Said a bit more directly, they didn't miss it, they consider it market acceptable. >>
Mike, Don't you think that coin would go 66 at PCGS with natural color? If so, the the flipper would have sent it to PCGS for a regrade as the PCGS coin would have brought slightly more at resale. But they knew PCGS wouldn't holder a recolored coin. They know NGC would. Of course, that's one reason why PCGS coins bring more at resale. Another is that the coin might not have gone 66 at PCGS with the ding in the upper obv field. --Jerry >>
No, I don't. 66 BN is a very difficult grade for brown copper at PCGS. Without looking at the pops, I'd bet there might be one or two for the date, and zero wouldn't surprise me either. Regardless, at best that's a PCGS 65, IMO.
Collector of Large Cents, US Type, and modern pocket change.
<< <i>So...a very good discussion here. But, in light of all of this, what do you think Heritage should do? Edit the description to say "something" was done to said coin between May and July, pull the auction all together, .....what do you think Heritage should do? >>
Nothing. The coin is "market acceptable" to one of the top grading companies and to most buyers. If it were a 6 or 7 figure coin, they might want to point out the conservation but I think that is expecting too much in an auction description for a $2500 "widget". --Jerry
<< <i>Yet the original cent was very lack luster... so my question would be did the recoloring add sheen >>
Yes, it does. To recolor, generally the coin is stripped to a pink red. After the color is restored it has a slightly un-natural looking sheen that helps one recognized a recolored cent. --jerry >>
Thanks notwilight!
If this auction lot isn't pulled it would most likely be purchased by a collector how wouldn't know how to recognize a recolored coin as this is a extremely well executed enhancedment.
Really great catch DAM!
To Err Is Human.... To Collect Err's Is Just Too Much Darn Tootin Fun!
<< <i>So...a very good discussion here. But, in light of all of this, what do you think Heritage should do? Edit the description to say "something" was done to said coin between May and July, pull the auction all together, .....what do you think Heritage should do? >>
I'm not sure what they should do, but a quick call to NGC to see who submitted the coin and comparing that with who bought it from the first auction and who consigned it this time around would certainly be interesting.
All that said, I'm not 100% convinced the coin's been worked between photos -- just like 95%. The pictures sure suggest it, and clearly something's been done to the coin, but photos of copper, particularly recolored high grade copper, change with subtle change of lighting more than just about any other type of coin (proofs would be the other one notable for this feature). What you see in two sets of pictures can be quite different. While I'd guess the odds are rather low the coin hasn't been worked, this conclusion cannot be discounted entirely, in my opinion.
Collector of Large Cents, US Type, and modern pocket change.
<< <i>So...a very good discussion here. But, in light of all of this, what do you think Heritage should do? Edit the description to say "something" was done to said coin between May and July, pull the auction all together, .....what do you think Heritage should do? >>
Nothing. The coin is "market acceptable" to one of the top grading companies and to most buyers. If it were a 6 or 7 figure coin, they might want to point out the conservation but I think that is expecting too much in an auction description for a $2500 "widget". --Jerry >>
For a poor schmuck like me, if I bought that at auction and paid good money for it....then later it was pointed out by 10+ people in an internet forum that the coin had been messed with....I would be really really really really mad. $100 is a lot of money to me.... Maybe I am the only one that thinks this way though? It just seems dishonest to me. I would want full disclosure.
"If it's not fun, it's not worth it." - KeyMan64 Not really looking for much these days but if I were, it might be a toner.
Said a bit more directly, they didn't miss it, they consider it market acceptable. >>
Mike, Don't you think that coin would go 66 at PCGS with natural color? If so, the the flipper would have sent it to PCGS for a regrade as the PCGS coin would have brought slightly more at resale. But they knew PCGS wouldn't holder a recolored coin. They know NGC would. Of course, that's one reason why PCGS coins bring more at resale. Another is that the coin might not have gone 66 at PCGS with the ding in the upper obv field. --Jerry >>
No, I don't. 66 BN is a very difficult grade for brown copper at PCGS. Without looking at the pops, I'd bet there might be one or two for the date, and zero wouldn't surprise me either. Regardless, at best that's a PCGS 65, IMO. >>
Mike, You're right. Pop at PCGS is 0 in 66, 4 or 5 in 65 (I just checked but I got distracted on the way back, read several posts, and forgot which it is). --Jerry
<< <i>So...a very good discussion here. But, in light of all of this, what do you think Heritage should do? Edit the description to say "something" was done to said coin between May and July, pull the auction all together, .....what do you think Heritage should do? >>
Nothing. The coin is "market acceptable" to one of the top grading companies and to most buyers. If it were a 6 or 7 figure coin, they might want to point out the conservation but I think that is expecting too much in an auction description for a $2500 "widget". --Jerry >>
For a poor schmuck like me, if I bought that at auction and paid good money for it....then later it was pointed out by 10+ people in an internet forum that the coin had been messed with....I would be really really really really mad. $100 is a lot of money to me.... Maybe I am the only one that thinks this way though? It just seems dishonest to me. I would want full disclosure. >>
Just because a coin is in a slab, doesn't mean it isn't worked on, conserved, or in this case, recolored. Sticking with PCGS is some help, but if you consider originality that important, you should either stick with series you know intimately, buy with the help of a very knowledgeable dealer or collector friend who specializes in the series, or both. --Jerry
Said a bit more directly, they didn't miss it, they consider it market acceptable. >>
Mike, Don't you think that coin would go 66 at PCGS with natural color? If so, the the flipper would have sent it to PCGS for a regrade as the PCGS coin would have brought slightly more at resale. But they knew PCGS wouldn't holder a recolored coin. They know NGC would. Of course, that's one reason why PCGS coins bring more at resale. Another is that the coin might not have gone 66 at PCGS with the ding in the upper obv field. --Jerry >>
No, I don't. 66 BN is a very difficult grade for brown copper at PCGS. Without looking at the pops, I'd bet there might be one or two for the date, and zero wouldn't surprise me either. Regardless, at best that's a PCGS 65, IMO. >>
I just looked at the Heritage auction (doh!) which confirmed the PCGS MS 66 BN population of this date is 0.
As stated above, 66 BN is a VERY tough coin in any braided hair -- there were 48 examples at PCGS for all braided hair large cents in 2006, for example. There was a single 67 -- out of 4,700 odd BNs.
And it's not like 66 RB or RD are easy coins either -- there were like 24 RB and 29 RD in 2006 with one lone 67 RD (an 1853, that I think our own Cardinal owns).
As for NGC, they hand out 66's like candy (relatively speaking). They simply grade to a different standard for this series in the upper grades and with their definition of market acceptable -- buyer beware.
Collector of Large Cents, US Type, and modern pocket change.
Good advice Jerry. I will stick with what I know best but I have always been interested in owning a select few copper coins but stuff like this would just scare the crap out of me and tell me to stay far far far far away. I think I know Mercury Dimes fairly well and will stick with them for a long time. It sure would be nice to find some good honest pieces of copper in my future one day though...
"If it's not fun, it's not worth it." - KeyMan64 Not really looking for much these days but if I were, it might be a toner.
<< <i>Good advice Jerry. I will stick with what I know best but I have always been interested in owning a select few copper coins but stuff like this would just scare the crap out of me and tell me to stay far far far far away. I think I know Mercury Dimes fairly well and will stick with them for a long time. It sure would be nice to find some good honest pieces of copper in my future one day though... >>
Your gut is usually right, and in this case I believe strongly it is.
Collector of Large Cents, US Type, and modern pocket change.
I think the coin was probably not original in the older holder/auction. Or at least didn't look like it does in the first auction image when it was graded. It was likely a good coin, gone bad. I mean it was in a 66BN holder, right? It may have looked something like what it looks like now when it was initially graded but sadly changed, possibly due to contaminants on the surface. My guess is the buyer sent it to NCS and had them remove the contaminants.
I think you could say this is doctoring if they tried to change the color. But if all NCS (assuming it was sent to them - I think since it is in the same grade holder, they did the work) did was remove the contaminants, then I think it would be acceptable to most EACers. The color looks like it is a hard, deep brown color which is looks natural but is a bit too slate-colored. I don't think it warrants a 66BN grade, more like a 63BN with all those nicks.
Edited to add, I'm saying it is not original in either image. It is a worked on coin, nonetheless.
<< <i>Good advice Jerry. I will stick with what I know best but I have always been interested in owning a select few copper coins but stuff like this would just scare the crap out of me and tell me to stay far far far far away. I think I know Mercury Dimes fairly well and will stick with them for a long time. It sure would be nice to find some good honest pieces of copper in my future one day though... >>
There is plenty of original copper out there and several guys here who are very helpful in offering opinions of coins if you post or PM them. Good luck, Jerry
<< <i>I think the coin was probably not original in the older holder/auction. Or at least didn't look like it does in the first auction image when it was graded. It was likely a good coin, gone bad. I mean it was in a 66BN holder, right? It may have looked something like what it looks like now when it was initially graded but sadly changed, possibly due to contaminants on the surface. My guess is the buyer sent it to NCS and had them remove the contaminants.
I think you could say this is doctoring if they tried to change the color. But if all NCS (assuming it was sent to them - I think since it is in the same grade holder, they did the work) did was remove the contaminants, then I think it would be acceptable to most EACers. The color looks like it is a hard, deep brown color which is natural (a bit too slate-colored, but not an artificial brown). I don't think it warrants a 66BN grade, more like a 63BN with all those nicks.
I'd like to hear from any other EAC people. >>
Rick, You're a tougher grader than I am. But I was looking at the color too much and not the coin. I saw the one nick to confirm it was the same coin and quit looking. It has quite a few marks on it. I agree that it should be lower. I don't grade by EAC standards but by PCGS standards I'd be ok with it in a 64 holder or 65. It would be a strong 64 or a weak 65 IMHO.
As for the first auction, I'd say it is mostly just bad pictures. The buyer probably saw it in hand. --Jerry
There are a few marks that are visible on the second coin that are not on the first, but that could happen. Then there are a few marks on the first coin that are not visible on the second. That can't happen, unless its lighting, but the second image shows marks very well.
Look at the denticles between the 12h and 13th star.
They appear very similar to my eye. My suspicion is they are the same coin. Among other things, look at the set of 3 mushed denticles toward star 9 between stars 8 and 9.
They are the same coin. Look at the pics in Frank's post. There is a small mark on the rim near the left side of the D. In both pics, they are the same shape, size, location, orientation, etc. What are the chances of two low pop NGC MS66 large cents with the same exact date having the same exact mark? The pics may have been made with different lighting but they are definitely the same coin. Whoever did the so called doctoring of this coin greatly improved the appearance of this coin IMO.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
There are a few marks that are visible on the second coin that are not on the first, but that could happen. Then there are a few marks on the first coin that are not visible on the second. That can't happen, unless its lighting, but the second image shows marks very well.
Look at the denticles between the 12h and 13th star. >>
I'm extremely confident it's the same coin. While there are a few instances where something on one image doesn't appear on the other, there are too many cases where the pictures coincide perfectly.
I am pretty confident they are different, otherwise I wouldn't stick my neck out. I forwarded the image (I couldn't post it for some reason) to the Region 8 of the EAC and see what they think. If they are different, then one or both could be, dare I say it, fake.
<< <i>I am pretty confident they are different, otherwise I wouldn't stick my neck out. I forwarded the image (I couldn't post it for some reason) to the Region 8 of the EAC and see what they think. If they are different, then one or both could be, dare I say it, fake. >>
Rick, I'm 100% sure it's the same coin. The big hit in the obverse field is evident in all photos, but if you take a look at the blown up photos of both obverses, there are identical hits on the nose, in front of the nose, and above the die crack at 12:00. Definitely the same coin.
Edited to add: I understand what you're saying about the possibility of counterfeits due to the repeating marks, but I don't think that is the case.
<< <i> I'm not sure what you mean by the first attempt? I think the first auction was probably an original surface --Jerry >>
I never said first attempt that is why you did not understand what I ment. I was using MS70 as a metaphor and did not mean to offend anyone who uses it. I am not very savey when it comes to the use or abuse of chemicals on coin surfaces. However I do not agree with your statement that the first photo shows a original surface and I think the staining was a result of the surface being doctored. But I am here to learn so school me.
Give the laziest man the toughest job and he will find the easiest way to get it done.
An interesting mix of how changing the appearance of coins is viewed.
I'm really confused why it was done to begin with. I didn't see an upgrade possibility in its previous state. And certainly don't see one now. So why? Maybe someone is on a learning curve.
<< <i>An interesting mix of how changing the appearance of coins is viewed.
I'm really confused why it was done to begin with. I didn't see an upgrade possibility in its previous state. And certainly don't see one now. So why? Maybe someone is on a learning curve. >>
I agree. Before or after I would say no chance of an upgrade, and not due to the spot, just from the hits. Only reason I can think of is it might have been thought to be more salable without the spot, but financially that does not make sense - Flipping it at the same grade after spending the time and effort on it.
<< <i>Looks to me like a simple bath in "MS 70". You guys usually applaud the "MS 70" look. >>
It took 4 pages to come to the most likely theory.
TRUTH >>
If I was the one to "do the deed", I wouldn't try to do it on my own. I definately would send it into NCS for a professional job. A $2500 coin, IMHO, would not be messed with by me. BTW, with all this "doctoring" talk, what is it exactly that NCS does that is not doctoring?
<< <i>Looks to me like a simple bath in "MS 70". You guys usually applaud the "MS 70" look. >>
Joe, Although I don't think it was a simple MS70 bath, they were appreciating it pretty well until a copper guy showed up late last night and somewhat rained on the parade.
I don't really think this is an MS70 coin but I could be wrong. I'll play with a little MS70 tonight. I have some just for this purpose. I also have some deller's darkener that I've never tried.
To those who PMd me thanking me for my comments I'll get back to you tonight. I've never recolored a coin myself, although I probably have a few candidates. (The candidates I have are not in holders and will never be in holders.) I was just repeating what I'd heard about how it is done. As for what it looks like, just keep watching copper and talking to guys who know. When you hear, "OK for a recolored coin" about 20 times you start to recognize it yourself.
I dinked around a little o photoshop and think that they are same coin. In any case I think that I would rather have the worked over one if I had to pick - be interesting to see it "in the flesh"
<< <i>Good advice Jerry. I will stick with what I know best but I have always been interested in owning a select few copper coins but stuff like this would just scare the crap out of me and tell me to stay far far far far away. I think I know Mercury Dimes fairly well and will stick with them for a long time. It sure would be nice to find some good honest pieces of copper in my future one day though... >>
There is plenty of original copper out there and several guys here who are very helpful in offering opinions of coins if you post or PM them. Good luck, Jerry >>
Right on. Tom B. helped me with these and I couldn't be happier. Lance.
<< <i>Just a random hypothetical wondering - would CAC sticker that coin? Do they look for recoloring with old copper?
-Fred >>
I just looked at all the CAC stickered large cents in the Boston Auction (11 of them) and they all look quite natural. I don't recall ever seeing a cent that I thought was recolored with a cac sticker.
edit to add: I don't think that coin would come close to stickering on technical grade independent of color.
<< <i>I dinked around a little o photoshop and think that they are same coin. In any case I think that I would rather have the worked over one if I had to pick - be interesting to see it "in the flesh" >>
Joe, Have you ever done any brushing of copper? I think some of the old EAC guys with their super soft brush and fine touch could have done a much better job of conserving the coin while leaving it looking natural. --Jerry
I do brush but only lightly and not on UNCs (only have 3 or 4 but one is CC1 - I pray it just stays red). The trick is to get the brush broken-in. I have well over 100 hours (praboably much more) on old English pennies and Blue Ribbon (the real stuff). Just get a bunch of OEP's, some BR, a pair of pliers and brush away on Sunday afternoon football. When the brush is really deep green you are good to go. Wally Lee gave his brush away and it did not last 30 seconds after the add hit - I think one noted EAC'er offered to sell his for $10,000 (he did brush A-1 stuff though). I think that it can really give a bit of pizzazz - many times it is a bit remarkable how it works. It also adds a bit of protection.
I do brush but only lightly and not on UNCs (only have 3 or 4 but one is CC1 - I pray it just stays red). The trick is to get the brush broken-in. I have well over 100 hours (praboably much more) on old English pennies and Blue Ribbon (the real stuff). Just get a bunch of OEP's, some BR, a pair of pliers and brush away on Sunday afternoon football. When the brush is really deep green you are good to go. Wally Lee gave his brush away and it did not last 30 seconds after the add hit - I think one noted EAC'er offered to sell his for $10,000 (he did brush A-1 stuff though). I think that it can really give a bit of pizzazz - many times it is a bit remarkable how it works. It also adds a bit of protection. >>
Am I the only one that thinks all this is weird?
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
<< <i>Am I the only one that thinks all this is weird? >>
Probably not, but it's certainly not weird and actually standard practice among the real copper fanatics. Don't knock it until you've seen the results. I have seen the dealers, like Doug Bird, graciously brush large cents at shows for collectors and customers as a service. I wished I could find the right kind of brush, and then make the effort to break it in. Currently I use worn, 'fluffy' Q-tips with old Blue Ribbon residue on them. Maybe this is really weird, but I get reasonable results. And the coins when submitted to both major TPG's certified just fine.
During the seminar at the Conder class we were told that the biggest mistake made by copper collectors is to NOT wash the camel-hair brush, as it picks up loose debris that turns the brush into sandpaper. Is accumulated debris and blue ribbon in the brush advantageous? He said it should be washed and blow-dried regularly.
Comments
<< <i>
<< <i>
Said a bit more directly, they didn't miss it, they consider it market acceptable. >>
Mike, Don't you think that coin would go 66 at PCGS with natural color? If so, the the flipper would have sent it to PCGS for a regrade as the PCGS coin would have brought slightly more at resale. But they knew PCGS wouldn't holder a recolored coin. They know NGC would. Of course, that's one reason why PCGS coins bring more at resale. Another is that the coin might not have gone 66 at PCGS with the ding in the upper obv field. --Jerry >>
No, I don't. 66 BN is a very difficult grade for brown copper at PCGS. Without looking at the pops, I'd bet there might be one or two for the date, and zero wouldn't surprise me either. Regardless, at best that's a PCGS 65, IMO.
<< <i>So...a very good discussion here. But, in light of all of this, what do you think Heritage should do? Edit the description to say "something" was done to said coin between May and July, pull the auction all together, .....what do you think Heritage should do? >>
Nothing. The coin is "market acceptable" to one of the top grading companies and to most buyers. If it were a 6 or 7 figure coin, they might want to point out the conservation but I think that is expecting too much in an auction description for a $2500 "widget". --Jerry
<< <i>
<< <i>Yet the original cent was very lack luster... so my question would be did the recoloring add sheen
Yes, it does. To recolor, generally the coin is stripped to a pink red. After the color is restored it has a slightly un-natural looking sheen that helps one recognized a recolored cent. --jerry >>
Thanks notwilight!
If this auction lot isn't pulled it would most likely be purchased by a collector how wouldn't know how to recognize a recolored coin as this is a extremely well executed enhancedment.
Really great catch DAM!
<< <i>So...a very good discussion here. But, in light of all of this, what do you think Heritage should do? Edit the description to say "something" was done to said coin between May and July, pull the auction all together, .....what do you think Heritage should do? >>
I'm not sure what they should do, but a quick call to NGC to see who submitted the coin and comparing that with who bought it from the first auction and who consigned it this time around would certainly be interesting.
All that said, I'm not 100% convinced the coin's been worked between photos -- just like 95%. The pictures sure suggest it, and clearly something's been done to the coin, but photos of copper, particularly recolored high grade copper, change with subtle change of lighting more than just about any other type of coin (proofs would be the other one notable for this feature). What you see in two sets of pictures can be quite different. While I'd guess the odds are rather low the coin hasn't been worked, this conclusion cannot be discounted entirely, in my opinion.
<< <i>
<< <i>So...a very good discussion here. But, in light of all of this, what do you think Heritage should do? Edit the description to say "something" was done to said coin between May and July, pull the auction all together, .....what do you think Heritage should do? >>
Nothing. The coin is "market acceptable" to one of the top grading companies and to most buyers. If it were a 6 or 7 figure coin, they might want to point out the conservation but I think that is expecting too much in an auction description for a $2500 "widget". --Jerry >>
For a poor schmuck like me, if I bought that at auction and paid good money for it....then later it was pointed out by 10+ people in an internet forum that the coin had been messed with....I would be really really really really mad. $100 is a lot of money to me.... Maybe I am the only one that thinks this way though? It just seems dishonest to me. I would want full disclosure.
Not really looking for much these days but if I were, it might be a toner.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
Said a bit more directly, they didn't miss it, they consider it market acceptable. >>
Mike, Don't you think that coin would go 66 at PCGS with natural color? If so, the the flipper would have sent it to PCGS for a regrade as the PCGS coin would have brought slightly more at resale. But they knew PCGS wouldn't holder a recolored coin. They know NGC would. Of course, that's one reason why PCGS coins bring more at resale. Another is that the coin might not have gone 66 at PCGS with the ding in the upper obv field. --Jerry >>
No, I don't. 66 BN is a very difficult grade for brown copper at PCGS. Without looking at the pops, I'd bet there might be one or two for the date, and zero wouldn't surprise me either. Regardless, at best that's a PCGS 65, IMO. >>
Mike, You're right. Pop at PCGS is 0 in 66, 4 or 5 in 65 (I just checked but I got distracted on the way back, read several posts, and forgot which it is). --Jerry
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>So...a very good discussion here. But, in light of all of this, what do you think Heritage should do? Edit the description to say "something" was done to said coin between May and July, pull the auction all together, .....what do you think Heritage should do? >>
Nothing. The coin is "market acceptable" to one of the top grading companies and to most buyers. If it were a 6 or 7 figure coin, they might want to point out the conservation but I think that is expecting too much in an auction description for a $2500 "widget". --Jerry >>
For a poor schmuck like me, if I bought that at auction and paid good money for it....then later it was pointed out by 10+ people in an internet forum that the coin had been messed with....I would be really really really really mad. $100 is a lot of money to me.... Maybe I am the only one that thinks this way though? It just seems dishonest to me. I would want full disclosure. >>
Just because a coin is in a slab, doesn't mean it isn't worked on, conserved, or in this case, recolored. Sticking with PCGS is some help, but if you consider originality that important, you should either stick with series you know intimately, buy with the help of a very knowledgeable dealer or collector friend who specializes in the series, or both. --Jerry
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
Said a bit more directly, they didn't miss it, they consider it market acceptable. >>
Mike, Don't you think that coin would go 66 at PCGS with natural color? If so, the the flipper would have sent it to PCGS for a regrade as the PCGS coin would have brought slightly more at resale. But they knew PCGS wouldn't holder a recolored coin. They know NGC would. Of course, that's one reason why PCGS coins bring more at resale. Another is that the coin might not have gone 66 at PCGS with the ding in the upper obv field. --Jerry >>
No, I don't. 66 BN is a very difficult grade for brown copper at PCGS. Without looking at the pops, I'd bet there might be one or two for the date, and zero wouldn't surprise me either. Regardless, at best that's a PCGS 65, IMO. >>
I just looked at the Heritage auction (doh!) which confirmed the PCGS MS 66 BN population of this date is 0.
As stated above, 66 BN is a VERY tough coin in any braided hair -- there were 48 examples at PCGS for all braided hair large cents in 2006, for example. There was a single 67 -- out of 4,700 odd BNs.
And it's not like 66 RB or RD are easy coins either -- there were like 24 RB and 29 RD in 2006 with one lone 67 RD (an 1853, that I think our own Cardinal owns).
As for NGC, they hand out 66's like candy (relatively speaking). They simply grade to a different standard for this series in the upper grades and with their definition of market acceptable -- buyer beware.
Not really looking for much these days but if I were, it might be a toner.
<< <i>Good advice Jerry. I will stick with what I know best but I have always been interested in owning a select few copper coins but stuff like this would just scare the crap out of me and tell me to stay far far far far away. I think I know Mercury Dimes fairly well and will stick with them for a long time. It sure would be nice to find some good honest pieces of copper in my future one day though...
Your gut is usually right, and in this case I believe strongly it is.
I think you could say this is doctoring if they tried to change the color. But if all NCS (assuming it was sent to them - I think since it is in the same grade holder, they did the work) did was remove the contaminants, then I think it would be acceptable to most EACers. The color looks like it is a hard, deep brown color which is looks natural but is a bit too slate-colored. I don't think it warrants a 66BN grade, more like a 63BN with all those nicks.
Edited to add, I'm saying it is not original in either image. It is a worked on coin, nonetheless.
I'd like to hear from any other EAC people.
<< <i>Good advice Jerry. I will stick with what I know best but I have always been interested in owning a select few copper coins but stuff like this would just scare the crap out of me and tell me to stay far far far far away. I think I know Mercury Dimes fairly well and will stick with them for a long time. It sure would be nice to find some good honest pieces of copper in my future one day though...
There is plenty of original copper out there and several guys here who are very helpful in offering opinions of coins if you post or PM them. Good luck, Jerry
Not really looking for much these days but if I were, it might be a toner.
<< <i>I think the coin was probably not original in the older holder/auction. Or at least didn't look like it does in the first auction image when it was graded. It was likely a good coin, gone bad. I mean it was in a 66BN holder, right? It may have looked something like what it looks like now when it was initially graded but sadly changed, possibly due to contaminants on the surface. My guess is the buyer sent it to NCS and had them remove the contaminants.
I think you could say this is doctoring if they tried to change the color. But if all NCS (assuming it was sent to them - I think since it is in the same grade holder, they did the work) did was remove the contaminants, then I think it would be acceptable to most EACers. The color looks like it is a hard, deep brown color which is natural (a bit too slate-colored, but not an artificial brown). I don't think it warrants a 66BN grade, more like a 63BN with all those nicks.
I'd like to hear from any other EAC people. >>
Rick,
You're a tougher grader than I am. But I was looking at the color too much and not the coin. I saw the one nick to confirm it was the same coin and quit looking. It has quite a few marks on it. I agree that it should be lower. I don't grade by EAC standards but by PCGS standards I'd be ok with it in a 64 holder or 65. It would be a strong 64 or a weak 65 IMHO.
As for the first auction, I'd say it is mostly just bad pictures. The buyer probably saw it in hand. --Jerry
Link to a comparison of the images
There are a few marks that are visible on the second coin that are not on the first, but that could happen. Then there are a few marks on the first coin that are not visible on the second. That can't happen, unless its lighting, but the second image shows marks very well.
Look at the denticles between the 12h and 13th star.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
<< <i>Good call Frank. I don't think they are the same coin. But there are many marks that are very similarly placed. Could they be from China?
Link to a comparison of the images
There are a few marks that are visible on the second coin that are not on the first, but that could happen. Then there are a few marks on the first coin that are not visible on the second. That can't happen, unless its lighting, but the second image shows marks very well.
Look at the denticles between the 12h and 13th star. >>
I'm extremely confident it's the same coin. While there are a few instances where something on one image doesn't appear on the other, there are too many cases where the pictures coincide perfectly.
<< <i>I am pretty confident they are different, otherwise I wouldn't stick my neck out. I forwarded the image (I couldn't post it for some reason) to the Region 8 of the EAC and see what they think. If they are different, then one or both could be, dare I say it, fake. >>
Rick, I'm 100% sure it's the same coin. The big hit in the obverse field is evident in all photos, but if you take a look at the blown up photos of both obverses, there are identical hits on the nose, in front of the nose, and above the die crack at 12:00. Definitely the same coin.
Edited to add: I understand what you're saying about the possibility of counterfeits due to the repeating marks, but I don't think that is the case.
-Paul
<< <i>
<< <i> I'm not sure what you mean by the first attempt? I think the first auction was probably an original surface --Jerry >>
I never said first attempt that is why you did not understand what I ment. I was using MS70 as a metaphor and did not mean to offend anyone who uses it. I am not very savey when it comes to the use or abuse of chemicals on coin surfaces. However I do not agree with your statement that the first photo shows a original surface and I think the staining was a result of the surface being doctored.
But I am here to learn so school me.
I'm really confused why it was done to begin with. I didn't see an upgrade possibility in its previous state. And certainly don't see one now. So why? Maybe someone is on a learning curve.
<< <i>An interesting mix of how changing the appearance of coins is viewed.
I'm really confused why it was done to begin with. I didn't see an upgrade possibility in its previous state. And certainly don't see one now. So why? Maybe someone is on a learning curve. >>
I agree. Before or after I would say no chance of an upgrade, and not due to the spot, just from the hits. Only reason I can think of is it might have been thought to be more salable without the spot, but financially that does not make sense - Flipping it at the same grade after spending the time and effort on it.
<< <i>Looks to me like a simple bath in "MS 70". You guys usually applaud the "MS 70" look. >>
It took 4 pages to come to the most likely theory.
TRUTH
<< <i>
<< <i>Looks to me like a simple bath in "MS 70". You guys usually applaud the "MS 70" look. >>
It took 4 pages to come to the most likely theory.
TRUTH >>
If I was the one to "do the deed", I wouldn't try to do it on my own. I definately would send it into NCS for a professional job. A $2500 coin, IMHO, would not be messed with by me.
BTW, with all this "doctoring" talk, what is it exactly that NCS does that is not doctoring?
<< <i>BTW, with all this "doctoring" talk, what is it exactly that NCS does that is not doctoring? >>
Pmac, I think you reached the first plateau.
<< <i>Looks to me like a simple bath in "MS 70". You guys usually applaud the "MS 70" look. >>
Oh come on Joe, those purple blue toned Indians that are so lauded are naturally that color
<< <i>Oh come on Joe, those purple blue toned Indians that are so lauded are naturally that color
Feelin' a little purple and blue right about now, myself.
<< <i>Looks to me like a simple bath in "MS 70". You guys usually applaud the "MS 70" look. >>
Joe,
Although I don't think it was a simple MS70 bath, they were appreciating it pretty well until a copper guy showed up late last night and somewhat rained on the parade.
I don't really think this is an MS70 coin but I could be wrong. I'll play with a little MS70 tonight. I have some just for this purpose. I also have some deller's darkener that I've never tried.
To those who PMd me thanking me for my comments I'll get back to you tonight. I've never recolored a coin myself, although I probably have a few candidates. (The candidates I have are not in holders and will never be in holders.) I was just repeating what I'd heard about how it is done. As for what it looks like, just keep watching copper and talking to guys who know. When you hear, "OK for a recolored coin" about 20 times you start to recognize it yourself.
--Jerry
In any case I think that I would rather have the worked over one if I had to pick - be interesting to see it "in the flesh"
My opinion has not changed - given the choice I still prefer the coin the way it was. I think it looks quite unusual the way it is now.
Best,
Eric
<< <i>
<< <i>Good advice Jerry. I will stick with what I know best but I have always been interested in owning a select few copper coins but stuff like this would just scare the crap out of me and tell me to stay far far far far away. I think I know Mercury Dimes fairly well and will stick with them for a long time. It sure would be nice to find some good honest pieces of copper in my future one day though...
There is plenty of original copper out there and several guys here who are very helpful in offering opinions of coins if you post or PM them. Good luck, Jerry >>
Right on. Tom B. helped me with these and I couldn't be happier.
Lance.
-Fred
Successful BST (me as buyer) with: Collectorcoins, PipestonePete, JasonRiffeRareCoins
<< <i>Just a random hypothetical wondering - would CAC sticker that coin? Do they look for recoloring with old copper?
-Fred >>
I just looked at all the CAC stickered large cents in the Boston Auction (11 of them) and they all look quite natural. I don't recall ever seeing a cent that I thought was recolored with a cac sticker.
edit to add: I don't think that coin would come close to stickering on technical grade independent of color.
--Jerry
<< <i>I dinked around a little o photoshop and think that they are same coin.
In any case I think that I would rather have the worked over one if I had to pick - be interesting to see it "in the flesh" >>
Joe,
Have you ever done any brushing of copper? I think some of the old EAC guys with their super soft brush and fine touch could have done a much better job of conserving the coin while leaving it looking natural. --Jerry
I do brush but only lightly and not on UNCs (only have 3 or 4 but one is CC1 - I pray it just stays red). The trick is to get the brush broken-in. I have well over 100 hours (praboably much more) on old English pennies and Blue Ribbon (the real stuff). Just get a bunch of OEP's, some BR, a pair of pliers and brush away on Sunday afternoon football. When the brush is really deep green you are good to go. Wally Lee gave his brush away and it did not last 30 seconds after the add hit - I think one noted EAC'er offered to sell his for $10,000 (he did brush A-1 stuff though). I think that it can really give a bit of pizzazz - many times it is a bit remarkable how it works. It also adds a bit of protection.
<< <i>Jerry,
I do brush but only lightly and not on UNCs (only have 3 or 4 but one is CC1 - I pray it just stays red). The trick is to get the brush broken-in. I have well over 100 hours (praboably much more) on old English pennies and Blue Ribbon (the real stuff). Just get a bunch of OEP's, some BR, a pair of pliers and brush away on Sunday afternoon football. When the brush is really deep green you are good to go. Wally Lee gave his brush away and it did not last 30 seconds after the add hit - I think one noted EAC'er offered to sell his for $10,000 (he did brush A-1 stuff though). I think that it can really give a bit of pizzazz - many times it is a bit remarkable how it works. It also adds a bit of protection. >>
Am I the only one that thinks all this is weird?
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
<< <i>Am I the only one that thinks all this is weird? >>
Probably not, but it's certainly not weird and actually standard practice among the real copper fanatics. Don't knock it until you've seen the results. I have seen the dealers, like Doug Bird, graciously brush large cents at shows for collectors and customers as a service.
I wished I could find the right kind of brush, and then make the effort to break it in. Currently I use worn, 'fluffy' Q-tips with old Blue Ribbon residue on them. Maybe this is really weird, but I get reasonable results. And the coins when submitted to both major TPG's certified just fine.