Options
Darkside question - what's it worth? 1892 Peru 1/2 Dinero
roadrunner
Posts: 28,374 ✭✭✭✭✭
Back in 1988 I split a 20 coin group of gem Peruvian 1892 silver 1/2 dinero coins with a friend of mine. We paid the "obscene" price of $12 each for the coins (ok so we sort of ripped them from the B&M dealer). In the mid-1990's I sent one in to Teletrade to be graded and sold ($9 grade fee) just to see what they would do. It was graded NGC MS66 and fetched $100. This was just an average one from the group. As a group these coins all grade 66 to 68 with 67 being the norm. All are semi-PL with lots of clash marks.....same size as half dimes. All of these superb pieces have wild rainbow tones...that's why we bought them. The guy selling them felt they were pretty common. But who would put away rolls of these back in 1892? If only all my MS Barber and seated coins looked like these.
I still have 9 of these left raw. Figured they would only continue to advance in price over the long haul. If these were Barber dimes of the same era they'd be worth $3000+ each. Of course that analogy is somewhat flawed.
Any darkside thoughts on what these would retail for?
roadrunner
I still have 9 of these left raw. Figured they would only continue to advance in price over the long haul. If these were Barber dimes of the same era they'd be worth $3000+ each. Of course that analogy is somewhat flawed.
Any darkside thoughts on what these would retail for?
roadrunner
0
Comments
especially surprising since such coins bring far higher prices than in
the past.
Thanks for the inputs.
roadrunner
of 228,000 and containing .036 Oz silver. This series was minted from 1886 to 1917 with
similar versions in 1863/4. Most of these listed for 5 to $25 back in the mid-'90's. Thiere
was one rarity which listed at a high price indicating that a few people collect them by date.
Some of the later dates are exceedingly common in unc probably meaning they were used
to back the currency and stored out of country. All of these are still seen in poundage so
the coins probably weren't melted by the issuer. Poundage coins tend to be fairly well cir-
culated across the board with a few XF/AU later dates. It's unlikely these circulated concur-
rently with the cu/ ni version which was introduced only a couple years later.
At $12 each you actually paid a very strong price. In those days buying darkside at 20%
of catalog was not uncommon for the more readily available coins and these listed at about
$15. Good 19th century silver in unc had a floor of about 50% of catalog usually.
For those interested the catalog prices have not been adjusted yet on the cu/ni coin which
replaced the silver one. This coin still isn't available so the price will no doubt get adjusted
one of these days. It's not seen in poundage either so it won't be only the uncs that are
scarce but also the circs.
The demand for world coins has traditionally been a tiny fraction of the demand for US coins
but this has been changing in the last ten years. Where 1000 examples of a coin used to be
plenty for the US market and hold the prices of most esoteric coins low, it's a drop in the buc-
ket now days. Even coins like the 1/2 dinero experience solid demand in Peru, the US, and
other countries.
You got lucky getting $100 for it IMHO.
Speaking of Peruvian 1/2 Dinero pieces, here's a batch I picked out of the "foreign melt bag" at the local dealer about a month ago. Obviously not in the same grade as what you are referring to, but for what amounts to roughly 25 cents each, how can you go wrong?
1/2 Cents
U.S. Revenue Stamps
<< <i>Somewhat disappointing but reality is ok. Still, I don't think the average MS65 of this type looks like a toner Morgan. But if that's the case, at $12 each, not much downside.
Thanks for the inputs.
roadrunner >>
If they are as nice as you say I would pay $18 a coin.
I give away money. I collect money.
I don’t love money . I do love the Lord God.