Options
Do the historically high prices of gold discourage or encourage collectors of coins ?
TwoSides2aCoin
Posts: 45,343 ✭✭✭✭✭
Concerning public sentiment I wonder how the "few" on the boards who are involved in coins, or precious metals think.
0
Comments
It would encourage the collectors who are selling gold at a huge profit. They can now buy some of the set stoppers or even maybe a dream coin with hefty profits from gold that they a sell off.
I love those coins but dont have any interest in them when gold is so high.
Empty Nest Collection
<< <i>Gold is high? What's gold doing? >>
Smoking funny things, I think.
Stewart Huckaby
mailto:stewarth@HA.com
------------------------------------------
Heritage Auctions
Heritage Auctions
2801 W. Airport Freeway
Dallas, Texas 75261
Phone: 1-800-US-COINS, x1355
Heritage Auctions
Coin's for sale/trade.
Tom Pilitowski
US Rare Coin Investments
800-624-1870
I've held off on continuing my typeset with another round of double eagles and eagles due to the pog. However, I'd had my eye on a couple of panpac commem pieces, got the $1, just got the $2.5. I should have my head examined for straying from my early Walker pursuits, but y'all know how it goes, especially with a piece like the $2.5 panpac commem. It's back to Walkers, I promise. Well, maybe a merc, or slq, maybe a seated half?
I can't imagine paying those ridiculous prices for a common date Coronet twenty.
Of course some might say,"gold can and probably will go much much higher, so the current prices are a real bargain!"
In the end, I might be the big loser, but $1370 for a lousy ounce of gold? Oh well, for now, I'll just look at pictures.
I give away money. I collect money.
I don’t love money . I do love the Lord God.
potato - potato
priced out or discouraged?
affordability vs. yeow, do I want to keep collecting first spouses and AGE and such in the face of record high prices that might correct?
I think there is also a certain amount of discouragement involved. Do I wanna keep spending the money???
<< <i>What does the price of gold have to do with type coins? >>
Following and watching trends has changed some of my planning and the order with which I'm putting a collection together. About two months back I had saved up with the idea of looking for a Classic $5 in the mid-AU grade range. When the prices of Saint Gaudens $20s went down, even as gold was going up, I had to take advantage of it. I'm finding myself focusing on larger-sized pre-1933 gold, since it's lagging the price in bullion by a few months. I figure they'll either go up if gold continues its climb or stay the same if gold drops.
<< <i>What does the price of gold have to do with type coins? >>
Depending on your type collecting goals, it could mean everything.
Consider, for example, the comparative prices of a 20th century type set with and without gold coins. Now take into account the huge gold price increases in the last few years. I should have purchased a generic 1904 $20 piece in 2005 for my type set. Not now.
gold coin collectors who experience a lot of wealth effect as gold increases.
It will encourage random gold purchases among a few and discourage peo-
ple beginning gold collecting so is harmful in the long term. Of course in the
long term gold will be at a more natural level so the net effect might be pos-
itive even in the longer term.
Good question.I dont think it has a net effect on collectors because intrinsinct value is not what matters to a c ollector.If they want a $10 indian piece for example they can get one from many dealers for about $750.00 in BU. A nice MS64 somewhere between 1700.00 and 2200.00.As far as I can see this level of prices has been constant for at least a few years.In fact higher gold prices may allow them to sell a no longer wanted piece for a better grade piece in a different series.Most collector coins dont move up in price in step with the weekly increases in gold.
Even if they did most collectors are disiplined enough to wait a few months longer to make that purchase for their collection if more funds are needed.
Stackers and accumulaters may go either way.Prices go up and some say I will wait for a pullback to buy more,while others say I must buy today before it goes up more.
Speculators buy with the vision of selling at the highest price.They keep buying as long as someone tells them gold will hit the moon.They dont care about coins,collections,or collectors.These guys can affect metal prices because they can buy huge amounts at a time causing prices to rise and they can dump alot at one time causing the prices to drop like a rock.
True collectors will rarely be discouraged by the price of a PM.For them its all about the coins.
<< <i>Good question.I dont think it has a net effect on collectors because intrinsinct value is not what matters to a c ollector.If they want a $10 indian piece for example they can get one from many dealers for about $750.00 in BU. A nice MS64 somewhere between 1700.00 and 2200.00.As far as I can see this level of prices has been constant for at least a few years.In fact higher gold prices may allow them to sell a no longer wanted piece for a better grade piece in a different series.Most collector coins dont move up in price in step with the weekly increases in gold.
Even if they did most collectors are disiplined enough to wait a few months longer to make that purchase for their collection if more funds are needed.
Stackers and accumulaters may go either way.Prices go up and some say I will wait for a pullback to buy more,while others say I must buy today before it goes up more.
Speculators buy with the vision of selling at the highest price.They keep buying as long as someone tells them gold will hit the moon.They dont care about coins,collections,or collectors.These guys can affect metal prices because they can buy huge amounts at a time causing prices to rise and they can dump alot at one time causing the prices to drop like a rock.
True collectors will rarely be discouraged by the price of a PM.For them its all about the coins. >>
And that sums it up!
<< <i>
<< <i>What does the price of gold have to do with type coins? >>
Depending on your type collecting goals, it could mean everything.
Consider, for example, the comparative prices of a 20th century type set with and without gold coins. Now take into account the huge gold price increases in the last few years. I should have purchased a generic 1904 $20 piece in 2005 for my type set. Not now. >>
Having started on another TYPE set, it's easier to address this question with photos. The grey sheet is from last November 13th when the price was $1190. While it's encouraging from the point that I have some gold coins, it's discouraging from the point that it is more expensive to fill those empty holes, which is the basis of the thread. Thanks for the responses , thus far.
WS
Successful BST transactions with: SilverEagles92; Ahrensdad; Smitty; GregHansen; Lablade; Mercury10c; copperflopper; whatsup; KISHU1; scrapman1077, crispy, canadanz, smallchange, robkool, Mission16, ranshdow, ibzman350, Fallguy, Collectorcoins, SurfinxHI, jwitten, Walkerguy21D, dsessom.
For those collecting date sets in circ to MS61 where most dates are being sold for their bullion then the answer is YES.
For type set collectors of choice Mint State coins the answer is a resounding NO for anything but the $20's.
Generic mint state gold is quite cyclical and moves with both the gold bullion price as well as overall financial market liquidity. Those 2 can't be separated except maybe for the $20's which tend to be more bullion related.
For those trying to build MS61-65 type sets the prices on $1's to $20's were quite low this past summer....where $1-$10 MS63-65 Liberties and Indian gold were cheaper than they were in spring of 2006 when gold first hit $735, and 30% off the highs of November 2009....which where in most cases still cheaper than the 2006 and 2008 highs. So I don't quite get the "too expensive" mentality being applied here. If anything, these generics are severely lagging the gold bullion prices. Just because $20 Libs in MS63-64 are at much higher prices than they were in 2008 doesn't mean all the denominations are. Those same $20's are also about 30% off their Nov 2009 highs....but doesn't mean they'll soon go back that high again. Last November a MS64 $10 Indian would have set you back $2400, 2-3 months ago they were around $1650. I didn't hear anyone complaining when they were $2400. Why complain now? 2-3 months ago I recommended anyone looking for a MS63 $10 Lib/Indian go get one while they were still stupidly cheap at $1000-$1050. That opportunity is already long gone.
roadrunner
The rising price of gold over the past few years I suspect is bringing more people into the bourse floors, getting more people into collecting rarer coins as a way to combine hobby with investment. I just hope we don't loose too many people when the rebound finally happens--even if it's five years from now, and gold drops from $3000 an ounce to $2000. Hopefully, the awareness will bring in long-term thinkers who pack away a little every few months regardless of what the charts are doing that day.
Two steps forward, one step back, over and over again, bothers you? why is that?
Liberty: Parent of Science & Industry