Home› U.S. Coin Forum
Options

Platinum Sales Figures...Not Adding Up?

RichRRichR Posts: 3,987 ✭✭✭✭✭
Ok...I'm a professional numbers guy...so I can't resist...so here's my take on the Plat sales numbers...which don't quite seem to wash (yet) IMHO.

Unc. Plats
11/30 Report vs. 12/7 Report
1.0 1522 1951
0.5 1257 1257
0.25 1905 1778
0.10 2485 2485
Set 2158 2158


Proof Plats
11/30 Report vs. 12/7 Report
1.0 2257 2432
0.5 1031 1056
0.25 1238 1293
0.10 2694 2810
Set 2217 2296


So...let's take the 1/4-ounce Uncs for instance, if these numbers are accurate, we're to believe that only 127 orders were cancelled over the past week? I personally had at least 5 coins cancelled and quite a few others posted notes about multiple coin orders being cancelled...but only 127 in total...unlikely. And what's up with not a single 4-coin Unc. set being returned? I have a couple of sets that are still within the 30-day return window...as do others...but no returns...NONE?

And as for the proofs...with so much attention being paid to mintages by posters on this board alone, we're to believe that practically no sales (especially for the 1/10, 1/4 and 1/2 sizes) were rung up by ANYONE for multiple denominations over an 8-day period?!? Also unlikely.

I'm also leery that the proof numbers are going to climb dramatically across the board after the sudden plat sales orgy yesterday.


Comments

  • Options
    LALASD4LALASD4 Posts: 3,602 ✭✭✭
    Well, you know that numbers are only as good as the person who gives you the numbers.image And numbers could be added or subtracted due to a number of factors, while one number could be updated one way and other numbers could be updated a different way.image

    Just check the quarterly report of the banks.image
    Coin Collector, Chicken Owner, Licensed Tax Preparer & Insurance Broker/Agent.
    San Diego, CA


    image
  • Options
    coolestcoolest Posts: 2,281 ✭✭✭
    Yes, the fact that the four coin set has not dropped by a single set is highly suspicious.
  • Options
    RichRRichR Posts: 3,987 ✭✭✭✭✭

    <<Yes, the fact that the four coin set has not dropped by a single set is highly suspicious. >>

    And speaking of that...I guess I should just hold on to my two plat sets (which are still within the 30-day return window) and hang on and hope for the best?!?
  • Options


    << <i>Ok...I'm a professional numbers guy...so I can't resist...so here's my take on the Plat sales numbers...which don't quite seem to wash (yet) IMHO.

    Unc. Plats
    11/30 Report vs. 12/7 Report
    1.0 1522 1951
    0.5 1257 1257
    0.25 1905 1778
    0.10 2485 2485
    Set 2158 2158


    Proof Plats
    11/30 Report vs. 12/7 Report
    1.0 2257 2432
    0.5 1031 1056
    0.25 1238 1293
    0.10 2694 2810
    Set 2217 2296


    So...let's take the 1/4-ounce Uncs for instance, if these numbers are accurate, we're to believe that only 127 orders were cancelled over the past week? I personally had at least 5 coins cancelled and quite a few others posted notes about multiple coin orders being cancelled...but only 127 in total...unlikely. And what's up with not a single 4-coin Unc. set being returned? I have a couple of sets that are still within the 30-day return window...as do others...but no returns...NONE?

    And as for the proofs...with so much attention being paid to mintages by posters on this board alone, we're to believe that practically no sales (especially for the 1/10, 1/4 and 1/2 sizes) were rung up by ANYONE for multiple denominations over an 8-day period?!? Also unlikely.

    I'm also leery that the proof numbers are going to climb dramatically across the board after the sudden plat sales orgy yesterday. >>




    You are right and I have had thoughts like this every step of the way...this is the way the mint operates....

    Riddle me this Bat Man...why does it take 2 LONG + years for the IDIOTS at the mint to give final mintage numbers/sales on the proofs? We will NOT know the actual mintage numers/sales for the 2008 proof plats until the middle or end of 2010! The 2006 proof numbers/sales still have not been posted!

    All I can say is RIDICULOUS! image
    Platinum Is Best
  • Options
    nycounselnycounsel Posts: 1,229 ✭✭
    So...let's take the 1/4-ounce Uncs for instance, if these numbers are accurate, we're to believe that only 127 orders were cancelled over the past week? I personally had at least 5 coins cancelled and quite a few others posted notes about multiple coin orders being cancelled...but only 127 in total...unlikely.

    This requires a belief that the sales figures includes unfilled orders.

    That seems to be a common belief, and it could very well be true.

    I just never have seen anything to confirm that's the case.

    Is there any hard evidence that the reported sales figures include open orders/backorders??

    Dan
  • Options
    coolestcoolest Posts: 2,281 ✭✭✭


    << <i>So...let's take the 1/4-ounce Uncs for instance, if these numbers are accurate, we're to believe that only 127 orders were cancelled over the past week? I personally had at least 5 coins cancelled and quite a few others posted notes about multiple coin orders being cancelled...but only 127 in total...unlikely.

    This requires a belief that the sales figures includes unfilled orders.

    That seems to be a common belief, and it could very well be true.

    I just never have seen anything to confirm that's the case.

    Is there any hard evidence that the reported sales figures include open orders/backorders?? >>



    I would say the fact that the numbers drop on some denominations is proof that the sales figures include some coins that are not available.
  • Options


    << <i>So...let's take the 1/4-ounce Uncs for instance, if these numbers are accurate, we're to believe that only 127 orders were cancelled over the past week? I personally had at least 5 coins cancelled and quite a few others posted notes about multiple coin orders being cancelled...but only 127 in total...unlikely. And what's up with not a single 4-coin Unc. set being returned? I have a couple of sets that are still within the 30-day return window...as do others...but no returns...NONE? >>




    You can add 5 more 1/4 ounce uncs that were cancelled to the ad hoc list.

    5 were shipped, 5 were cancelled.

    My orders were all over 5-6 weeks old and keep getting the shipping date pushed back.
    "Lenin is certainly right. There is no subtler or more severe means of overturning the existing basis of society(destroy capitalism) than to debauch the currency. The process engages all the hidden forces of economic law on the side of destruction, and it does it in a manner which not one man in a million is able to diagnose."
    John Marnard Keynes, The Economic Consequences of the Peace, 1920, page 235ff
  • Options
    RichRRichR Posts: 3,987 ✭✭✭✭✭
    <<This requires a belief that the sales figures includes unfilled orders. That seems to be a common belief, and it could very well be true. I just never have seen anything to confirm that's the case. Is there any hard evidence that the reported sales figures include open orders/backorders??>>


    I'm sure others have the specifics more readily available, but I definitely do remember that as various denominations started to become unavailable in late October/early November, that the subsequently reported "sales" numbers by the Mint were not jiving with when the backorder notices were initially posted on the Mint site. Therefore, this seemed to indicate that more orders had been taken as compared to coins actually having being shipped.

    Does that make any sense...?

    7over8 is much better at describing this "sales" vs "mintage" contradition.
  • Options
    nycounselnycounsel Posts: 1,229 ✭✭
    7over8 is much better at describing this "sales" vs "mintage" contradition.

    Sales are the tally of coins sold, mintage are the number of coins made and not destroyed.

    The question is not one of sales versus mintage, it is how the Mint counts sales.

    The popular belief seems to be that the Mint includes all placed orders as sales. If the orders are filled, fine. If they are not filled, but are put on backorder, they remain part of the sales number. Eventually, backorders are filled from returns or canceled, and the sales numbers are reconciled to give a more accurate count.


    I'm just not sure that's the case.

    The Mint could easily report sales as only those placed orders that have been filled. If there are returns, they would be used to fill backorders (reflecting no net gain or loss in sales), or, in the case of damaged coins, destroyed (with sales adjusted downward accordingly).

    I'm asking if anyone has actual knowledge (as opposed to a firm belief) that the Mint includes ALL placed orders in the sales figures.

    Dan
  • Options
    nycounselnycounsel Posts: 1,229 ✭✭
    I would say the fact that the numbers drop on some denominations is proof that the sales figures include some coins that are not available.


    The downward adjustment would also occur for returns that were marked as "damaged," so were not used to fill backorders but destroyed.

    Again, I understand the belief here-- reported sales include all backorders, including many that will not be filled. I'm open to that being true. I just haven't seen anything that compels the belief.

    Dan
  • Options
    nycounselnycounsel Posts: 1,229 ✭✭
    And as for the proofs...with so much attention being paid to mintages by posters on this board alone, we're to believe that practically no sales (especially for the 1/10, 1/4 and 1/2 sizes) were rung up by ANYONE for multiple denominations over an 8-day period?!? Also unlikely.

    I understand the question here and agree. But who's to say if any of the sales figures have pinpoint accuracy?

    Week after week it's the same thing. We look at the current reported sales (week x) with suspicion. Then the next week (week y), we treat the week x figures as if they were set in stone. The whole data set is probably flawed to some extent, and a big adjustment one week or the other might only reflect a revision at some earlier point in the chain.

    Dan
  • Options
    I received (2) 1/4 plat unc last week. These were ordered on 10/21/08. The one I ordered on the 27th (10/27/08) was never cancelled nor did I get any email about the order from the mint. But when I checked today it said "no longer available"

    Should I presume the 1/4 plats I got were returns?

    Also I had a 1/4 buff unc shipped to me but never received.

    The mint did credit me back.

    Now the one I ordered to replace it was shipped on 12/3/08 via usps.

    I have not yet received it. This seems like a repeat of before.

    I hope I get it.

    I thought the mint shipped all gold, platinum, etc fedx.

    Never lost ever shipped to me except that mia buffalo.

    Also received a box via fedx that was missing my plats.

    The usps worker I deal with tells me that the brown tape can be steamed off the plastic tape and then reglued. Interesting! I would think the mint would know this.

    Ships are safe in harbor but thats not what ships were built for.
  • Options


    << <i>Ok...I'm a professional numbers guy...so I can't resist...so here's my take on the Plat sales numbers...which don't quite seem to wash (yet) IMHO.

    Unc. Plats
    11/30 Report vs. 12/7 Report
    1.0 1522 1951
    0.5 1257 1257
    0.25 1905 1778
    0.10 2485 2485
    Set 2158 2158


    Proof Plats
    11/30 Report vs. 12/7 Report
    1.0 2257 2432
    0.5 1031 1056
    0.25 1238 1293
    0.10 2694 2810
    Set 2217 2296


    So...let's take the 1/4-ounce Uncs for instance, if these numbers are accurate, we're to believe that only 127 orders were cancelled over the past week? I personally had at least 5 coins cancelled and quite a few others posted notes about multiple coin orders being cancelled...but only 127 in total...unlikely. And what's up with not a single 4-coin Unc. set being returned? I have a couple of sets that are still within the 30-day return window...as do others...but no returns...NONE?

    And as for the proofs...with so much attention being paid to mintages by posters on this board alone, we're to believe that practically no sales (especially for the 1/10, 1/4 and 1/2 sizes) were rung up by ANYONE for multiple denominations over an 8-day period?!? Also unlikely.

    I'm also leery that the proof numbers are going to climb dramatically across the board after the sudden plat sales orgy yesterday. >>




    <<<plat sales orgy>>>imageimageimage



    my ebay items BST transactions/swaps/giveaways with: Tiny, raycyca,mrpaseo, Dollar2007,Whatafind, Boom, packers88, DBSTrader2, 19Lyds, Mar327, pontiacinf, ElmerFusterpuck.
  • Options
    NeoStarNeoStar Posts: 1,123 ✭✭✭
    Another thing to take into consideration is that the US Mint is moving its Fulfillment Center and that the data might be slow coming in at times from the current Fulfillment Center and DC (home of the VP office)...
  • Options
    7over87over8 Posts: 4,733 ✭✭✭
    Guys -

    Confirmed with the USM Mint Office of Public Affairs today -

    "Sales Numbers realeased in Sales reports this week do not include order cancellations".

    I suppose we have to wait another week to see if they are included then........

    why they arent included is anyone's guess, there was dramatic amounts of cancellations in all product offerings of the plat unc's last week as confirmed by many on this forum.....
  • Options
    7over87over8 Posts: 4,733 ✭✭✭
    NYC -

    Both myself and EricJ96 have talked to individuals in the USM Office of Public Affairs and the USM Marketing Dept and THEY have confirmed that sales includes ALL ORDERS - they do not segregate backorders......

    Why is this so hard to understand? I ask because the same question keeps coming up..........

    I guess if you dont want to believe the comments of individuals within that department, then I would argue you would not even read their sales report.....
  • Options
    RichRRichR Posts: 3,987 ✭✭✭✭✭

    <<"Sales Numbers realeased in Sales reports this week do not include order cancellations". I suppose we have to wait another week to see if they are included then........>>


    Hi 7over8...

    1. So you're basically saying that I shouldn't throw my plat 4-coin Unc sets against the wall YET in a fit of anger and disgust...while screaming "Common trash!!!"

    and

    2. I shouldn't kill the FedEx guy and bury his body in the woods while taking my neighbor's Plat proof set?
  • Options
    coolestcoolest Posts: 2,281 ✭✭✭


    << <i>NYC -

    Both myself and EricJ96 have talked to individuals in the USM Office of Public Affairs and the USM Marketing Dept and THEY have confirmed that sales includes ALL ORDERS - they do not segregate backorders......

    Why is this so hard to understand? I ask because the same question keeps coming up..........

    I guess if you dont want to believe the comments of individuals within that department, then I would argue you would not even read their sales report..... >>



    You know I have been with you on these issues, but it is nice to hear it again with no ambiguity. It will be fun to watch the numbers drop. I

    will be posting the dancing smiley.
  • Options


    << <i><<"Sales Numbers realeased in Sales reports this week do not include order cancellations". I suppose we have to wait another week to see if they are included then........>>


    Hi 7over8...

    1. So you're basically saying that I shouldn't throw my plat 4-coin Unc sets against the wall YET in a fit of anger and disgust...while screaming "Common trash!!!"

    and

    2. I shouldn't kill the FedEx guy and bury his body in the woods while taking my neighbor's Plat proof set? >>



    imageimage
    Platinum Is Best
  • Options
    Two questions that should be asked of the Mint Director if he ever appears at a coin show.

    1. How does the US Mint come up with the numbers that Numismatic News publishes?

    2. Why does it take years for final mintage figures to be published?
    Successful BST transactions: clackamas, goldman86, alohagary, rodzm, bigmarty58, Hyperion, segoja, levinll, dmarks
  • Options
    Type2Type2 Posts: 13,985 ✭✭✭✭✭
    I have a 1/4 on back order they will kill all of them as soon as the 30days are over so if some one send one back they have a buyer. So all we can do is sit and wait. image


    Hoard the keys.
  • Options
    GATGAT Posts: 3,146 ✭
    It's amazing that I offered 1/4 and 1/2 oz unc platinum coins on the BST board at the Mint's price before I sent them back with no takers,
    USAF vet 1951-59
  • Options
    RichRRichR Posts: 3,987 ✭✭✭✭✭

    Just to reiterate what 7over8 has been saying all along, buried in the 12/15 issue of Coin World on p. 68 is the following gem:

    "Monthly sales totals, posted cumulatively on a daily basis over the Mint's Web site at www.usmint.gov for Uncirculated platinum, gold and silver American Eagles, may include coins dated from more than one calendar year and do not represent mintages for a particular date."

    Not a completely apples to apples definitive statement in regards to the APE or the Buffs...but enough to indicate that sales figues at the Mint should be considered "fluid" to say the least...and not as a hard and fast indicator of ultimate mintage figures.
  • Options
    NeoStarNeoStar Posts: 1,123 ✭✭✭
    "Monthly sales totals, posted cumulatively on a daily basis over the Mint's Web site at www.usmint.gov for Uncirculated platinum, gold and silver American Eagles, may include coins dated from more than one calendar year and do not represent mintages for a particular date."

    They are referring to these sales figures posted at the mint website on a monthly basis and not sales figures posted on NN on a weekly basis:

    LINKY to US Mint Page
  • Options
    OK guys...........................if it will put a stop to this endless bickering over mintages I'll let you know a secret................

    This is how I got the correct audited mintage numbers for the 2005 APE proofs 6 months before mint posted them.

    Sometime after Jan 1st. of 09 call your congressional office and ask them to obtain from mint the final audited mintages of APE and AGEs.

    Be specific in your wording.......remember these staffers know nothing about coins.

    Almost all congressional staffers are happy and eager to help a voter...............they really are............

    They will forward your question on congressional letterhead to mint management and you will get a correct answer long before it is ever posted on mint web site.

    When you get the answer please post it for all to see.
  • Options
    RichRRichR Posts: 3,987 ✭✭✭✭✭
    <<They are referring to these sales figures posted at the mint website on a monthly basis and not sales figures posted on NN on a weekly basis:>>

    Agreed...but my primary point is that in Mint speak...sales figures DO NOT equal mintage figures.
  • Options


    << <i>OK guys...........................if it will put a stop to this endless bickering over mintages I'll let you know a secret................

    This is how I got the correct audited mintage numbers for the 2005 APE proofs 6 months before mint posted them.

    Sometime after Jan 1st. of 09 call your congressional office and ask them to obtain from mint the final audited mintages of APE and AGEs.

    Be specific in your wording.......remember these staffers know nothing about coins.

    Almost all congressional staffers are happy and eager to help a voter...............they really are............

    They will forward your question on congressional letterhead to mint management and you will get a correct answer long before it is ever posted on mint web site.

    When you get the answer please post it for all to see. >>




    Now that is an excellent idea! image
    Platinum Is Best
  • Options
    Yes they may not pay any attention to calls from individuals but when their masters from the hill call their ears perk up and they snap to attention.
  • Options
    nycounselnycounsel Posts: 1,229 ✭✭
    <<They are referring to these sales figures posted at the mint website on a monthly basis and not sales figures posted on NN on a weekly basis:>>

    Agreed...but my primary point is that in Mint speak...sales figures DO NOT equal mintage figures.


    All the grown ups in the room understand that sales figures are not the same as mintage figures.

    As I said before, sales figures are simply the tally of coins sold, mintage figures are the total number of coins made and not destroyed.

    Sales figures are merely an indicator of mintage figures-- presumably, for a coin to have been "sold" it must have been minted.

    Really, the only issue is whether or not the Mint includes "orders" as "sales".

    If I order a 2008 platinum set, does the Mint count that placed order as a sale regardless of whether or not they have the inventory to fill the order?

    I've never been confident in that; just as sales figures are different from mintage figures, orders are different from sales.

    An order is only an order until it is filled. Once it is filled, it is a sale.

    That being the case, it's certainly possible that the Mint is not as exact in its terminology and that what it calls "sales" are in fact only "orders."

    According to 7/8, he and Eric have confirmed with the Mint that is the case. If they're right, the sales numbers will need to be adjusted downwards for all orders carried as "backorder" that were not filled by returns and eventually canceled. The adjustment downward will depend on the count of backorders. 7/8 bases his estimate of that on the given sales figures that preceded when a given coin or set went on backorder.

    Anyone who knows me knows that I really don't mind how this turns out; I would be very pleased if 2008 numbers are adjusted down as low as 7/8 expects; I would not be devastated if they are not. My belief that 2006 will probably hold up is based on the fact that the reported 2008 numbers, at this point, are just SO much higher.

    The Mint is reporting
    1951
    1257.
    1778
    2485
    2158

    7/8's opinion is that the real numbers are:

    1oz unc 1250
    1/2 oz unc 1100
    1/4 oz unc 1100
    1/10 oz unc 2000
    4 coin sets 1250

    For 7/8 to be right, we'd need an adjustment down of almost 1,000 sets, 485 $10, 678 $25, 157 $50 and 701 $100 coins.

    That's simply too dramatic an adjustment for me to have much faith in; I'd rather just live with the reported numbers and be pleasantly surprised if and when they drop than hope for a huge correction and be disappointed if it doesn't happen.
    Dan
  • Options
    nycounselnycounsel Posts: 1,229 ✭✭
    also, in support of 7/8's position, I've had an order for 11 platinum unc sets on backorder since November 13.

    As of today, that order shows as backordered, order request in process, with an expected ship date of 12/25 (yesterday was 12/24--every day, it is pushed back another day).

    If the reported sales numbers are in fact only order numbers, that would account for 11 inflated set sales.
    Dan
  • Options
    renman95renman95 Posts: 7,037 ✭✭✭✭✭


    << <i>Just to reiterate what 7over8 has been saying all along, buried in the 12/15 issue of Coin World on p. 68 is the following gem:

    "Monthly sales totals, posted cumulatively on a daily basis over the Mint's Web site at www.usmint.gov for Uncirculated platinum, gold and silver American Eagles, may include coins dated from more than one calendar year and do not represent mintages for a particular date."

    Not a completely apples to apples definitive statement in regards to the APE or the Buffs...but enough to indicate that sales figues at the Mint should be considered "fluid" to say the least...and not as a hard and fast indicator of ultimate mintage figures. >>



    OK, it really comes down to what the definition of "is" is.image
  • Options
    renman95renman95 Posts: 7,037 ✭✭✭✭✭


    << <i>also, in support of 7/8's position, I've had an order for 11 platinum unc sets on backorder since November 13.

    As of today, that order shows as backordered, order request in process, with an expected ship date of 12/25 (yesterday was 12/24--every day, it is pushed back another day).

    If the reported sales numbers are in fact only order numbers, that would account for 11 inflated set sales. >>



    That reminds me of 2006. I had a few orders that were "dead man walking" back then.
  • Options
    coolestcoolest Posts: 2,281 ✭✭✭


    << <i><<They are referring to these sales figures posted at the mint website on a monthly basis and not sales figures posted on NN on a weekly basis:>>

    Agreed...but my primary point is that in Mint speak...sales figures DO NOT equal mintage figures.


    All the grown ups in the room understand that sales figures are not the same as mintage figures.

    As I said before, sales figures are simply the tally of coins sold, mintage figures are the total number of coins made and not destroyed.

    Sales figures are merely an indicator of mintage figures-- presumably, for a coin to have been "sold" it must have been minted.

    Really, the only issue is whether or not the Mint includes "orders" as "sales".

    If I order a 2008 platinum set, does the Mint count that placed order as a sale regardless of whether or not they have the inventory to fill the order?

    I've never been confident in that; just as sales figures are different from mintage figures, orders are different from sales.

    An order is only an order until it is filled. Once it is filled, it is a sale.

    That being the case, it's certainly possible that the Mint is not as exact in its terminology and that what it calls "sales" are in fact only "orders."

    According to 7/8, he and Eric have confirmed with the Mint that is the case. If they're right, the sales numbers will need to be adjusted downwards for all orders carried as "backorder" that were not filled by returns and eventually canceled. The adjustment downward will depend on the count of backorders. 7/8 bases his estimate of that on the given sales figures that preceded when a given coin or set went on backorder.

    Anyone who knows me knows that I really don't mind how this turns out; I would be very pleased if 2008 numbers are adjusted down as low as 7/8 expects; I would not be devastated if they are not. My belief that 2006 will probably hold up is based on the fact that the reported 2008 numbers, at this point, are just SO much higher.

    The Mint is reporting
    1951
    1257.
    1778
    2485
    2158

    7/8's opinion is that the real numbers are:

    1oz unc 1250
    1/2 oz unc 1100
    1/4 oz unc 1100
    1/10 oz unc 2000
    4 coin sets 1250

    For 7/8 to be right, we'd need an adjustment down of almost 1,000 sets, 485 $10, 678 $25, 157 $50 and 701 $100 coins.

    That's simply too dramatic an adjustment for me to have much faith in; I'd rather just live with the reported numbers and be pleasantly surprised if and when they drop than hope for a huge correction and be disappointed if it doesn't happen. >>




    How can you account for the additional sale of about 400 1oz coins in the last week?
  • Options
    nycounselnycounsel Posts: 1,229 ✭✭
    How can you account for the additional sale of about 400 1oz coins in the last week?

    I'm not making predictions, so my view here-- which is simply to accept the sales figures as they are, ballpark numbers, understanding that some adjustment will be made-- doesn't need to account for anything.

    However, for what it's worth, I will share my own experience:

    I placed an order for 5 $100 coins in mid November, it was shown as on backorder until it was filled Dec. 3.

    If my order was NOT reported as part of the "sales" figures when ordered, but only reported as a sale when the order is filled, it and sales like it could account for the additional 400 coins reported as sold.

    Of course, if the coins I received were someone else's returns, then I can also imagine that my filled backorder was reported as a sale of an additional 5 coins, which will eventually be adjusted down by 5 coins when returns are subtracted out.
    Dan
  • Options
    7over87over8 Posts: 4,733 ✭✭✭
    We all have to sit and wait for the numbers to be revised.

    There were real problems with the unc-w's (sales/orders taken) this year, I believe the USM got themselves in a bind, opened up the floodgates and took as many orders as possible. Repeated calls to the USM Public Affairs office drew no explanation for the "overordered" situation, but rather acceptance that it happened and that there wasnt enough stock to fill all those orders.

    337 returns in 2 weeks for the 1/4's. 311+ cancellations that I know of - not included in the sales number this week, and most likely many more. No substantial deliveries for 7+ weeks.

    I dont know about you, but, 311 cancellations puts us within 367 pieces of my number. Not very hard to accept in my book.

    900 orders for 4 coin sets accepted after backorder. Many may dispute the 900 number, and say its 100-200 less, but I stick with my number and expect to see decreases there as well.

    This is not a normal year. Many issues are extremely short struck. Whatever was available for sale has been in stock since mid year. Presses were not warmed up in October.

    If you are a believer in ultra low plat-w proofs, ultra low buffs, etc etc etc, why would the mint blow out the unc-w plats?

    Exactly.

    As I stated earlier, my points are well known. I have my information that I am very happy with and base my opinions on it.

  • Options
    OK, I'll throw my two cents into the ring....

    IMO, the mint was being extremely cautious and had the "meter set high" for returns when accepting orders for the plat uncs. First the tenths went B/O, and they remained in B/O for several days.

    Next, the quarters went B/O, and they too remained in B/O status for several day.

    Next, the 4 coin sets went B/O, and these also remained in B/O status for several days.

    In my scenario, the reported "sales" of the three above items include all orders, regardless of stock available.

    Finally, the half and 1 oz went B/O, and in both of those cases, they went dark within hours.

    Is it reasonable to assume that many more people were jumping on the half and 1 oz bandwagon (once they went on B/O), given the substantially higher cost then of the quarter and dimes, in such a short period of time, compared to the time the tenths, quarters, and 4 coins sets, which remained in B/O for DAYS?

    Supporting this theory, look at the halves vs. the quarters. The halves went dark very quickly after going into B/O, and the reported sales are 1257. The quarters stayed open for several days after going into B/O, and are reported at over 2,000.

    I suggest that after the RUN on the tenths, quarters, and possibly the 4 coin sets, the mint "reset the meter" for over-sales. This is supported by the fact that all the subsequent "short strikes" of 2008...the plat unc. halves and 1 oz, all the buffs, the plat proofs, and soon to be the first hags and AGE....all of these have been orderly moved from B/O to not available in a timely basis.

    Therefore, I think 7/8 is dead on about the tenths and quarters. The 4 coin sets are the rub....at what point did the mint reset the meter....if it was AFTER the 4 coins sets went black, than they were subject to the same over-sell criteria and the actual mintage was 2,000 (minus returns for damage). If it was BEFORE the 4 coin sets went B/O, then the reported numbers are pretty close to accurate.

    FWIW, I personally returned 44 halves at the higher price and have received 44 at the lower price. So deduct 44 from the reported 1257 sales on the halves.

    FloridaBill



  • Options
    BAJJERFANBAJJERFAN Posts: 31,694 ✭✭✭✭✭


    << <i><<They are referring to these sales figures posted at the mint website on a monthly basis and not sales figures posted on NN on a weekly basis:>>

    Agreed...but my primary point is that in Mint speak...sales figures DO NOT equal mintage figures. >>



    Nor should they. If the mint strikes 10,000 coins and sells half of them, then why would one expect the mintage and sales figures to be equal? If half of the sold coins get returned; the mintage is still 10K coins.
    theknowitalltroll;
  • Options
    The following was taken from http://mintnewsblog.blogspot.com/

    Better watch the numbers carefully...I am going to return my extras to the mint if the numbers are above 2004 and 2005 next week...I can tell there are many virgins in this forum who have not been screwed by the mint so be careful and read everything you can and watch the numbers before the 30 days runs out!


    Thursday, December 11, 2008
    2008-W Uncirculated & Proof Platinum Eagle Sales Figures

    This morning the last of the US Mint's 2008 platinum products sold out. The only platinum product which remains available for sale is the 2007 10th Anniversary Platinum Eagle Set.

    As it stands, all 2008-W Uncirculated Platinum Eagles are gone, including the 1 oz, 1/2 oz, 1/4 oz, 1/10 oz individual options and the 4 Coin Set. All 2008 Proof Platinum Eagles are gone, also including the 1 oz, 1/2 oz, 1/4 oz, 1/10 oz individual options and the 4 Coin Set.

    The official sell outs for these products mark a somewhat bittersweet ending. In November the US Mint announced a large number of product discontinuations for 2009, which included the majority of the collectible Platinum Eagle offerings. The only platinum coin that will return next year is the One Ounce Proof Platinum Eagle.

    Over at Numismaster, the latest Mint Stats through December 7th have been posted. The sales figures for all platinum coins are included below. The first column shows the individual totals per product type. The second column shows the cumulative totals per coin (individual sales plus 4 coin set sales).

    2008-W Uncirculated Platinum Eagle Sales Figures
    1 oz 1,951 4,109
    1/2 oz 1,257 3,415
    1/4 oz 1,778 3,936
    1/10 oz 2,485 4,643
    4 Coin 2,158

    2008 Proof Platinum Eagle Sales Figures
    1 oz 2,432 4,728
    1/2 oz 1,056 3,352
    1/4 oz 1,293 3,589
    1/10 oz 2,810 5,106
    4 Coin 2,296

    For the uncirculated coins, the sales number increased for the 1 ounce coin and decreased for the 1/4 ounce coin. The last time I looked at these sales figures, I ran comparisons to the prior 2006 & 2007-W Platinum Eagle mintages. Low numbers for 2008 are now the 1/2 ounce coin and 1/10 ounce coin, which are lower than 2007 numbers, but still above 2006.

    On the proof side, the numbers will continue to grow since they only report sales through December 7th. It appears that a big rush of buying may have taken place early this week, which might have a big impact. The current numbers are still comfortably below the 2007 Proof Platinum Eagle mintages. However, we will have to revisit this next week when new numbers for 2008 become available.
    Platinum Is Best

Leave a Comment

BoldItalicStrikethroughOrdered listUnordered list
Emoji
Image
Align leftAlign centerAlign rightToggle HTML viewToggle full pageToggle lights
Drop image/file