake. >>
When you're buying, you don't get to insist that sellers do things the way you would if you were the seller. Without having seen the actual communications from both parties, it's hard to be sure exactly who's responsible for what here. Based on the feedback he's received (you did look at it before bidding, didn't you?) he appears to be new to selling on eBay. Just right there, you've got a good reason to think there could be issues that wouldn't arise with a more experienced seller, I'd think.
<< <i>He probably already closed out his Paypal, so I'd be stuck. >>
And he probably figures after he sent you a refund, you'd leave a neg anyway. Why shouldn't he assume the worst? You are.
<< <i>Again, he blew this way out of proportions. >>
You left negative feedback after less than a week, and he's the one blowing things out of proportion?
<< <i>It's $8. I cared more on principle than anything. He wanted it his way, I wanted it mine, and he didn't want to negotiate. >>
Negotiate what? He wanted the coin that was shipped in error returned in order to replace it and you apparently refused. His refund policy (you read it, didn't you?) doesn't provide for partial refunds so why should he negiotiate, anyway?
<< <i>Neg, move on, end of story. >>
Nice.
I am not taking sides but he does have a point-you should send back the wrong coin and he would send you the right coin in return. This is the correct way to correct this mistake, Or at his option send you the difference in silver value. The pix is not clear enough to determine the date on the coin. Anyone who leaves this kind of feedback;
<< <i> Reply by joeyshay69 (Sep-20-11 16:13): buyer wouldnt send back coin i sent to get right coin just wanted refund. fn ass >>
i do not want to deal with. Thanks for the heads-up. Bob
-Paul
Who should pay for the shipping when a mistake like this is made? The buyer because he is returning a coin or the seller because it was his mistake?
I know what I think, but want to hear others....
2nd question:
Should the seller, particularly on a low value issue like this, cross-ship or wait until they got the item back in order to send the correct one?
I've been told I tolerate fools poorly...that may explain things if I have a problem with you. Current ebay items - Nothing at the moment
<< <i>I'm not taking sides but let me ask this:
Who should pay for the shipping when a mistake like this is made? The buyer because he is returning a coin or the seller because it was his mistake?
I know what I think, but want to hear others....
2nd question:
Should the seller, particularly on a low value issue like this, cross-ship or wait until they got the item back in order to send the correct one? >>
The seller should pay for shipping, however this is an eBay transaction, and given ebay's backwards logic, the seller probably isn't responsible.
The seller should ship the second item once the wrong item is received.
<< <i>Side with the guy who told me to f off and go die, >>
I'm not siding with anybody here- you both could be (and IMO, are, from what's been posted so far) at fault here. It would be interesting to have a chance to see the correspondence between both parties for this transaction in order to better evaluate the situation, I'd think.
<< <i>Obviously he's not someone you'd want to deal with on eBay, so you're welcome. >>
These kinds of threads are good for pointing out people who might be best avoided as buyers/sellers, that's for sure.
<< <i>Stop chastising me for trying to help. >>
I'm trying to help, too. Why are you chastising me?
<< <i>i claimed in a scenario like this the buyer would prevail and the seller likely negged if it came to a dispute...whadda ya know. >>
Of course a buyer can neg a seller. Whenever they feel like it. Does anybody believe otherwise?
<< <i>The seller does have a great looking scottish sword for sale, at only $750 starting bid- nickel plating anyone? Tassels?
I don't know much about swords,but I don't think that is a broad sword. More like a dress sword- not heavy enough to be a broad sword.
<< <i>So, let me get this straight. You asked for a partial refund without returning the coin while hinting at bad feedback? Are you reallu surprised at the seller's reaction? >>
<< <i>This guy wanted me to waste a few dollars to send a 1967 Kennedy back, and then he SAID he was going to send a 64 Kennedy back. I simply didn't trust him to keep his word, do you blame me? I would have just been out my shipping fees PLUS the 40%er, and I really don't think I would have gotten the 64. >>
So the seller made a mistake and sent you the wrong coin, well sh*t happens.
Then you refuse to return the coin and hint at negative feedback if he doesn't accept your grossly unfair scenario.
Interesting.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
<< <i>
<< <i>Never mention neg feedback in an ebay message when trying to resolve a conflict with a seller. He could easily report feedback extortion and ebay would agree with him. >>
I actually didn't, even though I sort of alluded to it in my OP. I mentioned that if we could resolve the issue I would still leave a positive. I wouldn't exactly call that a threat.
-Paul >>
Quote from your original post "I told him I didn't want to neg him".
I'd say you did a bit more than allude to it.
<< <i>
<< <i>i claimed in a scenario like this the buyer would prevail and the seller likely negged if it came to a dispute...whadda ya know. >>
Of course a buyer can neg a seller. Whenever they feel like it. Does anybody believe otherwise? >>
Yes , perhaps i should have mentioned your stance was a seller can list one thing but send whatever it is he likes or "intended" to list and still be defendable.
<< <i>When the seller offered a 900 fine silver coin and then sent a 400 fine silver coin, suggesting a small price adjustment sounds like a quick and simple solution that would be fair to both parties without the hassel and expense of shipping by both of the parties involved. Fortunately, we aren't talking about a real expensive coin here. >>
Exactly! The price difference was technically $8.50. I asked him if he could just Paypal me $6.00 and save us both the trouble of mailing coins back and forth. Here's his response:
"send it back. so u paid melt and gota 64 for free. wow u did terible i d be better sell pawn shop. done with ebay"
He had an attitude just after my SUGGESTION. It already started to go down hill at this point.
-Paul
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Never mention neg feedback in an ebay message when trying to resolve a conflict with a seller. He could easily report feedback extortion and ebay would agree with him. >>
I actually didn't, even though I sort of alluded to it in my OP. I mentioned that if we could resolve the issue I would still leave a positive. I wouldn't exactly call that a threat.
-Paul >>
Quote from your original post "I told him I didn't want to neg him".
I'd say you did a bit more than allude to it. >>
I didn't say ANYTHING about a neg to the guy. The OP was a mistake as I mentioned in a subsequent post. Here's what I sent him:
"Would you rather just give me a refund of say, $6 and call it a deal? It's less than the $8.50 more you'd be out if yu sent me the 64. It would probably be cheaper for you in the end and less of a hassle for me. I'll still leave a positive for you too."
And he responded with the post right above this one. I was trying to be polite.
-Paul
<< <i>Yes , perhaps i should have mentioned your stance was a seller can list one thing but send whatever it is he likes or "intended" to list and still be defendable. >>
This is about the third time you've put words in my mouth I did not say. What I *did* say is that sometimes, sellers list an item with a mistake in the listing. And that it is a sign of somebody who is not thinking clearly to expect the seller to send an item other than the one he has in his possession, and intended to sell.
<< <i>
<< <i>Yes , perhaps i should have mentioned your stance was a seller can list one thing but send whatever it is he likes or "intended" to list and still be defendable. >>
This is about the third time you've put words in my mouth I did not say. What I *did* say is that sometimes, sellers list an item with a mistake in the listing. And that it is a sign of somebody who is not thinking clearly to expect the seller to send an item other than the one he has in his possession, and intended to sell. >>
Ok then , lets get it straight , you are saying a seller can list an item and send a different item and the buyer should leave a positive because after all it was a mistake on the sellers part.
I say its a sign of someone not thinking at all if you think you'll get away with that on the bay and its clearly illustrated here.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>But after that it quickly went south... >>
Without the return of the coin that was shipped to you in error, I'm not surprised. Try looking at it from his point of view- he's got the coin you shipped by mistake, won't return it, and is hinting at leaving you negative feedback. How happy are you going to be with the situation? >>
Let's get this straight. This isn't a coin, really. It's bullion. He sent me 0.15oz instead of the 0.37oz I was supposed to get. So now because of HIS mistake, I have to send him the 0.15 oz back on MY dime and then HOPE he sends me the rest? If I were him, I would send me the difference in value via Paypal without hesitation and would apologize for MY mistake.
He stated in one of his emails that he was no longer going to sell on eBay anyways because of the poor prices he got (undoubtedly because of his spelling), so why would I send a coin back to someone who has no fear of getting a neg? He probably already closed out his Paypal, so I'd be stuck. Again, he blew this way out of proportions. It's $8. I cared more on principle than anything. He wanted it his way, I wanted it mine, and he didn't want to negotiate. Neg, move on, end of story.
-Paul >>
Wow. On 9/13 silver was at $41 and you got a 1oz Silver Round AND a 40% Silver Kennedy for only $41. To me, it sounds like you already got the Kennedy for free regardless of what it was.
And now, because it was "supposed" to be a 90% Silver Kennedy ($15 melt) and not a 40% Silver Kennedy ($6) you want an $8.00 refund or your gonna neg him because you don't want to bother with return shipping and don't trust the seller?
Whatever.
The name is LEE!
-Paul
<< <i>It doesn't matter WHAT I paid. That's irrelevant. He sent me the wrong coin, end of story. And just to get it straight, with his $3 shipping charge I essentially paid melt. If I went to my favorite dealer who gives me dealer prices I wouldn't even make my money back. I might make 5 bucks if I had gotten the coin THAT WAS LISTED IN THE DESCRIPTION.
-Paul >>
Careful. It sounds like you're nit-picking.
The name is LEE!
<< <i>
<< <i>It doesn't matter WHAT I paid. That's irrelevant. He sent me the wrong coin, end of story. And just to get it straight, with his $3 shipping charge I essentially paid melt. If I went to my favorite dealer who gives me dealer prices I wouldn't even make my money back. I might make 5 bucks if I had gotten the coin THAT WAS LISTED IN THE DESCRIPTION.
-Paul >>
Careful. It sounds like you're nit-picking. >>
I'm not nit-picking. I simply wanted the coin listed or an equivalent. I thought I was being very reasonable with my compromise. Also, I would NOT have bought the lot @$43 if it were listed properly as a 40%.
-Paul
<< <i>coinkid, unless a seller comes to your house and steals your jewels and impregnates your daughter you're going to take flak here for leaving anything worse than a neutral. and then, depending on how old the daughter is you might still get flak for even leaving that terrible terrible neutral or not giving firewall fives for the DSR ratings.
Yeah, I've begun to realize this. You can't make everyone happy, obviously. I think I was polite, and acted appropriately, especially after he cursed at me and told me to die. Only after that did I leave a neg and report him to eBay.
-Paul
<< <i>Ok then , lets get it straight , you are saying a seller can list an item and send a different item and the buyer should leave a positive because after all it was a mistake on the sellers part. >>
No, you don't have it straight. That's not what I'm saying.
One more time- sometimes, sellers make mistakes in their listings. The fact you happen to bid on one is no reason to expect to get something the seller doesn't have. Example- seller intends to sell a 1977 proof set and mistypes the description as "1987". You win the auction, but you're not going to get a 1987 set because the seller doesn't have one. This would seem to be self-evident. The adult response to a seller making such a mistake is to treat him the same way you'd like to be treated when (not if) you make a mistake yourself. Feedback is optional.