Believe me everyone I will be buying insurance on ALL my purchases in the future. As for working this out, Ben and I are now discussing this matter further via PM.
Thanks for your comments everyone even if you felt I may be in the wrong here. You never quite know how to handle something until it happens to you.
All I can hope for is that the package gets found by the USPS someday stuck in the back of a mail room or truck and delivered to me.
And I publicly apologize to Ben for accusing him of keeping the coin for himself. I guess I just took it one step too far and let my emotions get the best of me. I really liked the way this coin looked and couldn't wait to get it after I won the auction.
I certainly learned a very important lesson from this whole situation.
<< <i>I can understand everyone's point of view on this matter, but the one thing I don't know is if the seller mailed me anything or not. All he provided me was a delivery confirmation number for a package that had NO destination.
For all I know he mailed something to someone WITHOUT an address.
Still wondering if I will get anything back from paypal. I feel that I deserve some compensation, even if I decided against purchasing insurance. I believe the seller has an obligation to the buyer to provide goods that were paid for.
You chose not to insure. The seller has a delivery confirmation number on a low dollar item, still "in the mail" somewhere. It will probably appear in 1 week, month or year. You made the mistake of not insuring. The seller sent the item per your instructions. You are now unhappy because you lost the gamble you took. You deserve no compensation whatsoever. You want someone else to pay for your mistake. If I were the seller, I'd be upset. I always pay for insurance in case the USPS loses an item, then both the buyer and seller can leave whole. I suggest next time buying the insurance. >>
This sums up the real world pretty well, except that by most state and federal law, the seller is responsible for delivery and title does not convey unless the seller can substantitate delivery.
From a cost-benefit standpoint, insuring items under $50 is not cost effective.
The seller always assumes the risk when shipping without insurance. Likewise, if the buyer does pay for insurance, it is the seller who is insured, NOT the buyer.
I have had many dealings with Ben and I know he is of good character and an honest person. If he says he mailed it according to you instructions and they way you chose I know for certain he did. It's ashame this has happened to both of you and even sadder a neat coin is floating around.
I can reassure you though you are dealing with a first class seller and the act of not taking insurance was your decission.
It's very difficult when the costs of something are marginal as to whether to insure or not. But we all have to make our decisions and then accept the result. I hope for everyone the coin still turns up.
Maybe wishful thinking but stranger things have happened.
I'm amazed at how many times there are problems with transactions usually on ebay that both the buyer and seller are members here and can work out a solution. Do I feel a
Listen. Strange women lying in ponds distributing swords is no basis for a system of government. Supreme executive power derives from a mandate from the masses, not from some farcical aquatic ceremony. Will’sProoflikes
When I mail a package at my Post office and do not use insurance or delivery confirmation. The receipt handed to me lists each package and the zip code it is going to.
Advanced collector of BREWERIANA. Early beer advertising (beer cans, tap knobs, foam scrapers, trays, tin signs, lithos, paper, etc)....My first love...U.S. COINS!
Ben the bottom line here is that you should up your shipping amount to 4 bucks and insure anything that is sold for over 30 bucks up to 100. My guess is that you would lose very few bidders if you raised the shipping amount.
The extra 1 buck saves a bunch of headaches for both parties.
<< <i><< p8nt, when you punch in the delivery confirm number, what does it say? >>
Status: Acceptance
Your item was accepted at 8:07 pm on October 04, 2006 in PORTLAND, OR 97238. No further information is available for this item. >>
That right there is enough to state that Paypal will side with p8nt and deny the dispute. All Paypal wants is an online trackable number (preferablly a Delivery Conformation). If it shows that the item was delivered they side with the seller. The problem is a DC just shows that it was delivered, there is no way to know WHERE it was delivered (They don't have to be signed for and can just be left in the mailbox.) . If the post office leaves it at the wrong address the DC shows it as delivered and the seller wins.
<<<When I mail a package at my Post office and do not use insurance or delivery confirmation. The receipt handed to me lists each package and the zip code it is going to.>>>
When the Post Office finds out you tightwad collectors are using cash register reciepts as proof of mailing they'll start charging for the reciepts. Like the stamp machines: "Would you like a reciept?" enter yes or no "Yes" 'Please deposit 25¢ and hit enter"
Change that we can believe in is that change which is 90% silver.
"I can provide pictures of the receipt and delivery confirmation slip (showing the address the package was sent to)."
If it shows the address, it's because you wrote it in after the fact. The post office just lists city/state/zip code.
It is the obligation of the seller to deliver the item, insurance protects the seller not the buyer, PayPal will return the funds. P8nt screwed-up by not including insurance in the shipping fee.
"It's far easier to fight for principles, than to live up to them." Adlai Stevenson
Paypal will not return the funds. They will ask for the Delivery Confirmation, check it online, it will say the item was delivered, case closed. If P8nt did NOT have the DC then they would side with the buyer because there is no evidence the item was delivered.
Your item was accepted at 8:07 pm on October 04, 2006 in PORTLAND, OR 97238. No further information is available for this item. "
That means it was accepted at the Post office, NOT delivered (to NY). >>
I agree. It does not show it was delivered. My dealings with PayPal is if you can't prove it was delivered, your loss. By the way, insurance protects the shipper, not the buyer. It is that way with UPS anyways. The shipper has to file the claim for the loss.
Keep us posted as to what happens (even though it is going to take 30+ days to resolve).
Your item was accepted at 8:07 pm on October 04, 2006 in PORTLAND, OR 97238. No further information is available for this item. "
That means it was accepted at the Post office, NOT delivered (to NY). >>
I agree. It does not show it was delivered. My dealings with PayPal is if you can't prove it was delivered, your loss. By the way, insurance protects the shipper, not the buyer. It is that way with UPS anyways. The shipper has to file the claim for the loss.
Keep us posted as to what happens (even though it is going to take 30+ days to resolve). >>
Buyer blocked. He is unreasonable to even suggest a negative is in order. I feel bad he did not get his coin and as a seller, I offer the option for the buyer to purchase insurance. If the buyer chooses not to, I will usually purchase it myself on higher priced items to protect my feedback from cheap, loose cannons like this. The buyer new the exact terms of the auctionm, was offered and declined the opportunity to buy insurance knowing full well his coin would be shipped by the Post Office. The Post Office loses things. Simple as that and they lost HIS coin. To even consider a negative is petty, childish , vindictive. Suck it up and learn your lesson.
Any opinions as to whether he actually mailed this coin to me or not? >>
There are equally as many questions as to whether you actually recieved the coin. You could hypothetically have recieved it. and now want to strong arm the seller to give your money back. That way you get the coin for free.
I am sure you are as offended as p8nt when your integrity is questioned.
They say in retail that 20% of the customers cause you 80% of your problems. The solution to the problem is to eliminate the 20% as customers. I believe that the seller has found some of the 20%.
Comments
Thanks for your comments everyone even if you felt I may be in the wrong here. You never quite know how to handle something until it happens to you.
All I can hope for is that the package gets found by the USPS someday stuck in the back of a mail room or truck and delivered to me.
And I publicly apologize to Ben for accusing him of keeping the coin for himself. I guess I just took it one step too far and let my emotions get the best of me. I really liked the way this coin looked and couldn't wait to get it after I won the auction.
I certainly learned a very important lesson from this whole situation.
<< <i>And I publicly apologize to Ben for accusing him of keeping the coin for himself. >>
"The Villain"
Shiba Rescue Organization
A Shiba Inu is a terrible thing to waste!
<< <i>I can understand everyone's point of view on this matter, but the one thing I don't know is if the seller mailed me anything or not. All he provided me was a delivery confirmation number for a package that had NO destination.
For all I know he mailed something to someone WITHOUT an address.
Still wondering if I will get anything back from paypal. I feel that I deserve some compensation, even if I decided against purchasing insurance. I believe the seller has an obligation to the buyer to provide goods that were paid for.
You chose not to insure. The seller has a delivery confirmation number on a low dollar item, still "in the mail" somewhere. It will probably appear in 1 week, month or year. You made the mistake of not insuring. The seller sent the item per your instructions. You are now unhappy because you lost the gamble you took. You deserve no compensation whatsoever. You want someone else to pay for your mistake. If I were the seller, I'd be upset. I always pay for insurance in case the USPS loses an item, then both the buyer and seller can leave whole. I suggest next time buying the insurance. >>
This sums up the real world pretty well, except that by most state and federal law, the seller is responsible for delivery and title does not convey unless the seller can substantitate delivery.
From a cost-benefit standpoint, insuring items under $50 is not cost effective.
The seller always assumes the risk when shipping without insurance. Likewise, if the buyer does pay for insurance, it is the seller who is insured, NOT the buyer.
I have had many dealings with Ben and I know he is of good character and an honest person. If he says he mailed it according to you instructions and they way you chose I know for certain he did. It's ashame this has happened to both of you and even sadder a neat coin is floating around.
I can reassure you though you are dealing with a first class seller and the act of not taking insurance was your decission.
It's very difficult when the costs of something are marginal as to whether to insure or not. But we all have to make our decisions and then accept the result. I hope for everyone the coin still turns up.
Maybe wishful thinking but stranger things have happened.
Website-Americana Rare Coin Inc
As for buying insurance, I now realize I should have purchased it and WILL do so on ALL my future purchases, no matter how small.
It's just not worth all the aggravation.
I would actually prefer if all eBay sellers would make insurance a requirement so as to not have to deal with this situation if it ever came up.
Just my thought.
That was a class post. It also takes a good person to apologize.
Good job.
Website-Americana Rare Coin Inc
Will’sProoflikes
The extra 1 buck saves a bunch of headaches for both parties.
Ken
<< <i><< p8nt, when you punch in the delivery confirm number, what does it say? >>
Status: Acceptance
Your item was accepted at 8:07 pm on October 04, 2006 in PORTLAND, OR 97238. No further information is available for this item. >>
That right there is enough to state that Paypal will side with p8nt and deny the dispute. All Paypal wants is an online trackable number (preferablly a Delivery Conformation). If it shows that the item was delivered they side with the seller. The problem is a DC just shows that it was delivered, there is no way to know WHERE it was delivered (They don't have to be signed for and can just be left in the mailbox.) . If the post office leaves it at the wrong address the DC shows it as delivered and the seller wins.
When the Post Office finds out you tightwad collectors are using cash register reciepts as proof of mailing they'll start charging for the reciepts.
Like the stamp machines:
"Would you like a reciept?" enter yes or no
"Yes"
'Please deposit 25¢ and hit enter"
If it shows the address, it's because you wrote it in after the fact. The post office just lists city/state/zip code.
It is the obligation of the seller to deliver the item, insurance protects the seller not the buyer, PayPal will return the funds. P8nt screwed-up by not including insurance in the shipping fee.
<< <i>PayPal will return the funds. >>
Paypal will not return the funds. They will ask for the Delivery Confirmation, check it online, it will say the item was delivered, case closed. If P8nt did NOT have the DC then they would side with the buyer because there is no evidence the item was delivered.
"Status: Acceptance
Your item was accepted at 8:07 pm on October 04, 2006 in PORTLAND, OR 97238. No further information is available for this item. "
That means it was accepted at the Post office, NOT delivered (to NY).
<< <i>"I can provide pictures of the receipt and delivery confirmation slip (showing the address the package was sent to)."
If it shows the address, it's because you wrote it in after the fact. The post office just lists city/state/zip code. >>
It is post office policy that the full address information be filled out by the shipper prior to processing the slip.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>The USPS info says:
"Status: Acceptance
Your item was accepted at 8:07 pm on October 04, 2006 in PORTLAND, OR 97238. No further information is available for this item. "
That means it was accepted at the Post office, NOT delivered (to NY). >>
I agree. It does not show it was delivered. My dealings with PayPal is if you can't prove it was delivered, your loss. By the way, insurance protects the shipper, not the buyer. It is that way with UPS anyways. The shipper has to file the claim for the loss.
Keep us posted as to what happens (even though it is going to take 30+ days to resolve).
<< <i>
<< <i>The USPS info says:
"Status: Acceptance
Your item was accepted at 8:07 pm on October 04, 2006 in PORTLAND, OR 97238. No further information is available for this item. "
That means it was accepted at the Post office, NOT delivered (to NY). >>
I agree. It does not show it was delivered. My dealings with PayPal is if you can't prove it was delivered, your loss. By the way, insurance protects the shipper, not the buyer. It is that way with UPS anyways. The shipper has to file the claim for the loss.
Keep us posted as to what happens (even though it is going to take 30+ days to resolve). >>
Didn't take 30 days....and Ben lost
I've been told I tolerate fools poorly...that may explain things if I have a problem with you. Current ebay items - Nothing at the moment
<< <i>
Any opinions as to whether he actually mailed this coin to me or not? >>
There are equally as many questions as to whether you actually recieved the coin. You could hypothetically have recieved it. and now want to strong arm the seller to give your money back. That way you get the coin for free.
I am sure you are as offended as p8nt when your integrity is questioned.