Home› U.S. Coin Forum
Options

Guess the grade - 1958-D Half - Grade REVEALED p.3

CoinJunkieCoinJunkie Posts: 8,772 ✭✭✭✭✭
I recently sent Mark Goodman some of my favorite toned coins to be photographed,
and will be presenting them in a series of "Guess the Grade" threads. All comments
welcome.

Grade is revealed on page 3.

image
image

Comments

  • Options
    MS66. Unless it was graded more than 4-5 yrs ago, in which case it would be MS66FBL.
    "Wars are really ugly! They're dirty
    and they're cold.
    I don't want nobody to shoot me in the foxhole."
    Mary






    Best Franklin Website
  • Options
    MS66FBL. I love that obverse.
  • Options
    DoubleEagle59DoubleEagle59 Posts: 8,433 ✭✭✭✭✭
    ms65 FBL,

    there's a couple of hits on the neck, head and fields (left of Ben), that I think should keep it from a 66.
    "Gold is money, and nothing else" (JP Morgan, 1912)

    "“Those who sacrifice liberty for security/safety deserve neither.“(Benjamin Franklin)

    "I only golf on days that end in 'Y'" (DE59)
  • Options
    STONESTONE Posts: 15,275 ✭
    IMO it's not better than a 65, and the FBL is in question.

    Final grade MS-65 (no FBL)
  • Options
    DoubleEagle59DoubleEagle59 Posts: 8,433 ✭✭✭✭✭


    << <i>IMO it's not better than a 65, and the FBL is in question.

    Final grade MS-65 (no FBL) >>



    Yes, I see that hit to the left of the BLInes, where it's a little iffy.

    Could go either way I guess.

    50-50 FBL.
    "Gold is money, and nothing else" (JP Morgan, 1912)

    "“Those who sacrifice liberty for security/safety deserve neither.“(Benjamin Franklin)

    "I only golf on days that end in 'Y'" (DE59)
  • Options
    IrishMikeIrishMike Posts: 7,737 ✭✭✭
    I've seen frankies with more hits than that grade 66. Those are common in 66 coins.
  • Options
    I agree about the FBL, but I say 64. There seems to be something goin on in the rim, the stike is not at all impressive and i barely see luster and I do NOT like the reverse. Bush man, I know you know your your stink on the serries, but 66? Enlighten me please.
  • Options
    TwoSides2aCoinTwoSides2aCoin Posts: 45,340 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Bodybag. This belongs in a beer coaster as GENUINE

    but it's cool, anyway. Too bad about that color. The mottling on the back is laughable.
    PCGS should buy this back and put it in a Beer Coaster.

    NET GRADE AU 64
  • Options
    but it's cool, anyway. Too bad about that color. The mottling on the back is laughable.

    NET GRADE AU 64

    Speaking of beer....I think you have had too many. What are you talking about?image
  • Options
    TwoSides2aCoinTwoSides2aCoin Posts: 45,340 ✭✭✭✭✭


    << <i>but it's cool, anyway. Too bad about that color. The mottling on the back is laughable.

    NET GRADE AU 64

    Speaking of beer....I think you have had too many. What are you talking about?image >>



    Look at the coin carefully and tell me you love the reverse image If you really do, I'll buy you a beer. The obverse looks cute, though.
  • Options
    Halfhunter06Halfhunter06 Posts: 1,349 ✭✭✭
    66 fbl
  • Options
    65 FBL is my wag. I like the toning it's better then a blast white dipped out coin.



    Dan
    U S Navy Retired 22 years - ENC(SW) Ret. - Travling Nuclear Maintanence Contractor - Working Indian Point Nuclear plant Buchanan New York
    image

    ">Franklin Halves
    ">Kennedy Halves
  • Options
    JJMJJM Posts: 8,131 ✭✭✭✭✭
    67FBL, older holder...............
    👍BST's erickso1,cone10,MICHAELDIXON,TennesseeDave,p8nt,jmdm1194,RWW,robkool,Ahrensdad,Timbuk3,Downtown1974,bigjpst,mustanggt,Yorkshireman,idratherbgardening,SurfinxHI,derryb,masscrew,Walkerguy21D,MJ1927,sniocsu,Coll3tor,doubleeagle07,luciobar1980,PerryHall,SNMAM,mbcoin,liefgold,keyman64,maprince230,TorinoCobra71,RB1026,Weiss,LukeMarshall,Wingsrule,Silveryfire, pointfivezero,IKE1964,AL410, Tdec1000, AnkurJ,guitarwes,Type2,Bp777,jfoot113,JWP,mattniss,dantheman984,jclovescoins,Collectorcoins,Weather11am,Namvet69,kansasman,Bruce7789,ADG,Larrob37,Waverly, justindan
  • Options
    tightbudgettightbudget Posts: 7,299 ✭✭✭
    65FBL
  • Options
    LotsoLuckLotsoLuck Posts: 3,786 ✭✭✭
    64 no FBL
  • Options
    65 fbl
    "If you hit a midget on the head with a stick, he turns into 40 gold coins." - Patty Oswalt
  • Options
    DRUNNERDRUNNER Posts: 3,948 ✭✭✭✭✭
    66 FBL from a nice Mint Set.

    Superb . . . and I have 10 Mint Set toners coming back (today???) that have similar toning. Great coin!

    Drunner
  • Options
    coinkatcoinkat Posts: 24,626 ✭✭✭✭✭
    66FBL

    Experience the World through Numismatics...it's more than you can imagine.

  • Options
    PCcoinsPCcoins Posts: 3,354 ✭✭✭
    66FBL
    "It is what it is."
  • Options


    << <i>IMO it's not better than a 65, and the FBL is in question. >>



    I agree sort of. I do not see FBL, eye appeal not so great. Nothing special about the strike.....I was guessing in the MS-63 to MS-64 area. I could be wrong, nobody pays me the big bucks for my grading opinion anyway.
  • Options
    65FBL, that chunk out of Ben's head disqualifies it from 66.
  • Options
    There are several hits and scratches going through the bell lines . Hard to see
    through all that "toning" , but look close. No way it deserves to be in a FBL holder.
    As to the grade, again, lots of minor hits/scratches can be seen if you look through all
    that toning. If I were to guess, I'd say it's a MS65 FBL @ NGC, and MS64 non-FBL @ PCGS.
    MY personal grade.....MS64 non-FBL .

    Actually, after going back and reviewing the coin a little more,
    I'd actually feel more comfortable calling it an MS63 non-FBL.
    Any grade higher than a 4 is a "gift" based on what the grader
    CAN'T see. The bad thing about this coin, If someone wanted to dip it back to
    "blast-white"to remove the (scratch-hiding )
    tarnish, you would wind up with pretty much a textbook MS62 non-FBL once all the flaws are
    no longer hidden.

    I guess the moral to the story is "Just Say no to Brown monsters" (?)

    Lewis


  • Options
    robkoolrobkool Posts: 5,934 ✭✭✭✭✭
    MS65FBL...
  • Options
    MS-65 FBL
  • Options
    rec78rec78 Posts: 5,969 ✭✭✭✭✭
    65 FBL
    image
  • Options
    CoxeCoxe Posts: 11,139 ✭
    MS63FBL. Those long scratches (particularly on the obverse) are partially hidden by the toning but are still there and distracting. Could mayne make 64, but any higher would be just wrong.
    Select Rarities -- DMPLs and VAMs
    NSDR - Life Member
    SSDC - Life Member
    ANA - Pay As I Go Member
  • Options
    LongacreLongacre Posts: 16,720 ✭✭✭
    65FBL, sticker. image
    Always took candy from strangers
    Didn't wanna get me no trade
    Never want to be like papa
    Working for the boss every night and day
    --"Happy", by the Rolling Stones (1972)
  • Options
    MS65FBL imageimage
  • Options


    << <i>I agree about the FBL, but I say 64. There seems to be something goin on in the rim, the stike is not at all impressive and i barely see luster and I do NOT like the reverse. Bush man, I know you know your your stink on the serries, but 66? Enlighten me please. >>



    I don't see any "rim problems". Where, exactly?

    I say 66 because:
    1) The luster looks fine to me, especially on the obverse, which carries far more weight than the rev.
    2) The only significant contact mark I see is the bump in the middle of the portraits' head. It is shallow and is magnified by the size of the image. In-hand, it would be easily overlooked.
    3) The other obverse marks look like they fall into two categories
    a] Trivial contact marks (such as the tic on the "8", or the tics in the field between the nose and rim) and
    b] Planchet imperfections that were not obliterated during the striking (ie. the mark on the light area of the neck, and, probably, the scratch below the "L" of Liberty ).
    4) The obverse eye-appeal gets a big bump from the attractive toning.
    5) The strike, while not being full (particularly, there is weakness showing on "LIBE") is acceptable for the 66 grade. This exemplifies one of the most glaring discrepancies between PCGS's written grading standards and the actual standard in use. Namely, that a coin does not have to be fully struck to be MS65 or even higher.
    6) The reverse is not butt ugly to me, as some are implying in this thread. I would consider it nuetral to slightly positive.
    7) Last, but NOT LEAST: PCGS loves mint set toned Franklins. Dip it, and it would lower the grade 1 or 2 points.

    Rebuttals are welcome, especially by those that care to put their money where their mouth is!image
    "Wars are really ugly! They're dirty
    and they're cold.
    I don't want nobody to shoot me in the foxhole."
    Mary






    Best Franklin Website
  • Options
    TwoSides2aCoinTwoSides2aCoin Posts: 45,340 ✭✭✭✭✭
    I did my pot stirring yesterday image tyvm
  • Options
    lcoopielcoopie Posts: 8,875 ✭✭✭✭✭
    66FBL

    LCoopie = Les
  • Options
    Do we get to see hat PCGS graded this one?
  • Options
    TwoSides2aCoinTwoSides2aCoin Posts: 45,340 ✭✭✭✭✭


    << <i>Do we get to see hat PCGS graded this one? >>


    You know it's a 65 non fbl, don't you ?
  • Options
    ConnecticoinConnecticoin Posts: 13,278 ✭✭✭✭✭
  • Options
    MS-68 FBL , PROOFLIKE DOUBLE DIE
  • Options
    mcheathmcheath Posts: 2,441 ✭✭✭
    66 fbl IMO.
  • Options
    CoxeCoxe Posts: 11,139 ✭
    Aren't these scratches significant? They are hidden by the foning some but vlear enough. Possibly more but I ignored the ones that could be toning breaks.

    imageimage
    imageimage
    Select Rarities -- DMPLs and VAMs
    NSDR - Life Member
    SSDC - Life Member
    ANA - Pay As I Go Member
  • Options
    <<Namely, that a coin does not have to be fully struck to be MS65 or even higher.>>
    I was sure I read this! I think the exception is the Buffalo Nickel. Strike always plays a factor with them and I always thought I misunderstood the above.
    Thank you for the elaboration, I hope to learn more from you ~the new dude
    PS-I still don't like the reverse, looks like it was in a construction site workers shirt pocket for years.
  • Options
    DoubleEagle59DoubleEagle59 Posts: 8,433 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Tuesday morning has passed.......waiting for grade.
    "Gold is money, and nothing else" (JP Morgan, 1912)

    "“Those who sacrifice liberty for security/safety deserve neither.“(Benjamin Franklin)

    "I only golf on days that end in 'Y'" (DE59)
  • Options
    Another guess the grade thread and no grade posted.
    image
    Positive:
    BST Transactions: DonnyJf, MrOrganic, Justanothercoinaddict, Fivecents, Slq, Jdimmick,
    Robb, Tee135, Ibzman350, Mercfan, Outhaul, Erickso1, Cugamongacoins, Indiananationals, Wayne Herndon

    Negative BST Transactions:
  • Options
    gripgrip Posts: 9,962 ✭✭✭✭✭
    65 FBL.
  • Options
    lcoopielcoopie Posts: 8,875 ✭✭✭✭✭


    << <i>Aren't these scratches significant? They are hidden by the foning some but vlear enough. Possibly more but I ignored the ones that could be toning breaks.

    imageimage
    imageimage >>



    from the PCGS grading guide
    MS-66 Marks
    there might be several noticeable, but very minor defects.
    if marks or hairlines are in an important focal area, they
    must be minimal and compensated for by the rest of the
    coins suberbness
    LCoopie = Les
  • Options
    OK, Tuesday morning has come and gone. Post the grade!
  • Options
    65 barely due to contact marks
  • Options
    CoinJunkieCoinJunkie Posts: 8,772 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Actual grade: PCGS MS66FBL (green label)

    (cut me some slack on the posting time, we stayed overnight in Vegas last night and the Bellagio
    wanted $25 for freakin' Internet access!!!)

    Congrats to bushmaster, who completely nailed it on the very first post. I bought this coin on eBay
    several years ago for about $150, and really love the natural look of the obverse. It was the first
    toned Franklin I ever purchased, and as such, will always have a place in my collection and my
    heart. Having seen many PCGS-holdered Franklins since, I would not necessarily say this is
    overgraded by their standards. BTW, there is more color on the reverse than came through in the
    photos, with some nice green near the upper left rim.
  • Options
    ConnecticoinConnecticoin Posts: 13,278 ✭✭✭✭✭


    << <i>Actual grade: PCGS MS66FBL (green label)
    . >>



    image
  • Options
    TreemanTreeman Posts: 426 ✭✭✭
    " I'd say it's a MS65 FBL @ NGC, and MS64 non-FBL @ PCGS.
    MY personal grade.....MS64 non-FBL ."

    I always get a kick out of people posting the "NGC" grade vs the "PCGS" grade. In this instance, I think the poster of the above staement was close with the grade NGC would have assigned, but I'm not sure they would have given it the FBL designation. People trying to insinuate that PCGS grading is tighter is one thing, but when you're discussing Franklins, I'm fairly sure that even the Kool-aid gang would admit that NGC is tighter......
  • Options


    << <i>... when you're discussing Franklins, I'm fairly sure that even the Kool-aid gang would admit that NGC is tighter...... >>



    Absolutely, unequivocally, NOT.

    There are so many overgraded NGC Franklins that I now avoid them like the plague on-line. You can find some correctly graded examples if you are able to examine them in-hand. But as far as Ebay, Teletrade, etc., I just will not bid on them anymore. It's just not worth the hassle of making all those returns.
    "Wars are really ugly! They're dirty
    and they're cold.
    I don't want nobody to shoot me in the foxhole."
    Mary






    Best Franklin Website
  • Options
    NGC was/is/has been tighter on the FBL designation .

    But NGC's overall standards of what constitutes a MS65 or a MS66 Franklin

    have fluctuated a great deal over the years .

    Therefor there are far more over graded mint state Franklin's in NGC holders then in PCGS holders .

    This is a fact and as such has been stated by myself and other Franklin experts so many time's I'm getting sick of repeating it .
  • Options
    TreemanTreeman Posts: 426 ✭✭✭
    I apologize for making you sick :-) I just get kind of sick of seeing the "NGC" vs "PCGS" comments on the "guess the grade" threads. I think the OP's are usually looking for individuals to guess the grade. They are not looking for a new way to try dissing NGC. I like both services, and find great (and not so great) coins in both slabs. When the crap is pointed out in an NGC holder. it's a good old fashioned lynching. When the crap is pointed out in a PCGS holder... it must have turned after it was slabbed, ... I can see why it's graded that way, ...they do so many coins that it was easy for a Proof to slide by as MS, ...I hardly noticed the graffitti myself, I can see how they missed it, and on, and on......
    There are two GREAT services out there, they both make mistakes on occasion, but they are both capable of having really nice coins in their slabs. Anyway, sorry about making you repeat yourself :-)

Leave a Comment

BoldItalicStrikethroughOrdered listUnordered list
Emoji
Image
Align leftAlign centerAlign rightToggle HTML viewToggle full pageToggle lights
Drop image/file