<< <i>WTF? Almost 2100 for a common date, one side toner? I wonder which eye the new owner will have that placed over when they lay him in his casket? >>
Good one and so true. P.T. Barnum has another reason for a good chuckle. >>
I don't consider the winning bidder to be a sucker. Why do you, especially if you haven't seen the coin? >>
Mark,
To be fair, paying over $1700 in premium for toning is usually reserved for monsters. I see nothing from those photos to indicate that this is anything but a typical rainbow toned common date Morgan Dollar. My first reaction when I saw the price was that the winning bidder was nuts. This coming from a guy who routinely pays ridiculous premiums for toned coins and is usually on the receiving end of such criticisms. I was going to guess $1,200 but you posted the answer to quick. Out of curiosity, what was your planned sale price on this coin? >>
Paul, I believe that you would feel at least somewhat differently, were you to see the coin in person. Either way, however, I don't automatically label a buyer who pays an extremely large premium for a coin, a fool. Especially when I haven't seen the coin in-hand. That was my disagreement (and complaint) with Dizzy's post.
In answer to your question, if I had bought the coin at or about my maximum bid of $920, I would have priced it at approximately $1050.
<< <i>The Doctor did a good job on that one... nice symmetry on the front, leaves the eye and top of the head relatively untoned. The reverse is a little uneven, what happened at LLAR of "Dollar"? Is the fingerprint at K6 where the coin was held during " the process "?
edit: above comment refers to OP coin. Different set of remarks (but not unrelated) would apply to above posted coin >>
The toning on both these coins is natural. That's what oxidation is. Whether it was expedited through human intervention, or aged gradually over time, nobody will ever know. The one thing we do know is, two independent third-parties the hobby generally recognizes as experts purport to stand behind the coins' marketability. That's what tips the scales, in these, always. Let's just take the coin the OP references as an illustration, as we don't know the cost of yours. I'll roughly break that $2070 down to, $270 for the coin, $1800 for the third-party endorsements.
First, a hearty round of thanks to Mark Feld for stating that the coin is lovely in hand. I was concerned about the noise in front of Liberty’s face – was hoping it was toning related. My anticipation for receipt of the dollar in hand has increased. Ditto for soty27. Having two pair of expert eyes being laid on the dollar gives me additional confidence that the coin will be a fitting addition to the harem.
I’m going to print this thread and include it in my records related to this coin. The lot appears in the auction manual on page 119, but does not sport a picture. When I first opened the auction page for this coin, I was awestruck. So, I set about systematically determining what I would give for it and the more mundane task of tracking the auction, as is my typical meticulous manner.
Setting aside DMPLs and PLs; there was a tab toned NGC-star monster that went for over $3700 in ‘06. Dismissed as a statistical outlier. Other toners went in the range of $7-900. A comparable (in that the toning had bands) went for $750 in ’05.
PCGS price guide for the 86-p in 66 = $500, 67 = $1625.
I also took a look at the toner dollars I purchased from Legend and compared comparable ‘common dates’: my 79-s, 88-o, 89-p and found a range of 2.2 to 3.7 times the PCGS price guide for the given grade. Note that the 89-p possesses a more desirable (IMHO) toning scheme – it was the 3.7 multiplier. The 89-p also went for more than its PCGS price guide in the next higher grade.
Finally, there is the ‘skunk’ factor – the noise in front of Liberty could have looked nasty in hand. The PCGS certification and the augmented Albanese/CAC attribution reduced the skunk factor substantially. Nevertheless, I figured if the dollar did not exceed $750 prior to the live auction time, it was a skunk and would be passed on.
Peering through this statistical fog, I arrived at a wide bid range of 1200-1900. Next, I monitored the auction progress, recognizing auction price versus time to auction is a basically parabolic function.
As the online bidding time window approached closing, I decided on a bid price to truly capture the coin would be 1800. I placed my bid of 1800 at about 8:30 AM. I was surprised and disappointed that it took the full 1800 to claim high bidder status. The surprise and disappointment also represented a vindication/verification of the coin’s quality. The ‘thrill of the hunt’ would have to extend to the live auction. I try my best to bottle up my emotions – would have preferred to have a good $3-400 margin between my max bid and current high bid, but this was not the case. I figured my emotional attachment to the coin was worth one bid cycle – would have gone to 2K. No one added to the sum at the live auction, thank heavens. I always feel uncomfortable mixing emotion and finances.
Obviously, to some of you pros – I’m living proof that PTBarnum was right. No offense taken whatsoever. From my perspective, this acquisition is a chance to fill a one-point coin in the J B N dollar collection with a distinctive coin that my heirs will be able to get good money for. For my part, I will surely enjoy gazing at the dollar, especially with the knowledge that two of you pros have already found the coin to be eye-candy.
In closing, thanks again to Mark Feld. It is nice to ‘know’ that to a trained, profession eye, I did well in capturing this quarry. I’m also aware of your generous offer vis-a-vie the upcoming B&M sale. I will not hesitate to PM you should a nice coin appear at this sale.
<< <i>WTF? Almost 2100 for a common date, one side toner? I wonder which eye the new owner will have that placed over when they lay him in his casket? >>
Good one and so true. P.T. Barnum has another reason for a good chuckle. >>
I don't consider the winning bidder to be a sucker. Why do you, especially if you haven't seen the coin? >>
Mark,
To be fair, paying over $1700 in premium for toning is usually reserved for monsters. I see nothing from those photos to indicate that this is anything but a typical rainbow toned common date Morgan Dollar. My first reaction when I saw the price was that the winning bidder was nuts. This coming from a guy who routinely pays ridiculous premiums for toned coins and is usually on the receiving end of such criticisms. I was going to guess $1,200 but you posted the answer to quick. Out of curiosity, what was your planned sale price on this coin? >>
Paul, I believe that you would feel at least somewhat differently, were you to see the coin in person. Either way, however, I don't automatically label a buyer who pays an extremely large premium for a coin, a fool. Especially when I haven't seen the coin in-hand. That was my disagreement (and complaint) with Dizzy's post.
In answer to your question, if I had bought the coin at or about my maximum bid of $920, I would have priced it at approximately $1050. >>
If you really feel that seeing the coin in hand could change my opinion then I think soty27's comment must valid that Heritage's photo really doesn't do this coin justice. Personally, I do not like the new photographic method of Heritage and I find it much harder to predict what the coin will actually look like in hand.
I looked at the coin for quite some time Wednesday morning during lot viewing. I can say with 100% certainty that in this case the image was nowhere near the coin in hand. The coin exhibits a stunning vivid emerald green almost monocromaticly on the obverse that IMO is the toughest color to find on a toned morgan. I am also a pretty big fan of the geometrical lines going horizontaly accross the obverse of the coin, it reminds me of the old albums people would house morgans in that had the clear strip that would cause these toning lines. Its a very deep rich color and very nice luster as well. It's a coin I would have no problem paying a nice premium for and almost did although obviously I was outbid.
JBN,
Congrats on the new purchase, if time comes to sell that beauty feel free to give me a ring
Sometimes the coins look better in hand than the Heritage pics,sometimes they do not.My advice is ALWAYS see the coin in hand,or have a trusted representative look at it for you BEFORE you bid.JMHO
Great coins are not cheap,and cheap coins are not great!
Maybe the bidders weren't scared off, but consider this hypothetical:
Let's say Joe Blow comes out of the woodwork now and shows a videotape of the OP coin being transformed chemically from white to its present colors. It is proven to be AT.
Now does PCGS pay out $200 or $2000 ???
"Wars are really ugly! They're dirty and they're cold. I don't want nobody to shoot me in the foxhole." Mary
The toning isn't an issue and the date isn't as common as others that come attractively toned but the actual price realized is much higher than what would be expected.
Apparently at least two people really liked the coin this time.
Follow me on Twitter @wtcgroup Authorized dealer for PCGS, PCGS Currency, NGC, NCS, PMG, CAC. Member of the PNG, ANA. Member dealer of CoinPlex and CCE/FACTS as "CH5"
<< <i>Maybe the bidders weren't scared off, but consider this hypothetical:
Let's say Joe Blow comes out of the woodwork now and shows a videotape of the OP coin being transformed chemically from white to its present colors. It is proven to be AT.
Now does PCGS pay out $200 or $2000 ??? >>
It's clear the buyer relied on both PCGS and CAC in the bidding ("The PCGS certification and the augmented Albanese/CAC attribution reduced the skunk factor substantially."). I don't know the answer to your question, though.
<< <i>Maybe the bidders weren't scared off, but consider this hypothetical:
Let's say Joe Blow comes out of the woodwork now and shows a videotape of the OP coin being transformed chemically from white to its present colors. It is proven to be AT.
Now does PCGS pay out $200 or $2000 ??? >>
It's clear the buyer relied on both PCGS and CAC in the bidding ("The PCGS certification and the augmented Albanese/CAC attribution reduced the skunk factor substantially."). I don't know the answer to your question, though. >>
I don't think that CAC is confirming the toning as NT.; just that the coin is good/great for the grade.
<< <i>The toning isn't an issue and the date isn't as common as others that come attractively toned but the actual price realized is much higher than what would be expected.
Apparently at least two people really liked the coin this time. >>
Nice toning on the money side of a high grade coin will do that. If that was a 63 one would be lucky to get a third of that.
First, a hearty round of thanks to Mark Feld for stating that the coin is lovely in hand. I was concerned about the noise in front of Liberty’s face – was hoping it was toning related. My anticipation for receipt of the dollar in hand has increased. Ditto for soty27. Having two pair of expert eyes being laid on the dollar gives me additional confidence that the coin will be a fitting addition to the harem.
I’m going to print this thread and include it in my records related to this coin. The lot appears in the auction manual on page 119, but does not sport a picture. When I first opened the auction page for this coin, I was awestruck. So, I set about systematically determining what I would give for it and the more mundane task of tracking the auction, as is my typical meticulous manner.
Setting aside DMPLs and PLs; there was a tab toned NGC-star monster that went for over $3700 in ‘06. Dismissed as a statistical outlier. Other toners went in the range of $7-900. A comparable (in that the toning had bands) went for $750 in ’05.
PCGS price guide for the 86-p in 66 = $500, 67 = $1625.
I also took a look at the toner dollars I purchased from Legend and compared comparable ‘common dates’: my 79-s, 88-o, 89-p and found a range of 2.2 to 3.7 times the PCGS price guide for the given grade. Note that the 89-p possesses a more desirable (IMHO) toning scheme – it was the 3.7 multiplier. The 89-p also went for more than its PCGS price guide in the next higher grade.
Finally, there is the ‘skunk’ factor – the noise in front of Liberty could have looked nasty in hand. The PCGS certification and the augmented Albanese/CAC attribution reduced the skunk factor substantially. Nevertheless, I figured if the dollar did not exceed $750 prior to the live auction time, it was a skunk and would be passed on.
Peering through this statistical fog, I arrived at a wide bid range of 1200-1900. Next, I monitored the auction progress, recognizing auction price versus time to auction is a basically parabolic function.
As the online bidding time window approached closing, I decided on a bid price to truly capture the coin would be 1800. I placed my bid of 1800 at about 8:30 AM. I was surprised and disappointed that it took the full 1800 to claim high bidder status. The surprise and disappointment also represented a vindication/verification of the coin’s quality. The ‘thrill of the hunt’ would have to extend to the live auction. I try my best to bottle up my emotions – would have preferred to have a good $3-400 margin between my max bid and current high bid, but this was not the case. I figured my emotional attachment to the coin was worth one bid cycle – would have gone to 2K. No one added to the sum at the live auction, thank heavens. I always feel uncomfortable mixing emotion and finances.
Obviously, to some of you pros – I’m living proof that PTBarnum was right. No offense taken whatsoever. From my perspective, this acquisition is a chance to fill a one-point coin in the J B N dollar collection with a distinctive coin that my heirs will be able to get good money for. For my part, I will surely enjoy gazing at the dollar, especially with the knowledge that two of you pros have already found the coin to be eye-candy.
In closing, thanks again to Mark Feld. It is nice to ‘know’ that to a trained, profession eye, I did well in capturing this quarry. I’m also aware of your generous offer vis-a-vie the upcoming B&M sale. I will not hesitate to PM you should a nice coin appear at this sale. >>
What a gracious and thoughtful post, especially considering a few of the comments here.
And regardless of what anyone might think about the price paid for the coin, based on the analysis and thought that you put into it, you sure don't sound like a sucker to me. Congratulations on your new purchase.
<< <i>Maybe the bidders weren't scared off, but consider this hypothetical:
Let's say Joe Blow comes out of the woodwork now and shows a videotape of the OP coin being transformed chemically from white to its present colors. It is proven to be AT.
Now does PCGS pay out $200 or $2000 ??? >>
It's clear the buyer relied on both PCGS and CAC in the bidding ("The PCGS certification and the augmented Albanese/CAC attribution reduced the skunk factor substantially."). I don't know the answer to your question, though. >>
I don't think that CAC is confirming the toning as NT.; just that the coin is good/great for the grade. >>
If CAC didn't think the toning was natural, they wouldn't have stickered the coin.
Edited to add: Oops, I see that Realone beat me to it AND that I agree with him.
Bajjerfan, You can't compare an Obverse only toner to a reverse only toner.the price differences and demand just aren't the same. oh, sure, it's crazy money for this coin,but the new owner has done his homework and more importantly likes the coin alot. I myself would have liked a more bright irridescence on a Morgan for that money. But,what do I know?I also wonder about how a pattern like that was achieved.I've seen somewhat similar blank centers when a coin was eiither kept in a certain album with a strip of elasticized cloth to hold it in the space rather that a plastic lens or if it were in a "tidy house" or similar holder where tape was used to secure it. Any other ideas?
Let's say Joe Blow comes out of the woodwork now and shows a videotape of the OP coin being transformed chemically from white to its present colors. It is proven to be AT.
Now does PCGS pay out $200 or $2000 ??? >>
I musta missed the answer to this question ...........
That was rather refreshing response and I enjoyed it immensely. Well done, well done indeed. MJ
Walker Proof Digital Album Fellas, leave the tight pants to the ladies. If I can count the coins in your pockets you better use them to call a tailor. Stay thirsty my friends......
The PCGS MS66 1886 Morgan Dollar below looked much more impressive in-hand, but I was still surprised that it brought as much as it did. The last three to be sold by Heritage brought an average price of about $236. Care to guess what this one brought?
<< <i>I was frankly blown away by the research but my question is, if one is the only collector who would go to that extent to justify price to be paid and no one else would go to that extent would you then run into trouble next time around when you go to sell it? >>
Why not ask the same about any coin that sells to a high bidder in an auction, or via private sale, for that matter?
<I was frankly blown away by the research but my question is, if one is the only collector who would go to that extent to justify price to be paid and no one else would go to that extent would you then run into trouble next time around when you go to sell it?>
There is no doubt in my mind that if this coin ended up on Legend or a comparable site and today was properly photographed it would bring near or more money. I think there are at least three folks posting in this thread that would buy this piece today at the same price. Who knows in the future. The coin will always have beaucoup eye appeal. JMHO. MJ
Walker Proof Digital Album Fellas, leave the tight pants to the ladies. If I can count the coins in your pockets you better use them to call a tailor. Stay thirsty my friends......
The PCGS MS66 1886 Morgan Dollar below looked much more impressive in-hand, but I was still surprised that it brought as much as it did. The last three to be sold by Heritage brought an average price of about $236. Care to guess what this one brought?
>>
Very nice rainbow tone, but $2000+? I mean, WTH?
>>
The 2 or 3 -1886 morgans you posted are not even in the ballpark of the one that just sold in heritage nor are any in the recent archives. You cant compare coins in that way and excpect to come to an understanding of why one sold for more than another.
I understand that there is alot of misinforamtion out there regarding toned coins and a lot of collectors that don't understand the prices paid for some coins with outstanding toning. The bottom line is that if you are not an avid collector of such coins you are most likely never going to understand simply due to the amount of time it takes to gain the information needed to understand. I find it amusing the number of people in this thread bashing the recent buyer of this coin but I can guarantee that none of the people bashing the recent purchase put in half the work determining an appropriate price to pay for the coin as the new buyer did. Just because someone doesn't understand or agree with something does not mean you need to go around assuming others are stupid for knowing more about an area of numismatics. Generally when people do step out and pay big money for a coin they have put some time in to determine an appropriate price, there are very very few people out there that just drop tens of thousands on coins without any idea of what they are buying.
<< <i>why is it this man is applauded for paying 4X PCGS guide for a coin such as this ,
and yet when I do no different with a superb toned PCGS Franklin ,
I get batted around like a step child ? >>
I think some assume you like the beatings
Besides you Frankies guys march to a beat of a different drummer
I wouldn't sweat it for one second.................MJ
Walker Proof Digital Album Fellas, leave the tight pants to the ladies. If I can count the coins in your pockets you better use them to call a tailor. Stay thirsty my friends......
<< <i>why is it this man is applauded for paying 4X PCGS guide for a coin such as this ,
and yet when I do no different with a superb toned PCGS Franklin ,
I get batted around like a step child ? >>
I dont think anyone applauded him? I actually took the thread as the opposite, it sounded like he was the step child except for a few people who saw the coin in hand and agreed that it was much better then the images. I could be wrong though as it has happend before.
The PCGS MS66 1886 Morgan Dollar below looked much more impressive in-hand, but I was still surprised that it brought as much as it did. The last three to be sold by Heritage brought an average price of about $236. Care to guess what this one brought?
>>
Very nice rainbow tone, but $2000+? I mean, WTH?
>>
The 2 or 3 -1886 morgans you posted are not even in the ballpark of the one that just sold in heritage nor are any in the recent archives. You cant compare coins in that way and excpect to come to an understanding of why one sold for more than another.
I understand that there is alot of misinforamtion out there regarding toned coins and a lot of collectors that don't understand the prices paid for some coins with outstanding toning. The bottom line is that if you are not an avid collector of such coins you are most likely never going to understand simply due to the amount of time it takes to gain the information needed to understand. I find it amusing the number of people in this thread bashing the recent buyer of this coin but I can guarantee that none of the people bashing the recent purchase put in half the work determining an appropriate price to pay for the coin as the new buyer did. Just because someone doesn't understand or agree with something does not mean you need to go around assuming others are stupid for knowing more about an area of numismatics. Generally when people do step out and pay big money for a coin they have put some time in to determine an appropriate price, there are very very few people out there that just drop tens of thousands on coins without any idea of what they are buying. >>
"there is alot of misinforamtion out there regarding toned coins"
"a lot of collectors that don't understand the prices paid for some coins with outstanding toning"
Besides not knowing how to spell, what kind of stupid statements are these? Don't question my experience with toned coins or my buying experience.
Geez, that toner for more than $300 is total crap if you ask me. It isn't even CLOSE to my top THIRTHY rainbow Morgans. What a joke! What a SCAM!
The PCGS MS66 1886 Morgan Dollar below looked much more impressive in-hand, but I was still surprised that it brought as much as it did. The last three to be sold by Heritage brought an average price of about $236. Care to guess what this one brought?
>>
Very nice rainbow tone, but $2000+? I mean, WTH?
>>
The 2 or 3 -1886 morgans you posted are not even in the ballpark of the one that just sold in heritage nor are any in the recent archives. You cant compare coins in that way and excpect to come to an understanding of why one sold for more than another.
I understand that there is alot of misinforamation out there regarding toned coins and a lot of collectors that don't understand the prices paid for some coins with outstanding toning. The bottom line is that if you are not an avid collector of such coins you are most likely never going to understand simply due to the amount of time it takes to gain the information needed to understand. I find it amusing the number of people in this thread bashing the recent buyer of this coin but I can guarantee that none of the people bashing the recent purchase put in half the work determining an appropriate price to pay for the coin as the new buyer did. Just because someone doesn't understand or agree with something does not mean you need to go around assuming others are stupid for knowing more about an area of numismatics. Generally when people do step out and pay big money for a coin they have put some time in to determine an appropriate price, there are very very few people out there that just drop tens of thousands on coins without any idea of what they are buying. >>
"there is alot of misinforamtion out there regarding toned coins"
"a lot of collectors that don't understand the prices paid for some coins with outstanding toning"
Besides not knowing how to spell, what kind of stupid statements are these? Don't question my experience with toned coins or my buying experience.
Geez, that toner for more than $300 is total crap if you ask me. It isn't even CLOSE to my top THIRTHY rainbow Morgans. What a joke! What a SCAM! >>
It was a typo but thanks
How is saying that there is alot of misinformation out there regarding toned coins a stupid statement? How is saying alot of colectors dont understand the prices paid for coins with outstanding toning a stupid statement? Its a fact!!
On another note I was not questioning your experience simply stating what I have found to be facts.
I assume you have not seen the coin in question in hand?? As stated by others then myself the coin is far better then the heritage image. Judging by the other 1886 morgans you posted in comparison to the one in question and the fact that you dont feel the coin is worth more then 300.00 then its pretty clear we have a different opinion on the matter. I would however love to see one of your coins you feel top the coin in question, or several of them considering you stated this coin would not even be close to your top thirty coins.
<< <i> I assume you have not seen the coin in question in hand?? As stated by others then myself the coin is far better then the heritage image. Judging by the other 1886 morgans you posted in comparison to the one in question and the fact that you dont feel the coin is worth more then 300.00 then its pretty clear we have a different opinion on the matter. I would however love to see one of your coins you feel top the coin in question, or several of them considering you stated this coin would not even be close to your top thirty coins. >>
Look, I ain't got no dog in this fight, just calls them as I see them. But I am positive the first 4 coins are AT, and would bet that at least 2 of the others would be Questionable upon resubmission.
<< <i>PS: I'm STILL trying to understand how the OP coin was supposed to have gotten toned in that pattern. Is there a "story" to go with it? >>
I cant say for 100% as I dont know the coins history although there are some older morgan dollar books that do have a small strip that run horizontally accross the coin. I have seen other morgans that came straight from these books that have the same pattern.
The PCGS MS66 1886 Morgan Dollar below looked much more impressive in-hand, but I was still surprised that it brought as much as it did. The last three to be sold by Heritage brought an average price of about $236. Care to guess what this one brought?
>>
Very nice rainbow tone, but $2000+? I mean, WTH?
>>
The 2 or 3 -1886 morgans you posted are not even in the ballpark of the one that just sold in heritage nor are any in the recent archives. You cant compare coins in that way and excpect to come to an understanding of why one sold for more than another.
I understand that there is alot of misinforamtion out there regarding toned coins and a lot of collectors that don't understand the prices paid for some coins with outstanding toning. The bottom line is that if you are not an avid collector of such coins you are most likely never going to understand simply due to the amount of time it takes to gain the information needed to understand. I find it amusing the number of people in this thread bashing the recent buyer of this coin but I can guarantee that none of the people bashing the recent purchase put in half the work determining an appropriate price to pay for the coin as the new buyer did. Just because someone doesn't understand or agree with something does not mean you need to go around assuming others are stupid for knowing more about an area of numismatics. Generally when people do step out and pay big money for a coin they have put some time in to determine an appropriate price, there are very very few people out there that just drop tens of thousands on coins without any idea of what they are buying. >>
"there is alot of misinforamtion out there regarding toned coins"
"a lot of collectors that don't understand the prices paid for some coins with outstanding toning"
Besides not knowing how to spell, what kind of stupid statements are these? Don't question my experience with toned coins or my buying experience.
Geez, that toner for more than $300 is total crap if you ask me. It isn't even CLOSE to my top THIRTHY rainbow Morgans. What a joke! What a SCAM! >>
The fact that someone's post includes a typo doesn't necessarily have anything to do with whether they know how to spell.
And I happen to think the statements you referred to as" stupid" made plenty of sense, especially in the context of this thread. In fact, if you believe that " that toner for more than $300 is total crap", it says a lot about your lack of familiarity with such coins. Did you see the price guesses that others posted here, even though they didn't see how wonderful it looked in-hand?
Thats was one heck of an 1886 Morgan! I bid $1,200.00 on the internet and thought I would own it for sure. While I am glad it sold for $2,070.00, I am unhappy I did not buy it.
I'll tell everyone a little secret I knew about the coin: it was from Legends Sonnier Collection. Laura told me she sold it raw to a dealer who must have consigned it to the Heritage sale.
The originality and monster color of the piece in my mind never was in question. The image did not do it any good.
And to who ever it is (Griv??) posting those flaming AT Morgans-go take an ANA Seminar and learn about color!
My anticipation for receipt of the coin continues to grow….
Thanks to those who like the coin. I derive substantial additional confidence w/AB’s comment – as AB has posted coins that, to me, are drop dead gorgeous and worth ‘PTBarnum money’ to me. That collage picture still resonates in my mind.
Thanks to icsoccer, Barndog, and Justacommemen/MJ for your comments. And of course, the gracious Mark Feld.
To the PTBarnum group: Thanks for your comments as well. That is the beauty of the system – there will always be disagreement. If everybody liked the dollar, I would not own it today!
It is interesting to reconstruct the principal players in the auction.
Also note that this thread, in three places (Mark Feld, soty27 on a different coin, and DaveE), verifies the statement that ‘private treaty results in lower pricing’.
Second thanks to DaveE for the ‘little secret’. I’m going to roll that info into my attribution file for this coin.
Finally, I’ll take an action to photograph the dollar when it arrives and learn how to post pictures on this forum. I should learn how to post pix.
Walker Proof Digital Album Fellas, leave the tight pants to the ladies. If I can count the coins in your pockets you better use them to call a tailor. Stay thirsty my friends......
Comments
<< <i>
<< <i>WTF? Almost 2100 for a common date, one side toner? I wonder which eye the new owner will have that placed over when they lay him in his casket?
...i thought the cent was used for that.
The new owner of the 1886 obviously has no cents...
He must have big eyes then.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>WTF? Almost 2100 for a common date, one side toner? I wonder which eye the new owner will have that placed over when they lay him in his casket?
Good one and so true. P.T. Barnum has another reason for a good chuckle.
I don't consider the winning bidder to be a sucker. Why do you, especially if you haven't seen the coin? >>
Mark,
To be fair, paying over $1700 in premium for toning is usually reserved for monsters. I see nothing from those photos to indicate that this is anything but a typical rainbow toned common date Morgan Dollar. My first reaction when I saw the price was that the winning bidder was nuts. This coming from a guy who routinely pays ridiculous premiums for toned coins and is usually on the receiving end of such criticisms. I was going to guess $1,200 but you posted the answer to quick. Out of curiosity, what was your planned sale price on this coin? >>
Paul, I believe that you would feel at least somewhat differently, were you to see the coin in person. Either way, however, I don't automatically label a buyer who pays an extremely large premium for a coin, a fool. Especially when I haven't seen the coin in-hand. That was my disagreement (and complaint) with Dizzy's post.
In answer to your question, if I had bought the coin at or about my maximum bid of $920, I would have priced it at approximately $1050.
<< <i>The Doctor did a good job on that one... nice symmetry on the front, leaves the eye and top of the head relatively untoned. The reverse is a little uneven, what happened at LLAR of "Dollar"? Is the fingerprint at K6 where the coin was held during " the process "?
edit: above comment refers to OP coin. Different set of remarks (but not unrelated) would apply to above posted coin
The toning on both these coins is natural. That's what oxidation is. Whether it was expedited through human intervention, or aged gradually over time, nobody will ever know. The one thing we do know is, two independent third-parties the hobby generally recognizes as experts purport to stand behind the coins' marketability. That's what tips the scales, in these, always. Let's just take the coin the OP references as an illustration, as we don't know the cost of yours. I'll roughly break that $2070 down to, $270 for the coin, $1800 for the third-party endorsements.
Now, that's just roughly, I'm just estimating...
First, a hearty round of thanks to Mark Feld for stating that the coin is lovely in hand. I was concerned about the noise in front of Liberty’s face – was hoping it was toning related. My anticipation for receipt of the dollar in hand has increased. Ditto for soty27. Having two pair of expert eyes being laid on the dollar gives me additional confidence that the coin will be a fitting addition to the harem.
I’m going to print this thread and include it in my records related to this coin. The lot appears in the auction manual on page 119, but does not sport a picture. When I first opened the auction page for this coin, I was awestruck. So, I set about systematically determining what I would give for it and the more mundane task of tracking the auction, as is my typical meticulous manner.
Setting aside DMPLs and PLs; there was a tab toned NGC-star monster that went for over $3700 in ‘06. Dismissed as a statistical outlier. Other toners went in the range of $7-900. A comparable (in that the toning had bands) went for $750 in ’05.
PCGS price guide for the 86-p in 66 = $500, 67 = $1625.
I also took a look at the toner dollars I purchased from Legend and compared comparable ‘common dates’: my 79-s, 88-o, 89-p and found a range of 2.2 to 3.7 times the PCGS price guide for the given grade. Note that the 89-p possesses a more desirable (IMHO) toning scheme – it was the 3.7 multiplier. The 89-p also went for more than its PCGS price guide in the next higher grade.
Finally, there is the ‘skunk’ factor – the noise in front of Liberty could have looked nasty in hand. The PCGS certification and the augmented Albanese/CAC attribution reduced the skunk factor substantially. Nevertheless, I figured if the dollar did not exceed $750 prior to the live auction time, it was a skunk and would be passed on.
Peering through this statistical fog, I arrived at a wide bid range of 1200-1900. Next, I monitored the auction progress, recognizing auction price versus time to auction is a basically parabolic function.
Auction tracking progress:
Date Bidders Trackers Views HiBid
6/26 6 17 88 240
6/27 6 19 101 280
6/28 7 20 114 425
6/29 7 19 121 425
6/30 7 22 123 425
7/2 7 23 132 425
7/3 7 23 137 425
7/4 7 23 139 425
7/5 7 25 146 425
7/6 7 24 151 425
7/7 8 24 161 550
7/8 5AM 13 26 178 950
7/8 4PM 13 26 192 1200
7/8 7PM 13 26 194 1200
7/9 5AM 13 25 201 1200
As the online bidding time window approached closing, I decided on a bid price to truly capture the coin would be 1800. I placed my bid of 1800 at about 8:30 AM. I was surprised and disappointed that it took the full 1800 to claim high bidder status. The surprise and disappointment also represented a vindication/verification of the coin’s quality. The ‘thrill of the hunt’ would have to extend to the live auction. I try my best to bottle up my emotions – would have preferred to have a good $3-400 margin between my max bid and current high bid, but this was not the case. I figured my emotional attachment to the coin was worth one bid cycle – would have gone to 2K. No one added to the sum at the live auction, thank heavens. I always feel uncomfortable mixing emotion and finances.
Obviously, to some of you pros – I’m living proof that PTBarnum was right. No offense taken whatsoever. From my perspective, this acquisition is a chance to fill a one-point coin in the J B N dollar collection with a distinctive coin that my heirs will be able to get good money for. For my part, I will surely enjoy gazing at the dollar, especially with the knowledge that two of you pros have already found the coin to be eye-candy.
In closing, thanks again to Mark Feld. It is nice to ‘know’ that to a trained, profession eye, I did well in capturing this quarry. I’m also aware of your generous offer vis-a-vie the upcoming B&M sale. I will not hesitate to PM you should a nice coin appear at this sale.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>WTF? Almost 2100 for a common date, one side toner? I wonder which eye the new owner will have that placed over when they lay him in his casket?
Good one and so true. P.T. Barnum has another reason for a good chuckle.
I don't consider the winning bidder to be a sucker. Why do you, especially if you haven't seen the coin? >>
Mark,
To be fair, paying over $1700 in premium for toning is usually reserved for monsters. I see nothing from those photos to indicate that this is anything but a typical rainbow toned common date Morgan Dollar. My first reaction when I saw the price was that the winning bidder was nuts. This coming from a guy who routinely pays ridiculous premiums for toned coins and is usually on the receiving end of such criticisms. I was going to guess $1,200 but you posted the answer to quick. Out of curiosity, what was your planned sale price on this coin? >>
Paul, I believe that you would feel at least somewhat differently, were you to see the coin in person. Either way, however, I don't automatically label a buyer who pays an extremely large premium for a coin, a fool. Especially when I haven't seen the coin in-hand. That was my disagreement (and complaint) with Dizzy's post.
In answer to your question, if I had bought the coin at or about my maximum bid of $920, I would have priced it at approximately $1050. >>
If you really feel that seeing the coin in hand could change my opinion then I think soty27's comment must valid that Heritage's photo really doesn't do this coin justice. Personally, I do not like the new photographic method of Heritage and I find it much harder to predict what the coin will actually look like in hand.
I looked at the coin for quite some time Wednesday morning during lot viewing. I can say with 100% certainty that in this case the image was nowhere near the coin in hand. The coin exhibits a stunning vivid emerald green almost monocromaticly on the obverse that IMO is the toughest color to find on a toned morgan. I am also a pretty big fan of the geometrical lines going horizontaly accross the obverse of the coin, it reminds me of the old albums people would house morgans in that had the clear strip that would cause these toning lines. Its a very deep rich color and very nice luster as well. It's a coin I would have no problem paying a nice premium for and almost did although obviously I was outbid.
JBN,
Congrats on the new purchase, if time comes to sell that beauty feel free to give me a ring
Let's say Joe Blow comes out of the woodwork now and shows a videotape of the OP coin being transformed chemically from white to its present colors. It is proven to be AT.
Now does PCGS pay out $200 or $2000 ???
and they're cold.
I don't want nobody to shoot me in the foxhole."
Mary
Best Franklin Website
Apparently at least two people really liked the coin this time.
Authorized dealer for PCGS, PCGS Currency, NGC, NCS, PMG, CAC. Member of the PNG, ANA. Member dealer of CoinPlex and CCE/FACTS as "CH5"
<< <i>Maybe the bidders weren't scared off, but consider this hypothetical:
Let's say Joe Blow comes out of the woodwork now and shows a videotape of the OP coin being transformed chemically from white to its present colors. It is proven to be AT.
Now does PCGS pay out $200 or $2000 ??? >>
It's clear the buyer relied on both PCGS and CAC in the bidding ("The PCGS certification and the augmented Albanese/CAC attribution reduced the skunk factor substantially."). I don't know the answer to your question, though.
<< <i>
<< <i>Maybe the bidders weren't scared off, but consider this hypothetical:
Let's say Joe Blow comes out of the woodwork now and shows a videotape of the OP coin being transformed chemically from white to its present colors. It is proven to be AT.
Now does PCGS pay out $200 or $2000 ??? >>
It's clear the buyer relied on both PCGS and CAC in the bidding ("The PCGS certification and the augmented Albanese/CAC attribution reduced the skunk factor substantially."). I don't know the answer to your question, though. >>
I don't think that CAC is confirming the toning as NT.; just that the coin is good/great for the grade.
<< <i>The toning isn't an issue and the date isn't as common as others that come attractively toned but the actual price realized is much higher than what would be expected.
Apparently at least two people really liked the coin this time. >>
Nice toning on the money side of a high grade coin will do that. If that was a 63 one would be lucky to get a third of that.
<< <i>I am the new owner of this dollar.
First, a hearty round of thanks to Mark Feld for stating that the coin is lovely in hand. I was concerned about the noise in front of Liberty’s face – was hoping it was toning related. My anticipation for receipt of the dollar in hand has increased. Ditto for soty27. Having two pair of expert eyes being laid on the dollar gives me additional confidence that the coin will be a fitting addition to the harem.
I’m going to print this thread and include it in my records related to this coin. The lot appears in the auction manual on page 119, but does not sport a picture. When I first opened the auction page for this coin, I was awestruck. So, I set about systematically determining what I would give for it and the more mundane task of tracking the auction, as is my typical meticulous manner.
Setting aside DMPLs and PLs; there was a tab toned NGC-star monster that went for over $3700 in ‘06. Dismissed as a statistical outlier. Other toners went in the range of $7-900. A comparable (in that the toning had bands) went for $750 in ’05.
PCGS price guide for the 86-p in 66 = $500, 67 = $1625.
I also took a look at the toner dollars I purchased from Legend and compared comparable ‘common dates’: my 79-s, 88-o, 89-p and found a range of 2.2 to 3.7 times the PCGS price guide for the given grade. Note that the 89-p possesses a more desirable (IMHO) toning scheme – it was the 3.7 multiplier. The 89-p also went for more than its PCGS price guide in the next higher grade.
Finally, there is the ‘skunk’ factor – the noise in front of Liberty could have looked nasty in hand. The PCGS certification and the augmented Albanese/CAC attribution reduced the skunk factor substantially. Nevertheless, I figured if the dollar did not exceed $750 prior to the live auction time, it was a skunk and would be passed on.
Peering through this statistical fog, I arrived at a wide bid range of 1200-1900. Next, I monitored the auction progress, recognizing auction price versus time to auction is a basically parabolic function.
Auction tracking progress:
Date Bidders Trackers Views HiBid
6/26 6 17 88 240
6/27 6 19 101 280
6/28 7 20 114 425
6/29 7 19 121 425
6/30 7 22 123 425
7/2 7 23 132 425
7/3 7 23 137 425
7/4 7 23 139 425
7/5 7 25 146 425
7/6 7 24 151 425
7/7 8 24 161 550
7/8 5AM 13 26 178 950
7/8 4PM 13 26 192 1200
7/8 7PM 13 26 194 1200
7/9 5AM 13 25 201 1200
As the online bidding time window approached closing, I decided on a bid price to truly capture the coin would be 1800. I placed my bid of 1800 at about 8:30 AM. I was surprised and disappointed that it took the full 1800 to claim high bidder status. The surprise and disappointment also represented a vindication/verification of the coin’s quality. The ‘thrill of the hunt’ would have to extend to the live auction. I try my best to bottle up my emotions – would have preferred to have a good $3-400 margin between my max bid and current high bid, but this was not the case. I figured my emotional attachment to the coin was worth one bid cycle – would have gone to 2K. No one added to the sum at the live auction, thank heavens. I always feel uncomfortable mixing emotion and finances.
Obviously, to some of you pros – I’m living proof that PTBarnum was right. No offense taken whatsoever. From my perspective, this acquisition is a chance to fill a one-point coin in the J B N dollar collection with a distinctive coin that my heirs will be able to get good money for. For my part, I will surely enjoy gazing at the dollar, especially with the knowledge that two of you pros have already found the coin to be eye-candy.
In closing, thanks again to Mark Feld. It is nice to ‘know’ that to a trained, profession eye, I did well in capturing this quarry. I’m also aware of your generous offer vis-a-vie the upcoming B&M sale. I will not hesitate to PM you should a nice coin appear at this sale. >>
What a gracious and thoughtful post, especially considering a few of the comments here.
And regardless of what anyone might think about the price paid for the coin, based on the analysis and thought that you put into it, you sure don't sound like a sucker to me. Congratulations on your new purchase.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Maybe the bidders weren't scared off, but consider this hypothetical:
Let's say Joe Blow comes out of the woodwork now and shows a videotape of the OP coin being transformed chemically from white to its present colors. It is proven to be AT.
Now does PCGS pay out $200 or $2000 ??? >>
It's clear the buyer relied on both PCGS and CAC in the bidding ("The PCGS certification and the augmented Albanese/CAC attribution reduced the skunk factor substantially."). I don't know the answer to your question, though. >>
I don't think that CAC is confirming the toning as NT.; just that the coin is good/great for the grade. >>
If CAC didn't think the toning was natural, they wouldn't have stickered the coin.
Edited to add: Oops, I see that Realone beat me to it AND that I agree with him.
<< <i>I don't think that CAC is confirming the toning as NT.; just that the coin is good/great for the grade. >>
Yeah, who knows? But then the PCGS grade the CAC is endorsing is a "market grade" and that would necessarily incorporate the toning in the grade.
I'm going to say these both limit their liability, here, but I don't know, I'm not familiar with their guarantees.
You can't compare an Obverse only toner to a reverse only toner.the price differences and demand just aren't the same. oh, sure, it's crazy money for this coin,but the new owner has done his homework and more importantly likes the coin alot. I myself would have liked a more bright irridescence on a Morgan for that money. But,what do I know?I also wonder about how a pattern like that was achieved.I've seen somewhat similar blank centers when a coin was eiither kept in a certain album with a strip of elasticized cloth to hold it in the space rather that a plastic lens or if it were in a "tidy house" or similar holder where tape was used to secure it. Any other ideas?
Now does PCGS pay out $200 or $2000 ??? >>
I musta missed the answer to this question ...........
That was rather refreshing response and I enjoyed it immensely. Well done, well done indeed. MJ
Fellas, leave the tight pants to the ladies. If I can count the coins in your pockets you better use them to call a tailor. Stay thirsty my friends......
<< <i>
The PCGS MS66 1886 Morgan Dollar below looked much more impressive in-hand, but I was still surprised that it brought as much as it did. The last three to be sold by Heritage brought an average price of about $236. Care to guess what this one brought?
Very nice rainbow tone, but $2000+? I mean, WTH?
<< <i>I was frankly blown away by the research but my question is, if one is the only collector who would go to that extent to justify price to be paid and no one else would go to that extent would you then run into trouble next time around when you go to sell it? >>
Why not ask the same about any coin that sells to a high bidder in an auction, or via private sale, for that matter?
AB
There is no doubt in my mind that if this coin ended up on Legend or a comparable site and today was properly photographed it would bring near or more money. I think there are at least three folks posting in this thread that would buy this piece today at the same price. Who knows in the future. The coin will always have beaucoup eye appeal. JMHO. MJ
Fellas, leave the tight pants to the ladies. If I can count the coins in your pockets you better use them to call a tailor. Stay thirsty my friends......
<< <i>
<< <i>
The PCGS MS66 1886 Morgan Dollar below looked much more impressive in-hand, but I was still surprised that it brought as much as it did. The last three to be sold by Heritage brought an average price of about $236. Care to guess what this one brought?
Very nice rainbow tone, but $2000+? I mean, WTH?
The 2 or 3 -1886 morgans you posted are not even in the ballpark of the one that just sold in heritage nor are any in the recent archives. You cant compare coins in that way and excpect to come to an understanding of why one sold for more than another.
I understand that there is alot of misinforamtion out there regarding toned coins and a lot of collectors that don't understand the prices paid for some coins with outstanding toning. The bottom line is that if you are not an avid collector of such coins you are most likely never going to understand simply due to the amount of time it takes to gain the information needed to understand. I find it amusing the number of people in this thread bashing the recent buyer of this coin but I can guarantee that none of the people bashing the recent purchase put in half the work determining an appropriate price to pay for the coin as the new buyer did. Just because someone doesn't understand or agree with something does not mean you need to go around assuming others are stupid for knowing more about an area of numismatics. Generally when people do step out and pay big money for a coin they have put some time in to determine an appropriate price, there are very very few people out there that just drop tens of thousands on coins without any idea of what they are buying.
and yet when I do no different with a superb toned PCGS Franklin ,
I get batted around like a step child ?
<< <i>why is it this man is applauded for paying 4X PCGS guide for a coin such as this ,
and yet when I do no different with a superb toned PCGS Franklin ,
I get batted around like a step child ? >>
I think some assume you like the beatings
Besides you Frankies guys march to a beat of a different drummer
I wouldn't sweat it for one second.................MJ
Fellas, leave the tight pants to the ladies. If I can count the coins in your pockets you better use them to call a tailor. Stay thirsty my friends......
<< <i>why is it this man is applauded for paying 4X PCGS guide for a coin such as this ,
and yet when I do no different with a superb toned PCGS Franklin ,
I get batted around like a step child ? >>
I dont think anyone applauded him? I actually took the thread as the opposite, it sounded like he was the step child except for a few people who saw the coin in hand and agreed that it was much better then the images. I could be wrong though as it has happend before.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
The PCGS MS66 1886 Morgan Dollar below looked much more impressive in-hand, but I was still surprised that it brought as much as it did. The last three to be sold by Heritage brought an average price of about $236. Care to guess what this one brought?
Very nice rainbow tone, but $2000+? I mean, WTH?
The 2 or 3 -1886 morgans you posted are not even in the ballpark of the one that just sold in heritage nor are any in the recent archives. You cant compare coins in that way and excpect to come to an understanding of why one sold for more than another.
I understand that there is alot of misinforamtion out there regarding toned coins and a lot of collectors that don't understand the prices paid for some coins with outstanding toning. The bottom line is that if you are not an avid collector of such coins you are most likely never going to understand simply due to the amount of time it takes to gain the information needed to understand. I find it amusing the number of people in this thread bashing the recent buyer of this coin but I can guarantee that none of the people bashing the recent purchase put in half the work determining an appropriate price to pay for the coin as the new buyer did. Just because someone doesn't understand or agree with something does not mean you need to go around assuming others are stupid for knowing more about an area of numismatics. Generally when people do step out and pay big money for a coin they have put some time in to determine an appropriate price, there are very very few people out there that just drop tens of thousands on coins without any idea of what they are buying. >>
"there is alot of misinforamtion out there regarding toned coins"
"a lot of collectors that don't understand the prices paid for some coins with outstanding toning"
Besides not knowing how to spell, what kind of stupid statements are these? Don't question my experience with toned coins or my buying experience.
Geez, that toner for more than $300 is total crap if you ask me. It isn't even CLOSE to my top THIRTHY rainbow Morgans. What a joke! What a SCAM!
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
The PCGS MS66 1886 Morgan Dollar below looked much more impressive in-hand, but I was still surprised that it brought as much as it did. The last three to be sold by Heritage brought an average price of about $236. Care to guess what this one brought?
Very nice rainbow tone, but $2000+? I mean, WTH?
The 2 or 3 -1886 morgans you posted are not even in the ballpark of the one that just sold in heritage nor are any in the recent archives. You cant compare coins in that way and excpect to come to an understanding of why one sold for more than another.
I understand that there is alot of misinforamation out there regarding toned coins and a lot of collectors that don't understand the prices paid for some coins with outstanding toning. The bottom line is that if you are not an avid collector of such coins you are most likely never going to understand simply due to the amount of time it takes to gain the information needed to understand. I find it amusing the number of people in this thread bashing the recent buyer of this coin but I can guarantee that none of the people bashing the recent purchase put in half the work determining an appropriate price to pay for the coin as the new buyer did. Just because someone doesn't understand or agree with something does not mean you need to go around assuming others are stupid for knowing more about an area of numismatics. Generally when people do step out and pay big money for a coin they have put some time in to determine an appropriate price, there are very very few people out there that just drop tens of thousands on coins without any idea of what they are buying. >>
"there is alot of misinforamtion out there regarding toned coins"
"a lot of collectors that don't understand the prices paid for some coins with outstanding toning"
Besides not knowing how to spell, what kind of stupid statements are these? Don't question my experience with toned coins or my buying experience.
Geez, that toner for more than $300 is total crap if you ask me. It isn't even CLOSE to my top THIRTHY rainbow Morgans. What a joke! What a SCAM! >>
It was a typo but thanks
How is saying that there is alot of misinformation out there regarding toned coins a stupid statement? How is saying alot of colectors dont understand the prices paid for coins with outstanding toning a stupid statement? Its a fact!!
On another note I was not questioning your experience simply stating what I have found to be facts.
I assume you have not seen the coin in question in hand?? As stated by others then myself the coin is far better then the heritage image. Judging by the other 1886 morgans you posted in comparison to the one in question and the fact that you dont feel the coin is worth more then 300.00 then its pretty clear we have a different opinion on the matter. I would however love to see one of your coins you feel top the coin in question, or several of them considering you stated this coin would not even be close to your top thirty coins.
<< <i> I assume you have not seen the coin in question in hand?? As stated by others then myself the coin is far better then the heritage image. Judging by the other 1886 morgans you posted in comparison to the one in question and the fact that you dont feel the coin is worth more then 300.00 then its pretty clear we have a different opinion on the matter. I would however love to see one of your coins you feel top the coin in question, or several of them considering you stated this coin would not even be close to your top thirty coins. >>
Here's a few, Mr. Expert On Toned Coins.
Liberty: Parent of Science & Industry
<< <i>Griv, IMO all of the coins you posted are AT. >>
Except for the first 4, ALL are PCGS graded. So much for your OPINION. Maybe you should read a book or something before you make another silly post.
prove me wrong, I dare ya
Liberty: Parent of Science & Industry
Liberty: Parent of Science & Industry
<< <i>PS: I'm STILL trying to understand how the OP coin was supposed to have gotten toned in that pattern. Is there a "story" to go with it? >>
I cant say for 100% as I dont know the coins history although there are some older morgan dollar books that do have a small strip that run horizontally accross the coin. I have seen other morgans that came straight from these books that have the same pattern.
<< <i>Some people just pay stupid money for silly coins. This thread is a perfect example. >>
Alcohol and keyboards... Tsk.
Check out my current listings: https://ebay.com/sch/khunt/m.html?_ipg=200&_sop=12&_rdc=1
<< <i>why is it this man is applauded for paying 4X PCGS guide for a coin such as this ,
and yet when I do no different with a superb toned PCGS Franklin ,
I get batted around like a step child ? >>
Why is it that in order to try to make your point, you presented an incorrect set of facts?
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
The PCGS MS66 1886 Morgan Dollar below looked much more impressive in-hand, but I was still surprised that it brought as much as it did. The last three to be sold by Heritage brought an average price of about $236. Care to guess what this one brought?
Very nice rainbow tone, but $2000+? I mean, WTH?
The 2 or 3 -1886 morgans you posted are not even in the ballpark of the one that just sold in heritage nor are any in the recent archives. You cant compare coins in that way and excpect to come to an understanding of why one sold for more than another.
I understand that there is alot of misinforamtion out there regarding toned coins and a lot of collectors that don't understand the prices paid for some coins with outstanding toning. The bottom line is that if you are not an avid collector of such coins you are most likely never going to understand simply due to the amount of time it takes to gain the information needed to understand. I find it amusing the number of people in this thread bashing the recent buyer of this coin but I can guarantee that none of the people bashing the recent purchase put in half the work determining an appropriate price to pay for the coin as the new buyer did. Just because someone doesn't understand or agree with something does not mean you need to go around assuming others are stupid for knowing more about an area of numismatics. Generally when people do step out and pay big money for a coin they have put some time in to determine an appropriate price, there are very very few people out there that just drop tens of thousands on coins without any idea of what they are buying. >>
"there is alot of misinforamtion out there regarding toned coins"
"a lot of collectors that don't understand the prices paid for some coins with outstanding toning"
Besides not knowing how to spell, what kind of stupid statements are these? Don't question my experience with toned coins or my buying experience.
Geez, that toner for more than $300 is total crap if you ask me. It isn't even CLOSE to my top THIRTHY rainbow Morgans. What a joke! What a SCAM! >>
The fact that someone's post includes a typo doesn't necessarily have anything to do with whether they know how to spell.
And I happen to think the statements you referred to as" stupid" made plenty of sense, especially in the context of this thread. In fact, if you believe that " that toner for more than $300 is total crap", it says a lot about your lack of familiarity with such coins. Did you see the price guesses that others posted here, even though they didn't see how wonderful it looked in-hand?
I'll tell everyone a little secret I knew about the coin: it was from Legends Sonnier Collection. Laura told me she sold it raw to a dealer who must have consigned it to the Heritage sale.
The originality and monster color of the piece in my mind never was in question. The image did not do it any good.
And to who ever it is (Griv??) posting those flaming AT Morgans-go take an ANA Seminar and learn about color!
<< <i>Griv, IMO all of the coins you posted are AT. >>
..................Baley , you are one smooth operator
Didn't we serve together in Calif. on a Destroyer in the U.S.N ?
<< <i>
<< <i>why is it this man is applauded for paying 4X PCGS guide for a coin such as this ,
and yet when I do no different with a superb toned PCGS Franklin ,
I get batted around like a step child ? >>
Why is it that in order to try to make your point, you presented an incorrect set of facts?
as usual , you are correct Sir !
how about:
Why is it this person is commended ( by knowledgeable and respected experts ) for paying multiples of PCGS Guide for this coin ,
and yet when I do similarly with a superb toned PCGS Franklin ,
the disrespectful and naive infer that I am a loon ?
My anticipation for receipt of the coin continues to grow….
Thanks to those who like the coin. I derive substantial additional confidence w/AB’s comment – as AB has posted coins that, to me, are drop dead gorgeous and worth ‘PTBarnum money’ to me. That collage picture still resonates in my mind.
Thanks to icsoccer, Barndog, and Justacommemen/MJ for your comments. And of course, the gracious Mark Feld.
To the PTBarnum group: Thanks for your comments as well. That is the beauty of the system – there will always be disagreement. If everybody liked the dollar, I would not own it today!
It is interesting to reconstruct the principal players in the auction.
Also note that this thread, in three places (Mark Feld, soty27 on a different coin, and DaveE), verifies the statement that ‘private treaty results in lower pricing’.
Second thanks to DaveE for the ‘little secret’. I’m going to roll that info into my attribution file for this coin.
Finally, I’ll take an action to photograph the dollar when it arrives and learn how to post pictures on this forum. I should learn how to post pix.
Fellas, leave the tight pants to the ladies. If I can count the coins in your pockets you better use them to call a tailor. Stay thirsty my friends......