Options
Is a change in the composition of the cent part of the Government's proposed budget?
I was taking a read through the Government proposed FY2011 budget that just got released. Other than reading the international tax sections and getting into a frothy frenzy about the government's extension of the active financing exception to Subpart F income under Section 954(h), I wondered if there was anything in there in the numismatic interest. I saw a report on www.cnnmoney.com that mentioned cents. Here is the text that was on the website:
"A penny saved...Savings: $150 million per year by reducing material costs.
Think about this when you're rolling up your change: The government spends 1.8 cents to make one penny and 9 cents to produce a nickel.
Because metal prices are volatile and have shot up lately, the cost to make these two coins is more than what the metal being used to make 'em is worth -- by as much as $100 million a year.
So the government is loosening up its rules for what metals are used to used to make coins. Using cheaper metal should help bring the cost of making one penny closer to, well, one penny. "
Has anyone else heard about this?
"A penny saved...Savings: $150 million per year by reducing material costs.
Think about this when you're rolling up your change: The government spends 1.8 cents to make one penny and 9 cents to produce a nickel.
Because metal prices are volatile and have shot up lately, the cost to make these two coins is more than what the metal being used to make 'em is worth -- by as much as $100 million a year.
So the government is loosening up its rules for what metals are used to used to make coins. Using cheaper metal should help bring the cost of making one penny closer to, well, one penny. "
Has anyone else heard about this?
Always took candy from strangers
Didn't wanna get me no trade
Never want to be like papa
Working for the boss every night and day
--"Happy", by the Rolling Stones (1972)
Didn't wanna get me no trade
Never want to be like papa
Working for the boss every night and day
--"Happy", by the Rolling Stones (1972)
0
Comments
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
That would reduce material cost, although die costs would increase.
The cents of 1943 were made of galvanized steel, but the steel strips were zinc plated before the planchets were punched out.
That's why the 1943 Cents are slowly rusting away. There's no plating on the edge.
Ray
Subpart K [c] income is more important for corporations with domestic net earnings over $175MM.
The current state of affairs is a coin that probably costs 2 1/2 cents each to make and
another cent each and every time it gets used because of counting and handling costs.
A VF cent in circulation represents many dollars of pure waste and there are some two
hundred and fifty billion cents in circulation. Dirkson said a "a billion here and a
billion there and it starts adding up to real money". If this isn't enough there's enough
highly toxic zinc in a single coin to kill a baby. Babies may have no rights once they're
born but they are Americans. They are "Unabled Americans" and deserve to have some
rights on this basis.
The problem with the penny is very easily solved. We've been looking in the wrong
places for a substitute for the metal used. There is nothing that can be fabricated for
less than about two cents each so the solution is simple.
Make the penny out of nuclear waste material.
This kills three or four birds with one stone. (or a single penny). We spend billions get-
ting rid of nuclear waste because people have an irrational fear of it. This material is so
highly maligned it actually has a high negative value. Every coin made removes about
a quarters worth of spent nuclear materials meaning a net profit of 23c on every coin
minted. This material will now serve a useful purpose so can no longer be called "waste".
People will be very careful with the pennies in change and keep them away from "unabled
Americans". The wear rate on these will be very very low as they will be handled very
gingerly and some people won't even touch them with a 10' pole.
It's time to return sanity and strontium 90 to our circulating coinage.
<< <i>I've got a modest proposal. >>
Jonathan Swift is at it again!
"Bongo hurtles along the rain soaked highway of life on underinflated bald retread tires."
~Wayne
<< <i>
Jonathan Swift is at it again!
>>
I resent this insuation.
Swift satirically suggestyed eating babies to ease the problem of starvation. The
only similarity to my suggestion is that he's killing two birds with a single stone.
Not only does each baby eaten represent nourishment to several abled people,
but it's one fewer mouth to feed. If this plan were actually carried out there would
not only be unforeseen consequences but it would require the permanent unability
of many thousands of babies.
My idea on the other hand is hardly satirical. But best of all is that it will help to
protect those Americans least able to protect themselves. No one looks out after
these folks because they form the world's weakest voting block.
The fact that it also rids us of "waste" and allows a profit to be made on the coinage
is mere gravy as it were.
<< <i>
No one looks out after these folks because they form the world's weakest voting block. *
>>
Except in Chicago where many people are lifelong voters even after they die.
Again, from the treasury
.pdf page 38, document page 32
Unit Cost incl. SG&A + Distribution to the FRB
FY2009
Cent ..... .0162
Nickel ... .0603
FY2008
Cent ..... .0142
Nickel ... .0883
FY2007
Cent ..... .0167
Nickel ... .0953
Material cost would go to zero. Die life would be greatly extended. Distribution costs much lower due to lower weight. Storage in vaults would be inexpensive because they would conform to the shape of the vault quite perfectly. Profit from seignorage would be high as they would be hard to spend. Labor cost -- well nobody cares about that as long as the union is happy.
Keeper of the VAM Catalog • Professional Coin Imaging • Prime Number Set • World Coins in Early America • British Trade Dollars • Variety Attribution
<< <i>
FY2009
Cent ..... .0162
Nickel ... .0603
FY2008
Cent ..... .0142
Nickel ... .0883
FY2007
Cent ..... .0167
Nickel ... .0953 >>
It appears they dump much of the cost of making pennies onto other denominations.
Not only do they claim a fabrication cost of under a penny for the cent but this same fabrication
cost for the dollar coin is nearly a quarter or 25 times as much.
It is the production of the many dies to make pennies that caused them to have to open a new
die shop but the cost is dumped on other coins. It is the production of billions of cents each year
which forces presses to be run at high speed so ALL the coins have to be low relief and unattractive.
We've been paying an incredibly high price for pennies for decades. It's not only the waste and
the danger to babies and pets but the dull uninspiring coinage and the mountains of smog produced
for no reason at all. It's the waste engendered by not even having a dollar coin to make transactions
smoother or possible by machines.
All this waste is money that could be going for things that enrich human life rather than drag it down
to the lowest common denominator.
If it weren't so much trouble for them, I would call the mint one day to verify it. Perhaps another large news org. will confirm it.
It would be an interesting turn of events for the 2010 cent.
<< <i>
<< <i>
FY2009
Cent ..... .0162
Nickel ... .0603
FY2008
Cent ..... .0142
Nickel ... .0883
FY2007
Cent ..... .0167
Nickel ... .0953 >>
It appears they dump much of the cost of making pennies onto other denominations.
Not only do they claim a fabrication cost of under a penny for the cent but this same fabrication
cost for the dollar coin is nearly a quarter or 25 times as much.
It is the production of the many dies to make pennies that caused them to have to open a new
die shop but the cost is dumped on other coins. It is the production of billions of cents each year
which forces presses to be run at high speed so ALL the coins have to be low relief and unattractive.
We've been paying an incredibly high price for pennies for decades. It's not only the waste and
the danger to babies and pets but the dull uninspiring coinage and the mountains of smog produced
for no reason at all. It's the waste engendered by not even having a dollar coin to make transactions
smoother or possible by machines.
All this waste is money that could be going for things that enrich human life rather than drag it down
to the lowest common denominator. >>
You may be right, but the fabrication costs for the dollar coins are much higher than for the cents.
Cent planchets arrive ready to strike in two-ton bins that are raised by a machine and automatically emptied into a system that supplies planchets to many machines. The struck coins are simply bagged, weighed and shipped.
The dollar blanks are punched from coil strip, upset, annealed, burnished with a chemical to keep them from tarnishing, transported by cart into the next room, struck, transported by conveyor belt to the edge lettering machine, edge lettered, bagged, weighed and shipped.
TD
"Make the penny out of nuclear waste material."
I was thinking more along the lines of making them out of cake.
We could also drop the nickel to the size of a cent.
The nickel should be kept same size/composition, but with a hole punched in it which removed 50% of the weight. We could have a pnorama picture on one side, and all the writing split between the inside rim, the outside rim and the reverse.
<< <i>
You may be right, but the fabrication costs for the dollar coins are much higher than for the cents.
Cent planchets arrive ready to strike in two-ton bins that are raised by a machine and automatically emptied into a system that supplies planchets to many machines. The struck coins are simply bagged, weighed and shipped.
The dollar blanks are punched from coil strip, upset, annealed, burnished with a chemical to keep them from tarnishing, transported by cart into the next room, struck, transported by conveyor belt to the edge lettering machine, edge lettered, bagged, weighed and shipped.
>>
I was just subtracting the value of the metal from the reputed cost of the coin.
There are various numbers floating around for the costs of production but they all
appear to transfer the real costs onto the larger denominations. The fabrication
cost should depend primarily on the hardness of the metal. Obviously cents are cheap
but but to figure their fabrication cost at a few percent of a dollar coin is simply absurd.
In one such list I've seen the nickel costs one third as much to make as a dime. It real-
ly actually costs a little more based on die life and added handling costs associated with
the higher weight.
<< <i>Make the penny out of nuclear waste material. >>
What a marvelous idea....!!.
on the white house site
.pdf page 99, document page 100
OTHER SAVINGS: COINAGE MATERIAL
Department of the Treasury
The Budget proposes to provide the U.S. Mint with greater flexibility in the material composition of coins
to reduce its losses on some coins and the production costs associated with volatile metal prices.
Justification
The Mint’s primary cost driver is the price of metal, a factor over which it has no control. Daily spot prices
of copper and zinc, the Mint’s two main metallic materials, have fluctuated in excess of 100 percent, and
the price of nickel by 500 percent in recent years.1 This contributes to volatile and negative margins on both
the penny and nickel: in recent years the penny has cost approximately 1.8 cents and the nickel approximately
9 cents to produce.2 Costs have exceeded the value of these two coins by over $100 million in prior years.
Through its gains on other coins, the Mint annually returns hundreds of millions of dollars to the Treasury
General Fund (GF) and is funded by the Mint Public Enterprise Fund.
Greater flexibility in the composition of coinage materials could enable the Mint to utilize less expensive
metals in the minting process and substantially reduce its production costs. Using alternative coinage
materials could save $150 million annually after an initial period of development and capital adjustments.
These savings result from increased seigniorage, or the difference between the face value of the coin paid
by the Federal Reserve and the cost of production. Seigniorage increases the available means of financing,
but has no direct budgetary impact. Specifically, the Budget includes provisions that authorize the
Department of the Treasury to approve alternative coinage compositions and weights across five
denominations (half dollar, quarter, dime, nickel, and penny).
The 2011 Budget would bring the costs of coins more in-line with their face values and create a more
sustainable, cost-effective 21st Century use of materials in the minting process. The Budget enables the
Department of the Treasury to explore, analyze, and approve new, less expensive materials for all circulating
coins based on factors that will result in the highest quality of coin production at the most cost-effective
price. Such factors may include physical, chemical, metallurgical and technical characteristics; material,
fabrication, minting, and distribution costs; materials availability and sources of raw materials; durability;
effects on sorting, handling, packaging and vending machines; and resistance to counterfeiting. The added
flexibility the Budget proposes will improve the minting process and enable the Mint to mitigate the high,
volatile costs of commodity metals.
Citations
1 Global InfoMine, Metals Prices, http://www.infomine.com/investment/metalprices/ (January 2010).
2 USA TODAY, Coins Cost More to Make than Face
Value, http://www.usatoday.com/money/2006-05-09-penny-usat_x.htm (May 2006).
EDIT: I do note that the mint hedges silver.
they snuck a non-change past us ::
not discontinuing the dollar bill.
wonder how that happened.....
I think I have some uk half pennys from the 70;s that are smaller in diameter and thinner than a US dime
and made from some copper clad or plated material