Options
Any update on ICG after their move to Florida? Is ICG going to survive?
oreville
Posts: 11,799 ✭✭✭✭✭
Any update on ICG after their move to Florida? Is ICG going to survive?
Will ICG be at the FUN show for real?
Reason:
I need to get some medals slabbed and PCGS and NGC will not slab them.
I only have ANACS and ICG to choose from.
Will ICG be at the FUN show for real?
Reason:
I need to get some medals slabbed and PCGS and NGC will not slab them.
I only have ANACS and ICG to choose from.
A Collectors Universe poster since 1997!
0
Comments
<< <i>Any update on ICG after their move to Florida? Is ICG going to survive?
Will ICG be at the FUN show for real? >>
With all due respect (and I'm not sure how much is due to ICG at this point) ... does it really matter?
After all... they are now nothing more than a watered down version of a watered down ANACS... and apparently destined to be a marketing tool of the owning entity...
As far as I am concerned, they are now as relevant as PCI... if you catch my drift...
"Bongo hurtles along the rain soaked highway of life on underinflated bald retread tires."
~Wayne
<< <i>There is only PCGS and NGC and CAC that command respect, anything else is bath water
Personally I would narrow this list down to two.
"Because I can"
myurl The Franklin All Old Green Holder Set
I only have ANACS and ICG to choose from.
<< <i>I need to get some medals slabbed and PCGS and NGC will not slab them.
I only have ANACS and ICG to choose from. >>
NGC seems to be taking the lead in slabbing more and more medals, including some that aren't listed in HK and other guides. While they don't seem to have allowed anything like ICG, you may want to give them a shot.
I have a few from deals, estates - mainly bullion and some Franks.
OLD THREAD ALERT
(Thanks for your thought provoking and insightful addition, cougar)
But oh boy, I bet @Insider3 will love this thread! 😈
Founder- Peak Rarities
Website
Instagram
Facebook
Why are these necro threads being resurrected?
Trolling (intentional or otherwise) by one particular board member.
Chopmarked Trade Dollar Registry Set --- US & World Gold Showcase --- World Chopmark Showcase
It is the Necro Monger way!
Sorry just my silly humor.
Another worthless thread that should have been put to death in 2009.
@Manifest_Destiny
Huh. Learn something every day I guess.
Chopmarked Trade Dollar Registry Set --- US & World Gold Showcase --- World Chopmark Showcase
The correct answer to the title of this 2009 thread revived in 2024 turns out to be - - yes.
What's next on the on thread revival tour?
"To Be Esteemed Be Useful" - 1792 Birch Cent --- "I personally think we developed language because of our deep need to complain." - Lily Tomlin
Ask Cougar. There's at least 100 threads from 2003 that haven't benefited from his wisdom.
Any mods willing to step up and freeze this thread?
Last comment before it gets axed.
ICG = “I Can’t Grade.”
I don't know the full story, frankly I found the old holders better aesthetically. It looks like they are upgrading operations with software so submitters can track their submission online. At this point their system is a lot slower due to the changes.
I started a thread about words the TPGS initials could stand for because they are funny. Additionally, all the "fly-by-night" services copy their names as close as they can such as PCG = Personal Coin Graders. I made up funny phrases for all the major TPGS beginning with ICG and asked members to come up with more humor. The thread was deleted before anyone could post.
Sure they can! 😉
Disclaimer: I'm not a dealer, trader, grader, investor or professional numismatist. I'm just a hobbyist. (To protect me but mostly you! 🤣 )
They, like all the others, have their niche. They have great customer service. They'll be fine.
Well, did they survive? Does anyone here really care?
I do.
I sold 3 ICG coins at a show setup at last week. Inexpensive stuff under $50. Nice coins.
ICG grades at least two things none of the other three do.
Encased postage stamps. I love that my one and only example is holdered (protected), and attributed to it's EP #.
Counterfeit coins. Encased for educational purposes and clearly marked as counterfeit. I'm sure that some may not like this but contemporary counterfeits are highly collectible. Especially so in series such as Bust Halves. PCGS and PMG holder counterfeit notes. Secondly, by being holdered and labeled as fake, they are off the marked to be sold as genuine. And yes, I know, they can be taken out of the holder.
Tag: @OAKSTAR @Insider3
Since we have an ICG grader who is currently on staff here posting, maybe they could share some of their hurt feelings about all the abuse they have gotten over the years and how he deals with it? They shouldn't be like Rodney Dangerfield who was famous for saying that he "gets no respect"! All the hard work, trying to do the right thing, living through decades of service to numismatics with the eye strain and many other challenges must be quite a test.
I have found the folks at ICG to be very friendly. I may have them slab a few counterfeits for me. I find it cool that they set up at the Fun Show each year and give out free opinions. They help a lot of people understand what they have. I believe they will be around for a long time to come. I also believe that they are really good with conservation.
I own about two dozen George II and George III counterfeit halfpennies, all slabbed. All but one are attributed to American counterfeiters and are in PCGS and NGC slabs. One isn't attributed, but is likely of English origin. It's in an ICG slab with the "crime scene" presentation, but it's encased and protected. I appreciate the extra service.
When they call you unsolicited, out of the blue, to give you a detailed update on your submission; is all you need to know I'll be a customer forever!
Disclaimer: I'm not a dealer, trader, grader, investor or professional numismatist. I'm just a hobbyist. (To protect me but mostly you! 🤣 )
They also encapsulate all/most Moonlight Mint pieces which the big3 do not. Although ANACS is the more preffered service for his work by far.
P.S. No problem resurrecting old threads from where I sit. As long as they give some value added.
Disclaimer: I'm not a dealer, trader, grader, investor or professional numismatist. I'm just a hobbyist. (To protect me but mostly you! 🤣 )
One of my favorite coins is graded by ICG. Apparently Phil took pictures of it when it was first submitted to PCGS, but he didn’t have permission to share them with me. I would absolutely love to get this in a pcgs slab similar to this, and would love to see those pictures.
https://icgcoin.com/2023/05/03/counterfeit-gsa-found-at-summer-fun-in-orlando-fl/
When a person or company is secure in its own "skin," the ravings of ignorant people have no affect. As they say, any mention - good or bad - is better than silence. Besides, most bad comments come from people who have never used whatever they badmouth OR they have a vested interest pushing a competitor. ICG is considered a second tier TPGS. That's the way it is. Remember we all have PGCS to thank for letting me and ANACS graders post in their forum so they cannot be worried about a second tier services.