Options
Bulk Submission1967 SMS
I was going to send (36) 1967 SMS for bulk grading. Most of the sets (33) have never been opened. What should I pick as my minimum grade? ms64 or maybe ms65?
0
Comments
If they aren't high grade (MS68) or CAMEOs they aren't worth grading. Plus, SMS sets come in boxes, open the end, slide them out and look at them!
<< <i>Why would you want to do that?
If they aren't high grade (MS68) or CAMEOs they aren't worth grading. Plus, SMS sets come in boxes, open the end, slide them out and look at them! >>
Agreed -- anything less and you will be slabbing coins worth $5 tops.
-Paul
<< <i>36 sets X 5 coins X $8 per coin. Hmmmm $1440, PCGS appreciates it!!! >>
Well it's only $2 a coin if they don't grade the min. 36*5*2=360$ if I don't get any to grade. Maybe I should hold out for ms67 and swallow the 360$
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>Well it's only $2 a coin if they don't grade the min. 36*5*2=360$ if I don't get any to grade. >>
This is not correct. There is a minimum percentage threshold for your minimum grade. If you fall below that threshold you pay the full bulk fee.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>
<< <i>36 sets X 5 coins X $8 per coin. Hmmmm $1440, PCGS appreciates it!!! >>
Well it's only $2 a coin if they don't grade the min. 36*5*2=360$ if I don't get any to grade. Maybe I should hold out for ms67 and swallow the 360$ >>
Send me the sets along with $300 and I'll tell you if there is anything worth submitting!!!
<< <i>Ok I've deciided to go for 66 and above.... >>
An MS66 is an $8 to $10 coin. Unless it's the Lincoln, even an MS66CAM isn't worth much more.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>Ok I've deciided to go for 66 and above....most of these coins have never seen the light of day. MS68CAM for the boxes alone.
If you send these in under bulk without looking at them first you are the kind of fool PCGS (or any grading service) loves.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>Perhaps the responses weren't as blunt as they should have been, so let me rephrase. This is a stupid idea and you will be flushing your money down a rat hole.
Russ, NCNE >>
Like VOC Numismatics on facebook
Keeper of the VAM Catalog • Professional Coin Imaging • Prime Number Set • World Coins in Early America • British Trade Dollars • Variety Attribution
??????????
if you are working on a registry set, NONE of these will be eligible for entry in a 1967 mint set
I wish I had 1000's of dollars to burn
good luck on your bulk submission
<< <i>This is for my wife's Mint Set
??????????
if you are working on a registry set, NONE of these will be eligible for entry in a 1967 mint set
>>
Why?
<< <i>if you are working on a registry set, NONE of these will be eligible for entry in a 1967 mint set >>
There's a 1967 SMS set in the registry.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>I thought to qualify for bulk rate, you had to have 100 coins all of the same type. >>
You do have to have 100 coins, but they don't have to be all of the same type. That can be split in to groups as little as 25 of each same type. I've even heard of as little as 20 of each.
<< <i>You also have to take them out of the holder and carefully put them in rolls. >>
Bulk can also be submitted still in sets.
Russ, NCNE
I guess some folks have lots of money, and the submission fees are a lunch tab to them, even at hundreds of dollars or more.
Finally, don't 60% of the coins have to meet the minimum grade to qualify for the special rate? Meaning, this is meant for pre-screened coins, not the spaghetti-at-the-wall, hoping something sticks submitter. Good luck, I wish I had that kind of money to throw away.
<< <i>Perhaps the responses weren't as blunt as they should have been, so let me rephrase. This is a stupid idea and you will be flushing your money down a rat hole.
Russ, NCNE >>
Ditto.
I would like to think the OP is kidding, but, sadly, it appears he is not. This is a REALLY STUPID IDEA. This is like spending dollar bills and getting back dimes.
<< <i>What are the chances there's one DCAM in the lot....From the mint Boxes never opened 33 of 35 sets? >>
Why leave the boxes unopened if you're planning on submitting them? Is there a postmark making them eligible for "First Strike?" That might make a blind submission worthwhile, given the marketplace's odd obsession with that label, but it'll cost you extra. If not, then look for the cameos yourself. If you need a grading benchmark, go through all the sets, find the very best coin of each denomination, and submit only them, then figure out what your return might be with the rest of the sets.
Keeper of the VAM Catalog • Professional Coin Imaging • Prime Number Set • World Coins in Early America • British Trade Dollars • Variety Attribution
<< <i>What are the chances there's one DCAM in the lot....From the mint Boxes never opened 33 of 35 sets? >>
First off, are you talking about unopened shipping boxes, or the little blue box that the plastic holder slides in to? If it's the little blue box, how do you know they've never been opened? It's not like they're sealed anywhere.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>
<< <i>What are the chances there's one DCAM in the lot....From the mint Boxes never opened 33 of 35 sets? >>
>>
35 sets? DCAM?
Not very good. '67 is a lot easier for CAMS but it's not that much easier for DCAMS.
There's a good chance of getting some CAMS but DCAMS are well over 100: 1. Though,
on the bright side, if you get one DCAM you'll probably get a few.
Good luck.
I've opened them up.
11 sets where obvious losers.
The rest ho hum.
I'll fish out the best 20 and send them in for sport.
Maybe I'll add 10 2006 Mint Sets...
<< <i>Okay,already.
I've opened them up.
11 sets where obvious losers.
The rest ho hum.
I'll fish out the best 20 and send them in for sport. >>
Any cameos? If not, don't waste your money.
Russ, NCNE
DCAMS are pricey but some people don't like the white frost look
<< <i>for the $1000-$1500 you were talking of spending, you could buy a nice group of 5 coins
DCAMS are pricey but some people don't like the white frost look >>
It is an acquired taste for smoe people. Part of the reason many learn to
like it is that most of the frosted coins are among the best strikes and typ-
ically from new dies.
There are still a lot of moderns that you can find raw if you don't mind put-
ting in the time and effort. But some of these weren't worth the effort even
when they were new if you could buy them somewhere. Coins like CAM SMS
cents for instance are simply to rare to expend the effort looking. Sure, set
them aside if you see them but they're like finding a needle in a haystack.
DCAM SMS is pretty much the same thing. They were out there in small num-
bers and you used to be able to find them with effort but now the chances
aren't very good. Since they were tough from the beginning just having ori-
ginal sets isn't sufficient to be able to find one without luuck or a substantial
number of sets.
A lot of the SMS coins look really nice even without cameo and are underap-
preciated. These often look very proof like and are extremely attractive. Some
will have a light cameo and some none at all.
<< <i>A lot of the SMS coins look really nice even without cameo and are underap-
preciated. These often look very proof like and are extremely attractive. Some
will have a light cameo and some none at all. >>
Here is one I just received in a SMS set..not stellar buy any account but for a rookie like me, I love it. Going to assemble a nice proof CAM and DCAM and SMS collection of Kennedy's in a Capital holder. Still working on it.
<< <i>Going to assemble a nice proof CAM and DCAM and SMS collection of Kennedy's in a Capital holder. >>
Geez, more friggin' competition!
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>
<< <i>Going to assemble a nice proof CAM and DCAM and SMS collection of Kennedy's in a Capital holder. >>
Geez, more friggin' competition!
Russ, NCNE >>
hehehehe. Don't worry...I'm almost broke from buying crap and not knowing just to get a couple so far.
I almost bid on that 64 last night but decided you would get it. Then MadM got it. Will probably grade a 70 DCAM knowing my luck.
<< <i>I almost bid on that 64 last night but decided you would get it. Then MadM got it. Will probably grade a 70 DCAM knowing my luck. >>
Not to worry, Marty got hosed.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>
<< <i>I almost bid on that 64 last night but decided you would get it. Then MadM got it. Will probably grade a 70 DCAM knowing my luck. >>
Not to worry, Marty got hosed.
Russ, NCNE >>
Sending unopened SMS sets to be graded would have been a very bad idea. Since there is no "special label", like first strike, to be had on these, there is absolutely no reason for you not to open them and only send the best coins. Also, they do not need to be sent to PCGS as "sets". Each set can easily be opened, and just the best 1 or 2 coins can be sent in separately.
Maybe you already know this, but from your statement about the "11 Sets" are losers, it sounds like you may think they have to be sent in as a group.
The truth is that most of these SMS coins should never be graded. I have looked at thousands of them to find the coins in my SMS Registry Set.
The truth is that the likelihood of getting even a single coin worth more than the grading fee is less than 50%. My bet is that if you send in even the best few sets in their entirety, you will not get back a single coin worth $10. I hate to be so negative, but that is the truth.
You have to spend a lot of time, have a good eye AND get lucky, not to lose money grading coins.
<< <i>The truth is that most of these SMS coins should never be graded. I have looked at thousands of them to find the coins in my SMS Registry Set. >>
Man, I wish you had images in that set. There are some of us that would go through a dozen drool towels.
Russ, NCNE
I am going to get around to taking photos this year.
I am simplifying some things in my life and should have some time to dedicate to this project soon.
I love looking through other peoples sets, it is the least I can do.
1967 25c sms ms66
1967 1c sms ms67RD
1967 50c sms ms67
1967 5c sms ms67
1967 10c sms ms68
Total with shipping $101.90
-Paul
and it sets us apart from practitioners and consultants. Gregor
did someone here end up with those 3 halves the other night that closed at $579. raw?
way happy with the one 65 half russ was under bidder on but still bewail being under bidder on the last 68cam ah of russ's i was to go all out on.
oneday i'll borrow my daughters cam and show a neat 65 half that has die cracks on the obverse and a sweet planchet crack reverse almost like the 21' morgans most display here.
i still think my best is a 64 in 65ucam ah that has type 2 obverse with ah reverse in "ucam" and grading was probably low due to the reverse broken rays
<< <i>
<< <i>Okay,already.
I've opened them up.
11 sets where obvious losers.
The rest ho hum.
I'll fish out the best 20 and send them in for sport. >>
Any cameos? If not, don't waste your money.
Russ, NCNE >>
WHAT? This is as bad as you getting on me for not wanting to send in my 2007 proof gold eagles if they had little marks on them for PR70's. Whats the difference here? Your telling him to not send them in if they're not cameos, so whats the problem with me not sending mine in if I can tell they weren't perfect?