Options
Is there any chance the Battle Creek Morgans went to NCS first?
There are a few reason's I ask this, but for now, just in general does anybody know for sure? Doesn't really matter I don't think, but since there has been a lot of discussion on these, I'm just curious really.
Please... Save The Stories, Just Answer My Questions, And Tell Me How Much!!!!!
0
Comments
<< <i>Interesting question but I'm not sure I understand what you're getting at? >>
Just wondering if it's a possibility is all. I've heard of people sending toned coins to NCS to perhaps get rid of film etc. I'm not insinuating anything.
Just curious.
Isn't he the self appointed authority on them?
<< <i>where's Dizzy or whatever is his name.
Isn't he the self appointed authority on them? >>
Yes, my name on this forum is Dizzy (short for dizzyfoxx), not to tough to figure out.
I own one Battle Creek coin, so 'self appointed authority' on them??? Think again.
Now, I absolutely love the collection, the pedigree, and the coins, so if there's a question as to whether or not I'm an advocate of them, that shouldn't be to tough to figure out also. They're an outstanding collection, I think that's been proven over and over and over again.
As far as being sent to NCS, I would have no idea, but my guess would be no.
<< <i>I'm still impressed that anybody could get that many star designations in one submission. You gotta be a good grader to do that. >>
<< <i>As I recall, the Flea-market Morgan™ made a trip to NCS to remove some type of film. >>
Yes, just before it became an ngc 66*...........then back to pcgs at 64!
<< <i>
<< <i>As I recall, the Flea-market Morgan™ made a trip to NCS to remove some type of film. >>
Yes, just before it became an ngc 66*...........then back to pcgs at 64!
Which I believe was originally a 65 at pcgs. Ya gotta love it!
Apropos of the coin posse/aka caca: "The longer he spoke of his honor, the tighter I held to my purse."
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>As I recall, the Flea-market Morgan™ made a trip to NCS to remove some type of film. >>
Yes, just before it became an ngc 66*...........then back to pcgs at 64!
Which I believe was originally a 65 at pcgs. Ya gotta love it! >>
Another reason to buy the coin, not the holder. I wonder how many times this saying has been stated???
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>As I recall, the Flea-market Morgan™ made a trip to NCS to remove some type of film. >>
Yes, just before it became an ngc 66*...........then back to pcgs at 64!
Which I believe was originally a 65 at pcgs. Ya gotta love it! >>
Yup.
Apropos of the coin posse/aka caca: "The longer he spoke of his honor, the tighter I held to my purse."
<< <i>Another reason to buy the coin, not the holder. I wonder how many times this saying has been stated??? >>
Thanks for trying to learn us Dizzy!
<< <i>I'm still impressed that anybody could get that many star designations in one submission. You gotta be a good grader to do that. >>
all BC toners got the star no matter what the color looked like. It was part of the bulk deal.
<< <i>
<< <i>Another reason to buy the coin, not the holder. I wonder how many times this saying has been stated??? >>
Thanks for trying to learn us Dizzy!
Hey Steve, I'm always looking to gain numismatic enlightenment from those who are numismatically perspicacious.
all BC toners got the star no matter what the color looked like. It was part of the bulk deal. >>
Not all BC Toners received stars see this one
Unfortunately, I don't think that battlecreek coins constitute a "collection". More of a hoard and the pretty toners were slabbed "Battle Creek Collection" because, well, the * was coveted before the coins were slabbed.
<< <i>NCS will take the toning off your coin like a peeled potato >>
NCS can, and does, conserve toners without removing the color.
<< <i><< As I recall, the Flea-market Morgan™ made a trip to NCS to remove some type of film. >>
Yes, just before it became an ngc 66*...........then back to pcgs at 64! >>
Which I believe was originally a 65 at pcgs. Ya gotta love it! >>
I can't help chuckling every time I think about that. If I'd have got that sucker in to an NGC MS66* holder there is no way in hell I'd have cracked it back out for another trip to PCGS. That was close to a ten fold value increase.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>They're an outstanding collection, I think that's been proven over and over and over again.
Unfortunately, I don't think that battlecreek coins constitute a "collection". More of a hoard and the pretty toners were slabbed "Battle Creek Collection" because, well, the * was coveted before the coins were slabbed. >>
Brandon, you are one of the most respected in this hobby IMO. However I must respectfully disagree.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>all BC toners got the star no matter what the color looked like. It was part of the bulk deal. >>
Not all BC Toners received stars see this one >>
maybe I should have been more clear. The ones with a numeric grade.
<< <i>all BC toners got the star no matter what the color looked like. It was part of the bulk deal. >>
Not all BC Toners received stars see this one >>
All that received a numeric grade were automatically given the designation.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>
<< <i>They're an outstanding collection, I think that's been proven over and over and over again.
Unfortunately, I don't think that battlecreek coins constitute a "collection". More of a hoard and the pretty toners were slabbed "Battle Creek Collection" because, well, the * was coveted before the coins were slabbed. >>
Brandon, you are one of the most respected in this hobby IMO. However I must respectfully disagree.
How do you know?
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>They're an outstanding collection, I think that's been proven over and over and over again.
Unfortunately, I don't think that battlecreek coins constitute a "collection". More of a hoard and the pretty toners were slabbed "Battle Creek Collection" because, well, the * was coveted before the coins were slabbed. >>
Brandon, you are one of the most respected in this hobby IMO. However I must respectfully disagree.
How do you know? >>
<< <i>
<< <i>all BC toners got the star no matter what the color looked like. It was part of the bulk deal. >>
Not all BC Toners received stars see this one >>
All that received a numeric grade were automatically given the designation.
Russ, NCNE >>
Wrong, of the entire submission, only those coins which recieved the star got the pedigree. Those that did not receive a star, did not receive the pedigree.
The insinuation that NCS toned the coins or somehow enhanced them is particularly slanderous and if I were a representative from NCS, and I saw this thread, I'd be speaking to my lawyers right now.
<< <i>
<< <i>They're an outstanding collection, I think that's been proven over and over and over again.
Unfortunately, I don't think that battlecreek coins constitute a "collection". More of a hoard and the pretty toners were slabbed "Battle Creek Collection" because, well, the * was coveted before the coins were slabbed. >>
Brandon, you are one of the most respected in this hobby IMO. However I must respectfully disagree.
Not really, since these came on the market in mysterious conditions, these are merely a "HOARD". They were not hand selected by a discerning eye by an individual looking to put together an assembly of coins. These, according to the available sources, were "hoarded" as a stockpile of silver. I can't imagine anyone classifying these coins alongside Eliasberg, Bass, Reiver, or any of the other important true "collections" that have been assembled over the years.
<< <i><< all BC toners got the star no matter what the color looked like. It was part of the bulk deal. >>
Not all BC Toners received stars see this one >>
All that received a numeric grade were automatically given the designation.
Russ, NCNE >>
Wrong, of the entire submission, only those coins which recieved the star got the pedigree. Those that did not receive a star, did not receive the pedigree. >>
That is not what has been widely reported. It also doesn't explain why hundreds of ho-hum nothing special coins received the star.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>NGC is pleased to announce that it has graded the Battle Creek Collection, an unparalleled group of over 1,400 Morgan dollars. Included in this group are coins that represent the very finest toned pieces to come out of original mint bags that had not seen the light of day for over a century, until now. Every coin is encapsulated with the pedigree Battle Creek Collection, and, even more significantly, each coin in the collection has received NGC’s coveted star designation for superior eye appeal. >>
Link
<< <i>Oh, you want me to "islandize" it? OK, here you go. >>
SPECTACULAR! It looks just like that in hand!
<< <i>
<< <i>Hey Robert! Do you have a second to snazz up that Morgan Russ posted, so the Battle Creek Gang can appreciate it also? >>
Oh, you want me to "islandize" it? OK, here you go.
robertpr
there is no need to slam people like that.
<< <i>
<< <i>Hey Robert! Do you have a second to snazz up that Morgan Russ posted, so the Battle Creek Gang can appreciate it also? >>
Oh, you want me to "islandize" it? OK, here you go.
ROFL. IMO, all of their pics look like that... JUICED.
<< <i>NCS can, and does, conserve toners without removing the color. >>
And this was basically my question. Is there a "chance" this could be the case with these coins is all, and does anybody know for sure?
Here's my entry:
<< <i>The insinuation that NCS toned the coins or somehow enhanced them is particularly slanderous and if I were a representative from NCS, and I saw this thread, I'd be speaking to my lawyers right now. >>
Robert, I don't think anyone has said that. Besides, it wouldn't be possible, would it?
Apropos of the coin posse/aka caca: "The longer he spoke of his honor, the tighter I held to my purse."
<< <i>
<< <i>NCS can, and does, conserve toners without removing the color. >>
And this was basically my question. Is there a "chance" this could be the case with these coins is all, and does anybody know for sure? >>
We don't know much of anything for sure. We don't know who owned them before, we don't know who bought them, and we don't know who submitted them.
This is a curious case where the submission itself becomes a pedigree.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Not really, since these came on the market in mysterious conditions, these are merely a "HOARD". They were not hand selected by a discerning eye by an individual looking to put together an assembly of coins. These, according to the available sources, were "hoarded" as a stockpile of silver. I can't imagine anyone classifying these coins alongside Eliasberg, Bass, Reiver, or any of the other important true "collections" that have been assembled over the years. >>
I would not call this group merely a hoard. They are beyond doubt the coolest group of toners to come along since the Continental Bank hoard.
Same deal with the naming as the Binion Collection coins, both were from stockpiles of silver.
<< <i>robertpr
there is no need to slam people like that. >>
That was my slam, and I take full credit/responsibility for it. I just knew he would know exactly what I was asking for.
I see Braddick also does some fine work!
<< <i>Nice coin Hadley. Got any luster shots? >>
Thanks, and here ya go.