Options
Bronze 1943 Lincoln cent
The rare bronze (as opposed to regular steel) 1943 Lincoln cents are mentioned in the text on page 116 of the Red Book. However, they're not given a separate line item in the price chart. Do you think they should be called out in the chart, as well?
0
Comments
Ryan
"Bongo hurtles along the rain soaked highway of life on underinflated bald retread tires."
~Wayne
The bronze 1943 Lincoln should definately be given a line and pricing in the 2010 Red Book. The 1917 Matte Proof Lincoln line should be eliminated in the 2010 Red Book. Such a coin has not and will not be accepted by the hobby unless and until a legitimate example is slabbed by either PCGS or NGC. Please, please remove that line in 2010.
Thanks,
Steve
My Complete PROOF Lincoln Cent with Major Varieties(1909-2015)Set Registry
I think the logic behind not including them is that they are being treated as off-metal errors, but I don't see any harm in including them in the chart.
The redbook has some real errors in other places; platinum bullion coin numbers are wrong for a number of the proof issues (fail to include coins issued in the sets) and there's nothing to indicate that the platinum w-uncirculated (burnished) coins have a changing reverse. (2009 ed. pp 344-47). No doubt there are more mistakes elsewhere, hopefully corrected in years to come.
<< <i>Dennis,
The bronze 1943 Lincoln should definately be given a line and pricing in the 2010 Red Book. >>
You see, that's the problem. It's not even 2009 and we're talking about the 2010 redbook!
<< <i>I think the logic behind not including them is that they are being treated as off-metal errors............. >>
Excellent point!
As for attainability, I guess once every last bronze coin has been gone through and checked then you could assume they would be unattainable but until then, it's any astute collector's game.
The name is LEE!
hey...i grew into such beliefs too except...it's a very popular desired off-metal
As wrong-planchet errors, they should not be listed. You will be crossing a fuzzy line where you will then have to list the 1944 steel cents, 1864 CN With L Indians, 40% silver Ikes from Denver, 1965 silver quarters and 1965 silver dimes.
<< <i>As wrong-planchet errors, they should not be listed. You will be crossing a fuzzy line where you will then have to list the 1944 steel cents, 1864 CN With L Indians, 40% silver Ikes from Denver, 1965 silver quarters and 1965 silver dimes. >>
And what's wrong with crossing the fuzzy line and listing those? Other errors are listed in the Red Book (55 DDO, 3 Legged Buffalo, etc). If you list such coins in the Red Book, you will increase awareness of such coins for new collectors and likely increase the value of those coins. What's the downside?
Planchet errors are not the same thing as die varieties (die varieties are not errors in numismatic parlance - the "error" is on the die so the coins are stuck properly) If you want to start listing errors, that's OK, but you should list all example of that same category as well.
For example the plain edge dollars are not listed because they are errors. Should they be listed? What about experimental washed planchets? Waffle coins?
The difference between a die variety and a minting error is very important.
and please list all those varieties you have listed in the new CherryPickers
I would rather have more US circulation coins listed and less territorial gold and pre-federal coinage
maybe the redbook should be split out like Krause World coins
and turn it into 3-5 books
<< <i>maybe the redbook should be split out like Krause World coins
and turn it into 3-5 books >>
"Inspiration exists, but it has to find you working" Pablo Picasso
<< <i>Absolutely. They include the 1804 Dollar and the 1913 Liberty Nickel, both of which are, at best, display proofs and at worst, mint employee created fantasy pieces. >>
I agree with this logic, and also with including the 1944 steel cent. It might be helpful on the 1943 copper cent after "A few specimens struck on bronze planchets by error are known to exist", you might want to add "Such pieces will not be attracted to a magnet."
Similarly, for the 1804 dollar, you might want to add "there are millions of struck counterfeit 1804 dollars which have no collector value."
An authorized PCGS dealer, and a contributor to the Red Book.
<< <i>I would rather have more US circulation coins listed and less...pre-federal coinage >>
Careful now...the Red Book is one of the few reference books available with a reasonably comprehensive listing of pre-federal coinage. If it wasn't for their inclusion in the Red Book, many people would not even know such coins existed.
Hmmmm....on second thought....never mind.