Options
A little game of "Ethics"...
I need to come up with a topic for this month's Ethics column in The Numismatist, so I'm going to ask you to play a little game.
As briefly as possible, please describe a scenario involving unethical numismatic conduct. For example, "Professional coin dealer knowingly sells counterfeit coin to his grandmother."
Try to come up with something that's both interesting and realistic, and different than anything that has already been posted to this thread. Thanks!!!
As briefly as possible, please describe a scenario involving unethical numismatic conduct. For example, "Professional coin dealer knowingly sells counterfeit coin to his grandmother."
Try to come up with something that's both interesting and realistic, and different than anything that has already been posted to this thread. Thanks!!!
Andy Lustig
Doggedly collecting coins of the Central American Republic.
Visit the Society of US Pattern Collectors at USPatterns.com.
Doggedly collecting coins of the Central American Republic.
Visit the Society of US Pattern Collectors at USPatterns.com.
0
Comments
Is it ethical to list a coin you know to have been cleaned on ebay and not describe it as such?
I've been told I tolerate fools poorly...that may explain things if I have a problem with you. Current ebay items - Nothing at the moment
There needs to be room for some debate. Where's the "gray area" with counterfeit slabs?
Doggedly collecting coins of the Central American Republic.
Visit the Society of US Pattern Collectors at USPatterns.com.
A dealer sells you a couple of pop top coins at top dollar as they make you the big cheese #1 registry set.
Then lists his own set that bumps you to # 2.
(2) You easily identify the IP address of an obvious competitor (who snipes you manually routinely) to an eBay lot (recent email header or web server log entry, for instance). Then in the closing minute of the sale, hammer him with a denial of service attack.
(3) You send non-premium-bearing early state of a VAM to Teletrade for auction. Before sending though, you scratch the holder so it will photograph in a way to suggest it is the very valuable later state. (That has been done!)
(4) You're a dealer who represents a client who wants to sell a coin. You also have a client who desperately wants that coin. Instead of getting the best money possible for the seller, you sell it to the buying client for less than you know others would pay if in competetion, just to maintain a lucrative relationship. (Securities guys do this in-house routinely, or at least used to.)
(5) A client comes into the store and wants to you to submit a nice VF+ 1893-S Morgan for grading. You have a well-made fake 1893-S you got stuck with many years ago around the same grade. You submit your own coin and it comes back in the expected bodybag. You show the results to the client and offer to take it off his hands for cheap so you have an example of this sort of fake. The deal is taken and you get out of the fake coin effectively by stealing the guy's authentic one.
Only a couple of these are ethical issues, but what the heck.
NSDR - Life Member
SSDC - Life Member
ANA - Pay As I Go Member
Who is that much of a dishonest person to scratch a full blown scarface onto the holder of an EDS?? I've never heard of this before, but would like to see pictures if able, Coxe.
Should the dealer tell the buyer that he will never get that coin in a PCGS or NGC holder? Or is it buyer beware?
2 customers back in line asks dealer when he's alone if he wanted to sell the 50 rolls of wheaties. Dealer says yea, they're probably junk, that guy never brings me anything good, 3 cents each. - Sold $75.00
2 Days later the purchaser comes back to the shop and tells the owner I think you should have looked in those 50 rolls. Although there were 40 rolls of common date circulated wheaties, there were also 5 rolls of XFish early date Indian Heads, and 5 rolls of uncirculated 1931S wheaties.
What would you do as the buyer who discovered what was really in the rolls?
What would you do as the shop owner?
What if Grandma's heir was in the shop and heard this conversation?
"You Suck Award" - February, 2015
Discoverer of 1919 Mercury Dime DDO - FS-101
I like this idea! Not for the column, but as a tactic. How about a tutorial?
Doggedly collecting coins of the Central American Republic.
Visit the Society of US Pattern Collectors at USPatterns.com.
<< <i>What would you do as the buyer who discovered what was really in the rolls? >>
If you're smart, you keep your mouth shut.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
A little old lady walks into a coin store. Her husband has just passed away.
She tells the dealer he left her some "gold coins in a book" and then proceeds to take out a dansco album with one of every kind of gold coin ever made (I don't collect gold, but the book was full of UNC plus coins).
The dealer tells her he can write her a check for $15K, after which she falls out of the chair.
She takes the check and skips out of the door because the other two dealers she already took the coins to barely offered her half the offer she took.
Two seconds after she leaves, the dealer turns to me and asks me if I want to buy a Gold Type Set.
I reply... How Much?
The Answer... $100K (the dealer stated the McKinley $1 would easily "go 66.")
So, the definition of ethical is:
eth·i·cal –adjective
1. pertaining to or dealing with morals or the principles of morality; pertaining to right and wrong in conduct.
2. being in accordance with the rules or standards for right conduct or practice, esp. the standards of a profession: It was not considered ethical for physicians to advertise.
3. (of drugs) sold only upon medical prescription.
The next question... which of the three dealers were ethical?
Steve
In memory of the USAF Security Forces lost: A1C Elizabeth N. Jacobson, 9/28/05; SSgt Brian McElroy, 1/22/06; TSgt Jason Norton, 1/22/06; A1C Lee Chavis, 10/14/06; SSgt John Self, 5/14/07; A1C Jason Nathan, 6/23/07; SSgt Travis Griffin, 4/3/08; 1Lt Joseph Helton, 9/8/09; SrA Nicholas J. Alden, 3/3/2011. God Bless them and all those who have lost loved ones in this war. I will never forget their loss.
Considering how much money you've just made, you can't wait to show off your amazing commitment to ethical standards. You return to the dealer, whom you shop several times a year, and explain your discovery that you were charged for only three of the four ultra-widgets -- which the dealer had priced at $50 each at the time of sale. You hold out a Grant in your hand when the dealer says, "you owe me what the ultra-widget is worth right now."
Doggedly collecting coins of the Central American Republic.
Visit the Society of US Pattern Collectors at USPatterns.com.
Older person buys stuff and includes some nice silver (SLQ, Walkers, Frankies) whatever.
Wifey shows store owner who is very happy to have the silver and says to keep a look-out for future silver.
Collector hubby says "What!" and wants wife to buy out silver at face for him, not nec for the silver but for the "coins".
More silver comes in.
OK if wife obliges hubby?
"If I say something in the woods and my wife isn't there to hear it.....am I still wrong?"
My Washington Quarter Registry set...in progress
1929 $5, 1893-s $, stella, etc.
I actually maintain that it is illegal to purchase a known commodity at too large of a discount.
What are your thoughts?
I firmly believe in numismatics as the world's greatest hobby, but recognize that this is a luxury and without collectors, we can all spend/melt our collections/inventories.
eBaystore
What are your thoughts?
I don't know about the illegality, but I agree with you in principal.
I knew it would happen.
New collectors, please educate yourself before spending money on coins; there are people who believe that using numismatic knowledge to rip the naïve is what this hobby is all about.
<< <i>I actually maintain that it is illegal to purchase a known commodity at too large of a discount.
What are your thoughts? >>
Would be interesting to know the legal interpretation per case law on that to grope out the boundaries of the illegality.
Certainly, if someone came in with a pile of slabs and the buying dealer wrote up one no-mintmark silver dollar that had S$1 for the denomination as the much cheaper San Francisco one. (Many of us have made the mistake in a quick initial observation.) If he then immediately priced it according to the Philly date, it would be obvious he effectively stole the coin.
It should be (whether it is will be for the lawyers to say) illegal to make such misrepresentations of what you are buying if the difference is commonly known by peers in the industry. OTOH, a cherrypicker shouldn't be held to this. They are deserving of the valuation differential through specialized knowledge. It is not unethical to buy a rare clashed die variety for the common price as it is reasonable to assume the seller bougt it also for common and the representation as the common variety is par for the typical professional coin dealer. Sharing with the seller is completely up to the buyer, as it would also be for the sellers up the chain before the transaction. It certainly should not be illegal.
NSDR - Life Member
SSDC - Life Member
ANA - Pay As I Go Member
First, realsteaves scenario is VERY good and VERY creative. Here's two that were actually featured in the Numismatist that specifically stand out in my mind:
Case One: A collector walks into a major show and has a coin to sell. He goes to a major pattern expert/dealer and shows him a 1796 Bust Dollar on a pewter planchet, not listed in the Judd Book. They agree upon a price of $10,000. The next couple of months roll around, and at another major show the same collector goes up to the same expert/dealer with two more of the 1796 Bust Dollars. The dealer becomes somewhat angry to know that his piece he bought for $10,000 is not unique, but he buys the other two for $8,000 combined. The next major show, the collector has A DOZEN of these, and the dealer becomes enraged and wants to know where the collector got them. The collector honestly says what happened: At a garage sale in Philly, the collector bought a pair of 1796 Bust Dollar Dies (originals). HE THEN MADE HIS OWN PEWTER PLANCHETS AND STUCK THEM WITH THE DIES!! The collector maintains that these are technically official restikes as they are from original dies, and the expert/dealer bought them on his own free will. The collector also says that since the dealer is such an expert, he should know "fakes" and didn't, and now reeps the consequences. The dealer maintains that these are not original restikes, but are in fact contemporary counterfeits, and wants his money back ($18,000). Who is right, both ethically and legally???
Case Two: Dealer 1 is at a local monthly show setting up, and sees an AU 1893-S morgan with a light cleaning for sale from dealer 2. The two dealers haggle on the price, and reach a midpoint at $10,000. Dealer 1 then takes his new purchase home, puts it in a potato, and bakes. The coin turns beautiful blue shades, and hides the cleaning quite well. He then puts the coin in an old Max Mehl 2 X 2, scribbles on "1893 S- Rare- VF", and when he sets up again, he puts the coin on his velvet tray. A collector comes up, sees the beautiful rare coin, along with the great pedigree, and inquires on a price. They eventually meet at $20,000. Six months later, after trying to submit the coin, the collector takes the coin back to dealer 1 and demands a refund. The Dealer says that ANA bylaws state the collector only had 10 days to return the coin (unless it is counterfeit), and offers to buy it back for the sum of $5,000. The collector believes that the doctoring constitutes counterfeiting, and seeks a refund through the ANA mediation committee. Who is responsible, both legally and ethically?
I would like to hear some thoughts/responses.
<< <i>Collector wants to buy a coin from his dealer, they agree on a price, and he pays with cash and some slabbed coins in trade. The collector asks for and is given a 10-day return. A couple days later the collector realizes he accidentally included a rare variety as one of the traded coins although it was not marked on the holder. He returns to the dealer to undo the deal within the return period. The dealer has already sold the traded-in coins and wants to refund the agreed-upon sale price in cash. The collector says the right to return the coin meant he could get his coins back (just the way the deal was done originally) and if that can't be done, he deserves the full value for the rare variety as part of the refund. The dealer refuses to discuss whether he can get the collector's coins back, only saying they were sold and he no longer has them. >>
I like this one! Definately has you scratching your head.
<< <i>Collector wants to buy a coin from his dealer, they agree on a price, and he pays with cash and some slabbed coins in trade. The collector asks for and is given a 10-day return. >>
When "the collector asks for and is given a 10-day return", what did each person at that time understand "a 10-day return" to consist of, and did both parties agree to that understanding?
Without that info, I wouldn't know how to accurately assess the situation without guessing and deciding (possibly unfairly) in favor of one party over the other.
<< <i>These ethics questions are interesting, but they always seem to leave me with the need for more info on the deal. Take this, for instance:
<< <i>Collector wants to buy a coin from his dealer, they agree on a price, and he pays with cash and some slabbed coins in trade. The collector asks for and is given a 10-day return. >>
When "the collector asks for and is given a 10-day return", what did each person at that time understand "a 10-day return" to consist of, and did both parties agree to that understanding?
Without that info, I wouldn't know how to accurately assess the situation without guessing and deciding (possibly unfairly) in favor of one party over the other. >>
I think that's the point. One party (the dealer) assumed the return privilege was for a cash refund, and the other party (the seller) assumed the return privilege was for a complete reversal of the initial trade.
I would probably side with the collector in this instance if the dealer was aware of the variety, but didn't offer a fair price. But that would be hard to prove.
<< <i>I think that's the point. One party (the dealer) assumed the return privilege was for a cash refund, and the other party (the seller) assumed the return privilege was for a complete reversal of the initial trade.
I would probably side with the collector in this instance if the dealer was aware of the variety, but didn't offer a fair price. But that would be hard to prove. >>
Noting the bolded part above, if you want to address that issue, it needs to be included in the original scenario, don't you think?
Otherwise, we're just making assumptions.
edited to add... for a real interesting ethics discussion, I think you need to find a situation where both parties are in agreement with the actual facts of the deal as it happened (who said what, who did what, who knew what, etc.) but disagreed with how it was resolved.
<< <i>
<< <i>I think that's the point. One party (the dealer) assumed the return privilege was for a cash refund, and the other party (the seller) assumed the return privilege was for a complete reversal of the initial trade.
I would probably side with the collector in this instance if the dealer was aware of the variety, but didn't offer a fair price. But that would be hard to prove. >>
Noting the bolded part above, if you want to address that issue, it needs to be included in the original scenario, don't you think?
Otherwise, we're just making assumptions. >>
I just think if that information is given, then the answer becomes too obvious. The reader will feel more like a judge without that tidbit, and based on the information given, will need to decide how the return privilege should be interpreted.
<< <i>I just think if that information is given, then the answer becomes too obvious. >>
Sorry- I edited my post while you were writing.
Still, I think that info is necessary in order to determine who is standing on firmer ethical ground. As an example, how would you like to be found guilty of something you didn't do, and be unable to present evidence that would exonerate you?
This is an interesting question, although I don't think it has much to do with ethics.
Doggedly collecting coins of the Central American Republic.
Visit the Society of US Pattern Collectors at USPatterns.com.
<< <i>Charlie refuses, saying that since he paid admission to get into the show, he should be able to look at every coin there. Is he right or wrong?
This is an interesting question, although I don't think it has much to do with ethics. >>
The dealer paid his table fee, yet potential buyers are free to refuse to do business with him. Why should he be required to do business with potential buyers against his will?
edited to add... and to tie in to my previous (edited) post asking for clarification of the scenario, what did the show promoter's rental agreement require of the dealer with regard to who he might be obligated or expected to do business with?
1. You look at a raw coin at a dealer's table, ask the price, and he quotes you a price to which you verbally agree. Because you know the dealer well, and he knows your specific area of interest, he then jokes with you about it possibly being a rare die marriage. You confide in him that it is not rare, but is a slightly better die marriage. He then pulls the coin back and says that he wants to "send it in to be graded". Despite your protests about the transaction being completed, he insists that he wants to have the coin graded. Several months later he offers the now slabbed coin to you again, in the same grade, but this time at five times the original price, and you elect to pass. Was he ethical?
2. You look at a raw coin at a dealer's table and instantly recognize that it is a significant rare die marriage, the finest known for the marriage. The dealer, unaware of the rarity, quotes you a price, to which you agree. You pay him the asking price and walk away, fully aware that you have just made the finest cherrypick of your life. Later, you feel guilty about the transaction and decide to go back to the dealer's table and give him more money. You discuss this with fellow collectors, who admonish you NEVER to do that. They state that as things stand now, the dealer is happy that he sold the coin at his asking price, and you are (obviously) happy with your cherrypick. However, if you go back and offer him more money, he will always wonder what the coin might really be worth, and will likely not offer you such things in the future. Who is right here?
As it happens, that is exactly what I did.
#1. Dealer is way wrong to do this.
#2. You're not obligated to pay more. I agree with your friends.
Both dealers should do their homework if they even care about die marriges. IMHO
"If I say something in the woods and my wife isn't there to hear it.....am I still wrong?"
My Washington Quarter Registry set...in progress
<< <i>I have two possible 'ethics' issues, both of which happened to me: >>
No. 1? IMO, a deal's a deal, verbal or otherwise. No. 2? Unless I already knew beforehand that the dealer would be okay with the cherrypick, I'd keep it to myself.
<< <i>Come on now....all these threads about the counterfeit slabs and people being asked to be the distributors in the US for the Chinese "companies" making these, and you can't come up with something?
There needs to be room for some debate. Where's the "gray area" with counterfeit slabs? >>
The gray area could be a newbie, getting involved with this chinese dude, importing a bunch of "ciounterfeits" that the newbie thinks he's getting the rip of a lifetime on only to later discovered he's been peddling crap!
Does he contact each of his buyer's and inform them? This is all under the presumption that he purchased these thinking they were genuine.
The name is LEE!
<< <i>for #2, it sounds like you have some smart friends/fellow collectors. Listen to them!!! I cherrypick all the time and would NEVER go back and give the dealer more money, regardless of how much i was going to make on the transaction. You could be branded as a cherrypicker, and this results in some very negative consequences, like getting booted from tables, getting raised prices on things from suspicious dealers, bad customer service, etc. I had a +$3000 cherrypick 6 months ago, and i never even began to think about giving that dealer a penny more. >>
If you did go back to the dealer and pay him more would he then go back to the person that he bought the coin from and share with him this additional money? Not likely.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
<< <i>I had an interesting real life scenario this week. A dealer asked me for offers on a number of coins from a deal he had just purchased. I made individual offers and bought them all. When I was checking the invoice, I realized that we had both missed an obvious rare major Red Book variety. (I know he missed it because his invoice listed the common variety.) I immediately told him of the mistake and offered him another $2000, which was more fair to me than to him. He accepted and we were both happy. But what if he had refused and demanded more? >>
Or even wanted the coin back...
Right. I definitely took a risk. I have to admit that I might have handled the situation differently with someone else, depending on how I thought he would respond, the nature of our pre-existing relationship, etc.
Doggedly collecting coins of the Central American Republic.
Visit the Society of US Pattern Collectors at USPatterns.com.
<< <i>Collector wants to buy a coin from his dealer, they agree on a price, and he pays with cash and some slabbed coins in trade. The collector asks for and is given a 10-day return. A couple days later the collector realizes he accidentally included a rare variety as one of the traded coins although it was not marked on the holder. He returns to the dealer to undo the deal within the return period. The dealer has already sold the traded-in coins and wants to refund the agreed-upon sale price in cash. The collector says the right to return the coin meant he could get his coins back (just the way the deal was done originally) and if that can't be done, he deserves the full value for the rare variety as part of the refund. The dealer refuses to discuss whether he can get the collector's coins back, only saying they were sold and he no longer has them. >>
First off if the dealer had agreed to undo the deal for up to 10 days then he really had no right to sell the coins until the 10 days were up. In the absence of a specific agreement to the contrary a return implies that you give me back what I gave to you and I give you back what you gave to me; though it probabaly wouldn't have to be the exact same bills/cash.