Options
Early MPL cent bidding action from Bowers and
BWRC
Posts: 1,448 ✭✭✭
Merena "Close to perfect collection"
Prices with buyers fee
1909 VDB PCGS PR65RD $46,000
1915 PCGS PR66RB $5,290
1916 PCGS PR66RB $10,637.50
I hope the PCGS price guide for these coins takes a few jumps up!!
Edited to change to PR65RD
Prices with buyers fee
1909 VDB PCGS PR65RD $46,000
1915 PCGS PR66RB $5,290
1916 PCGS PR66RB $10,637.50
I hope the PCGS price guide for these coins takes a few jumps up!!
Edited to change to PR65RD
Brian Wagner Rare Coins, Specializing in PCGS graded, Shield, Liberty and Buffalo Nickels varieties.
0
Comments
For a large selection of U.S. Coins & Currency, visit The Reeded Edge's online webstore at the link below.
The Reeded Edge
I' really bummed. I couldn't get there today. Kind of odd that the sale was today, as most people will be there next week. Anyway, the Lincolns appear to be holding strong. Looks like Dan certainly didn't need me there to run things up!! I will try to be there sometime this week.
Jack
BTW congrats on the 1915
(now kicking myself)
WS
<< <i>Wow, those prices are just unreal! Do you think the market for MPL cents will sustain or was this just a blip caused by all the hype? >>
I dont think these prices are unreal at all. The are more Lincoln cents collectors than any other series and MPLs are just plain scarce to rare. If a set of 2006 silver dollars can sell for $800, how much should an entire series sell for with a mintage that is only 1/14th the size.
It wouldnt surprise me at all if these coins TRIPLE over the next 2 years. Several dates have PCGS pops that are less than 100 pieces in gem or better grades. 100 pieces!!!!
There are probably less than 5000 total MPLs in existance. 5000!!! If these coins were modern bullion pieces how much would they be worth?
Hype my A$$!! If you want a truely classic example of US coinage, in the most widely collected series, with the longest run, in arguably the most important demonination, then you better start buying now.
Knowledge is the enemy of fear
But let's do a little analysis, just for fun...
<< <i>I dont think these prices are unreal at all. The are more Lincoln cents collectors than any other series... >>
Bingo! Lincoln cents are popular...and popularity (demand) dictates prices. But Lincoln cents are popular because they are generally inexpensive and obtainable by anyone, even in high grades. The prices quoted in the OP are not inexpensive!
<< <i>If a set of 2006 silver dollars can sell for $800, how much should an entire series sell for with a mintage that is only 1/14th the size.... >>
Fair enough...but I would never say that $800 for 2006 silver dollars represents actual, realistic value!
<< <i>Several dates have PCGS pops that are less than 100 pieces in gem or better grades. 100 pieces!!!! >>
Maybe so but, according to Coinfacts, each of the dates in the OP have a proof mintage of over 1,000 pieces.
1909 VDB - 1,194
1915 - 1,150
1916 - 1,050
<< <i>There are probably less than 5000 total MPLs in existance. 5000!!! If these coins were modern bullion pieces how much would they be worth? >>
Surely there are more than 5,000...but I get your point. They are relatively rare coins...especially within the Lincoln cent series. As for the comparison to modern bullion pieces, again I don't think the prices we've seen for modern bullion represent real value.
<< <i>Hype my A$$!! If you want a truely classic example of US coinage, in the most widely collected series, with the longest run, in arguably the most important demonination, then you better start buying now. >>
This brings us back to my original post. I had thought (and still do) that it's very possible the prices quoted in the OP were a result of the publicity (hype) generated by the "Close to Perfect Collection". I'm not convinced these prices will be sustainable because most Lincoln cent series collectors probably can't afford them. However, there may be enough registry-focused collectors with money to keep future market levels for MPLs higher than they should be. But this is all just my opinion. Cheers!
Here be the facts. The mintages listed in coinfacts are wrong. Anyone on these boards who knows anythong about MPLs would agree. The actual number for 09 VDB is 420. And our own RWB, has evidence that the 1916 is about 650. A quick glance at the pop reports will bear this out.
I will stand by my estimate that there are less than 5000 pieces extant. Probably less than 4000. You see, collectors for 80 yrs prior to the Lincoln cent were used to mirrors on their proof coins. When they ordered the new matte proofs from the mint they were very dissapointed as there were no mirrors and looked similiar to business strikes. These coins were purchased for about 10c from the mint so many collectors simply put these coins in their pockets and spent them.
As for value...I can make many arguements that AMZN or AAPL are overpriced, yet they still command those prices. If MPLs triple over the next 2 -3 years, then perhaps I may agree that they long longer are value opportunities.
And lastly, $1500 for a GEM 65 RB coin with a pop of less than 30 can hardly be considered expensive. You missed my point. If 200 out of the millions of Lincoln cent collectors wnat to build a GEM set, they can not. It is a very short set and not overwhelming. You dont even need the VDB for a complete date set.
Yes, I do have a vested interest in this series, however those who know me also know that I vest my interests wisely and with conviction.
Knowledge is the enemy of fear
<< <i>Here be the facts. The mintages listed in coinfacts are wrong. Anyone on these boards who knows anythong about MPLs would agree. The actual number for 09 VDB is 420. And our own RWB, has evidence that the 1916 is about 650. A quick glance at the pop reports will bear this out. >>
Thanks for your response and clarification. I quoted the portion above because I think it's the most important point in both our arguments. Based on the corrected mintage figures you provided, and your reasonable explanation as to why many proofs were spent - I'll have to change my opinion a bit about the value of these coins. Rarity + availability + demand = price.
I certainly agree that Lincolns in general, and MPLs specifically, are desireable and collectable. I'm proud to say I've owned my share of key date Lincolns - coins I could only dream about as a kid.
However (and I don't want to seem too contradictory), $46,000 is a LOT of money...even for what is probably the most popular MPL. And $10,637.50 aint chicken feed. The publicity of this particular auction may have had something to do with these bid levels.
If you have the money and the desire to own these coins, more power to you! It's all good.