Look at how free from marks it is, though. It has full luster and nice original looking skin. If that coin were struck well, it would grade 65. I wouldn't be in a hurry to buy a coin like this, because it is exactly the kind of coin you get beat up when you go to sell -- but I don't think the grade is unreasonable. If you want to compare apples to apples, you need other examples of the same date & mint. Was the 20-S typically struck soft? I don't know Walkers very well, but other series of that era -- buffs especially, but SLQ's, Peace dollars, and mercs too -- all have certain dates where finding a well struck coin is notoriously hard.
There's quite a difference between he two. Checking the Heritage archives, several of the MS63's had similar weakness in strike. But there were a couple others with much more detail especially a MS64. The other thing I noticed, most had lustrous surfaces, far exceeding what's being offered. Another thing, most 63-64 coins in the last year have fallen into the 3 to $4000 range and if a true coin collector is looking for detail, I don't see this coin selling for that?
Leo
The more qualities observed in a coin, the more desirable that coin becomes!
You don't think he would bless one of his own coins he is trying to sell do you???
On BS&T Now: Nothing. Fighting the Fight for 11 Years with the big "C" - Never Ever Give Up! Member PCGS Open Forum board 2002 - 2006 (closed end of 2006) Current board since 2006 Successful trades with many members, over the past two decades, never a bad deal.
Pros: -Looks to have very frosty lustre -Original skin -Overall very nice eye appeal -I think some of the details are obscured by the reflection of light off the coin in the image
While I don't know anything specific about the 1920-S, it's no secret that the San Francisco Mint produced very poorly struck coins during this time period (take, for instance, the 1926-S buffalo, and see how weak mid-grade MS examples are). Based on what I see, at the very least, the grade is consistent with how NGC and PCGS grade these issues. Yes, a 1945-P will have more detail, but this coin certainly doesn't look to be that bad.
Strength of strike is just one factor in determining the grade- particularly in context of the mint and time period as others have mentioned. Plus, it's got a freakin' sticker, so what else do you want?
My style is impetuous, my defense is impregnable !
The CAC sticker on the '21-P is too low and dips to the left, partially obstructing last two digits of SN. How much for re-sticker? Break out the Goo Gone.
Both coins look correctly graded to me. The first one has a very weak strike but no marks; thus, it is limited to 64. The second coin has a great strike; however, there are a bunch of ticks on both the obverse and reverse.
"It's far easier to fight for principles, than to live up to them." Adlai Stevenson
<< <i>You don't think he would bless one of his own coins he is trying to sell do you??? >>
Do you mean the CAC coin evaluators also sell CAC coins? Sounds like a major conflict of interests.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
<< <i>You don't think he would bless one of his own coins he is trying to sell do you??? >>
Do you mean the CAC coin evaluators also sell CAC coins? Sounds like a major conflict of interests. >>
Albanese Rare Coins (ARC) is owned by two individuals who, fortunately or unfortunately, share the last name of John Albanese. ARC has nothing to do whatsoever with John Albanese, the founder and head of the CAC.
<< <i>The CAC sticker on the '21-P is too low and dips to the left, partially obstructing last two digits of SN. How much for re-sticker? Break out the Goo Gone. >>
If PCGS wanted to thwart the CAC, they could redesign their label such that there was not enough space to place the coveted sticker.
I am glad that we are so expert to evaluate a coin based on a photograph/scan of middling quality better than a more experienced person was able to evaluate it in-hand.
The coin appears to be solid for the grade, which (from what I understand) would qualify for a CAC sticker. As some others mentioned, the coin has a soft strike (typical of 1920s Walkers), but also has nice surfaces and probably has nice luster. Most collectors who know how to grade early Walkers would not disagree with a 64 for this coin.
You can't compare a 1920 San Francisco with a 1921 PHILADELPHIA.
Compare a 1921-S Morgan dollar with a 1921-P Morgan dollar and you will see the soft strike problems common to the larger silver coins of this era at the SF Mint.
Frank Provasek - PCGS Authorized Dealer, Life Member ANA, Member TNA. www.frankcoins.com
<< <i>You don't think he would bless one of his own coins he is trying to sell do you??? >>
Do you mean the CAC coin evaluators also sell CAC coins? Sounds like a major conflict of interests. >>
Albanese Rare Coins (ARC) is owned by two individuals who, fortunately or unfortunately, share the last name of John Albanese. ARC has nothing to do whatsoever with John Albanese, the founder and head of the CAC. >>
Does John Albanese sell CAC sticked coins?
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
Walkers are certainly not my series, but I know that the first number of years are known for poor strikes and are thus graded differently. If one from the '40's looked like that it would never go 64.
<< <i>Walkers are certainly not my series, but I know that the first number of years are known for poor strikes and are thus graded differently. If one from the '40's looked like that it would never go 64. >>
Would you compare a 1926-S Buffalo nickel with a 1926-P? Ignoring the strike for the moment, everything else about the coin seems MS64. If the strike is not weak for the date, then that would make it a solid 64. Since 20-S comes with a lousy strike, the subject coin is not struck weakly for the date. If that coin were a 1940-S, it would be considered well-struck, since the hand is completely separated from the gown.
I like to look at Walkers with a critical eye, but I don't think we're being fair here. There are a lot of differences between coins in the series, so making comparisons across years and mints can raise some unreasonable expectations.
Fox's 1993 text on Walkers reads, "skirt lines are weak from 1916 to 1921 and should be ignored when grading the coin." Some of the examples in his text do show modest improvements in those lines for those years (and in the image of his 1920-S example), but he also writes that it is "rare as a fully struck gem."
Based on my experience with the later issues, I think the head and hand actually aren't that bad for a difficult issue. I wouldn't call them flat; you can see some separation of the thumb. The marks on the breast bother me, but I don't see that this coin is inaccurately graded from this image.
Interesting info about the Albaneses in the industry -- I didn't know that they weren't related.
Yes, these coins grading is problematic, and have been subject to market grading with comparisons to other coins of this date. If you were to hand this coin over to strict technical graders like the British (for the most part) they would call it EF because of strike issues.
When I look at this coin I see the obvious poor strike even if typical for date that severely impacts eye appeal. Also there ARE numerous conact/friction points likely from bag contact with other coins (see the front skirt fold and even the eagle's breast). These are not big "hits" but are definately present.
So the issue is whether we use the relatively poor standards of other coins of this date or tie this specific coin and date/mintmark to its mates or should there be some attempt to technically grade this coin and use a general series standard, or at least a date standard.
I can not but help of what QDB might say of this coin and picking a nice one for date and grade...
Love that Milled British (1830-1960) Well, just Love coins, period.
Not according to "Official Grading Standards for United States Coins." It's not in the listing for "seen with weak strike sometimes,"if you will. I would definitely pass on this coin as a MS64. The strike is a big deal in grades MS 64,and above, for these.
<< <i>What is the point in these never ending witchhunts? >>
I don't think the OP was on a "witchhunt", but rather was making an observation not knowing the nuances of grading Walkers. Hopefully the responses provided helpful information to the OP and to others.
So the sticker is not working we are split on this one, we send it to a grading service and then to a sticker service to get it graded and don't think it's right how many do we need to get it right.
For ease of grading a series, I think they should all be graded to a standard. If San Fransisco had a problem with their minting and struck weakly, than the grading should reflect this. The price of a weakly struck, rare coin should reflect the demand for the coin. In a series, an MS-63 could be the high for the year and mint. I do think that we can compare a 1921 and a 1921-S Walker. They are both Walkers. JMHO
<< <i>For ease of grading a series, I think they should all be graded to a standard. If San Fransisco had a problem with their minting and struck weakly, than the grading should reflect this. The price of a weakly struck, rare coin should reflect the demand for the coin. In a series, an MS-63 could be the high for the year and mint. I do think that we can compare a 1921 and a 1921-S Walker. They are both Walkers. JMHO >>
Yes look at some of the Buffalo nickels and Jefferson some will never have full strike / steps and are Graded and priceed as so.
The coin is probably accurately graded to PCGS and CAC standards, which doesn't make a happy damned, unless you're relying on them to price the coins you collect. The TPG holder was enough to certify the coin was genuine. I see little benefit in having the CAC sticker the coin. It doesn't take the stink off the strike. JMO
Developing theory is what we are meant to do as academic researchers and it sets us apart from practitioners and consultants. Gregor
As the world turns, like grains of sand through the hourglass - these are the days of our lives....................
Recognizing that many Walker dates from the early twenties have mushy strikes - since that is the case, why, oh why can't that simple fact be reflected in the grade? Why do there have to be exceptions to strict grading criteria when a coin isn't up to snuff? Have you ever thought about that? I have. The answer isn't pretty, and not many dealers want to hear it.
It's a typical mealy-mouthed approach to making money on someone else's back - just lobby for a change to the grading scales if there aren't enough nice specimens to go around - at least then you can raise the price and have more of them to promote. It's just that simple. It's also really convenient if you happen to have a stack of them in inventory.
It gets even more fun than this, however. Now, let's talk about "nice for the grade." If you take a mushy strike coin and sticker it because it has the required number of dings for MS-64, then you can jack up the price once again. Now, it's a mushy strike coin with dings and a "nice skin" that is labelled MS-64, but it can be sold for much more.
The sad truth that nobody wants to hear is that a nice set of Walkers has been priced out of reach for most collectors due to inflated grading/pricing for over 20 years, and most dealers are still trying to dump their sliders on the market for MS-65 and MS-66 prices. Demand might have something to do with the price increases, but hype is certainly a big factor as well. It's still a game of promoting the same inventory, over and over - and in finding new, exciting ways to do just that. Maybe a "grade within a grade" will work, and throw in some nice descriptives - the same old saw, over and over and over.
The Sheldon scale was a fine idea, but the nuances will *always* be there whether or not you use a 70-pt scale or a 1000-pt scale. The upper tier of TPGs have proven their value over time, as a professional third party grading opinion. I never agreed with the idea that a group of dealers should ever be given the keys to the castle and be allowed to dictate grading to the collecting community, but at least in the context of a grading consultant, it's justifiable if the collector is willing to pay for an opinion.
The TPGs have earned their stripes through consistancy over time, but they are still not infallible. As the market has changed, they've focused on Moderns out of necessity to keep the cash flow moving. Nothing wrong with that. But, for the grading "authorities" to become susceptible to suggestions of changing the grading scheme every 20 years or so, is unconscionable. And that's what stickers do. That's what "nice for the grade" is. That's what not marking off for a mushy strike is. Call it what it is!
And please do not let a critical fact escape you - that the collectors are not making these rules. Collectors are paying the cost of the changes in grading methodologies, but dealers are the ones who benefit first. In every case. Don't forget it.
Sorry, but that's how I see it, stickers and all.
Q: Are You Printing Money? Bernanke: Not Literally
"If this thread was about learning, then the title would have been more appropriate."
From what I can tell the discussion here is about nuances in grading and not about anybody being a witch.Do you have an opinion about the grade of this coin Oconner? In my opinion, its a 63.
Regarding the retail price of 1920-S Walkers, PCGS has this coin priced at $1050 in 60, $2800 in 63, $5000 in 64,$15000 in 65, and $32,500 in 66.Using MS 63 baseline, a 64 would trade at 78% more than a 63,a 65 would trade at 535% more than a 63.
The coin that is the subject of this thread is not a dog and I don't think anyone here has said that they think such.This coin,however, has no chance of ever being called 65,in my opinion.It has been "topped out" gradewise.The challenge for any dealer is to "top out" the money and, really, that's okay. I don't think anyone here would consider a dealer a witch for trying to get his/her coins graded as high as possible and then getting as much as the market can bear.
<< <i>It's got a sticker so just shut up and buy it. Be happy that you were lucky enough to own a blessed sticker coin and keep your mouth shut next time. >>
And Hold on!!!!
Please... Save The Stories, Just Answer My Questions, And Tell Me How Much!!!!!
When I read the title of your post, I knew it had to be either a 1920-S or the 1940-S. Those two have the worst strikes in the Walker series. I have seen some that are uncirculated that have zero details in the centers. Still, this 1920-S half is just too weak for me to grade it a 64. Maybe it looks better in hand.
<< <i>I don't think the OP was on a "witchhunt", but rather was making an observation not knowing the nuances of grading Walkers.
If this isn't yet another witchhunt, why the negative thread title? I see no point in searching through dealer websites for coins to trash in an open forum. If this thread was about learning, then the title would have been more appropriate.
If a dealer uses this forum to promote their wares, then they're fair game. But that isn't the case here. >>
The negative thread title reflects that the OP is ill-informed about grading Walkers and that he was bashing PCGS/CAC and not necessarily the dealer.
Comments
I have a 1917 au58 that looks better than that first ms64.
"“Those who sacrifice liberty for security/safety deserve neither.“(Benjamin Franklin)
"I only golf on days that end in 'Y'" (DE59)
Leo
The more qualities observed in a coin, the more desirable that coin becomes!
My Jefferson Nickel Collection
Fighting the Fight for 11 Years with the big "C" - Never Ever Give Up!
Member PCGS Open Forum board 2002 - 2006 (closed end of 2006) Current board since 2006 Successful trades with many members, over the past two decades, never a bad deal.
Cons:
-weak strike
Pros:
-Looks to have very frosty lustre
-Original skin
-Overall very nice eye appeal
-I think some of the details are obscured by the reflection of light off the coin in the image
While I don't know anything specific about the 1920-S, it's no secret that the San Francisco Mint produced very poorly struck coins during this time period (take, for instance, the 1926-S buffalo, and see how weak mid-grade MS examples are). Based on what I see, at the very least, the grade is consistent with how NGC and PCGS grade these issues. Yes, a 1945-P will have more detail, but this coin certainly doesn't look to be that bad.
Hoard the keys.
<< <i>You don't think he would bless one of his own coins he is trying to sell do you???
Do you mean the CAC coin evaluators also sell CAC coins? Sounds like a major conflict of interests.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
<< <i>
<< <i>You don't think he would bless one of his own coins he is trying to sell do you???
Do you mean the CAC coin evaluators also sell CAC coins? Sounds like a major conflict of interests. >>
Albanese Rare Coins (ARC) is owned by two individuals who, fortunately or unfortunately, share the last name of John Albanese. ARC has nothing to do whatsoever with John Albanese, the founder and head of the CAC.
<< <i>The CAC sticker on the '21-P is too low and dips to the left, partially obstructing last two digits of SN. How much for re-sticker? Break out the Goo Gone. >>
If PCGS wanted to thwart the CAC, they could redesign their label such that there was not enough space to place the coveted sticker.
I am glad that we are so expert to evaluate a coin based on a photograph/scan of middling quality better than a more experienced person was able to evaluate it in-hand.
OK...so let's assume it is a weak strike.
Then why is it CAC stickered?
Your first impression when viewing a coin is often 'strike' (ie. has the coin got an overly strong or weak strike).
I would think that a coin (such as this) that has a bad first impression (weak strike) would definitely not get CAC approval.
(Just my opinion and I'm not trying to sound like an 'expert', because I'm not).
"“Those who sacrifice liberty for security/safety deserve neither.“(Benjamin Franklin)
"I only golf on days that end in 'Y'" (DE59)
<< <i>You don't think he would bless one of his own coins he is trying to sell do you???
Different Albaneses, believe it or not. And they are not related.
CAC = John Albanese
Coinace = Dean Albanese
<< <i>
Now this looks more like a 64
>>
You can't compare a 1920 San Francisco with a 1921 PHILADELPHIA.
Compare a 1921-S Morgan dollar with a 1921-P Morgan dollar and you will see the soft strike
problems common to the larger silver coins of this era at the SF Mint.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>You don't think he would bless one of his own coins he is trying to sell do you???
Do you mean the CAC coin evaluators also sell CAC coins? Sounds like a major conflict of interests. >>
Albanese Rare Coins (ARC) is owned by two individuals who, fortunately or unfortunately, share the last name of John Albanese. ARC has nothing to do whatsoever with John Albanese, the founder and head of the CAC. >>
Does John Albanese sell CAC sticked coins?
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
and it sets us apart from practitioners and consultants. Gregor
<< <i>Walkers are certainly not my series, but I know that the first number of years are known for poor strikes and are thus graded differently. If one from the '40's looked like that it would never go 64. >>
A 41-S might.
Keeper of the VAM Catalog • Professional Coin Imaging • Prime Number Set • World Coins in Early America • British Trade Dollars • Variety Attribution
Doggedly collecting coins of the Central American Republic.
Visit the Society of US Pattern Collectors at USPatterns.com.
Fox's 1993 text on Walkers reads, "skirt lines are weak from 1916 to 1921 and should be ignored when grading the coin." Some of the examples in his text do show modest improvements in those lines for those years (and in the image of his 1920-S example), but he also writes that it is "rare as a fully struck gem."
Based on my experience with the later issues, I think the head and hand actually aren't that bad for a difficult issue. I wouldn't call them flat; you can see some separation of the thumb. The marks on the breast bother me, but I don't see that this coin is inaccurately graded from this image.
Interesting info about the Albaneses in the industry -- I didn't know that they weren't related.
<< <i>It would be helpful if somebody posted a picture of a full strike 1920-S half dollar. >>
Here we have hall-of-famer G B W's MS66:
And current #1 Cajun Collection's example, also an MS66 (so these images cover 50% of this issue in this grade):
Looks like you can expect to get a bit more on a coin that is, well, two grades higher.
When I look at this coin I see the obvious poor strike even if typical for date that severely impacts eye appeal. Also there ARE numerous conact/friction points likely from bag contact with other coins (see the front skirt fold and even the eagle's breast). These are not big "hits" but are definately present.
So the issue is whether we use the relatively poor standards of other coins of this date or tie this specific coin and date/mintmark to its mates or should there be some attempt to technically grade this coin and use a general series standard, or at least a date standard.
I can not but help of what QDB might say of this coin and picking a nice one for date and grade...
Well, just Love coins, period.
J
siliconvalleycoins.com
Not according to "Official Grading Standards for United States Coins." It's not in the listing for "seen with weak strike sometimes,"if you will. I would definitely pass on this coin as a MS64. The strike is a big deal in grades MS 64,and above, for these.
”Isn't learning fun?"
The Learning Channel
<< <i>What is the point in these never ending witchhunts? >>
I don't think the OP was on a "witchhunt", but rather was making an observation not knowing the nuances of grading Walkers. Hopefully the responses provided helpful information to the OP and to others.
Hoard the keys.
<< <i>For ease of grading a series, I think they should all be graded to a standard. If San Fransisco had a problem with their minting and struck weakly, than the grading should reflect this. The price of a weakly struck, rare coin should reflect the demand for the coin. In a series, an MS-63 could be the high for the year and mint. I do think that we can compare a 1921 and a 1921-S Walker. They are both Walkers. JMHO >>
Yes
Hoard the keys.
and it sets us apart from practitioners and consultants. Gregor
Recognizing that many Walker dates from the early twenties have mushy strikes - since that is the case, why, oh why can't that simple fact be reflected in the grade? Why do there have to be exceptions to strict grading criteria when a coin isn't up to snuff? Have you ever thought about that? I have. The answer isn't pretty, and not many dealers want to hear it.
It's a typical mealy-mouthed approach to making money on someone else's back - just lobby for a change to the grading scales if there aren't enough nice specimens to go around - at least then you can raise the price and have more of them to promote. It's just that simple. It's also really convenient if you happen to have a stack of them in inventory.
It gets even more fun than this, however. Now, let's talk about "nice for the grade." If you take a mushy strike coin and sticker it because it has the required number of dings for MS-64, then you can jack up the price once again. Now, it's a mushy strike coin with dings and a "nice skin" that is labelled MS-64, but it can be sold for much more.
The sad truth that nobody wants to hear is that a nice set of Walkers has been priced out of reach for most collectors due to inflated grading/pricing for over 20 years, and most dealers are still trying to dump their sliders on the market for MS-65 and MS-66 prices. Demand might have something to do with the price increases, but hype is certainly a big factor as well. It's still a game of promoting the same inventory, over and over - and in finding new, exciting ways to do just that. Maybe a "grade within a grade" will work, and throw in some nice descriptives - the same old saw, over and over and over.
The Sheldon scale was a fine idea, but the nuances will *always* be there whether or not you use a 70-pt scale or a 1000-pt scale. The upper tier of TPGs have proven their value over time, as a professional third party grading opinion. I never agreed with the idea that a group of dealers should ever be given the keys to the castle and be allowed to dictate grading to the collecting community, but at least in the context of a grading consultant, it's justifiable if the collector is willing to pay for an opinion.
The TPGs have earned their stripes through consistancy over time, but they are still not infallible. As the market has changed, they've focused on Moderns out of necessity to keep the cash flow moving. Nothing wrong with that. But, for the grading "authorities" to become susceptible to suggestions of changing the grading scheme every 20 years or so, is unconscionable. And that's what stickers do. That's what "nice for the grade" is. That's what not marking off for a mushy strike is. Call it what it is!
And please do not let a critical fact escape you - that the collectors are not making these rules. Collectors are paying the cost of the changes in grading methodologies, but dealers are the ones who benefit first. In every case. Don't forget it.
Sorry, but that's how I see it, stickers and all.
I knew it would happen.
From what I can tell the discussion here is about nuances in grading and not about anybody being a witch.Do you have an opinion about the grade of this coin Oconner? In my opinion, its a 63.
Regarding the retail price of 1920-S Walkers, PCGS has this coin priced at $1050 in 60, $2800 in 63, $5000 in 64,$15000 in 65, and $32,500 in 66.Using MS 63 baseline, a 64 would trade at 78% more than a 63,a 65 would trade at 535% more than a 63.
The coin that is the subject of this thread is not a dog and I don't think anyone here has said that they think such.This coin,however, has no chance of ever being called 65,in my opinion.It has been "topped out" gradewise.The challenge for any dealer is to "top out" the money and, really, that's okay. I don't think anyone here would consider a dealer a witch for trying to get his/her coins graded as high as possible and then getting as much as the market can bear.
”Isn't learning fun?"
The Learning Channel
<< <i>It's got a sticker so just shut up and buy it. Be happy that you were lucky enough to own a blessed sticker coin and keep your mouth shut next time. >>
And Hold on!!!!
I question whether a coin graded 64, with a mushy strike, deserves a sticker. No matter what the date or mint.
Maybe I'd feel differently if I saw the coin in person??
”Isn't learning fun?"
The Learning Channel
FrederickCoinClub
THE CAC SUCKS!!!!!!
TC71
<< <i>I don't think the OP was on a "witchhunt", but rather was making an observation not knowing the nuances of grading Walkers.
If this isn't yet another witchhunt, why the negative thread title? I see no point in searching through dealer websites for coins to trash in an open forum. If this thread was about learning, then the title would have been more appropriate.
If a dealer uses this forum to promote their wares, then they're fair game. But that isn't the case here. >>
The negative thread title reflects that the OP is ill-informed about grading Walkers and that he was bashing PCGS/CAC and not necessarily the dealer.