Options
Question for Those who have dealt with David Lawrence
Maybe one of them are reading the message boards and can answer.
If you bid on an auction and the reserve is not met, therefore the auction does not sell, you are generally offered the coin at a reduced price. Does anyone know if that is their absolute lowest, or can they still go just a tad lower?
That is my question.
Thanks.
If you bid on an auction and the reserve is not met, therefore the auction does not sell, you are generally offered the coin at a reduced price. Does anyone know if that is their absolute lowest, or can they still go just a tad lower?
That is my question.
Thanks.
0
Comments
World Collection
British Collection
German States Collection
Lance.
<< <i>Only DL knows for sure. I have made bids that didn't meet reserve, only to have them lower the reserve and sell to me. >>
This has happend a few times to me also.
Tom
<< <i>Only DL knows for sure. I have made bids that didn't meet reserve, only to have them lower the reserve and sell to me. >>
I have had that happen too.
<< <i>They have never gone lower for me. >>
You have to log into your account and look at your recent bids. Click on the item you bid on and that will show you the lower price. I am not a frequent bidder, because I often forget, I have bid on dozens of auctions and won some, lost some, and some unsold due to the reserve not being met. All of the ones where the reserve was unmet were always offered at a lower price. At least for me anyway, and I am nobody special.
<< <i>They have a coin I am really interested but wont budge on the asking price even though it didnt sell at auction for that price. Theyve had it over a year in inventory and I believe the markup from what they paid is 50%. Its also about 5x pcgs price guide list and possibly overgraded from what I can see and they just wont budge yet. >>
\
That's the kind of thing i have noticed. That being said i am still a fan, great, quick, easy service. Your going to pay top dollar though. It's not a regular auction in my oppinion.
<< <i>They have a coin I am really interested but wont budge on the asking price even though it didnt sell at auction for that price. Theyve had it over a year in inventory and I believe the markup from what they paid is 50%. Its also about 5x pcgs price guide list and possibly overgraded from what I can see and they just wont budge yet. >>
Lets see, in their inventory for over a year, overpriced and overgraded. Sounds like the "D" word! Move along!
EAC 6024
<< <i>
<< <i>They have a coin I am really interested but wont budge on the asking price even though it didnt sell at auction for that price. Theyve had it over a year in inventory and I believe the markup from what they paid is 50%. Its also about 5x pcgs price guide list and possibly overgraded from what I can see and they just wont budge yet. >>
Lets see, in their inventory for over a year, overpriced and overgraded. Sounds like the "D" word! Move along! >>
While true I talked it down like it was a dog, it really is unique and of outstanding eye appeal when said and done. At least to me anyway. Jut out of my reach and IMO outsoide of the market reach.
Other than that oddity, everything else was super smooth and I am very happy with the coin at 76% of the PCGS value - shipping speed, protective packaging, communication after the close. I like the website much more than others. On another note related to their auctions. I was very surprised to see that the "auction" results appeared very quickly in Coin Facts. I kind of wish I had control over that or at least knew it. It sort of puts personal information out on the street? Especially since the sale price might serve to lower the PCGS value on that grade??
I have gone back and would buy from there again.
That's a great question. Typically you'll be offered a coin that you bid on at a number slightly higher or equal to what it would have cost you in the auction. As to whether or not it is the best price on the coin, I don't really know as there isn't a set answer for that.
If you give shoot me an email and tell me what the coin is, I'd be happy to consider and offer or give you our best price on it. Unfortunately there's just way too many coins for us to give a general answer on the best price. My email address is john.brush@davidlawrence.com
Mumu,
Send me an email on the coin that you're interested in. I can't think of many coins that we've had over a year and I can't think of a single coin that we mark up 50% (unless our cost was under $25!), so hopefully I can help you with that question as well.
Papasteeze,
I'm glad that you were happy with our rather quick response. We try to answer emails and questions as quickly as possible, even when we are out of town (or the country!)
Thanks for the kind words from everyone else and if any of you have any questions for us, let me know!
John.Brush@davidlawrence.com
President of David Lawrence Rare Coins www.davidlawrence.com
email: John@davidlawrence.com
2022 ANA Dealer of the Year, Past Chair of NCBA (formerly ICTA), PNG Treasurer, Instructor at Witter Coin University, former Instructor/YN Chaperone ANA Summer Seminar, Coin World Most Influential, Curator of the D.L. Hansen Collection
<< <i>Rampage,
That's a great question. Typically you'll be offered a coin that you bid on at a number slightly higher or equal to what it would have cost you in the auction. As to whether or not it is the best price on the coin, I don't really know as there isn't a set answer for that.
If you give shoot me an email and tell me what the coin is, I'd be happy to consider and offer or give you our best price on it. Unfortunately there's just way too many coins for us to give a general answer on the best price. My email address is john.brush@davidlawrence.com
Mumu,
Send me an email on the coin that you're interested in. I can't think of many coins that we've had over a year and I can't think of a single coin that we mark up 50% (unless our cost was under $25!), so hopefully I can help you with that question as well.
Papasteeze,
I'm glad that you were happy with our rather quick response. We try to answer emails and questions as quickly as possible, even when we are out of town (or the country!)
Thanks for the kind words from everyone else and if any of you have any questions for us, let me know!
John.Brush@davidlawrence.com >>
I haven't done business with DL, however I will say I'm impressed with this level of responsiveness.
Please visit my website Millcitynumismatics.com
this old marine biologist thinks somebody should be ashamed of their self.
you people better listen to what mumu is trying to say.
<< <i>As I sit here and ponder my last few visits to the site(which I like a lot), I cant help but wonder if the auction is really some kind of marketing model. I havent gone to the site with enough regularity to say this is for sure what is happening but if I go during the week it seems that I can add the coin to my cart and purchase it outright in a traditional store front way. But If I go there around the "auction time" the coin appears as an auction item with the next bid meeting the reserve every time, which coincidently happens to be for the price listed as a regular buy it now earlier in the week. >>
my experience tells me that the first time a coin is listed on DLRC, it is offered via auction. If you call them, they won't sell it to you during that first week while it is being auctioned (I know, I've tried). After that first week, offers are fair game whether the coin is up for auction or for sale.
I've gotten a few very, very cool coins from DLRC
<< <i>As I sit here and ponder my last few visits to the site(which I like a lot), I cant help but wonder if the auction is really some kind of marketing model. I havent gone to the site with enough regularity to say this is for sure what is happening but if I go during the week it seems that I can add the coin to my cart and purchase it outright in a traditional store front way. But If I go there around the "auction time" the coin appears as an auction item with the next bid meeting the reserve every time, which coincidently happens to be for the price listed as a regular buy it now earlier in the week. >>
I wasnt trying to be judgemental in any way with this obvservation. It wasnt meant to imply any kind of dishonesty. Just that it is a stray form a traditional business model and a stray from what would truly be an auction setting.
Again I am not being judgemental. I am a free market believer so I am not trying to argue that a 50% markup is in any way dishonest. Frustrating yes because Id like the coin at a lower entry but I believe and would hope that there are values out there to be had that offer an investor/collector the opportunity for a 50% profit and dont feel that a dealer's dealer status disqualifies them from these opportunities. My comment though was made in the frustration that given that the coiin hasnt sold in the time since I first noticed it, I had hoped the price might start creeping my way, and given the book value about 1/10th the ask + the presumed described markup i was surprised there was no wiggle room on this one. But again they have every right IMO to ask wahtever they want for it and stick to it, but i also have the right to be frustrated I cant have the coin
Successful Trades: Swampboy,
As for Mumu's original questions, the auctions are not marketing events, but are true auctions. The prices mentioned are not quite correct as the auction prices, buy-it-nows, and the regular retail prices are all calculated through the computer system and are completely different.
As for the coin mentioned in particular, the offer (800ish) was quite a bit south of our cost ($1050) and we'd sell it for 1200 or a little less. The computer program does reject offers that are too far below our cost, but it doesn't reject all offers below cost as we do lose money on some coins and we like the human element to come into effect when offers are close.
That being said, I appreciate the apology Mumu, I just wanted to set the pricing straight so that it doesn't confuse anyone here.
If anyone else has any other questions or issues, feel free to email me. If it's about a particular coin, I'll pass it along to a co-worker as I am out of the office for the week, but I can try to answer anything else.
Thanks and I appreciate all of the messages and emails!
President of David Lawrence Rare Coins www.davidlawrence.com
email: John@davidlawrence.com
2022 ANA Dealer of the Year, Past Chair of NCBA (formerly ICTA), PNG Treasurer, Instructor at Witter Coin University, former Instructor/YN Chaperone ANA Summer Seminar, Coin World Most Influential, Curator of the D.L. Hansen Collection
great place for coins.Sometimes I growl at really nice coins at fair prices there when I wanted to pay less but thats my problem.Dont remember any times that I was offered a coin for less when the reserve wasnt met.That being said I check the site a few times a week....have bought quite a few coins there and always top notch service.