Seems like a conflict of interest to have a group of insiders with pre-existing business relationships within the industry getting to choose which TPGs get to play and which ones don't. Regulating TPGs should be up to the FTC or some other agency since they have no ties to the hobby and they'd actually have the power to enforce their rules. Ebay should stay out of it too. They've been saying all along that they're only a venue. They don't get to control the hobby and choose which TPGs are going to go out of business.
<< <i>Seems like a conflict of interest to have a group of insiders with pre-existing business relationships within the industry getting to choose which TPGs get to play and which ones don't. Regulating TPGs should be up to the FTC or some other agency since they have no ties to the hobby and they'd actually have the power to enforce their rules. Ebay should stay out of it too. They've been saying all along that they're only a venue. They don't get to control the hobby and choose which TPGs are going to go out of business. >>
While I agree in principal with you, these bogus homemade slabs have really made it difficult to sell a decent PCGS or NGC coin on Ebay at a fair price. Personally, I would expand the list to the 8 or so established graders, and like another poster said, make the new guys prove some level of competence and integrity.
And I totally agree with the idea, but what is a graded coin other than someone's opinion?
Most I think would agree that PCGS sets the standard, with NGC, ANACS, ICG, and others following. How do you draw the line where the lower echelon of slabs are 'approved' or not?
Another lawsuit waiting from those not making 'the list'?
And I totally agree with the idea, but what is a graded coin other than someone's opinion?
Most I think would agree that PCGS sets the standard, with NGC, ANACS, ICG, and others following. How do you draw the line where the lower echelon of slabs are 'approved' or not?
Another lawsuit waiting from those not making 'the list'? >>
As they say, the devil is in the details. It is frustrating to see MS62 Morgans in MS67 DMPL holders. Not a level playing field by any stretch.
<< <i> eBay already has an approved list for payment methods, why not TPGs? >>
Because eBay doesn't own any TPGs to promote or compete against any of them to shut them out?
Sorry, was that too cynical? >>
Although they might allow it even if the did own a grading company, so long as that other company did not charge any less, or offer any real competition to their product.
"It's not that the Irish are cynical. It's simply that they have a wonderful lack of respect for everything and everybody." - Brendan Behan
Proud Participant in Operation "Stone Holey" August 7, 2008
Comments
<< <i>Seems like a conflict of interest to have a group of insiders with pre-existing business relationships within the industry getting to choose which TPGs get to play and which ones don't. Regulating TPGs should be up to the FTC or some other agency since they have no ties to the hobby and they'd actually have the power to enforce their rules. Ebay should stay out of it too. They've been saying all along that they're only a venue. They don't get to control the hobby and choose which TPGs are going to go out of business. >>
While I agree in principal with you, these bogus homemade slabs have really made it difficult to sell a decent PCGS or NGC coin on Ebay at a fair price. Personally, I would expand the list to the 8 or so established graders, and like another poster said, make the new guys prove some level of competence and integrity.
<< <i>
<< <i>Is Ebay willing to lose all the third world grading service's listing fees? I hope so, but bet not. >>
Good point. Seller's like Centsles, (NNC), and Abon, (SGS), are generating a lot of revenue.
Russ, NCNE >>
After reading this it made me think of the "Close AM" listing I saw of Abon, this morning. Check it out on ebay.
And I totally agree with the idea, but what is a graded coin other than someone's opinion?
Most I think would agree that PCGS sets the standard, with NGC, ANACS, ICG, and others following.
How do you draw the line where the lower echelon of slabs are 'approved' or not?
Another lawsuit waiting from those not making 'the list'?
<< <i>Going out on a limb here.
And I totally agree with the idea, but what is a graded coin other than someone's opinion?
Most I think would agree that PCGS sets the standard, with NGC, ANACS, ICG, and others following.
How do you draw the line where the lower echelon of slabs are 'approved' or not?
Another lawsuit waiting from those not making 'the list'? >>
As they say, the devil is in the details. It is frustrating to see MS62 Morgans in MS67 DMPL holders. Not a level playing field by any stretch.
<< <i>
<< <i> eBay already has an approved list for payment methods, why not TPGs? >>
Because eBay doesn't own any TPGs to promote or compete against any of them to shut them out?
Sorry, was that too cynical?
Although they might allow it even if the did own a grading company, so long as that other company did not charge any less, or offer any real competition to their product.
Proud Participant in Operation "Stone Holey" August 7, 2008