Who holds the record: Most resubs on one card?

Topps29 · January 22, 2010 2:15AM

Since PSA when to the 1/2 grade system, who holds the record for submitting the same card until the appropiate grade was awarded?

FavreFan1971 · January 22, 2010 2:31AM

You sure it is the appropriate grade if you had to sub it a dozen times to get an 8.5?

hammered · January 22, 2010 2:38AM

My record is 4 times
A '71 Garvey, it got 8,8,8,8.5
The reviews cost me about $30 in all but the bump got me an extra 150 on the sale

Topps29 · January 22, 2010 2:40AM

Sweet! Love the 71 Topps Garvey!

OAKESY25 · January 22, 2010 2:45AM

I have resubbed a 92 s/c favre around 6-7 times it either comes back eot or min size
I pulled it myself from a sealed box it is actually in house right now again
I am too stubborn to admit defeat

DavidPuddy · January 22, 2010 2:52AM

3 times.
1982 Topps Ripken. EOT, Min Size, PSA 8.

Allen · January 22, 2010 2:56AM

Have to think some of the 52 Mantles in PSA 7 and PSA 8 are on a first name basis with the graders.

italianstallionyankees · January 22, 2010 3:25AM

<< <i>My record is 4 times
A '71 Garvey, it got 8,8,8,8.5
The reviews cost me about $30 in all but the bump got me an extra 150 on the sale >>

Cool that you used a review instead of cracking and altering the pop reports like most do! Congrats on that nice little bump!

Reljac · January 22, 2010 3:30AM

This is one record I hope to never be in contention for!

MrG · January 22, 2010 3:48AM

>My record is 4 times
>A '71 Garvey, it got 8,8,8,8.5
>The reviews cost me about $30 in all but the bump got me an extra 150 on the sale

Just wondering if you got the same grader and reviewer on the first three attempts and then he went on a holiday during the 4th attempt?

Edited to say: Cheers on the bump!

Mickey71 · January 22, 2010 4:01AM

I think "Who holds the record on a raw sub" would be the most interesting question.

MrG · January 22, 2010 4:03AM

I have had some 73 Topps baseball variations that I have submitted 4 or 5 times with their opposite example variation and still did not get the expected variation outcome. (And the grade was not relevant!)

Cheers,
Michael

epatmythes · January 22, 2010 4:05AM

My current record is three times, convinced it was a GEM when I bought it raw, but it's got a tricky corner depending how it's cut (IE. can look like a white dinged corner because of the logo on his jersey, but is actually undamaged and razor sharpe under 16x magnification)...

2001 Fleer Game Time Albert Pujols: PSA 8.5, Min Size, PSA 10

burke23 · January 22, 2010 4:10AM

I got 4 - cracked a bgs 9.5 card that got a 9, eot, eot, 10.

fuj · January 22, 2010 6:15AM

I think I'm up to 4 times on a '92 UD Shaq RC. Got 9's every time but was hoping for a 10.

I also subbed a '86 Fleer Mullin RC several times. Was hoping for a 9 but got min size every time. At least those came back with vouchers.

thedutymon · January 22, 2010 6:44AM

Afternoon,
Have several that exceed 4-5 times, most recent:

1953 Topps Who-Z-At Star Card #73 Mona Freeman NM-MT 8, NM-MT 8, NM+ 7.5, NM-MT 8, NM-MT 8, and finally NM-MT+ 8.5, still should be a Nine but am staying with the 8.5.

Always, always cracked and re-subbed Raw, would never ask them to second guess their own impeccable judgement !!!!!

Yeehah

Neil

Griffins · January 22, 2010 7:13AM

I spoke to a dealer a few years ago at the national that said he routinely will send a high dollar card in 10-12 times until it gets the grade he thinks it should.

I once cracked out a 6 that I knew should be a 7 and submitted it. It came back a 3, which was ridiculous. So as a matter of principle I kept sending it in- final tally- 6 to a 3 to a 3 to a 3 to a 3 to a 7.
1st and last time I played that game.

Who holds the record: Most resubs on one card?

Comments