Options
1805 half- what would it grade?- Opinion posted
I don't often participate in the many "WWHRHGI" (what will HRH grade it) threads because I'm not very good at them. I take a more technical view of grading and less of a market view. Grade the remaining surfaces and luster or lack thereof, as opposed to 'well, this sure is pretty so it's a 58 even though it has lots of wear in the fields'.
Anyway, this coin just arrived and there was some debate with the seller regarding the grade. Julian and other wise coin experts will, if asked, advise you to never debate grade with a dealer. Rather, debate price. Debating grade is a no win situation; debate value, and you can often reach agreement. Knowing this, I chose to disregard it. There was no debate as to value. Besides, the seller is my mentor and he taught me most of what I know about grading. Since we both tend to grade on technical merit, I thought one might convince the other of his view. We ended up 10 points apart. No big deal, except that this is a condition census coin for the die marriage.
I look forward to your responses. One point to consider- how much allowance do you make for the fact that some metal has flowed into the reverse cud instead of striking up elsewhere on the coin?
Edited to add- I thought the coin a 25, just missing CC, but extra nice for the grade, with almost no hits, which is rare for a coin of this grade. The seller called it 35, and I have almost come around. For the BHNC census, I'm going with 30. I may decide to submit it for grading, in which case I believe it has a solid shot at 40. The Norweb 1805 O.104, graded 30 when it sold in '88, is now in a 40 slab after a couple failed efforts. The Reiver 05 104a was graded 12 by NGC, I cracked it out, sold it, and now is in a P20 slab. This only proves that PCGS can show some mercy in grading low grade 1805s.
The only consideration I would show to a coin with a cud is in not downgrading it because of weakness opposite the cud. Path of least resistance and such.

Anyway, this coin just arrived and there was some debate with the seller regarding the grade. Julian and other wise coin experts will, if asked, advise you to never debate grade with a dealer. Rather, debate price. Debating grade is a no win situation; debate value, and you can often reach agreement. Knowing this, I chose to disregard it. There was no debate as to value. Besides, the seller is my mentor and he taught me most of what I know about grading. Since we both tend to grade on technical merit, I thought one might convince the other of his view. We ended up 10 points apart. No big deal, except that this is a condition census coin for the die marriage.
I look forward to your responses. One point to consider- how much allowance do you make for the fact that some metal has flowed into the reverse cud instead of striking up elsewhere on the coin?
Edited to add- I thought the coin a 25, just missing CC, but extra nice for the grade, with almost no hits, which is rare for a coin of this grade. The seller called it 35, and I have almost come around. For the BHNC census, I'm going with 30. I may decide to submit it for grading, in which case I believe it has a solid shot at 40. The Norweb 1805 O.104, graded 30 when it sold in '88, is now in a 40 slab after a couple failed efforts. The Reiver 05 104a was graded 12 by NGC, I cracked it out, sold it, and now is in a P20 slab. This only proves that PCGS can show some mercy in grading low grade 1805s.
The only consideration I would show to a coin with a cud is in not downgrading it because of weakness opposite the cud. Path of least resistance and such.
0
Comments
The court jester does not play, but gently pulls the strings…
Liberty: Parent of Science & Industry
Old coins with cuds are great as the show the lack or amount of wear as they are a added high point.
<< <i>I like that coin and would go EF-40. Old coins with cuds are great as the show the lack or amount of wear as they are a added high point. >>
Oh so close, but I believe there's just a tad too much wear on the reverse ribbon.
A strong VF35 IMHO.
I like that cud! But it doesn't really look like the coin suffered much of a striking detriment because of it.
-Amanda
I'm a YN working on a type set!
My Buffalo Nickel Website Home of the Quirky Buffaloes Collection!
Proud member of the CUFYNA
Nice cud.
Experience the World through Numismatics...it's more than you can imagine.
siliconvalleycoins.com
It is a very nice example of difficult to find rarity that tends to be hoarded for die states. There was about a five year period where no 05 105's made it to auction.
Your 1805 exhibits nice even wear patterns on both the obverse and reverse. In the resesses around the stars there appears to be the original mint luster, dulled by age and not a very harsh circulation life. (200+1 years) Good solid rims with that 12:00 O'clock cud makes this coin have nice eye appeal.
I'm not sure I understand your question:
One point to consider- how much allowance do you make for the fact that some metal has flowed into the reverse cud instead of striking up elsewhere on the coin?
Poser:
When a coin is struck by a broken die the place where the die is broken or missing will often show up as extra metal on the surface of a coin. This extra piece of metal or "cud" can be from a piece of the die being missing or a still intact, but moved.
Based on the wear in the ribbons/hair/drapery obv./wear on banner/wing tips/tail feathers rev. I'm inclined to go with
VF-30+
Nice early circulated example from this period.
The Sheldon grading scale
perfect uncirculated .................... MS70,MS69,MS68
superb gem uncirculated ..................... MS67,MS66
gem uncirculated ..................... MS65,MS64
choice uncirculated ...................... MS63,MS62,MS61
uncirculated ...................... MS60
choice about uncirculated ....................... AU58,AU55
about uncirculated ............ AU50
choice extremely fine ....... XF45
extremely fine .................... XF40,VF35
choice very fine ................. VF30,VF25
very fine .............................. VF20
fine - very fine .................... F15
fine ...................................... F12
very good ........................... VG8
good ................................... G4
about good ........................ G3
poor .................................... 1
"Keep your malarkey filter in good operating order" -Walter Breen
<< <i>WWHRHGI >>
That's one heck of a nice O105a you've got there sir!
1803 xf 45
I would throw a 35 at her and bet it would stick. 5 points up or down would be debatable though.
Nice coin that I wish were mine
<< <i>This one brought a 45 so I'd say 30 >>
That's a very nice 1803. But compare this coin to mine.
1805 O.101 PCGS40
Liberty: Parent of Science & Industry
Capped Bust Half Series
Capped Bust Half Dime Series