Options
A comment on the 1805 Half Cent.
keets
Posts: 25,351 ✭✭✭✭✭
About three years ago I came upon the idea of starting a Denomination Type Set. During the intervening years I've posted coins which have been added as well as discussing which issues/designs/dates I was looking for and any subsequent progress. The experience has been good for me as a learning tool since it's forced me to pay attention to a broader range of coinage than I would otherwise have done, being a rather myopic Jefferson Nickel and So-Called Dollar collector.
One of the more intriguing things I've learned along the way is the actual scarcity of certain coins. Perhaps the best example has come from the first denomination, the Half-Cent. Quite by accident, I happen to have stumbled onto the fact that 1805 Half Cents are not only difficult to locate in all grades, but in true AU+ grades they rarely make an appearance. Considering a low Mint State grade for the open hole has been the bane of my collecting interest!!! The choice of the 1805 date was predicated on the fact that there are only four die pairings, two that are rare, one that's scarce and one that's listed as common(which searching has told me is an overstatement). I falsely assumed I could find the "common" one easily and move on............................
What's happened is that I discovered the coins almost always are impaired and overgraded when found in Mint State/AU. There are either scratches, stains, porosity, altered surfaces and any number of other problems. Recent auctions have listed many examples of tough early dates and multiple examples of the easy dates------with no 1805's. Occasionally one of the rare die pairings will show up as a VF/XF and the price shoots through the roof as the EAC guys squirrel away another coin to hold with their hoards(they already have all the choice coins!!), but typically every major auction has nothing. I've sought help from a major dealer but his advice has been that most of the Mint State coins are overgraded so I should be very selective, hold on tight and make a move when I can find a properly graded coin. I've seen coins at shows that were from recent auctions, coins I had considered and then passed on. Seeing them in dealer showcases was enjoyable if not refreshing because they were easy to pass on in person.
As a quick example of what I've found, consider that the just concluded F.U.N. Show signature auction by Heritage had no 1805 Half Cents, the upcoming Long Beach signature auction by Heritage has no 1805 Half cents, the upcoming Stack's/ANR Americana auction has no 1805 Half Cents....................need I go on??? My question to anyone who can answer is this; Is this particular date really as difficult to find as my experience has taught me??
One other thing that I've learned along the way which may apply to other early 19th Century issues-----the Mint kept lousy records back then. Breen notes the following: The mintage figures for 1804-5 included many coins dated 1803, those for 1805-6 included many dated 1804, that for 1807 included many dated 1806. Evidentally it seems the easiest way for me to get a gem 1805 Half Cent is to purchase either an 1803, 1804 or 1806 and then just tell myself it's really an 1805!!!
Do me a favor, if you have a nice AU/BU 1805 dated Half Cent would you please post a picture of it to placate my angst. Thanks.
Al H.
One of the more intriguing things I've learned along the way is the actual scarcity of certain coins. Perhaps the best example has come from the first denomination, the Half-Cent. Quite by accident, I happen to have stumbled onto the fact that 1805 Half Cents are not only difficult to locate in all grades, but in true AU+ grades they rarely make an appearance. Considering a low Mint State grade for the open hole has been the bane of my collecting interest!!! The choice of the 1805 date was predicated on the fact that there are only four die pairings, two that are rare, one that's scarce and one that's listed as common(which searching has told me is an overstatement). I falsely assumed I could find the "common" one easily and move on............................
What's happened is that I discovered the coins almost always are impaired and overgraded when found in Mint State/AU. There are either scratches, stains, porosity, altered surfaces and any number of other problems. Recent auctions have listed many examples of tough early dates and multiple examples of the easy dates------with no 1805's. Occasionally one of the rare die pairings will show up as a VF/XF and the price shoots through the roof as the EAC guys squirrel away another coin to hold with their hoards(they already have all the choice coins!!), but typically every major auction has nothing. I've sought help from a major dealer but his advice has been that most of the Mint State coins are overgraded so I should be very selective, hold on tight and make a move when I can find a properly graded coin. I've seen coins at shows that were from recent auctions, coins I had considered and then passed on. Seeing them in dealer showcases was enjoyable if not refreshing because they were easy to pass on in person.
As a quick example of what I've found, consider that the just concluded F.U.N. Show signature auction by Heritage had no 1805 Half Cents, the upcoming Long Beach signature auction by Heritage has no 1805 Half cents, the upcoming Stack's/ANR Americana auction has no 1805 Half Cents....................need I go on??? My question to anyone who can answer is this; Is this particular date really as difficult to find as my experience has taught me??
One other thing that I've learned along the way which may apply to other early 19th Century issues-----the Mint kept lousy records back then. Breen notes the following: The mintage figures for 1804-5 included many coins dated 1803, those for 1805-6 included many dated 1804, that for 1807 included many dated 1806. Evidentally it seems the easiest way for me to get a gem 1805 Half Cent is to purchase either an 1803, 1804 or 1806 and then just tell myself it's really an 1805!!!
Do me a favor, if you have a nice AU/BU 1805 dated Half Cent would you please post a picture of it to placate my angst. Thanks.
Al H.
0
Comments
1805: A most frustrating date. Of it's four die combinations, two are are and extremely dificult to locate above Fine condition; the other two are common enough in low grades, but rare in full mint state
So you are definately right. My advice: Place a want list with all the early copper dealers you know, and just wait. In some time, it can be months or years or decades, the right coin will come along, as the EAC people decide to sell their collections, publicly.
Dennis
Like VOC Numismatics on facebook
Diplomacy is what it takes to get out of what tact would have kept you out of.
the EAC guys have all the choice coins and i go to look at them every now and then, like this past Thanksgiving in Michigan where i actually saw a few of the tougher die pairings one guy had in his display case. they also tend to have coins with the hard, glossy brown color i hope to find but the way they grade and price makes it difficult for me to make a judgement. your correct about waiting for the right coin, i just hope you're wrong about the decade i may have to wait!!
But, like you said, most of the EAC guys have all the good stuff already
My OmniCoin Collection
My BankNoteBank Collection
Tom, formerly in Albuquerque, NM.
<< <i>Al, EAC is having a convention in April in St. Louis. You might be able to find one there.
>>
Well Al, I googled the coin and it's the only one that showed up on a search. So I went to the guy's site but that coin was "SOLD OUT" at $75.
I hoped you would find the humor. Now you know why I'm not a grader
Joe
Diplomacy is what it takes to get out of what tact would have kept you out of.
What were your criteria for choosing the year 1805? Are you selecting only one date per denomination for your Denomination Type Set? If that is the case, there are MANY dates of half cents that are available in AU/MS. If you want just a Draped Bust AU/MS, there are varieties of 1804s and 1806 that can be obtained with a little patience. Heritage has a few 1806s on their web site now.
If you TRULY want an 1805, your best bet is going to be with a Copper Dealer. Most choice early copper only goes through an auction house if a significant collection is sold. Significant copper collections are not sold very often. We EACers call the finest collections as "being held in strong hands". We also call certain coins that are conditionally rare as being "funeral coins" for obvious reasons. The finest Half Cents are generally thinly traded. Many (read "MOST") of the nicest half cents never see an auction. They are sold and traded among us "copper nuts" so to speak.
When searching through a copper dealer, you have to remember that they use much stricter "EAC" style grading standards. If you are seeking a coin that will slab as a commercial AU, you will need to look for a choice VF35 through EF45. If you are looking for a coin that will slab as a commercial MS, you will need to look for an AU50 or above. I have seen more than one Choice EF45 slab with PCGS in an MS holder. If you decided to seek an EAC AU or MS coin, you are basically limiting yourself to two VERY SLIM possibilities...the 1805 Cohen 1, Medium 5 Stemless and the 1805 Cohen 4, Large 5 with Stems. There are NO 1805 C2s above VF and only one 1805 C3 that is an EF (EAC grades). MOST of these will be "funeral" coins.
The other consideration...CHOICE early copper is truly rare. I have one coin that has had only five owners since 1880, including me. Most copper collectors and EAC members I know are committed to their chosen collecting interest and are generally very serious. I don't know any that are "hoarding" half cents. Most of us sell our duplicates when we are lucky enough to upgrade. There are usually several other EACers who are more than glad to purchase such a coin.
Chris McCawley and Bob Grellman are hosting a copper auction in conjunction with Goldberg's in February. There are even three MS or near MS Liberty Caps in the sale. The catalog should come out by January 15, so you could take a look there.
I have attached some pics of coins that you said you would like to see. The 1805 C1 is graded an EAC AU58 and has never been slabbed. The 1805 C4 is graded EAC 45+/50 and would slab MS63 or so. Both of these coins are among the finest known of their variety, the C4 probably being one of the top 5 or so.
I would recommend copper collecting if you are looking for series with a long and interesting history. Dies states, varieties and providences are particularly fun and rewarding.
i'm well aware that other dates would be easier. when i first strarted the searching i picked up Breen's Half-Cent book and did some research, started looking around and decided on the date(i only want a single choice example for my set) because i assumed with only four die combinations it would be simpler. a short while into my hunt made me realize most of what you confirmed, tough date in the grades above XF for the easy C-1 and C-4, impossible to find the other two above VF and way too expensive for a type coin. at the Pittsburgh ANA convention the boys at JadeRareCoins suggested an earlier date in a lower grade, but i was already committed and hooked.
i find your use of the term "commercial" to be amusing yet accurate because most of what i see as MS coins in PCGS/NGC holders seem overgraded to me, while most of the coins i see in the EAC cases seem undergraded------what a pickle. my dilemma must be to compromise on both grade and price, finding a coin in an EAC grade adjusted to the "commercial" price-grade. it's been a difficult thing to accept. your suggestion of the Goldberg's related sale sounds nice on the surface buit i suspect i'd be in a fruitless fight with diehard collectors from the EAC which would be doomed to end in frustration. the better approach may be to just connect with a member and allow him/her to assist me. i imagine i could find a choice example in that fashion with the qualities i'm hoping for.
BTW, thanks for the pictures.
Coin Junkie
cameoproofcoins.com
I think you are on track with your thoughts towards contacting a copper dealer or established half cent collector (if you know one). The major copper dealers like Reynolds, Bird, McCawley, Jim McGuigan, etal, are your best chances for locating nice pieces. For example If you are looking for a near choice or average plus piece, nice medium brown surfaces, with only minor detractions EAC graded 45/40 - one of these guys will know exactly what to look for and won't waste your time with overgraded or sub-par pieces that will disappoint you. Also, they may be able top advise on what you may realistically expect to obtain in you price range.
EAC in St. Louis this year promises to be one of the better EAC conventions and the major copper dealers and collectors will be certain to have tables and lots of copper.
I am photo challenge. I have a digital camera etc. some one help
me. I will post my coins and you can see that I am one of us.
Then you can applaud my collection or mock it as you see fit.