Home› U.S. Coin Forum
Options

1958 PCGS MS65 Franklin : $3800.00 ?

2»

Comments

  • Options
    PawPaulPawPaul Posts: 5,845 ✭
    did anyone buy the coin R. Tomaska had for sale ?
  • Options
    This one just sold on NEN for $200 image

    image

    image
  • Options
    MikeInFLMikeInFL Posts: 10,192 ✭✭✭✭
    The numismatic axiom "never buy the coin from the guy who wrote the book" seems quite apropos to the discussion of this mint set toner.
    Collector of Large Cents, US Type, and modern pocket change.
  • Options
    DIMEMANDIMEMAN Posts: 22,403 ✭✭✭✭✭
    What a RIP !!!!!

    I've seen much prettier 58's for $100 !!

    I wouldn't give $3800 for the whole set !!

    What a RIP !!!!

    Not even a pretty coin !!!
  • Options
    .......the NEN specimen might be the third one of the trio , heck -maybe there's more of them then I thought .

    I see one on eBay for a buy it now of 125$ .......it's a MS66 PCGS though ......... looks very similar to the "three"
  • Options
    RonyahskiRonyahski Posts: 3,120 ✭✭✭✭✭


    << <i>o.k. , moving on image


    here is the brother coin , also sold @ T.T in August this year .

    It just sold off eBay for less then 400$ ........maybe not quite the coin of it's peer , but surely we should see it for sale soon for a couple grand image

    image
    image


    and here is the runt of the litter of three ; you know - I sure would like Ronyahski to give his opinion on this triplet >>





    PawPaul - Haven't been on the boards much lately, but just saw this post. I never had these coins in hand and always hesitate to opine based on a pic... but ... I feel enough to say with a high degree of confidence ... to move on. It is interesting to read everybody's opinion, but I'll offer my why:

    -Somebody mentioned that these coins are Type II, but I believe all mint set 58s are Type I. Somebody here with more knowledge than me can chime in, but I don't think there are any Type I mint set coins. Besides it doesn't look like a natural mint set coin, so the toning must have happened otherwise. No benefit of the doubt because it is blue like most 58 mint set coins.

    - Some of the high points of the coins have less progression of toning. If it was from envelope or something else, why aren't the high points toned more. You'd think the most progressed toning would be there. Yet the fields are the most toned. This can happen if those high points are somehow protected, but is unusual.

    - The toning progression is abrupt. Going abruptly from blue to purple is suspect. Less suspect with a mint set coin, but these aren't.

    - The toning is too abrupt between the areas of high metal stress to less stress due to the striking. That is expected, but this is more extreme. E Pluribus Unum looks like a neon sign. Some of the desgins look like they were outlined with crayons.

    -But for the high points, the toning progression of colors is very narrow along the scale, likely from an abrupt source that caused the toning.

    - There is no toning at all on the rims.

    - The most progressed toning is in the fields. Yet some of the marks in the fields show less progression of toning. Any coin that has naturally toned for decades will either have the same level of toning in the marks, or will have more progression as a result of the marks being more succeptible to toning. That they have less is a tell tale sign of accelerated toning.

    Some refer to overgraded slabs as Coffins. I like to think of them as Happy Coins.
  • Options


    << <i>This one just sold on NEN for $200 image

    image

    image >>

    image Oh my God! Spare me with the color already! image
  • Options
    ManorcourtmanManorcourtman Posts: 8,516 ✭✭✭✭✭


    << <i>This one just sold on NEN for $200 image

    image

    image >>



    Is this a Type 1 or 2? Sorry not my series. And are you guys calling this one AT that NEN just sold?
  • Options


    << <i>Hey PawPaul, just wanted to let you know that I'm still hanging on to those babies of yours from years ago. image >>



    Toneluver - p.m me man ......your killing me !
  • Options
    Somebody mentioned that these coins are Type II, but I believe all mint set 58s are Type I. Somebody here with more knowledge than me can chime in, but I don't think there are any Type I mint set coins. Besides it doesn't look like a natural mint set coin, so the toning must have happened otherwise. No benefit of the doubt because it is blue like most 58 mint set coins. - Some of the high points of the coins have less progression of toning. If it was from envelope or something else, why aren't the high points toned more. You'd think the most progressed toning would be there. Yet the fields are the most toned. This can happen if those high points are somehow protected, but is unusual. - The toning progression is abrupt. Going abruptly from blue to purple is suspect. Less suspect with a mint set coin, but these aren't. - The toning is too abrupt between the areas of high metal stress to less stress due to the striking. That is expected, but this is more extreme. E Pluribus Unum looks like a neon sign. Some of the desgins look like they were outlined with crayons. -But for the high points, the toning progression of colors is very narrow along the scale, likely from an abrupt source that caused the toning. - There is no toning at all on the rims. - The most progressed toning is in the fields. Yet some of the marks in the fields show less progression of toning. Any coin that has naturally toned for decades will either have the same level of toning in the marks, or will have more progression as a result of the marks being more succeptible to toning. That they have less is a tell tale sign of accelerated toning.


    when someone that is a Master Franklin man speaks - I listen ;

    and although he didn't come right out and say it .........I will : The coins have toning that is fake , ..... that's F- A- K- E , case closed
  • Options
    disagree or not , a few of the top Franklin people in the world have dismissed these coins as being fake colored ;

    again , draw your own conclusions -

    but when the # 1 Franklin dealer in the country offers such coins , and touts such as the greatest thing since sliced bread -

    I see a big red flag

Leave a Comment

BoldItalicStrikethroughOrdered listUnordered list
Emoji
Image
Align leftAlign centerAlign rightToggle HTML viewToggle full pageToggle lights
Drop image/file