Although the general term "Error" has been used for both Die Varieities and Mechanical Errors, over the past few decades it's been divided up so that:
1. Die Varieties are on the coin Die itself.
2. Mechanical Errors refer to planchet or Striking Errors.
When I started in the 1960's, both the national and local error club members collected "Error Coins" (even earlier than that - "Fido's" (Freaks, Irregularities, Defects, Oddities) and no one gave a thought if you collected Double Struck coins, and Die Cracks or Pre-VAM Dollar Varieties...
Retired Collector & Dealer in Major Mint Error Coins & Currency since the 1960's.Co-Author of Whitman's "100 Greatest U.S. Mint Error Coins", and the Error Coin Encyclopedia, Vols., III & IV. Retired Authenticator for Major Mint Errors for PCGS. A 50+ Year PNG Member.A full-time numismatist since 1972, retired in 2022.
<< <i>Although the general term "Error" has been used for both Die Varieities and Mechanical Errors, over the past few decades it's been divided up so that:
1. Die Varieties are on the coin Die itself.
2. Mechanical Errors refer to planchet or Striking Errors.
When I started in the 1960's, both the national and local error club members collected "Error Coins" (even earlier than that - "Fido's" (Freaks, Irregularities, Defects, Oddities) and no one gave a thought if you collected Double Struck coins, and Die Cracks or Pre-VAM Dollar Varieties... >>
fred, should a overdate, such as 1918/7, be considered a variety or an error?
It's a variety because the "error" was on the Die itself..................
It's called an "Error" because, like many overdates and 3-leggers, Doubled Dies, etc. it's a fast, easy word to use., ie. "I want the Overdate Error Buffalo Nickel....."
As I mentioned, the general term Error is used for both Die Varieties and major Mechanical Errors......
Retired Collector & Dealer in Major Mint Error Coins & Currency since the 1960's.Co-Author of Whitman's "100 Greatest U.S. Mint Error Coins", and the Error Coin Encyclopedia, Vols., III & IV. Retired Authenticator for Major Mint Errors for PCGS. A 50+ Year PNG Member.A full-time numismatist since 1972, retired in 2022.
<< <i>Although the general term "Error" has been used for both Die Varieities and Mechanical Errors, over the past few decades it's been divided up so that:
1. Die Varieties are on the coin Die itself.
2. Mechanical Errors refer to planchet or Striking Errors.
When I started in the 1960's, both the national and local error club members collected "Error Coins" (even earlier than that - "Fido's" (Freaks, Irregularities, Defects, Oddities) and no one gave a thought if you collected Double Struck coins, and Die Cracks or Pre-VAM Dollar Varieties... >>
fred, should a overdate, such as 1918/7, be considered a variety or an error?
K S >>
I thought overdates were in a class of their own because they were done on purpose.
<< <i>It's a variety because the "error" was on the Die itself..................
It's called an "Error" because, like many overdates and 3-leggers, Doubled Dies, etc. it's a fast, easy word to use., ie. "I want the Overdate Error Buffalo Nickel....."
As I mentioned, the general term Error is used for both Die Varieties and major Mechanical Errors...... >>
They are Die Varieties, but many people consider them a sub-set of a Variety as some overdates were done on purpose.
However, the overdate IS on the Die itself.
Retired Collector & Dealer in Major Mint Error Coins & Currency since the 1960's.Co-Author of Whitman's "100 Greatest U.S. Mint Error Coins", and the Error Coin Encyclopedia, Vols., III & IV. Retired Authenticator for Major Mint Errors for PCGS. A 50+ Year PNG Member.A full-time numismatist since 1972, retired in 2022.
Errors are not VAMs. In the past some missing letters from grease fills were admitted to the lst of designated varieties, but Leroy is purging the remaining ones at each convenience. Only actual die varieties and die states/stages are currently designated as distinct VAMs. Nothing directly related to striking is.
Comments
been used for both Die Varieities and
Mechanical Errors, over the past
few decades it's been divided up
so that:
1. Die Varieties are on the coin Die itself.
2. Mechanical Errors refer to planchet or
Striking Errors.
When I started in the 1960's, both the
national and local error club members
collected "Error Coins" (even earlier than
that - "Fido's" (Freaks, Irregularities, Defects, Oddities)
and no one gave a thought if you collected
Double Struck coins, and Die Cracks or Pre-VAM
Dollar Varieties...
Free Trial
<< <i>Although the general term "Error" has
been used for both Die Varieities and
Mechanical Errors, over the past
few decades it's been divided up
so that:
1. Die Varieties are on the coin Die itself.
2. Mechanical Errors refer to planchet or
Striking Errors.
When I started in the 1960's, both the
national and local error club members
collected "Error Coins" (even earlier than
that - "Fido's" (Freaks, Irregularities, Defects, Oddities)
and no one gave a thought if you collected
Double Struck coins, and Die Cracks or Pre-VAM
Dollar Varieties... >>
fred, should a overdate, such as 1918/7, be considered a variety or an error?
K S
An error is a mistake that once you find , you shout out !
``https://ebay.us/m/KxolR5
was on the Die itself..................
It's called an "Error" because, like
many overdates and 3-leggers,
Doubled Dies, etc. it's a fast, easy
word to use., ie. "I want the Overdate
Error Buffalo Nickel....."
As I mentioned, the general term Error
is used for both Die Varieties and
major Mechanical Errors......
<< <i>
<< <i>Although the general term "Error" has
been used for both Die Varieities and
Mechanical Errors, over the past
few decades it's been divided up
so that:
1. Die Varieties are on the coin Die itself.
2. Mechanical Errors refer to planchet or
Striking Errors.
When I started in the 1960's, both the
national and local error club members
collected "Error Coins" (even earlier than
that - "Fido's" (Freaks, Irregularities, Defects, Oddities)
and no one gave a thought if you collected
Double Struck coins, and Die Cracks or Pre-VAM
Dollar Varieties... >>
fred, should a overdate, such as 1918/7, be considered a variety or an error?
K S >>
I thought overdates were in a class of their own because they were done on purpose.
Jerry
<< <i>It's a variety because the "error"
was on the Die itself..................
It's called an "Error" because, like
many overdates and 3-leggers,
Doubled Dies, etc. it's a fast, easy
word to use., ie. "I want the Overdate
Error Buffalo Nickel....."
As I mentioned, the general term Error
is used for both Die Varieties and
major Mechanical Errors...... >>
excellent! thanks, fred.
K S
but many people consider
them a sub-set of a Variety
as some overdates were
done on purpose.
However, the overdate IS
on the Die itself.
NSDR - Life Member
SSDC - Life Member
ANA - Pay As I Go Member