Home› U.S. Coin Forum
Options

MS 65 Saint Gaudens $20 good buy?

I recall some of roadrunner's excellent posts regarding the value of "true" MS-65 Saint Gaudens double eagles. I was toying with the idea of getting one for my collection.
My question for roadrunner and other knowledgeable gold guys:
Gold prices (as we all know) are hitting the roof, but are they having an effect on the current prices of MS-65, common date pieces? Is an accurately graded MS-65 Saint still a good value when compared to a 63 or 64?

Comments

  • Options
    roadrunnerroadrunner Posts: 28,374 ✭✭✭✭✭
    I think the value of a correctly graded MS65 saint is easily worth the premium to what 63's and 64's currently bring. The grading in the 65's and 66's was let to run wild a few years back and the ratio of the higher grades to lower grades clearly shows that trend. Honest 65's and higher are quite hard to find. Finding a nice 64 or 63 is relatively easy as they bring little premium in the market place. 65's have done decently the past 2 months and moved up faster than 63's and 64's which still seem stuck in the mud. And for only 10-12% you can get a legit 65 instead of a 64+ in a 65 holder. I don't know what CAC's hit rate is right now but it's probably in the 10-20% range for 65's. That means the vast majority of 65's offered wouldn't quality as more than a 64. Who wants to pay $2250 for a MS65 saint that might only be worth $1800? I'd rather pay the 10% premium and get one for $2400-2500. But then you can spend another $350 and get a PCGS 66. There's no set answer here. If you can cherry a non-beaned coin because you know what you're looking at, that's the way to go.

    The 65's have moved up around 10-15% over the past few months. Not a major move yet. If you want a nice one for your set select the grade that you feel you'd be most happy with. It's hard to select which grade will do better as we saw 63's and 64's promoted over 65's during the fall of 2009 and they were the best gainers. But the game never quite stays the same.

    If the current pullback lasts a while you may see the 65 saints fall back $100-$150.

    Veryfine, PM me and I'll give you a 65 saint pick that will cost no more than common dates, but has upside potential due to a much scarcer, but findable variety. I've been looking for these for the past 5 yrs and now have a grading set of them from 63 to 66. And the variety is easy to identify with just an auction photo.

    roadrunner
    Barbarous Relic No More, LSCC -GoldSeek--shadow stats--SafeHaven--321gold
  • Options
    veryfineveryfine Posts: 1,763 ✭✭✭
    Thanks for your well informed opinion.
    I'm keeping my eyes open for a nice one. A solid 65 seems like a better value than the lower grades, and I also like the eye-appeal that is usually associated with a 65.
  • Options
    homerunhallhomerunhall Posts: 2,496 ✭✭✭
    I believe all generic gold coins in MS63 to MS65 grades are tremendous relative values. Basically gold has tripled in price in the last few years and generic gold has seriously lagged behind in price. A person with a very large portfolio of fantastic rare coins (mostly gold) called me this week and said he was thinking of trading all his rare coins for bullion. I told him that if he did that it was my opinion that he'd be trading an undervalued asset for a fully priced asset. Gold could and should go up even more...hey, the dollar is becoming toilet paper you know...but on a relative value basis, the generic (and rare too) gold coins are under priced.

    Just my two cents worth. Personally, I have both rare gold and bullion socked away.

    hrh

  • Options
    What roadrunner and HRH said. Generic prices are way down right now. Go with a solid 65 Saint or two or three. These were $2600-$2700 last fall and now they're sometimes available under $2000. That's cheap for an honest 65.
  • Options
    orevilleoreville Posts: 12,444 ✭✭✭✭✭


    << <i>and said he was thinking of trading all his rare coins for bullion. >>



    I agree with HRH in that

    << <i>....that he'd be trading an undervalued asset for a fully priced asset. >>



    Furthermore, he would be creating capital gains tax on those rare coins in which he has any appreciation.

    To me, he would be better off taking a more measure approach and slowly re-balance his coin collection in perhaps taking 10% of his rare coins which show minimal appreciation AND are replaceable coins and trade them for solid MS-63 and MS-64 $20 Saints as well as some non 1904 MS-62 $20 Libs.

    Then take another 10% of those rare coins that does have some nice appreciation and trade them in the format of a like kind exchange for great MS-66 and some premium MS-65 Saints, as well as MS-64 Libs or similar kind of coins in which the price of the bullion is not more than 50% to 65% of the price of the coins.

    This way, this collector has made an initial step to move 20% of his collection and giving him more time to re-assess possibly another move of an additional 10% or 20% into significant but not total bullion based coinage.

    As far as bullion, such collector should or could be able to buy some from his other funds without disturbing the core of his collection???

    My concern is that such collector is NOW contemplating such a move AFTER gold has already appreciated from less than $300 an oz less than 10 years ago to nearly $1400 today and silver from $3 to $27 in the same time frame.

    I kind of like HRH's point in that despite whatever he thinks of bullion, he still has some socked away. He also has some rare stuff socked away. He also likes the MS-63 to MS-65 Saints so I ASSUME he also has some socked away. It appears he is not in any mood to try to outguess the market so he as well as i do, we keep a hand in all facets of the hobby/market so that we are not missing out on the great ride in any one segment which can happen at any time when you least expect it.

    It is not just about making a little profit as much as feeling that you were lucky to have been able to be on the great ride of a lifetime.
    It is really fun!

    Also being able to do well financially in one aspect of your collection helps you "hang onto" the rest of your beloved collection????


    A Collectors Universe poster since 1997!
  • Options
    roadrunnerroadrunner Posts: 28,374 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Good points by all. There's still good value in generic gold, it just might take gold above $1400-$1450 to really let it loose this time around. Generic gold typically responds later in each gold cycle when dealers are more flush with cash and then realize things like MS63 $10 Indians are way underpriced. During the gold run from Nov 2008 to Feb 2009 generic gold didn't really wake up until later in January. And in last year's gold run from Aug to November, generics really didn't fly until around later October. They sky rocketed in November. But like anything with leverage, they also rocket downwards when liquidity fleesthe gold coin market and major market makers just stop buying.

    That was my #1 "stupid cheap" call back in July/August....MS63 $10 Indians and Libs at $1000-$1050. It's about as cheap as they have been for the past several years. And multiple times scarcer than Saints or $20 Libs. They are needed in gold type sets as well. They're now around $1200-$1250. Even the 64's and 65's are still 25-35% off their 2009 highs when gold was only $1200-$1225. Another plus for the MS62/63 $10 Indians is that their pops have increased at < half the rate of the 64's and 65's. Which means they are getting scarcer relative to the higher grades. And since 63 $10 Indians have been promoted in years past, it may actually make them a better and safer buy than 64's and 65's along with potential speculative upside (more bullion for the price, less downside, etc.).

    roadrunner
    Barbarous Relic No More, LSCC -GoldSeek--shadow stats--SafeHaven--321gold
  • Options
    saintgurusaintguru Posts: 7,728 ✭✭✭
    Hey DHall....I'll take a few rolls of that toilet paper as long as you didn't use it. image
    image
  • Options
    derrybderryb Posts: 38,718 ✭✭✭✭✭


    << <i>...hey, the dollar is becoming toilet paper you know... >>



    image

    Governments can print currency. Only the people can print faith in it — and they’re running low on ink.

  • Options
    HalfStrikeHalfStrike Posts: 2,202 ✭✭✭
    I think the theory goes that as the price of gold rises fewer buyers are able to collect the series so the premiums should drop, if gold goes higher still then the premiums may drop even further.

Leave a Comment

BoldItalicStrikethroughOrdered listUnordered list
Emoji
Image
Align leftAlign centerAlign rightToggle HTML viewToggle full pageToggle lights
Drop image/file