Options
RIP Jim O'Donnell, Found Dead on Sept. 15
Coinosaurus
Posts: 9,615 ✭✭✭✭✭
Bill Bugert just announced via the E-Gobrecht that Jim O'Donnell was found dead on 9/15 in his NY apartment.
O'Donnell was always one of the mandatory tables to visit at the major shows, and I will miss him.
He never touched a computer and insisted on doing business the old-fashioned way until the end, relying on his well established network and customer base. He was the guy that never changed, who had lived in the same East-side apartment for forty years.
He loved to recount past transactions and great coins he had handled; and while you weren't always 100% sure you were getting the straight scoop it was always very entertaining.
It would be great to hear from his other clients, I am sure Roadrunner and MrHalfDime dealt w/him for a long time.
O'Donnell was always one of the mandatory tables to visit at the major shows, and I will miss him.
He never touched a computer and insisted on doing business the old-fashioned way until the end, relying on his well established network and customer base. He was the guy that never changed, who had lived in the same East-side apartment for forty years.
He loved to recount past transactions and great coins he had handled; and while you weren't always 100% sure you were getting the straight scoop it was always very entertaining.
It would be great to hear from his other clients, I am sure Roadrunner and MrHalfDime dealt w/him for a long time.
0
Comments
Very sad news. I bought and sold early type with him at shows. He had a great eye for the early stuff and was truly knowledgeable. I too witnessed one of his seizures. It was at the Santa Clara show about 4 years ago. Scary scene. Rest In Peace Jim......... You were one of the good guys and will always be remembered as such.
Buying top quality Seated Dimes in Gem BU and Proof.
Buying great coins - monster eye appeal only.
<< <i>hm >>
YES!! FIRST SHOTT TOO
EDITED TO SAY SORY GENTS, HAVE ONE ON ME
When I first met Jim O'Donnell, a mutual friend introduced us, introducing me to Jim as "an expert in Liberty Seated half dimes". I was mortified. Whatever I might have known about half dimes paled in comparison with what Jim had learned over his many years as a dealer. Jim looked at me with a doubting stare, and decided to quiz me on the spot to see if I was, in fact, an expert. He asked "Which of the Civil War Philadelphia dates (1863, 1864, 1865, 1866, and 1867) was the rarest?". I hesitated because I knew that most 'experts' at that time deemed the 1864 to be the rarest, but I did not agree, yet was reluctant to express my theory when being quizzed. I haltingly answered "Well, most people would probably say the 1864 was the rarest, but I think it is the 1865". Jim smiled, extended his hand, and said "You really are an expert, aren't you". From that moment on, Jim and I became best of friends.
I recently sent Jim a letter about a coin he had that I was interested in, as I knew that he did not have a computer, did not email, and virtually never answered a telephone call despite the many business cards he had given me over the years. I never received an answer. Sadly, now I know why.
Yes, it was difficult to watch Jim when he had an epileptic seizure, but he tried to never let that get him down, and quickly regained his composure and resumed life as normally as he could afterwards. He was sincere, friendly, fair and honest, and I always enjoyed my many dealings with him, and particularly our many numismatic discussions. The hobby has lost one of its giants, and he will be sorely missed.
Perhaps later I will post some of my more interesting memories of Jim, after his loss has had time to sink in.
He was one of the last, if not the very last of his kind in the business...dealers will know what I mean.
Authorized dealer for PCGS, PCGS Currency, NGC, NCS, PMG, CAC. Member of the PNG, ANA. Member dealer of CoinPlex and CCE/FACTS as "CH5"
<< <i>He was one of the last, if not the very last of his kind in the business...dealers will know what I mean. >>
Jim didn't much care about pop reports, registry sets, or whatever the latest fad was, even grading services. He had his own idea about what was rare & desirable and stuck to it, and it worked for him.
I remember my last coin transaction with Jim where I flipped him an undamaged 73cc dime in G/VG that I had bought at a local shop. While I made a fair profit on that coin I left 50-100% "on the table" as a way to say thanks for all the information he shared with me over the years. We didn't discuss anything about the deal so he was not aware why I was leaving him plenty of room. He probably thought he took advantage of me that day but in hindsight, it was me who got the lion's share because of what I learned from him.
We'll miss you Jim.
roadrunner
K S
I stopped by Jim's table at Baltimore conventions a few times over the years...always pleasant and friendly. I bought a 55 DDO Lincoln Cent from him once. He had two 64s on display, one RB and one BN and I was trying to choose. He recommended I buy the BN even though it was quite a bit less money. I listened to his recommendation and bought the BN and loved it. And I did well on it when I sold it a couple of years later. Clearly he had a good eye and was interested in building good relationships with his customers. One of the good guys.
<< <i>Never knew the guy personally but it sure sounds like he was one of the good ones. Wish I had known him now. Epilepsy can really suck and it can be horrifyingly scary to watch for someone not familiar with it. What many folks don't know is that once the siezure is over, if the person didn't physically hurt themselves by banging into something, there are virtually no ill effects. They go through a short post-ictal phase where mental capacity is not 100% and are often very tired afterwards but it's not quite the nightmarish thing that on lookers often think. >>
If I might offer some advice from personal experience, if you witness a grand mal seizure, don't try to do anything during the initial thrashing other than to pad the person's head with your hand or foot if it is banging against something.
After the thrashing has ended, roll the person on their side with their head facing down at an angle so that saliva and phlegm can drain from their mouth. If they are laying on their back, it can interfere with their breathing.
Never try to open their jaw to free up a tongue or lip caught between the teeth. You can't, and might injure the person by trying. Never put anything in their mouth.
Be patient. It will pass, but it helps if somebody can watch the person until they come around.
TD
<< <i>
<< <i>Never knew the guy personally but it sure sounds like he was one of the good ones. Wish I had known him now. Epilepsy can really suck and it can be horrifyingly scary to watch for someone not familiar with it. What many folks don't know is that once the siezure is over, if the person didn't physically hurt themselves by banging into something, there are virtually no ill effects. They go through a short post-ictal phase where mental capacity is not 100% and are often very tired afterwards but it's not quite the nightmarish thing that on lookers often think. >>
If I might offer some advice from personal experience, if you witness a grand mal seizure, don't try to do anything during the initial thrashing other than to pad the person's head with your hand or foot if it is banging against something.
After the thrashing has ended, roll the person on their side with their head facing down at an angle so that saliva and phlegm can drain from their mouth. If they are laying on their back, it can interfere with their breathing.
Never try to open their jaw to free up a tongue or lip caught between the teeth. You can't, and might injure the person by trying. Never put anything in their mouth.
Be patient. It will pass, but it helps if somebody can watch the person until they come around.
TD >>
Good advice. I say that both as a certified EMT with in the field experience dealing with seizures and as someone who has a very close relative with epilepsy. The old myth is to stick something in their mouths...even a finger...bad move. I've seen epileptics die because the "something" that was put into their mouth logded and they suffocated. I've also gone on calls with two patients....1 seizure patient and one amputation patient who just had their finger bitten clean off by the dude having the seizure.
You would never "cherry pick" a coin at Jim's table, but you were assured to find almost any rare variety and key date you might need or want for sale.
Rest well Jim, you will be sorrowly missed...
QN
Go to Early United States Coins - to order the New "Early United States Half Dollar Vol. 1 / 1794-1807" book or the 1st new Bust Quarter book!
We have had more than our share of losses this year?
I put Jim in the same class as Jack Lee. Great oldtimers!
Very sad to hear. I will say my blessings for both Jim and Jack next week.