Options
The Holy Grail up for Auction at David Lawrence
Barndog
Posts: 20,538 ✭✭✭✭✭
Barndog
Posts: 20,538 ✭✭✭✭✭
Comments
--Severian the Lame
"ONE MILLION DOLLARS!!".
sweet coin.
Sweeet coin though!
I didn't know this historical information.
Sure makes an ultra rare coin even more desirable!!
"“Those who sacrifice liberty for security/safety deserve neither.“(Benjamin Franklin)
"I only golf on days that end in 'Y'" (DE59)
I knew it would happen.
I prefer the pic of Cardinal's specimen over this coin - tho in hand it might be a different matter [as I recall, when the coin was on display at LB it appeared almost black].
Martha Washington's personal silver setting? Is this true? If so, that is a tremendous nugget of history! I know the country was in its infancy, but I'm sure there was an adequate supply of silver around to mint a limited amount of coins.
Collector of Early 20th Century U.S. Coinage.
ANA Member R-3147111
<< <i>
Martha Washington's personal silver setting? Is this true? If so, that is a tremendous nugget of history! I know the country was in its infancy, but I'm sure there was an adequate supply of silver around to mint a limited amount of coins.
>>
There is good evidence that Washington supplied the silver, but the part about Martha's personal silver setting is oral tradition at best and more likely pure mythology.
<< <i>Of all the examples I've seen, both in hand on online, that is my absolute favorite one.
I prefer the pic of Cardinal's specimen over this coin - tho in hand it might be a different matter [as I recall, when the coin was on display at LB it appeared almost black]. >>
Exactly what I like about it. The DLRC coin has a very nice thick layer of crust. Personally I'd take it over the Cardinal coin in a heartbeat.
Crust Is A Must™
Coin's for sale/trade.
Tom Pilitowski
US Rare Coin Investments
800-624-1870
$302,755.79 is my prediction but it will probably go higher.
<< <i>
<< <i>
Martha Washington's personal silver setting? Is this true? If so, that is a tremendous nugget of history! I know the country was in its infancy, but I'm sure there was an adequate supply of silver around to mint a limited amount of coins.
>>
There is good evidence that Washington supplied the silver, but the part about Martha's personal silver setting is oral tradition at best and more likely pure mythology. >>
I recently discovered a mid-1800s article by a coin dealer who tells a story much different than any current research shows regarding these pieces. Would you like to see it? It claims that these were struck in England and that G. Washington was upset about the obverse portrait being a likeness of Martha. As such, they kept most of the mintage as family heirlooms.
<< <i>Would you like to see it? >>
Most definitely, please.
<< <i>
<< <i>Would you like to see it? >>
Most definitely, please. >>
From Mason's Magazine (a coin collectors magazine), November, 1867 edition:
There were silver Dimes and Half Dimes coined in England from Washington's silver plate, which was sent to that country to be converted into coin. Upon the reception of the coins, Washington was grieved and offended to find his wife's likeness upon the obverse of the coins. It was owing to this fact that the small Washington silver pieces of 1792 had no general circulation, being considered "family coins" and but very few of these silver Dimes or Half Dimes can be found at the present day.
The article was titled "History of Coins in America" and was referring to Washington pieces. I was excited when I first read this article and thought that I had made a landmark discovery, since until now it was believed that these pieces were struck in Philadelphia. The other aspects of the article were in agreement with current research on the various subjects, which added some credibility in my eyes to the above excerpt. The fact that the author was one of the nation's leading coin dealers and was located in Philadelphia added more credibility. Also consider the fact that it was highly likely that Mason had been in contact with individuals who were eye witnesses to the introduction of the Half Dismes and Dismes, given the timeframe of the article. I still couldn't quite believe it and felt that it must have been an embellished article, so I consulted with a highly respected numismatic researcher, R.W. Julian, and he agreed that the facts were "invented by someone who did not know the true facts" and went on to provide other contemporary documentation to rebuke the article.
Neat coin, great history.
Beauty is purely in the eyes of the beholder.
<< <i>"... that is truly ugly classic crap"
Beauty is purely in the eyes of the beholder. >>
I'd say so!
<< <i>It may be worth a lot of money, but looking at the designs on both sides, that is truly ugly classic crap. >>
Babies are also ugly when they're first born. The beauty is in what the coin represents.
Russ, NCNE
My 1866 Philly Mint Set
Didn't wanna get me no trade
Never want to be like papa
Working for the boss every night and day
--"Happy", by the Rolling Stones (1972)
<< <i>Is it just me or does this coin have an X in the reverse field? LOVE 1792 HD's. K >>
I don't know if you have an "X" (I certainly did not notice one in Milwaukee
I'd give Russ' left nut for that coin without thinking twice.
I'd give both of Russ' and one of yours and not think once.
<< <i>Of all the examples I've seen, both in hand on online, that is my absolute favorite one.
I prefer the pic of Cardinal's specimen over this coin - tho in hand it might be a different matter [as I recall, when the coin was on display at LB it appeared almost black]. >>
No problem, the dealer buyer will just dip it and send it to NGC for MS61 !
I find this coin very interesting and worth the attention it is receiving.
Garrow
You absolutely must see the Rittenhouse-Knoxville-Cardinal coin IN HAND. When you see it in hand and swirl in the light (to free it from the shadows of its holder), it BLAZES with original silvery mint luster and monster rainbow toning. When Jim Halperin viewed the coin at the ANA in Milwaukee, he grinned from ear to ear and said "Wow...the reverse is a '9'!" I also met the builder of the Knoxville collection at the ANA who said he had compared the coin side by side with all of the top examples, including the Starr PCGS-SP67 coin, and said it was his pick as "by far" the finest. So, if the coin appeared almost black, that was just due to shadows. (Even the sun looks black when it is fully shadowed during an eclipse!)
But, in all fairness, the PCGS-AU55 coin should not cost quite as much.
<< <i>DLRC listed it post-auction at $212,000 and "make offer" -- suddenly today it has disappeard >>
Congratulations, Barndog!!
<< <i>DLRC listed it post-auction at $212,000 and "make offer" -- suddenly today it has disappeard >>
Bad, wicked, naughty Zoot! She has been setting fire to our beacon, which I have just remembered - is grail-shaped ... It is not the first time we've had this problem....Wicked wicked Zoot ... she is a bad person and she must pay the penalty. And here in DLRC, we have but one punishment ... you must tie her down on a bed ... and spank her. Come!......
NSDR - Life Member
SSDC - Life Member
ANA - Pay As I Go Member
Senior Numismatist
Legend Rare Coin Auctions
Awesome!!
Collector since 1976. On the CU forums here since 2001.