Options
Some people *really* have nerve...
coin22lover
Posts: 3,542 ✭✭✭
Rarely would I ever make a thread whining publicly about a trivial issue, but I thought this could also double as a bit of good natured entertainment. A few weeks ago, some one got one of my PCGS coins on ebay for a *steal* as the auction had no reserve. Thankfully, I'm not into buying and selling for profit and my other auctions balanced out the loss, but that's not the point. Here 3 weeks later, the guy has my coin re-listed using my pics for about an 80% profit (if it sells). I wonder if he thought I wouldn't notice or something?
0
Comments
He should of asked permission to use the pictures if they weren't part of the sale.
I would include the images of coins I sell if asked.
MJ
Fellas, leave the tight pants to the ladies. If I can count the coins in your pockets you better use them to call a tailor. Stay thirsty my friends......
<< <i>So...who is it? >>
Well, I knew some would be wondering this, but I'm not really interested in flogging him publicly...not yet anyway. I may ask him some "questions" first, perhaps from my ebay alternate ID
Barrytrot(2),Stupid,Savoyspecial,docq,ecoinquest, halfhunter,snman,Coll3ctor.
wondercoin. Blue594. internetjunky.
keepdachange. Scrapman1077.Ahrensdad, mrmom, mygrandeoso, blu62vette, Clackamas,giorgio11, adriana, cucamongacoin,
I mean, if it is a truly accurate depiction of the coin, wouldn't another truly accurate depiction, in another photograph, look exactly the same (theoretically)? I do realize that several different photos taken at different angles could all be accurate depictions and not look anything alike.
Would it be less of a problem if they used your pics, but also included some pics of their own to show the coin in different lighting/angles?
Raises some interesting questions.
Maybe it's sort of a compliment to your photography skills. They may be much better photos than he could ever take.
Personally, I would never do that. Just playing devil's advocate here.
Using them without the OP's permission is a no-no.
To support LordM's European Trip, click here!
<< <i>I'm pretty sure the pictures are the property of the photographer.
Using them without the OP's permission is a no-no. >>
pretty sure they need to be copy righted... after all he's not selling the picture.
Barrytrot(2),Stupid,Savoyspecial,docq,ecoinquest, halfhunter,snman,Coll3ctor.
wondercoin. Blue594. internetjunky.
keepdachange. Scrapman1077.Ahrensdad, mrmom, mygrandeoso, blu62vette, Clackamas,giorgio11, adriana, cucamongacoin,
It may take a day or two, but they will end his listing. If he has bids his bidders will only know they don't want to bid on his items any more!
Governments can print currency. Only the people can print faith in it — and they’re running low on ink.
<< <i>I'm pretty sure the pictures are the property of the photographer.
Using them without the OP's permission is a no-no. >>
What are the OP's damages?
Experience the World through Numismatics...it's more than you can imagine.
Please read and think before reporting me to our host.....you sold the coin, you did not tell him not to use the pics of "HIS" coin in "His" auction did you?
I'll bet you have not contacted him about the above.......are you a little niffed at the price he paid..and the price he will get..umm yeah ! that's why I posted this..........?
If I am even close as to what has taken place so far........IMO SDSU....Happy Holidays
Edited to add........coin22lover In no way is this intended to be an attack on you, I a am only questioning the motive, if you contact the OP and request he use his own photos that would probably be the end of it, If he got a deal on the coin from you...then well, you win some etc.....
Happy Holidays.....
Anyone who uses pictures that I have taken and does not ask my permission to do so is in the wrong…
I am not being compensated for my time in taking them or in the expense incurred buying the equipment to produce those pictures.
It takes very little extra effort to simply ask permission to use them for other purposes from the person who took the picture. However, be prepared for the answer to be no. If you purchase something with the intent to resell it, have the common courtesy to take your own pictures to do so.
The world is going to hell in a hand basket and common decency is a dying human trait!
QN
Go to Early United States Coins - to order the New "Early United States Half Dollar Vol. 1 / 1794-1807" book or the 1st new Bust Quarter book!
I copy and save every picture from every auction I win. Be it TT , Hert or the bay and
any coin I buy off a web site. Saves me from taking one BUT I keep them for own
reference so I an look at them latter on. If I do decide to sell that coin for so reason
I take my own picture for the auction and if it sells it belonge to the buyer, not mine any longer.
Doggedly collecting coins of the Central American Republic.
Visit the Society of US Pattern Collectors at USPatterns.com.
Using your photos, however, is a big deal in my opinion! They are automatically copyrighted at the time of creation, and using them is copyright infringement. He bought the coin not your photos.
Thanks to the Berne Convention. At the moment of creation, when the artwork is "fixed" in some tangible form, copyright applies automatically. For a photographer, when you press the shutter release you are making a photo and gaining copyright to that photo at the same time. You don't have to declare copyright or file any paperwork. It is yours to keep until you explicitly give it away or you die (copyright expires after you, the duration in the U.S. is the author's lifetime plus 70 years).
Thanks, Ralph
<< <i>Selling the coin for a profit, I see no problem with.
Using your photos, however, is a big deal in my opinion! They are automatically copyrighted at the time of creation, and using them is copyright infringement. He bought the coin not your photos.
Thanks to the Berne Convention. At the moment of creation, when the artwork is "fixed" in some tangible form, copyright applies automatically. For a photographer, when you press the shutter release you are making a photo and gaining copyright to that photo at the same time. You don't have to declare copyright or file any paperwork. It is yours to keep until you explicitly give it away or you die (copyright expires after you, the duration in the U.S. is the author's lifetime plus 70 years).
Thanks, Ralph >>
I'd like to see some case law saying that reusing an eBay photo isn't fair use.
<< <i>Here 3 weeks later, the guy has my coin re-listed using my pics >>
Three weeks? I've had buyers relist with my images within three hours. As long as I have their money, I couldn't care less.
Russ, NCNE
to put those pics up on ebay
so they have to at least crop it off
<< <i>I'd like to see some case law saying that reusing an eBay photo isn't fair use. >>
If someone is using my photos without my permission to turn a profit (using eBay or otherwise), I would hardly call that fair use. Just because I can't present case law to support my argument doesn't mean it's not "right."
I guess it's just easier for people to find ways to justify what they want to do, rather than do what is correct.
Thanks, Ralph
Copyrights are not automatically awarded. In most instances they have to be applied for. Or you need to be associated with an organization who has blanket copyrights over all they produce, like NBC, HBO, Warner Bros, Associated Press, etc
In this case, an uncopyrighted image posted on a public/3rd party forum is now public domain.
<< <i>Dudes!!!!
Copyrights are not automatically awarded. In most instances they have to be applied for. Or you need to be associated with an organization who has blanket copyrights over all they produce, like NBC, HBO, Warner Bros, Associated Press, etc
In this case, an uncopyrighted image posted on a public/3rd party forum is now public domain. >>
That's the way it was explained to me in the past by a lawyer.
I suggest that you sue the seller and report back to us when the case is over.
Oh, would it have made a difference if you sold the coin for a huge profit, and he took a loss on it?
eBay Policy:
"eBay members are not allowed to use images—including photos and other pictures—or text they didn't create themselves."
Thanks, Ralph
that it sounds like you are upset
he is doing better at his auction
Of course you are legally right
but he is your customer after all,
and you want to be nice to your customers
so
Let it go
--Jerry
<< <i>
<< <i>Here 3 weeks later, the guy has my coin re-listed using my pics >>
Three weeks? I've had buyers relist with my images within three hours. As long as I have their money, I couldn't care less.
Russ, NCNE >>
I am with Russ on this one they paid for the coin and I dont own it so I dont need it any more, But my pic suck so I dont need to worry about it. But that is just me.
Hoard the keys.
Wondercoin
<< <i>I'm pretty sure the pictures are the property of the photographer.
Using them without the OP's permission is a no-no. >>
You are correct.
Lane
See http://www.doubledimes.com for a free online reference for US twenty-cent pieces
Block him so he can't win anything else from you for a repeat performance.
It really seems you are make a big deal out of it.
<< <i>Dudes!!!!
Copyrights are not automatically awarded. In most instances they have to be applied for. Or you need to be associated with an organization who has blanket copyrights over all they produce, like NBC, HBO, Warner Bros, Associated Press, etc
In this case, an uncopyrighted image posted on a public/3rd party forum is now public domain. >>
Copyright is automatic once the work exists in a fixed form. You never have to apply for a copyright. This is neither a case of public domain or fair use. If he were to make a claim for violation of his copyright, the OP's damages would be whatever he feels is reasonable compensation for the commercial use of his photos.
Copyright Basics
<< <i>pretty sure they need to be copy righted... after all he's not selling the picture. >>
Copyright resides with the creator of a work at the time that it is created.
60 years into this hobby and I'm still working on my Lincoln set!
<< <i>Copyrights are not automatically awarded. In most instances they have to be applied for. Or you need to be associated with an organization who has blanket copyrights over all they produce, like NBC, HBO, Warner Bros, Associated Press, etc >>
You are incorrect, sir.
60 years into this hobby and I'm still working on my Lincoln set!
<< <i>The world is going to hell in a hand basket and common decency is a dying human trait!
"Common decency" is a relative term. To me, common decency says "hey, once he's bought my coin, he has every right to use the photos of it, since they are photos of his coin.". Depends on your perspective. But that's just me.
Photos are simply a pictorial description of the object and IMO, on the same lines as the name of the object.
If you called it an "1835 half dime", for example, wouldn't he also be allowed to call it an "1835 half dime"? He's just calling it what it is, just like a picture just shows what it is. If his photo looks identical to yours, because it is a photo of the same object, why is that different than actually using your photo?
I don't understand the big fuss.
<< <i>[ As long as I have their money, I couldn't care less.
Russ, NCNE >>
- Jim
I've had the same thing happen, except the seller was using it to sell his own pieces.
I contacted him and asked not to use my pic, he then pulled the pic down.
Insert some text right across the pic, an area that's tough to clone.
scott
linky
<< <i>Of course you are legally right
but he is your customer after all,
and you want to be nice to your customers
so
Let it go >>
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
<< <i>It would be so easy for eBay to say "Post your image on our site and we own it." It would also be easy for them to say "Feel free to use our images to help you sell your property on our site." I guess that's what I'm recommending. >>
They do exactly that.
Unless you opt out, feepay lays claim to ownership of images posted on their server and are free for others to use.
The idea is to get exposure and our little coin world is shrinking because of negatives, not positives.
(that's my opinion and may be totally wrong)