Options
Crossovers Round 2
Well I guess this is better then before. My comments next to the grades.
1 1 15571451 4582 1842-O 10C US AU55 - This is the Ex Pittman coin, NGC AU58 downgrade as I suspected a 58 may be too high
2 1 15571452 4689 1881 10C US Artificial Color - OUCH! Did not see that one coming, will have to look strong at the coin, NGC holdered
3 1 15571453 4686 1878-CC 10C US DNC - This is a nice 63, the reverse is very weak do to a shattered reverse variety, it they doengraded it for strike reasons than they missed the variety. I figured a 63 was a easy cross.
4 1 15571454 4598 1852-O 10C US Artificial Color - A rare unc, the color is a bit funky but I did not suspect AT but also can see the call.
5 1 15571455 4596 1851-O 10C US AU55 - This is a coin the sold for more than an NGC 58 in an ANACS 55 holder, no real sighns of a rub and I had one of the finest dealer preview and buy the coin for me.
6 1 15571456 4693 1884-S 10C US MS64 - Really nice coin
7 1 15571457 4704 1890 10C US DNC - hard to get a 66 to cross
8 1 15571458 4700 1888 10C US DNC MS65 NGC, seemed ok to me
9 1 15571459 4641 1865 10C US MS64
10 1 15571460 4643 1866 10C US MS63
11 1 15571461 4639 1864 10C US Altered Surfaces -??? NGC coin
12 1 15571462 4640 1864-S 10C US DNC - NGC65, borderline 64/65
13 1 15571463 4571 1839 10C No Drapery US MS64
14 1 15571464 4578 1840 10C Drapery US DNC - this one was one I hoped might no suprise.
1 1 15571451 4582 1842-O 10C US AU55 - This is the Ex Pittman coin, NGC AU58 downgrade as I suspected a 58 may be too high
2 1 15571452 4689 1881 10C US Artificial Color - OUCH! Did not see that one coming, will have to look strong at the coin, NGC holdered
3 1 15571453 4686 1878-CC 10C US DNC - This is a nice 63, the reverse is very weak do to a shattered reverse variety, it they doengraded it for strike reasons than they missed the variety. I figured a 63 was a easy cross.
4 1 15571454 4598 1852-O 10C US Artificial Color - A rare unc, the color is a bit funky but I did not suspect AT but also can see the call.
5 1 15571455 4596 1851-O 10C US AU55 - This is a coin the sold for more than an NGC 58 in an ANACS 55 holder, no real sighns of a rub and I had one of the finest dealer preview and buy the coin for me.
6 1 15571456 4693 1884-S 10C US MS64 - Really nice coin
7 1 15571457 4704 1890 10C US DNC - hard to get a 66 to cross
8 1 15571458 4700 1888 10C US DNC MS65 NGC, seemed ok to me
9 1 15571459 4641 1865 10C US MS64
10 1 15571460 4643 1866 10C US MS63
11 1 15571461 4639 1864 10C US Altered Surfaces -??? NGC coin
12 1 15571462 4640 1864-S 10C US DNC - NGC65, borderline 64/65
13 1 15571463 4571 1839 10C No Drapery US MS64
14 1 15571464 4578 1840 10C Drapery US DNC - this one was one I hoped might no suprise.
I seldom check PM's but do check emails often jason@seated.org
Buying top quality Seated Dimes in Gem BU and Proof.
Buying great coins - monster eye appeal only.
Buying top quality Seated Dimes in Gem BU and Proof.
Buying great coins - monster eye appeal only.
0
Comments
I was 1 for 3 in a recent crossover submission. I believe pcgs is prejudice to ngc ms67 coins
<< <i>I believe pcgs is prejudice to ngc ms67 coins >>
PCGS is extra careful when it comes to crossing UNCs, especially 65++. They have a lot riding on their guarantee and other holders can hide a lot. They're just erring on the side of caution. Perhaps it's wiser to crack first.
A few of the coins that crossed I accepted lower grades where I felt they were not solid for the grade. To me the difference between an AU58 and 55 is not a huge deal and in some cases the coins were just overgraded so I would not expect them to cross at the current NGC grade. One coin that was funny was a coin I cracked out of a PCGS holder a few years ago and submitted raw to NGC becuase I felt it was undergraded. PCGS now will not grade that one at any grade.
None were CAC stickered.
Buying top quality Seated Dimes in Gem BU and Proof.
Buying great coins - monster eye appeal only.
Buying top quality Seated Dimes in Gem BU and Proof.
Buying great coins - monster eye appeal only.
<< <i>Growing up there is an old saying - the customer is always right. >>
This well known maxim has a lesser known stipulation
Any customer that thinks they are right because 'the customer is always right' is always wrong.