Options
1958-D Franklin MS66FBL Star
1958-D is a common date for toned Frankies, but they are still very tough to find in this condition. In hand the obverse is nice and the reverse is a Monster, the image doesn't do it credit.
0
Comments
This was due to the rinse the Denver Mint used in combination with the paper found in the mint set of that year.
Would I love to image that gem....
"Senorita HepKitty"
"I want a real cool Kitty from Hepcat City, to stay in step with me" - Bill Carter
Knowledge is the enemy of fear
Thinking of 1958-D's, it is odd how timing works. At the Santa Clara show I bought two Killer toned raw '58-D's from a mintset. They both were toned on one side (one obverse, one reverse) with iridescent red and green with some fuchsia highlights. The reverse toner was a solid 65 with FBL, but with enough slashes in the FBL that I was pretty sure it wouldn't FBL. The obverse toner was IMO a high end non-FBL 64, that I was hoping the color would give a bump to 65. I sent them in to NGC to be graded and put in a dual coin holder (first time I've ever done that). I just got them back today, about an hour after I started this post.
Unfortunately quality control screwed up so that the reverse toner is rotated 180 degrees (e.g. the clapper is at 12 o'clock). I called up NGC and they said that they would fix that at no charge, so that is nice, and a good testament to their customer service outlook. Anyhow, the reverse toner graded out at MS65 as expected, and the obverse graded a MS66*. Given that there are currently (I just looked) only 38 starred '58-D's out of roughly 3,300 graded I'm a very happy camper. In any case, the two coins look very nice together in the holder.
U.S. Type Set
<< <i>You no doubt have experience with Franklins , and yet NGC graded a coin you thought a MS64 as a MS66 ! Wow ! >>
Two things, first I thought it was a high 64 low 65. Second, I own MS66 PCGS graded Franklins that I believe are 64-65. Certain coins unquestioned natural toning will trump hits, dings etc. I don't personally believe it should be that way, but that is simply the way the system works... for both major TPGs. Also, I tend to grade pretty conservatively.
U.S. Type Set
I remember looking at the two Frankies at Santa Clara when we met for show and tell. Glad they came back graded at or above your expectations. They are both stunning looking coins.
Congrats to you.
P.S. PM or e-mail me to say hi. SanctionII.
.
CoinsAreFun Toned Silver Eagle Proof Album
.
Gallery Mint Museum, Ron Landis& Joe Rust, The beginnings of the Golden Dollar
.
More CoinsAreFun Pictorials NGC FOR SALE