Interesting note I think these are both about the same varities your coin and mine look to be 110's. But don't bank on that I am just learning how to figure out the Overtone on these.
Lindedad ...something to me that suggests they are not the same variety at all. I have no clue about Overtons, but that die crack on the obverse of yours is a huge difference. Even the last digit, 7 is different from what I see. These wouldnt be the same varieties would they ?
This shows how little I know ... based on the toning patterns, I would have presumed that half to be AT. It looks to me like the higher relief portions of the obverse are dark and the lower relief portions are light (the antithesis of a circ-cam coin), thus indicating some type of accelerated toning. Could some one with more experience than I (which means just about anyone) explain to me why this is not in fact the case and how such toning would come to be by natural methods. I am not bashing the coin as I find it quite attractive ... I am just trying to learn more about the toning process so that I can become better at identifying ATed coins.
<< <i>This shows how little I know ... based on the toning patterns, I would have presumed that half to be AT. It looks to me like the higher relief portions of the obverse are dark and the lower relief portions are light (the antithesis of a circ-cam coin), thus indicating some type of accelerated toning. Could some one with more experience than I (which means just about anyone) explain to me why this is not in fact the case and how such toning would come to be by natural methods. I am not bashing the coin as I find it quite attractive ... I am just trying to learn more about the toning process so that I can become better at identifying ATed coins.
Thanks >>
I am no expert either, but based on the little I have seen, read, and heard, my guess is that the coin is not 100% original. It probably had a gentle cleaning many years ago and has retoned in an album rather nicely. The very light centers of the coin are what indicate this to me. This does not change the fact that I like the look (of the image, at least), and I would be happy to have that kind of coin in my collection. It does not have the look of a coin that has been deliberately colored.
Now, stman, jrocco, coinlt, okbustchaser, and the rest may come along and tell me that I am FOS, and that is okay. My opinion is not based on enough experience for me to be very confident in it.
If the linked coin and Russ imaged coin are the same. Russ's images higthen the colors more than Heritages did. And I agree that allmost all of the coins that are over 100 years old and are now in the EF and lower grades have probalbly been cleaned. That don't mean many of us don't want them in our collections. And yes I am against cleaning of coins but it used to be very common practice that collectors wanted nice shiney coins even if they where twenty or more years old. So every year or two out they poped for a scrub. Many of them are rubbed down to VF or so by now. Maybe those that we put into those plastice holders will escape the cleaning in the next 100 years.
<< <i>Interesting note I think these are both about the same varities your coin and mine look to be 110's. But don't bank on that I am just learning how to figure out the Overtone on these. >>
Yes, LindeDad, both are examples of O-110 although I would probably label yours as 110 "a".
<< <i>What determines the variety ? Is it different dies ? Or state of the wear of a die ? Im just curious and promoting the thread for the sake of chat ! >>
Twosides2acoin, the Overton variety is determined by the particular combination of dies themselves. The "a" that I added to LindeDad's coin is determined by the die state.
Just because I'm old doesn't mean I don't love to look at a pretty bust.
Clarification: I believe in this thread the term cleaning has been used to refer to dipping or chemical cleaning which is generally not grounds for a bb.
Often here we shorten "harsh cleaning" meaning polish with a cloth leaving hairlines to just "cleaning". Personally I like that usage better. I generally won't call any of these coins cleaned but I would call them dipped or just say "the original surface was removed some time ago and it has retoned". I save the term "cleaned" for a hairlined coin...
I point this out because harsh cleaning has such a harsh penalty while dipping will almost never get you a bb.
Come on, now! Is obverse star 1 in the same position on both coins? Does the reverse F in OF have the same lower serif? Hint - the PCGS45 is the most common 1807 variety. Lindedad, the reverse die on your 07 110a is the 5th and final usage, it was used twice in 1806 and three times in 1807.
Robert Scot: Engraving Liberty - biography of US Mint's first chief engraver
Let me throw my 2 cents worth into this thread also.
I would also think that the coin has been cleaned or dipped in its past. Unfortunately, this is common and the way most (the # 95% comes in here) of these coins are currently. This piece has re-toned in a nice pleasing way. The only area of this coin that I don't really care for is the area at the shoulder that has taken on that reddish hue. Coins that are re-toning look much nicer in my opinion when they show less "color" on the most worn areas. I agree with RYK in that I believe this coin has sat in an album for some time. I have seen PCGS put more coins with this wear pattern in 40 holders than 45 holders, but I am OK with a 45 for this one. Here is a VERY similar toning pattern on my 1806/5, I will include the close up pic to show the color better because I can't take a pic as good as Russ and want to show the colors more accurately on this one. The coin Russ posted does not look AT to me at all Fletcher
Comments
Question though - if you don't own it, who does?
<< <i>Question though - if you don't own it, who does? >>
The person who sent it to me to image.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>Accented hair? >>
Birthmark.
Different picture still trying.
Mine has about twenty points more wear. But it is mine.
BTW still trying to get the pictures as nice as you get them.
But don't bank on that I am just learning how to figure out the Overtone on these.
Joe
It looks a lot like this one.
Thanks
<< <i>This shows how little I know ... based on the toning patterns, I would have presumed that half to be AT. It looks to me like the higher relief portions of the obverse are dark and the lower relief portions are light (the antithesis of a circ-cam coin), thus indicating some type of accelerated toning. Could some one with more experience than I (which means just about anyone) explain to me why this is not in fact the case and how such toning would come to be by natural methods. I am not bashing the coin as I find it quite attractive ... I am just trying to learn more about the toning process so that I can become better at identifying ATed coins.
Thanks
I am no expert either, but based on the little I have seen, read, and heard, my guess is that the coin is not 100% original. It probably had a gentle cleaning many years ago and has retoned in an album rather nicely. The very light centers of the coin are what indicate this to me. This does not change the fact that I like the look (of the image, at least), and I would be happy to have that kind of coin in my collection. It does not have the look of a coin that has been deliberately colored.
Now, stman, jrocco, coinlt, okbustchaser, and the rest may come along and tell me that I am FOS, and that is okay. My opinion is not based on enough experience for me to be very confident in it.
And yes I am against cleaning of coins but it used to be very common practice that collectors wanted nice shiney coins even if they where twenty or more years old. So every year or two out they poped for a scrub. Many of them are rubbed down to VF or so by now. Maybe those that we put into those plastice holders will escape the cleaning in the next 100 years.
<< <i>Interesting note I think these are both about the same varities your coin and mine look to be 110's.
But don't bank on that I am just learning how to figure out the Overtone on these. >>
Yes, LindeDad, both are examples of O-110 although I would probably label yours as 110 "a".
<< <i>What determines the variety ? Is it different dies ? Or state of the wear of a die ? Im just curious and promoting the thread for the sake of chat ! >>
Twosides2acoin, the Overton variety is determined by the particular combination of dies themselves. The "a" that I added to LindeDad's coin is determined by the die state.
Often here we shorten "harsh cleaning" meaning polish with a cloth leaving hairlines to just "cleaning". Personally I like that usage better. I generally won't call any of these coins cleaned but I would call them dipped or just say "the original surface was removed some time ago and it has retoned". I save the term "cleaned" for a hairlined coin...
I point this out because harsh cleaning has such a harsh penalty while dipping will almost never get you a bb.
I would also think that the coin has been cleaned or dipped in its past. Unfortunately, this is common and the way most (the # 95% comes in here) of these coins are currently. This piece has re-toned in a nice pleasing way. The only area of this coin that I don't really care for is the area at the shoulder that has taken on that reddish hue. Coins that are re-toning look much nicer in my opinion when they show less "color" on the most worn areas. I agree with RYK in that I believe this coin has sat in an album for some time. I have seen PCGS put more coins with this wear pattern in 40 holders than 45 holders, but I am OK with a 45 for this one.
Here is a VERY similar toning pattern on my 1806/5, I will include the close up pic to show the color better because I can't take a pic as good as Russ and want to show the colors more accurately on this one.
The coin Russ posted does not look AT to me at all Fletcher
And no matter how it got that way I like the color of the 45 better than mine.