Options
$10 Indian - best value grade for a type coin?
clackamas
Posts: 5,615 ✭
Indian owners, what, in your opinon is the best value grade for a type Indian/ Of course an MS67 would be very nice but I want to keep my budget in the $2K or under range but could go to 4 or 5. I don't care the date I am looking for best type. Some dates have better stikes and luster, etc.
thanks
brian
thanks
brian
0
Comments
$20 Saint Gaudens Registry Set
Below is my 1907, (sorry for the dull picture.) It is an NGC61, and I paid about $500 for it three years ago as a Heritage 'Make Offer' coin. It has a better than average strike for the date and no major distractions, which I cannot say about more than half of the MS63s I have looked at, though I do concede most are more lusterous than my coin; still, it is hard for me to justify spending 3 to 4 times more money for luster alone.
>>>My Collection
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
<< <i>clackamas---To answer your question, we need to know you budget. AU58's can be very attractive and a good value. MS62 is the the grade before the big price jump. They also also represent good value and can be quite attractive. Of course if your rich, buy a higher grade. >>
"Best" value - if there is such a thing in $10 Indians - would be in ch AU/Unc or MS63 depending on your wallet.
Though to use the term "value" and "$10 Indians" seems contrary to me. These things have been crazy in recent months. At the rate they're going, even in the 58/62 range they may be more pricey than $20 Libs before long...
<< <i>You can buy a nice MS65 1932 for around $5k and I would suggest that as your best bet. >>
I bet you can find a nice, attractive 63 coin for less than 1/5th of that number.
I personally believe that paying a substantial grade premium is only warranted in series where the higher grades are legitimately rare and hard to find, and where the appearance of the higher graded item is materially different and finer than the lower alternative.
You may have to look around for a nice AU58 but they are out there...
">"http://www.cashcrate.com/5663377"
"bargain" to the majority. However if gold should head to $1000 or higher the MS65's will reap the biggest rewards. Recall that they were just promoted to $7500 or so with gold reaching $735. They could easily double in price from $4-5K as there will be a demand for them. At that time you can trade your MS65 for a lower "bargain" priced AU-MS62 coin.
Whatever you choose, find a higher end PQ example for the grade.
They are out there in any grade you desire. I picked up a choice PCGS MS64++ a few months back for just a 5% premium to bid (and turned down some offers to part with it). That kind of coin has far more potential than say a generic or low end specimen for bid or less.
roadrunner
LINK
All Indians are amazing expensive.....
I am just glad I stretch my budget back in 2002 when I got my 1926 PCGS MS-63 for $535
On all Indians are long term winners I think.....
”Isn't learning fun?"
The Learning Channel
As far as why he is selling.....only he knows.
For generic I'd buy the best 1926 I could afford, more bang for little less buck.
roadrunner
Yes Brian they are my #1 $10 Indian set. In fact part of Platinum night is the KUTASI collection of $10's and $20's along with some $5 Indians. I am parting with my collection (reluctantly I add) to pursue another business venture and I need to have the capital. It was sell my coins or my building and the wife won that discussion!
$20 Saint Gaudens Registry Set
One last warning: You will probably need to look at many dozens of coins before finding one that meets the "virgin PQ" standard.
Doggedly collecting coins of the Central American Republic.
Visit the Society of US Pattern Collectors at USPatterns.com.