Guess the grade contest - WINNER = Cubby.....Results on page 3

123Slider · January 2, 2010 9:08AM

I really enjoy the contests on here, and always wanted to do one of these myself, so I'm posting 10 already graded cards for everyone to guess the actual grades. The winner who guesses the most cards correctly will receive something vintage for their efforts. In case of a tie, first to post wins. Thanks for playing!

Chad

55 Brideweser -
55 Logan -
55 Schroll -
55 Hubbard -
55 Hurley -
56 Roberts -
56 Sauer -
56 Thomas
56 Fox -
56 Lennon -

KatsCards · January 2, 2010 9:13AM

55 Brideweser - 8
55 Logan - 7
55 Schroll - 8
55 Hubbard - 7
55 Hurley - 8
56 Roberts - 8
56 Sauer - 8
56 Thomas 8
56 Fox - 6
56 Lennon - 8

tsalems1 · January 2, 2010 9:14AM

55 Brideweser - 8
55 Logan - 7
55 Schroll - 7
55 Hubbard - 7
55 Hurley - 7
56 Roberts - 7
56 Sauer - 8
56 Thomas 8
56 Fox - 8
56 Lennon -8

handyman · January 2, 2010 9:15AM

All Graded 6s

Arsenal83 · January 2, 2010 9:17AM

55 Brideweser - 8OC
55 Logan - 8
55 Schroll - 8
55 Hubbard - 7
55 Hurley - 7
56 Roberts - 7
56 Sauer - 8
56 Thomas 7
56 Fox - 7
56 Lennon -8

firedawg45 · January 2, 2010 9:20AM

8
7
8oc
6.5
7.5
7
8
8.5
7
8

HeritageAddict · January 2, 2010 9:21AM

55 Brideweser - 7
55 Logan - 7
55 Schroll - 8
55 Hubbard - 7
55 Hurley - 8
56 Roberts - 7
56 Sauer - 8
56 Thomas - 7
56 Fox - 7
56 Lennon - 7

bigwilli · January 2, 2010 9:22AM

55 Brideweser - 7
55 Logan - 8
55 Schroll - 7
55 Hubbard - 8
55 Hurley - 7
56 Roberts - 7
56 Sauer - 8
56 Thomas - 7
56 Fox - 7
56 Lennon - 8

TheHun · January 2, 2010 9:24AM

55 Brideweser - 7
55 Logan - 6.5
55 Schroll - 9
55 Hubbard - 6.5
55 Hurley - 7
56 Roberts - 7
56 Sauer - 8
56 Thomas - 9
56 Fox - 8
56 Lennon - 9

thanks for the fun - Chad

RookieWax · January 2, 2010 9:25AM

8
7
8
7
8
6
9
8
7
8

Bosox1976 · January 2, 2010 9:27AM

55 Brideweser - 8
55 Logan - 7
55 Schroll - 8
55 Hubbard - 8
55 Hurley - 8
56 Roberts - 7
56 Sauer - 7.5
56 Thomas - 8
56 Fox - 7
56 Lennon - 8

As for my vintage prize, I'll take Racquel Welch.

bigwilli · January 2, 2010 9:30AM

" As for my vintage prize, I'll take Racquel Welch. "

Good choice....Glad you didnt say Betty White.....

diamondman · January 2, 2010 9:33AM

55 Brideweser - 9
55 Logan - 8
55 Schroll - 8
55 Hubbard - 7
55 Hurley - 7
56 Roberts - 8
56 Sauer - 9
56 Thomas- 8
56 Fox - 7.5
56 Lennon - 8

swartz1 · January 2, 2010 9:36AM

55 Brideweser -6.5
55 Logan -7
55 Schroll -8.5
55 Hubbard -8
55 Hurley -8
56 Roberts -7
56 Sauer -9
56 Thomas - 7.5
56 Fox -7.5
56 Lennon - 7.5

123Slider · January 2, 2010 9:37AM

<< 
As for my vintage prize, I'll take Racquel Welch. >>

"The woman is a menace!" - Kramer

PoppaJ · January 2, 2010 9:41AM

Hi Chad,

Just wanted to say that those are some very nice '55s and '56s!

I hope they all receive HIGH grades!

PoppaJ

NickM · January 2, 2010 9:41AM

55 Brideweser - 9
55 Logan - 8
55 Schroll - 8
55 Hubbard - 7
55 Hurley - 7
56 Roberts - 7.5
56 Sauer - 7
56 Thomas - 8.5
56 Fox - 8
56 Lennon - 8

Nick

fattymacs · January 2, 2010 9:44AM

55 Brideweser - 7.5
55 Logan - 7
55 Schroll - 8
55 Hubbard - 7
55 Hurley - 7.5
56 Roberts - 7.5
56 Sauer - 8
56 Thomas - 8
56 Fox - 7
56 Lennon - 7

Muchas Gracias

DrJ · January 2, 2010 9:53AM

55 Brideweser - 8
55 Logan - 7.5
55 Schroll - 8
55 Hubbard -8
55 Hurley - 8
56 Roberts - 8
56 Sauer - 9
56 Thomas-8.5
56 Fox - 8
56 Lennon - 7

Brick · January 2, 2010 10:08AM

55 Brideweser - 7
55 Logan - 7
55 Schroll - 5
55 Hubbard - 5
55 Hurley - 8
56 Roberts - 7
56 Sauer - 6
56 Thomas - 8
56 Fox - 6
56 Lennon - 7

leadoff4 · January 2, 2010 11:09AM

55 Brideweser - 8
55 Logan - 8
55 Schroll - 8
55 Hubbard - 7
55 Hurley - 7
56 Roberts - 7
56 Sauer - 8
56 Thomas-7
56 Fox - 8
56 Lennon - 7

onebamafan · January 2, 2010 11:21AM

55 Brideweser - 7
55 Logan - 6
55 Schroll - 6
55 Hubbard -6
55 Hurley - 6
56 Roberts - 6
56 Sauer - 7
56 Thomas 7
56 Fox - 8
56 Lennon -7

JB

Sportsamerica · January 2, 2010 11:31AM

<< I really enjoy the contests on here, and always wanted to do one of these myself, so I'm posting 10 already graded cards for everyone to guess the actual grades. The winner who guesses the most cards correctly will receive something vintage for their efforts. In case of a tie, first to post wins. Thanks for playing!

Chad

55 Brideweser - 7
55 Logan - 7
55 Schroll - 7
55 Hubbard - 6
55 Hurley - 6
56 Roberts - 7
56 Sauer - 7
56 Thomas - 7
56 Fox - 7
56 Lennon - 7

>>

jamesryanbell · January 2, 2010 11:38AM

5 Brideweser - 8
55 Logan - 7
55 Schroll - 8
55 Hubbard - 7
55 Hurley - 8
56 Roberts - 7
56 Sauer - 8
56 Thomas 8
56 Fox - 6
56 Lennon - 8

jeffcbay · January 2, 2010 11:45AM

55 Brideweser - 8
55 Logan - 8
55 Schroll - 7
55 Hubbard - 7
55 Hurley - 7
56 Roberts - 8
56 Sauer - 8
56 Thomas - 8
56 Fox - 8
56 Lennon - 8

gotsparks09 · January 2, 2010 12:04PM

55 Brideweser - 7
55 Logan - 7
55 Schroll - 6.5
55 Hubbard - 7
55 Hurley - 6
56 Roberts - 7
56 Sauer - 8
56 Thomas - 7
56 Fox - 7.5
56 Lennon - 7

Thanks for the contest!

vladguerrero · January 2, 2010 3:31PM

55 Brideweser - 7
55 Logan - 7
55 Schroll - 8
55 Hubbard - 7
55 Hurley - 6
56 Roberts - 7
56 Sauer - 8
56 Thomas-7
56 Fox - 7
56 Lennon - 8

Pigs · January 2, 2010 3:43PM

Nice cards Chad, thanks for the contest. My guesses. Doug

55 Brideweser - 7
55 Logan - 7
55 Schroll - 8
55 Hubbard - 6.5
55 Hurley - 7
56 Roberts - 8
56 Sauer - 8
56 Thomas 8
56 Fox - 7.5
56 Lennon - 7

mlbfan2 · January 2, 2010 4:21PM

55 Brideweser - 8
55 Logan - 7
55 Schroll - 8
55 Hubbard - 7
55 Hurley - 8
56 Roberts - 7
56 Sauer - 8
56 Thomas- 7
56 Fox - 8
56 Lennon - 8

Cubby · January 2, 2010 5:40PM

Brideweser - 8
Logan - 7.5
Schroll - 8.5
Hubbard -7.5
Hurley - 8
Roberts - 7.5
Sauer - 9
Thomas - 8.5
Fox - 8
Lennon - 7.5

And thanx for the opp

baseballfan · January 2, 2010 8:36PM

55 Brideweser - 8
55 Logan - 8
55 Schroll - 7
55 Hubbard - 7
55 Hurley - 8
56 Roberts -7
56 Sauer - 9
56 Thomas 8
56 Fox - 7
56 Lennon - 7

thanks

dpuccio · January 2, 2010 9:07PM

Thanks for the contest

55 Brideweser - 5
55 Logan - 5
55 Schroll - 6
55 Hubbard - 5
55 Hurley - 5
56 Roberts - 6
56 Sauer - 8
56 Thomas 8
56 Fox - 7
56 Lennon - 7

beef316 · January 2, 2010 9:25PM

55 Brideweser - 8
55 Logan - 8
55 Schroll - 8
55 Hubbard - 8
55 Hurley - 8
56 Roberts - 7
56 Sauer - 8
56 Thomas-7
56 Fox - 8
56 Lennon - 7

cpettimd · January 2, 2010 10:00PM

Thanks for the contest

55 Brideweser - 8
55 Logan - 8
55 Schroll - 8
55 Hubbard - 8
55 Hurley - 8
56 Roberts - 8
56 Sauer - 8
56 Thomas 8
56 Fox - 8
56 Lennon - 8

Indy78 · January 2, 2010 11:07PM

Thanks for the contest! All 8's except Hubbard a 7.

Editted: Didn't notice that the poster ahead of me had picked all 8's, so editted to be different.

metsfan · January 3, 2010 2:15AM

55 Brideweser - 8
55 Logan - 7.5
55 Schroll - 8(oc)
55 Hubbard - 7.5
55 Hurley - 8
56 Roberts - 7
56 Sauer - 7.5
56 Thomas 7
56 Fox - 8
56 Lennon - 7
Thanks for the contest, and nice cards.

VitoCo1972 · January 3, 2010 2:19AM

55 Brideweser - 8
55 Logan - 7
55 Schroll - 9
55 Hubbard - 8
55 Hurley - 8
56 Roberts - 7
56 Sauer - 7
56 Thomas - 8
56 Fox - 7
56 Lennon - 8

Thanks a lot!

calaban7 · January 3, 2010 3:21AM

55 Brideweser - 8.5
55 Logan - 8
55 Schroll - 8.5
55 Hubbard - 8
55 Hurley - 8
56 Roberts -7
56 Sauer - 9
56 Thomas - 9
56 Fox - 8.5
56 Lennon -7.5

pdub1819 · January 3, 2010 7:08AM

55 Brideweser - 8OC
55 Logan - 7
55 Schroll - 8
55 Hubbard - 7OC
55 Hurley - 6
56 Roberts -8
56 Sauer - 9
56 Thomas - 8
56 Fox - 9
56 Lennon -8

Thanks for the opportunity!

jimrad · January 3, 2010 8:55AM

55 Brideweser - 7.5
55 Logan - 7
55 Schroll - 7.5
55 Hubbard - 6
55 Hurley - 7
56 Roberts - 7
56 Sauer - 8
56 Thomas - 7
56 Fox -7.5
56 Lennon - 7.5

Thanks for the contest...........

123Slider · January 3, 2010 11:40AM

Just about that time. Winner TBA shortly. Thanks to everyone for your grading guesses!

Chad

SportsCardCollector · January 3, 2010 12:01PM

55 Brideweser - 7.5
55 Logan - 7.5
55 Schroll - 8
55 Hubbard - 8
55 Hurley - 8
56 Roberts - 7
56 Sauer - 7.5
56 Thomas - 7
56 Fox - 8
56 Lennon - 8

123Slider · January 3, 2010 12:03PM

Closed, results shortly.

123Slider · January 3, 2010 12:20PM

Congrats to Cubby!!! Correct on 4 of the 10!!! PM sent to you BTW.

Here is how the voting went along with the actual grades:

55 Brideweser – Actual Grade – 7.5 Guesses ranged from 5 to 9 with the average guess being 7.5!

55 Logan – Actual Grade – 7.5 Guesses ranged from 5 to 8 with the average guess being 7.25

55 Schroll - Actual Grade – 7 Guesses ranged from 5 to 9 with the average grade being 7.51. This card as a 7 is worth $25, as a 8 $250, so yes, I will resub it again!

55 Hubbard – Actual Grade – 7.5 Guesses ranged from 5 to 8 with the average guess being 7. Lowest of the 10 cards, so I guess I’ll stick on the 7.5!

55 Hurley - Actual Grade - 7.5 Guesses ranged from 5 to 8 with the average being 7.28

56 Roberts - Actual Grade - 7.5 Guesses from 6 to 8 with the average being 7.15, guess I’ll stick on the 7.5 here as well.

56 Sauer – Actual Grade 7.5 Guesses from 6 to 9 with 8 people guessing 9’s and 19 people guessing 8’s! Average guess was 7.96, so I guess it gets resubbed as well.

56 Thomas - Actual Grade - 7.5 Guesses from 6 to 9 with the average being 7.67. I’ll take a closer look to see about resubbing.

56 Fox - Actual Grade - 7.5 Guesses from 6 to 9 with the average being 7.4.

56 Lennon - Actual Grade – 7.5 Guesses ranged from 6 to 8 with the average guess being 7.51

Great looking bunch of cards, and hard to believe that there isn’t an 8 in the bunch. None of the cards have been submitted for the “bump”. All received their grade during the first submission.

Fun experiment for me, and for those that overgraded, don’t feel bad, I probably did on most of these too. A couple of the scans with grades are below.

Any thoughts throw them my way and thanks for playing!

Chad

Mickey71 · January 3, 2010 12:48PM

I've heard of the grader of death. Has he returned? Not 1 single PSA 8 out of those cards??? They look really nice from the scans.

Cubby · January 4, 2010 5:25AM

WOOO HOOO!!! The new year is off to a great start!

leadoff4 · January 4, 2010 8:54AM

Well, my avg. was 7.5 doesn't that count?

tsalems1 · January 4, 2010 8:56AM

<< Well, my avg. was 7.5 doesn't that count?

>>

As was mine but I posted before you

123Slider · January 4, 2010 8:59AM

<< Well, my avg. was 7.5 doesn't that count?

>>

Close only counts in horseshoes and hand grenades.

itzagoner · January 4, 2010 9:06AM

<< I've heard of the grader of death. Has he returned? Not 1 single PSA 8 out of those cards??? They look really nice from the scans. >>

geez. heck ya, what am i not seeing on the Sauer card?

Guess the grade contest - WINNER = Cubby.....Results on page 3

Comments