What would you say to the patient that comes in, is 35, 300 pounds, diabetic, smokes, uncontrolled HTN, non-compliant, doesn't exercise, family history of heart disease, and has an MI, then blames you for not addressing his risk factors when the only time you ever saw him was for a toenail fungus 3 years ago, for which he never followed up to address his major medical problems?
Answer:
Take responsibility for your own actions.
Listen. Strange women lying in ponds distributing swords is no basis for a system of government. Supreme executive power derives from a mandate from the masses, not from some farcical aquatic ceremony. Will’sProoflikes
What does giving $25 back to Ben do for my reputation now? It does everything for your reputation, You should consider giving Ben the whole $50. Ive dealt with Ben, and sent him several $1000ea. GSA CCs on cosignment/memo ect.. He has always went out of his way for his co-signors, If I chose not to elect insurance and the item never arrived, I certainly would not hold him liable.. Be glad is was not a $500 or $5000 coin
I haven't read every post from the two threads dealing with this and maybe I'm missing something but I felt like I was in the twilight zone or a parallel universe after reading many of the responses.
I am sure if you do a search that you will find countless threads that state over and over that insurance is for the SELLER and not the BUYER. It is the seller's responsibility to get the coin actually delivered to the buyer not to just maybe drop something off to the Post Office (or other service) and assume that it was packaged and addressed correctly or even had enough postage on the package. In a dispute, the seller is required to show DELIVERED documentation not documentation that something may have been mailed.
The buyer in this case owes the seller NOTHING. Anything that the buyer agrees to above nothing is a grand gesture IMO. Anyone that feels bad for the seller and offers to help him out is making a grand gesture.
But that doesn't take away from the fact that the seller is responsible for delivery proof. The seller will lose a dispute every time if the seller does not have DELIVERED documentation.
The rules do not and should not change just because you like one poster over another.
<< <i>I haven't read every post from the two threads dealing with this and maybe I'm missing something but I felt like I was in the twilight zone or a parallel universe after reading many of the responses.
I am sure if you do a search that you will find countless threads that state over and over that insurance is for the SELLER and not the BUYER. It is the seller's responsibility to get the coin actually delivered to the buyer not to just maybe drop something off to the Post Office (or other service) and assume that it was packaged and addressed correctly or even had enough postage on the package. In a dispute, the seller is required to show DELIVERED documentation not documentation that something may have been mailed.
The buyer in this case owes the seller NOTHING. Anything that the buyer agrees to above nothing is a grand gesture IMO. Anyone that feels bad for the seller and offers to help him out is making a grand gesture.
But that doesn't take away from the fact that the seller is responsible for delivery proof. The seller will lose a dispute every time if the seller does not have DELIVERED documentation.
The rules do not and should not change just because you like one poster over another.
Joe. >>
Joe, I believe that discussions regarding insurance protecting the seller (and not the buyer) often center around protecting sellers from unknown and or dishonest buyers who might falsely claim that they never received the goods. That is not the case here - no one has questioned the veracity of the buyer.
He was offered insurance and declined it, gambling that it wouldn't be necessary. The majority of posters apparently feel that he should take responsibility for that choice. That aside, frankly, even though he has since apologized (and I give him credit for that) the accusations he made against the seller, are reason enough in my book, that he should reimburse the $50 being discussed. Again, this has nothing to do with whether anyone "likes one poster over another".
I sell on Ebay and when I use Paypal I follow there rules or I am taking the risk as a seller. Play by the rules or do not accept Paypal. Anything over $20 that I sell I am glad that a buyer pays for insurance, if not I have to decide if the item is worth it to me to cover the insurance. Insurance is for the seller and that truth is back up by Paypal policy. Why you all ran to defend the seller when he gambled and lost gave the seller the idea that he was right. Try ordering anything by mail and if the seller cannot prove you received it they eat the costs, thats why most require insurance. Jim
The bottom line here is that All collectors,and or sellers on Ebay, should require enough signed for insurance for their items. If Ben would have charged 5 bucks for shipping he could have insured the item and also paided for his shipping supplies. The big boys charge more than 5 bucks and get away with it so why would 5 bucks be considered high for a little guy ? Enough of this low shipping amount just to make your auction look real attractive. Make the shipping amount enough to cover yourself and the other party involved. People just do not like to lose money, both sellers and buyers.
Both parties made a mistake here. I'm sure it will not happen again.
Looks like the basis of people taking sides is a different viewpoint on who should be at risk if an item disappears in shipping.
Some feel that if insurance is offered and the buyer declines, the shipment is at the buyer's risk. Some feel that the seller is responsible for getting the item there no matter what, even if the buyer chose to decline insurance.
Personally, I feel the seller is on the hook no matter what. As a buyer, I make sure the payment gets to the seller, so let the seller be responsible for getting the item to me. Whether that means mandatory insurance, or the shipper self-insures, or contracts with a third-party for insurance, it doesn't matter to me. But no matter what, the seller has to be accountable for getting the item delivered.
New collectors, please educate yourself before spending money on coins; there are people who believe that using numismatic knowledge to rip the naïve is what this hobby is all about.
Joe, I believe that discussions regarding insurance protecting the seller (and not the buyer) often center around protecting sellers from unknown and or dishonest buyers who might falsely claim that they never received the goods. That is not the case here - no one has questioned the veracity of the buyer.
He was offered insurance and declined it, gambling that it wouldn't be necessary. The majority of posters apparently feel that he should take responsibility for that choice. That aside, frankly, even though he has since apologized (and I give him credit for that) the accusations he made against the seller, are reason enough in my book, that he should reimburse the $50 being discussed. Again, this has nothing to do with whether anyone "likes one poster over another". Mark Feld
Both parties made a mistake here. I'm sure it will not happen again.
Disagree. The buyer did nothing wrong.
As the rules are currently set-up, the seller has to provide DELIVERED confirmation or he/she will lose a PayPal dispute everytime. End of story.
Until the rules change that's how the game is played. The seller cannot divest him/herself of the responsibility of delivery by giving an option to the buyer to buy insurance. Just because I choose not to purchase optional insurance does not mean that I waive the seller's responsibility to deliver the item.
This is how its been, and this is still how it works.
<< <i>Both parties made a mistake here. I'm sure it will not happen again.
<< <i>Disagree. The buyer did nothing wrong. >>
Yea only for buyers that do not believe in fair play. Delivery confirmation should have been enough for this buyer since insurance was declined. Does being cheap let a buyer off the hook ? You point says it does.
Back to the original quote that is highlited and revised to say...Ben will not let it happen again.
Does being cheap let a buyer off the hook ? You point says it does.
The point is that the buyer was never on the hook in the first place. That's my point.
If you are going to accept PayPal you must play by their rules or you will get burned. Regardless what anyone feels that this buyer should have or shouldn't have done is immaterial. Ben was burned because he didn't understand the rules of the game that he was playing and I'm trying to make sure that it doesn't happen to someone else.
"Yea only for buyers that do not believe in fair play. Delivery confirmation should have been enough for this buyer since insurance was declined. Does being cheap let a buyer off the hook ? You point says it does."
Delivery confirmation is enough, if it gets delivered. If not than the seller is on the hook per Paypal rules and he should have bought/required insurance if he was going to miss the item/money if it did not get delivered. The only reason he requires delivery confirmation is to play by Paypal rules and avoid a chargeback if buyer tries to get a refund for nondelivery. So why does he not play by the rules if the item is lost forever and he did not insure? Jim
<< <i>So why does he not play by the rules if the item is lost forever and he did not insure? >>
Insurance is not required by Paypal, and because it was not, I let the buyer have the choice. I followed every rule in the Paypal User Agreement perfectly.
However, now I know that it was not enough. As I said, insurance is now mandatory on all auctions.
The rule I was talking about has nothing to do with insurance which is secondary. Rule is no delivery = refund to buyer. Delivery confirmation is only good if it gets delivered, all you got was proof of shipping and that is not good enough to relive your risk. Even if the package was insured the buyer would get a refund from Paypal and you would receive a insurance settlement from USPS/shipper. So insurance is to insure the seller and the second guideline(not a written rule) is if you cannot live with the loss the seller must make sure the item is insured. Jim
<< <i>That sounds fair....split it down the middle.
Anyone else agree?
And tell me, what does giving $25 back to Ben do for my reputation NOW on this forum?
Does it buy it back?
Will anyone remember what I did to try and correct this situation or just see my name on future posts and feel compelled to bash me some more? >>
You know you keep digging the hole deeper. I see it as your mistake for not buying insurance. Ben's mistake for not requiring it. (A lesson I've well learned and all my future auctions will require it). Your attitude frankly stinks and you sound like a child. Buy back your reputation? If that's the only reason you feel compelled to do anything, if I were Ben, I'd tell you to keep your money.
For those that say a seller’s responsibility ends when the Post Office takes possession of the item being mailed… Then a buyer’s responsibility should end when the Post Office takes possession of the payment being mailed. All a buyer should have to say is ‘Well, I mailed the check, it’s out of my hands.” NO? Why not? The seller takes a gamble on the Post Office delivering his payment. But he still expects a replacement check or Money Order, right?
Change that we can believe in is that change which is 90% silver.
This has nothing to do with this transaction, but this happened to me last week.
I sent a signature to get PSA/DNA verified, insured for $200 although it is worth $1500, I just wanted some insurance, I figure more incentive to deliver the package.
So this package is going to a PO Box in CA from AZ. After a week I look at the delivery Confirm. online.
The package was going to a PO Box at zip code 92658, how they messed this up I don't know, they don't even show it delivered. The only way I know it was delivered is by checking my submission status:
Date Received: 11/09/2006 <<< ==== PSA web site
USPS website:
Enroute, November 03, 2006, 11:15 am, SANTA ANA, CA 92799 <<=== still wrong zip Missent, November 03, 2006, 5:48 am Missent, November 02, 2006, 4:33 pm Notice Left, November 02, 2006, 4:23 pm, HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92615 <<<=== wrong zip, but notice left ??? Enroute, November 02, 2006, 8:28 am, HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92615 Acceptance, October 31, 2006, 9:38 am, TEMPE, AZ 85284
This is just to show that things get messed up. If they had lost it I would have lost $1300 by trying to save a few bucks on insurance.
<< <i>As the rules are currently set-up, the seller has to provide DELIVERED confirmation or he/she will lose a PayPal dispute everytime. End of story. >>
Rules and morality are not necessarily the same thing. The buyer was offered the option of insurance, willfully refused that option, and then chose not to accept responsibility for the consequences of his own willful action. That is immoral. End of story.
I take check or money order when I sell on Ebay. I do not need paypal to take control of my money.
Advanced collector of BREWERIANA. Early beer advertising (beer cans, tap knobs, foam scrapers, trays, tin signs, lithos, paper, etc)....My first love...U.S. COINS!
<< <i>As the rules are currently set-up, the seller has to provide DELIVERED confirmation or he/she will lose a PayPal dispute everytime. End of story. >>
Rules and morality are not necessarily the same thing. The buyer was offered the option of insurance, willfully refused that option, and then chose not to accept responsibility for the consequences of his own willful action. That is immoral. End of story.
Russ, NCNE >>
Not true at all, it would be very easy for a seller to offer insurance and when declined not ship the item and then fall back on the arguement that it is the buyer's fault for declining insurance. I don't see anyone in this transaction as wrong, it just happened as other things in life just happen. Both now have learned a lesson, and actually fifty bucks is a cheap lesson. Frankly its off the mark in my opinion to diss either person. It's amazing how many "perfect" human beings have found this forum.
What a sad thread this is. The matter really should be between buyer and seller, to have a big public stink over a $50 transaction in which both the buyer and the seller made the mistake of being too cheap to pay for the insurance is just pathetic, IMHO.
<< <i><< As the rules are currently set-up, the seller has to provide DELIVERED confirmation or he/she will lose a PayPal dispute everytime. End of story. >>
Rules and morality are not necessarily the same thing. The buyer was offered the option of insurance, willfully refused that option, and then chose not to accept responsibility for the consequences of his own willful action. That is immoral. End of story.
Russ, NCNE >>
Not true at all, it would be very easy for a seller to offer insurance and when declined not ship the item and then fall back on the arguement that it is the buyer's fault for declining insurance. >>
Then the seller would be the one engaging in immoral behavior. In fact, in that scenario, the seller is a thief. That did not happen. The seller shipped the item.
Actually Russ is correct, in that, it is a moral issue. As an attorney told me a few weeks ago, "I see you wish for me to handle your case in a moral fashion, but I'm sorry the Law isn't about morality, it's strictly about the Law and it's provisions." PayPal has terrible guidelines, rules, and regulations. It's their law, it doesn't mean they're moral or right but the provisions they offer.
Freight rules and regulations are governed in the U.S. in many fashions dependant on the "legalese" given. FOB is a term sellers use that means "free on board" (not freight on board as many people think). Also there are two different types of FOB freight, FOB origination, and FOB destination. It's a legal term that tells you where transference of ownership takes place. If a seller sales an item, and in his contract and paperwork states FOB origination, that means the item is transfered to the seller at the point of origin. After it gets shipped, it is the buyer's responsibility, and if loss or damage occurs, it is up to the buyer to take it up with the freight company.
What it comes down to, is educating yourself on how any said carrier operates, and also third party individuals such as PayPal as you will be bound by their policies.
I agree with Russ in that it's a moral issue even if the rules side with the purchaser. One can legally cheat on their taxes by finding a loophole but it doesn't mean it's morally right.
Just my .2c
Prost!
Why step over the dollar to get to the cent? Because it's a 55DDO.
I made a mistake by not buying insurance and WILL NEVER DO IT AGAIN. I also made accusations of Ben that I cannot prove and for that I have already publicly apologized.
I went through paypal as I believe that was the right thing to do in this particular case in order to get back my money for something I never received.
Everyone here is entitled to their opinion and course of action.
I have exercised mine and would appreciate it if everyone would just drop the whole thing already!!!
Oh come on guys its no less immoral to accept paypal as a means of payment then try to avoid their rules, i.e. avoiding the responsibility of delivery. Its black and white, you take paypal its your responsibility to prove delivery if not you payup. Calling either one of these guys immoral is just being a jackass.
NO one forces you to take paypal as a means of payment.
Why would a seller leave completion of their transactions "up in the air" without insurance? It makes no business sense to trust a parcel service to complete a seller's transaction. It is in the best interest of the seller, and the integrity of the transaction for a seller to require insurance. Since the seller is giving (up) all responsibility of completion of their transaction to their delivery service, doesn't it make sense to insure that which is probably the most important part of their transaction?
<< <i>Why would a seller leave completion of their transactions "up in the air" without insurance? It makes no business sense to trust a parcel service to complete a seller's transaction. It is in the best interest of the seller, and the integrity of the transaction for a seller to require insurance. Since the seller is giving (up) all responsibility of completion of their transaction to their delivery service, doesn't it make sense to insure that which is probably the most important part of their transaction? >>
I am sure the kid received the message about insuring everything and not allowing buyers to decline. It is all part of the learning process. Most here have learned the buyers to avoid as well.
Collector and Researcher of Liberty Head Nickels. ANA LM-6053
DD. I agree with you that the kid probably did learn quite a bit, and probably will insure all deliveries. My post is for those who may still not see that a proper transaction ends upon successful delivery of the item sold.
Comments
"Keep your malarkey filter in good operating order" -Walter Breen
What would you say to the patient that comes in, is 35, 300 pounds, diabetic, smokes, uncontrolled HTN, non-compliant, doesn't exercise, family history of heart disease, and has an MI, then blames you for not addressing his risk factors when the only time you ever saw him was for a toenail fungus 3 years ago, for which he never followed up to address his major medical problems?
Answer:
Take responsibility for your own actions.
Will’sProoflikes
I am sure if you do a search that you will find countless threads that state over and over that insurance is for the SELLER and not the BUYER. It is the seller's responsibility to get the coin actually delivered to the buyer not to just maybe drop something off to the Post Office (or other service) and assume that it was packaged and addressed correctly or even had enough postage on the package. In a dispute, the seller is required to show DELIVERED documentation not documentation that something may have been mailed.
The buyer in this case owes the seller NOTHING. Anything that the buyer agrees to above nothing is a grand gesture IMO. Anyone that feels bad for the seller and offers to help him out is making a grand gesture.
But that doesn't take away from the fact that the seller is responsible for delivery proof. The seller will lose a dispute every time if the seller does not have DELIVERED documentation.
The rules do not and should not change just because you like one poster over another.
Joe.
<< <i>I haven't read every post from the two threads dealing with this and maybe I'm missing something but I felt like I was in the twilight zone or a parallel universe after reading many of the responses.
I am sure if you do a search that you will find countless threads that state over and over that insurance is for the SELLER and not the BUYER. It is the seller's responsibility to get the coin actually delivered to the buyer not to just maybe drop something off to the Post Office (or other service) and assume that it was packaged and addressed correctly or even had enough postage on the package. In a dispute, the seller is required to show DELIVERED documentation not documentation that something may have been mailed.
The buyer in this case owes the seller NOTHING. Anything that the buyer agrees to above nothing is a grand gesture IMO. Anyone that feels bad for the seller and offers to help him out is making a grand gesture.
But that doesn't take away from the fact that the seller is responsible for delivery proof. The seller will lose a dispute every time if the seller does not have DELIVERED documentation.
The rules do not and should not change just because you like one poster over another.
Joe. >>
Joe, I believe that discussions regarding insurance protecting the seller (and not the buyer) often center around protecting sellers from unknown and or dishonest buyers who might falsely claim that they never received the goods. That is not the case here - no one has questioned the veracity of the buyer.
He was offered insurance and declined it, gambling that it wouldn't be necessary. The majority of posters apparently feel that he should take responsibility for that choice. That aside, frankly, even though he has since apologized (and I give him credit for that) the accusations he made against the seller, are reason enough in my book, that he should reimburse the $50 being discussed. Again, this has nothing to do with whether anyone "likes one poster over another".
Jim
Both parties made a mistake here. I'm sure it will not happen again.
Ken
Some feel that if insurance is offered and the buyer declines, the shipment is at the buyer's risk.
Some feel that the seller is responsible for getting the item there no matter what, even if the buyer chose to decline insurance.
Personally, I feel the seller is on the hook no matter what. As a buyer, I make sure the payment gets to the seller, so let the seller be responsible for getting the item to me. Whether that means mandatory insurance, or the shipper self-insures, or contracts with a third-party for insurance, it doesn't matter to me. But no matter what, the seller has to be accountable for getting the item delivered.
New collectors, please educate yourself before spending money on coins; there are people who believe that using numismatic knowledge to rip the naïve is what this hobby is all about.
He was offered insurance and declined it, gambling that it wouldn't be necessary. The majority of posters apparently feel that he should take responsibility for that choice. That aside, frankly, even though he has since apologized (and I give him credit for that) the accusations he made against the seller, are reason enough in my book, that he should reimburse the $50 being discussed. Again, this has nothing to do with whether anyone "likes one poster over another".
Mark Feld
As always, Mark has some pretty good advise.
Ray
Disagree. The buyer did nothing wrong.
As the rules are currently set-up, the seller has to provide DELIVERED confirmation or he/she will lose a PayPal dispute everytime. End of story.
Until the rules change that's how the game is played. The seller cannot divest him/herself of the responsibility of delivery by giving an option to the buyer to buy insurance. Just because I choose not to purchase optional insurance does not mean that I waive the seller's responsibility to deliver the item.
This is how its been, and this is still how it works.
Joe.
<< <i>Since you're both in Oregon, take the fifty bucks, meet at a sports bar and have a few beers.
One party is not old enough to drink beer.
Yup.
If I gave Ben back the $50, would that fix this?
Yup.
Puro's Coins and Jewelry
Rutland, VT
(802)773-3883
Link to my website www.vtcoins.com
Link to my eBay auctions
Buy, sell and trade all coins, US paper money, jewelry, diamonds and anything made of gold, silver or platinum.
<< <i>Just curious, if the seller here was NOT Ben nor a forum member, would people here still bash me the way they did in this thread? >>
I would! That is why all my auctions have mandatory insurance, since I have dealt with a few people like you.
<< <i>Both parties made a mistake here. I'm sure it will not happen again.
<< <i>Disagree. The buyer did nothing wrong. >>
Yea only for buyers that do not believe in fair play. Delivery confirmation should have been enough for this buyer since insurance was declined. Does being cheap let a buyer off the hook ? You point says it does.
Back to the original quote that is highlited and revised to say...Ben will not let it happen again.
Ken
The point is that the buyer was never on the hook in the first place. That's my point.
If you are going to accept PayPal you must play by their rules or you will get burned. Regardless what anyone feels that this buyer should have or shouldn't have done is immaterial. Ben was burned because he didn't understand the rules of the game that he was playing and I'm trying to make sure that it doesn't happen to someone else.
I hope that is clearer.
Joe.
I do understand the rules of the game (Paypal's game). I played by the rules but the game had some interference, which caused me to lose.
However, you are right (along with Fairlaneman and a few others) and there is a lesson learned. All of my auctions now have mandatory insurance.
Delivery confirmation is enough, if it gets delivered. If not than the seller is on the hook per Paypal rules and he should have bought/required insurance if he was going to miss the item/money if it did not get delivered. The only reason he requires delivery confirmation is to play by Paypal rules and avoid a chargeback if buyer tries to get a refund for nondelivery. So why does he not play by the rules if the item is lost forever and he did not insure?
Jim
<< <i>So why does he not play by the rules if the item is lost forever and he did not insure? >>
Insurance is not required by Paypal, and because it was not, I let the buyer have the choice. I followed every rule in the Paypal User Agreement perfectly.
However, now I know that it was not enough. As I said, insurance is now mandatory on all auctions.
Jim
<< <i>That sounds fair....split it down the middle.
Anyone else agree?
And tell me, what does giving $25 back to Ben do for my reputation NOW on this forum?
Does it buy it back?
Will anyone remember what I did to try and correct this situation or just see my name on future posts and feel compelled to bash me some more? >>
You know you keep digging the hole deeper. I see it as your mistake for not buying insurance. Ben's mistake for not requiring it. (A lesson I've well learned and all my future auctions will require it). Your attitude frankly stinks and you sound like a child. Buy back your reputation? If that's the only reason you feel compelled to do anything, if I were Ben, I'd tell you to keep your money.
Then a buyer’s responsibility should end when the Post Office takes possession of the payment being mailed. All a buyer should have to say is ‘Well, I mailed the check, it’s out of my hands.”
NO? Why not?
The seller takes a gamble on the Post Office delivering his payment. But he still expects a replacement check or Money Order, right?
I sent a signature to get PSA/DNA verified, insured for $200 although it is worth $1500, I just wanted some insurance, I figure more incentive to deliver the package.
So this package is going to a PO Box in CA from AZ. After a week I look at the delivery Confirm. online.
The package was going to a PO Box at zip code 92658, how they messed this up I don't know, they don't even show it delivered. The only way I know it was delivered is by checking my submission status:
Date Received: 11/09/2006 <<< ==== PSA web site
USPS website:
Enroute, November 03, 2006, 11:15 am, SANTA ANA, CA 92799 <<=== still wrong zip
Missent, November 03, 2006, 5:48 am
Missent, November 02, 2006, 4:33 pm
Notice Left, November 02, 2006, 4:23 pm, HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92615 <<<=== wrong zip, but notice left ???
Enroute, November 02, 2006, 8:28 am, HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92615
Acceptance, October 31, 2006, 9:38 am, TEMPE, AZ 85284
This is just to show that things get messed up. If they had lost it I would have lost $1300 by trying to save a few bucks on insurance.
Lesson Learned.
<< <i>As the rules are currently set-up, the seller has to provide DELIVERED confirmation or he/she will lose a PayPal dispute everytime. End of story. >>
Rules and morality are not necessarily the same thing. The buyer was offered the option of insurance, willfully refused that option, and then chose not to accept responsibility for the consequences of his own willful action. That is immoral. End of story.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>
<< <i>As the rules are currently set-up, the seller has to provide DELIVERED confirmation or he/she will lose a PayPal dispute everytime. End of story. >>
Rules and morality are not necessarily the same thing. The buyer was offered the option of insurance, willfully refused that option, and then chose not to accept responsibility for the consequences of his own willful action. That is immoral. End of story.
Russ, NCNE >>
Not true at all, it would be very easy for a seller to offer insurance and when declined not ship the item and then fall back on the arguement that it is the buyer's fault for declining insurance. I don't see anyone in this transaction as wrong, it just happened as other things in life just happen. Both now have learned a lesson, and actually fifty bucks is a cheap lesson. Frankly its off the mark in my opinion to diss either person. It's amazing how many "perfect" human beings have found this forum.
PAYPAL SUCKS!
and they're cold.
I don't want nobody to shoot me in the foxhole."
Mary
Best Franklin Website
Why step over the dollar to get to the cent? Because it's a 55DDO.
<< <i><< As the rules are currently set-up, the seller has to provide DELIVERED confirmation or he/she will lose a PayPal dispute everytime. End of story. >>
Rules and morality are not necessarily the same thing. The buyer was offered the option of insurance, willfully refused that option, and then chose not to accept responsibility for the consequences of his own willful action. That is immoral. End of story.
Russ, NCNE >>
Not true at all, it would be very easy for a seller to offer insurance and when declined not ship the item and then fall back on the arguement that it is the buyer's fault for declining insurance. >>
Then the seller would be the one engaging in immoral behavior. In fact, in that scenario, the seller is a thief. That did not happen. The seller shipped the item.
Russ, NCNE
Freight rules and regulations are governed in the U.S. in many fashions dependant on the "legalese" given. FOB is a term sellers use that means "free on board" (not freight on board as many people think). Also there are two different types of FOB freight, FOB origination, and FOB destination. It's a legal term that tells you where transference of ownership takes place. If a seller sales an item, and in his contract and paperwork states FOB origination, that means the item is transfered to the seller at the point of origin. After it gets shipped, it is the buyer's responsibility, and if loss or damage occurs, it is up to the buyer to take it up with the freight company.
What it comes down to, is educating yourself on how any said carrier operates, and also third party individuals such as PayPal as you will be bound by their policies.
I agree with Russ in that it's a moral issue even if the rules side with the purchaser. One can legally cheat on their taxes by finding a loophole but it doesn't mean it's morally right.
Just my .2c
Why step over the dollar to get to the cent? Because it's a 55DDO.
I made a mistake by not buying insurance and WILL NEVER DO IT AGAIN. I also made accusations of Ben that I cannot prove and for that I have already publicly apologized.
I went through paypal as I believe that was the right thing to do in this particular case in order to get back my money for something I never received.
Everyone here is entitled to their opinion and course of action.
I have exercised mine and would appreciate it if everyone would just drop the whole thing already!!!
NO one forces you to take paypal as a means of payment.
<< <i>Why would a seller leave completion of their transactions "up in the air" without insurance? It makes no business sense to trust a parcel service to complete a seller's transaction. It is in the best interest of the seller, and the integrity of the transaction for a seller to require insurance. Since the seller is giving (up) all responsibility of completion of their transaction to their delivery service, doesn't it make sense to insure that which is probably the most important part of their transaction? >>
I am sure the kid received the message about insuring everything and not allowing buyers to decline. It is all part of the learning process. Most here have learned the buyers to avoid as well.