Options
PCGS Guarantee
How do I go about returning a coin to PCGS under their guarantee policy? I recently bought a 2006 PR70DCAM Buffalo on eBay which has at least three noticeable scratches on its obverse. One, about 2 mm is noticeable to the naked eye. I've been waiting to purchase one of these for a while and was disappointed to find these marks. I've contacted the eBay seller to see if they might replace the coin with another, but who knows how willing they will be. Also, Does PCGS pay "market" value, or the price at which the coin was purchased. Any help would be great. Thanks
0
Comments
Otherwise I believe you would have join the PCGS club to get submission rights.
<< <i>You can check the PCGS website for an authorized dealer and they can send it in for you. You will probably have to pay shipping fees.
Otherwise I believe you would have join the PCGS club to get submission rights. >>
I would highly doubt that you need to be a subscriber to be able to use the PCGS Guarantee.
My suggestion would be to call PCGS Customer Service and see what they say. My experience has been that you need to call at least 4 times and ask the same question because answers have varied. It's been awhile since I did anything with PCGS so that may have changed, but it was pretty bad for awhile. I would also see if you can return it to the seller as first resort.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>You check "other" on the submission form and write in "downgrade submission" on the line below it. The fee is $25 plus shipping. If PCGS agrees with your assessment, the fee is re-imbursed. They generally pay market value, not your purchase price. If the coin is as you described, it is likely they would reholder it as PR69 and cut a check for the value difference.
Russ, NCNE >>
One must be a collectors club member before being able to do that.
<< <i><< You check "other" on the submission form and write in "downgrade submission" on the line below it. The fee is $25 plus shipping. If PCGS agrees with your assessment, the fee is re-imbursed. They generally pay market value, not your purchase price. If the coin is as you described, it is likely they would reholder it as PR69 and cut a check for the value difference.
Russ, NCNE >>
One must be a collectors club member before being able to do that. >>
You have an excellent grasp of the obvious.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>
<< <i>You check "other" on the submission form and write in "downgrade submission" on the line below it. The fee is $25 plus shipping. If PCGS agrees with your assessment, the fee is re-imbursed. They generally pay market value, not your purchase price. If the coin is as you described, it is likely they would reholder it as PR69 and cut a check for the value difference.
Russ, NCNE >>
One must be a collectors club member before being able to do that. >>
You have a choice of market value and they keep the coin or the value difference and you get the coin back at the lesser grade.
- Bob -

MPL's - Lincolns of Color
Central Valley Roosevelts
<< <i>You have a choice of market value and they keep the coin or the value difference and you get the coin back at the lesser grade. >>
Sometimes they give you a choice, sometimes they don't. It's at their discretion. Sometimes they'll even replace the coin with one that does meet the grade and no monetary compensation is involved.
Russ, NCNE
- Bob -

MPL's - Lincolns of Color
Central Valley Roosevelts
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>You check "other" on the submission form and write in "downgrade submission" on the line below it. The fee is $25 plus shipping. If PCGS agrees with your assessment, the fee is re-imbursed. They generally pay market value, not your purchase price. If the coin is as you described, it is likely they would reholder it as PR69 and cut a check for the value difference.
Russ, NCNE >>
One must be a collectors club member before being able to do that. >>
You have a choice of market value and they keep the coin or the value difference and you get the coin back at the lesser grade. >>
They should also stand by their price guide and give you price guide value. I mean after all, it is in a PCGS slab!!
<< <i>PCGS will decide what the fair market value is and it may have no relationship to what you paid, or what the PCGS price guide says. >>
so why have the 'PCGS' price guide, if they don't think their slabbed coins are worthy of that 'value'?
<< <i>How do I go about returning a coin to PCGS under their guarantee policy? I recently bought a 2006 PR70DCAM Buffalo on eBay which has at least three noticeable scratches on its obverse. One, about 2 mm is noticeable to the naked eye. Thanks >>
Make sure they're not strike-thrus. "Mint lint" can look like short scratches on a coin, and stuff can and will come between dies and planchets, even in proofland. I also agree that you're best off trying to return the coin and buy another.
Keeper of the VAM Catalog • Professional Coin Imaging • Prime Number Set • World Coins in Early America • British Trade Dollars • Variety Attribution
<< <i><< PCGS will decide what the fair market value is and it may have no relationship to what you paid, or what the PCGS price guide says. >>
so why have the 'PCGS' price guide, if they don't think their slabbed coins are worthy of that 'value'? >>
No price guide is accurate. Price guides are static, the market is dynamic. In fact, there are plenty of coins in the price guide that would sell at a lot more than the listed value. If the grade guarantee involved one of those, the submitter would get screwed if PCGS used the guide instead of market value. A quick example: The price guide lists the 1967 MS68DCAM SMS Kennedy at $6500. The last one to change hands went for nearly double that.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>Price guides are static, the market is dynamic. >>
I like that, Russ. You've got my vote for the next Federal Reserve Board opening.
Governments can print currency. Only the people can print faith in it — and they’re running low on ink.
Since you can not print a form from the site, please call customer service and let them know you want to send a coin in for this service and have them send you a submission form.
If you have any questions on how to fill the form out once you get it, call back and someone should be able to walk you through it.
Carol
So after much scrutiny, it appears that at least two of the three "scratches" are really miniscule fibers. I had to hold the coin at a severe angle to see a small gap between the fiber and the surface, which was made difficult by the thick slab material. So my question now is, how concerned should I be that these foreign objects will somehow damage the coin? I saw a thread a while back about complaints of this type, but don't remember the resolution. Can they be sent back and re-slabbed after the objects have been removed by PCGS?