Options
finest known 1918 Buff nickel DDR MS 67* NGC image
Well here is another beauty for all to chime in about. This buffalo nickel is listed in Cherrypickers guide VOLUME 1. GO AHEAD GRIV - TELL ME WHAT IS THIS WORTH? For those that don't know this variety it has doubling and sometimes tripling on E PLURIBUS UNUM on the reverse. Seeing as this is the only one known at PCGS AND NGC in mint state what does the consensus beleive the value to be? Just for value the 1918 p in MS67 I beleive brings around 30 k in auction. I also want to let you know that Rick Snow viewed this coin and realized what it was in Baltimore. Great eye EAGLE EYE!
ed rodrigues
0
Comments
Rainbow Stars
<< <i>Not sure I understand the fascination with minor varieties. I can't even see the doubling on that super huge pic. >>
If I were going to market a coin that I believed to be worth in the mid-five figures, I would at least make the effort to get a decent image of it.
He will allow the experts such as Heritage or another auction company market it. JMO
Rainbow Stars
The photos of the 1918 are too dark for me to see anything.
I owned a very nice MS63+ 1914/3 nickel for a week or two until it kicked in that there was almost nothing to the variety imo. The longer I stared at it, the more uncomfortable I became. Funny that the retailer who ended up with it, got another $2000+ for it.
roadrunner
Phoenix
<< <i>Not sure I understand the fascination with minor varieties. I can't even see the doubling on that super huge pic. >>
Although this is a rather minor variety I'm still amazed to see that one exists in this grade.
<< <i>Interesting, but I've never been a fan of reverse doubling. The obv is where it's at imo. A great doubled die like the 55/55 is one thing. But over time, with less coins to be spread out among more people, I think minor varities will only become more popular....until the market tanks. Then it will be time to see what really has legs.
The photos of the 1918 are too dark for me to see anything.
I owned a very nice MS63+ 1914/3 nickel for a week or two until it kicked in that there was almost nothing to the variety imo. The longer I stared at it, the more uncomfortable I became. Funny that the retailer who ended up with it, got another $2000+ for it.
roadrunner >>
Seems to be the consensus in the hobby that DDRs, except for Lincoln Cents and a few others, such as the 1935 1-R-IV Buff, 1946 1-R-I Walker, and the 1961 PR 3-R-V half just don't get the respect they deserve. For instance, there are several nice DDO Washingtons listed in the Red Book while, at the same time several monster DDRs, among them a couple of 1942 varieties, aren't listed. There is also a number of outstanding copper-nickel doubled dies-obverse and reverse-not listed, either, so there seems to be a bias against anything not made of silver, too.
On the 1914/13 Buffs, there are currently seven known dies for this variety (most are minor and not very impressive) as the working hub, which produced several working dies, was responsible for it. Earlier die states of Dies #1 and #2 can show a very obvious underdigit-certainly the equal of other well recognized overdate coins like the 1943/42 5c or the 1942-D/41 dime. The fact that the 1914/13 IS a working hub variety, which is much more common than something from a single working die, which does negatively impact the coin, is a factor, too.
An authorized PCGS dealer, and a contributor to the Red Book.